« Some Guys Just Don't Give Up | Zahav's Blog | Economic Geometry Redux »

An Open Letter to Israel


    I grew up in Skokie, Illinois. My grandmother, who was one of eight women attorneys admitted to the Wisconsin bar in 1932, tutored me in Hebrew. She was an exacting teacher and half teased and half scolded me that I pronounced "Israel," of all words, like a goy. But I persevered; something in me felt some inexplicable connection to Israel, Artzenu, and the language of our heroic brethren. For a 14 or 15 year old Jewish kid in 1980's Skokie, there really was no other choice than to view Israelis in such terms. And certainly not for one of Mar Hoffman's students at Niles North High School. There, we learned as much about Israel's history, culture and politics as we did about conjugating reflexive verbs. Hitahavti, hitahavta, hitahavt . . . . By the time I landed in Israel for the first time in 1987, at age 22, I was already in love.

    Once on the ground, Israel did not disappoint. Three weeks I spent volunteering on an army base, and five weeks exploring the country from top to bottom. One evening we dropped into a bar in Haifa, and some elderly man turned to us and for no particular reason told us two stories about "Baron Rothschild." The details of the stories are not that important here, though the first ended with the Baron telling two beggars, who had thought they could take advantage of his generosity, that they could scratch each others' backs. The second, with the Baron remarking that he grew up the son of a shoemaker and that his son grew up the son of a Rothschild. Much later on, and when my two girls were little, I would tell them these Rothschild stories as I tucked them into bed at night.

    Yet, my love for Israel was even at that time a mature love. I understood that Israel was not perfect.

    Sleeping one night at a beach on the Kinneret, I heard something that has stuck with me to this day. Young kids were running around the beach late at night. Tired and in my sleeping bag, at first I couldn't quite make out the words. Then I clearly heard "Aravim" [Arabs]. Then I heard the word "Mavet" [Death]. And it soon became clear to me that these kids were chanting "Mavet L'Aravim" [Death to the Arabs]. But at the time, this just seemed an aberration and I remained struck by the Kinneret's quiet beauty. 
            
    From there I spent time at the beaches and bars of Tel Aviv, wandering around Jerusalem, Haifa, Naharyia, Netyana, the Golan, sleeping on the hiking trail leading in toward the Banias waterfalls. Fourth of July in Eilat.

    When I came back home after that summer to begin my second year of law school, I was determined to find a way to return to Israel. And I found a program that combined a kibbutz ulpan program and a clerkship at the Supreme Court of Israel. So after sitting for the bar, I flew to Israel. It was the summer of 1990, shortly after Iraq invaded Kuwait. Scuds would soon be falling on Tel Aviv. It was also the time of Operation Solomon, when Israel flew 15,000 Jews out of Ethiopia. Thousands of immigrants from Russia were still pouring into the country, some of whom I met at Kibbutz Yagur where I spent six months on an uplan program. It is at Kibbutz Yagur that I met Ayelet who took over from my grandmother and Mar Hoffman and introduced me to an Israel I hadn't known. 

    After a year in Israel, I returned home yet again with the plan to pay off my student loans and make aliyah. I exchanged letters with my friends in Israel. And it was Ayelet who told me that my letters read like love letters to Israel. And of course she was right.

    Back in Chicago I met my future wife, had a family, and developed a career. Though I've been back a couple times to Israel since, my dreams of aliyah were never realized. I have had to get along with listening to Galai Tzahal on the internet when I arrive at my office in the morning, by reading Yehoshua, Oz, Segev and Morris, perusing Haaretz, occasionally printing Yoel Marcus's columns in Hebrew for the train ride home, waiting for Broza to play in Chicago, searching You Tube for Einstein's black and white videos, and most recently reading on the internet about Maccabi Tel-Aviv's signing of my all time favorite college basketball player, Dee Brown. 

    At this point I suppose it is only right to disclose my political leanings. Unabashed peacenik I am. A believer in a two state solution, even today with all that's happened. My love for Israel has never been diminished by my criticism of her governments. In fact, it is my love for Israel that informs my criticisms. Still I have been very troubled, no, sick is the right word, as I read about the rise of Avigdor Lieberman and his Israel Beiteinu party. 

    And so it was this morning that I checked out the Haaretz website and read an article reporting on Avigdor Lieberman's popularity among Israeli teens. I have included an excerpt below:

        The youths, ages 16-18, many of them good friends from school, had stood for a long time before the event began at the intersection near the hotel, waving Israeli flags and shouting "Death to the Arabs" and "No loyalty, no citizenship" at passing cars.
              
        In the tent, they deliberate over what to shout when Lieberman enters: Calling out "The next prime minister" may sound a bit presumptuous with regard to the leader of what's likely to be the third-largest party in the next Knesset. But during a week when Yisrael Beiteinu won the highest level of support in mock high-school polls - the sky's the limit.
   
***

        "This country has needed a dictatorship for a long time already. But I'm not talking about an extreme dictatorship. We need someone who can put things in order. Lieberman is the only one who speaks the truth." Adds Edan Ivanov, an 18 year old who describes himself as being "up on current events":
       
        "We've had enough here with the 'leftist democracy' - and I put that term in quotes, don't get me wrong. People have put the dictator label on Lieberman because of the things he says. But the truth is that in Israel there can't be a full democracy when there are Arabs here who oppose it.
       
        "All Lieberman's really saying is that anyone who isn't prepared to sign an oath of loyalty to the state, because of his personal views, cannot receive equal rights; he can't vote for the executive authority. People here are gradually coming to understand what needs to be done concerning a person who is not loyal."
       
        Do these ideas fit with what you're learning in civics lessons?
       
        Ivanov: "In my opinion, school doesn't tell it like it is. In school, you want to get a matriculation certificate, you need the grades, but you don't learn the truth there. The truth you learn from the neighborhood, from the street. I don't mean the street in a negative sense - I mean that you learn the truth from what's happening here."
       
        What's happening here?
       
        "We have a problem: Upper Nazareth is surrounded by minorities. There are lots of incidents with them. Women are scared to walk in the streets, and people are afraid they'll be stabbed. No one knows what to do about it at this point. There are people who live here and during a war they act as a fifth column. It will only be possible to make peace with them after we make war."
       
        Is that why people shout "Death to the Arabs"?
       
        "The people who shout 'Death to the Arabs' - they mean death to those who support terror. There are Druze and Bedouin, too, and we have lots of friends who are minorities and we have no problem with them. By the way, there are also a lot of Arabs who come with us to demonstrations and shout 'Death to the Arabs,' meaning 'death to everyone except me.'" 

    After seeing Lieberman's rise in the polls, after reading this article, I cannot help but conclude that there are fascist winds blowing in Israel. Some winds die out, some gain strength, but that such winds are blowing is no longer in doubt.     

    The article prompted me to cut and paste the above excerpt and email it to my Ayelet, whose daughter now is pen pals with my daughter. Only half jokingly, I commented: "You guys can stay with us if things get really bad."

    I suppose as with most love affairs, you are bound to get your heart broken. I just didn't expect that it would come like this.

    There are now three days left until the election. For me, the election is no longer about war or peace or the Palestinians. It is about the soul of the country I love.    

16 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

How easy life would be if things were black and white. How difficult it is to have your heart broken by the one you love. I cannot heal your heart. But I suggest you are doing the right thing here. (I'm speaking as a therapist.) You are dwelling with the pain. Like Job's friends, sitting with him. I extend my hand, as if I could sit with you too. Mute with the suffering which transcends us both, which transcends all sides in this conflict, those directly involved and those of us who are bystanders. I am reminded of the title of a book by Thomas Merton: "Conjectures of a Guilty Bystander." Yes, even we bystanders can feel guilt. An existential guilt. That people suffer. That so many suffer without cause, without reason.

I personally believe that dwelling with the suffering of others - even in one's heart - does make a difference. On a cosmic level.

Shalom. Peace be with you.

user-pic

Thank you.

user-pic

Why doesn't Israel simply annex Gaza and quit killing those people?? Why can't they just give the Gazans full Israeli citizenship?? Don't the Israelis know that diversity is the very core and strength of a proper society??

Why don't the Israeli's renounce their laws which make illegal intermarriage between Gazans and Israelis?? Don't the Israelis know this is extreme racism?? Do the Israelis all belong to the Klan?? What is wrong with the racist Israelis???

user-pic

Zahav writes about the disturbing political situation in Israel, in particular the increase in racist invective of the right-wing political parties and their call of 'Death to Arabs'.

For me, it is equally disturbing to note that the corruption endemic in Israeli politics continues and that it is possible that a right-wing leader may succeed at the polls, who is being investigated for fraud. This follows, of course, upon the present incumbent who is under investigation for high-level corruption.

This trashes completely the incessant claim by Israel to be the only democracy in the Middle East.

That Israel is a corrupt society is not in question - at least as far as its political class is concerned. Which begs the question as to why anyone would take this forthcoming election seriously. Whatever the outcome, we will be left with a sleazy politician with sticky hands and an ability to bend facts to his or her satisfaction.

That is unfortunately, or even tragically, not to the benefit either of Israel or the Diaspora and both anti-Israel feeling as well as anti-Semitism will continue to rise worldwide.

The solution? Elect a government of integrity and probity that the world can see will make a genuine effort to co-operate with the indigenous peoples of the region so that a peaceful settlement to the conflict can ensue.

The alternative? Nuclear war in the Middle East and the consequential damage to the whole world.

user-pic

It would appear that the Israel of today has grown, sadly, into an utter hypocrisy. Pushing for immigration and minority rights in other countries but denying it in Israel. Encouraging "peace" while committing to violence. The elders that have taught you were raised on the beliefs that caused this.

How can one push for multicultural society and interracial marriage and sex in other place put damn it in his own?

http://www.brusselsjournal.com/node/3764

Not only in France, but in the US as well, they've been doing it for years here.. So much that its almost, wait, is, racist towards whites from Europe.

It seems that there is MUCH more than meets the eye.

Israel manages to pull billions of dollars from the US every year in aid; as much as all other countries receiving aid from the US combined.

Its gotten to the point where I think that a Dictatorship in Israel would stop our (US) support and possibly awaken the Israel government, making them change their ways.

You, with the love for your country and the clear idea of peace and acceptance, should look into this; research and expose the truth. I have been trying for a short while now and Ive been utterly surprised from what I have found, but with my small knowledge of the Jewish culture, its hard for me to understand the reason behind the actions of Israel.

This blog you have here -can- make a difference.

user-pic

Got to admit it always bring a smile to my face, hearing those accusations aout "racism".

May I ask of what two races are you guys talking about, and more spesifically of what specific "race" are the Israelis. Given that they come in all colors and forms, and given that about 60% of them, those who were expelled from Arab and Muslim cuntries, display an external appearence not much different from the people of those countries, I cosider Isrealis to be the most diverse and colorful of all nations. Not to mention the so many different religions and sects characterizing the Isreli view: Bahai, Catholics, Templers, Druz, Orthodox Chritians, Cherques, Ahmedinians, and of course Muslims of all sorts.

Also funny is hearing criticism coming from the US, who still house quite a bunch of those KKK admirers, and who fear for the life of its president just because he is black.

user-pic

Yeah, but in the US we elected a black president. How close is Israel to electing an Arab prime minister?

user-pic

True, after 232 years we elected a black president. As to how long it will take Israel to elect an Arab prime minister -- based on current demographic trends, I would bet the under. For those of you keeping score at home, that's another 171 years.

user-pic

Maybe sooner if he shouts "Death to the Arabs," and promises to deliver.


user-pic

Well it took us nearly 150 years to give women the vote, but I'm not about to argue that every younger country that denies women basic political rights should have a similar grace period . . .

user-pic

Yes it is indeed funny that you would assume me racist and not one who supported barrack obama in the election. Its even funnier since I said nothing about the "race" of Israelis. Im not some KKK, supremest asshat.

Its sad that one who would speak up is automatically assumed a racist or supremest, which, for most people, would throw all credibility out the window.

People like David Horowitz consistently refer to the Holocaust claiming that Arabs are attemting to finish Hitlers "Final Solution," referring to the holocaust gassing. This is not racism?

http://www.terrorismawareness.org/islamic-mein-kampf/

Even though, anyone willing to think for themselves and look at the facts with an open mind would tell that mass extermination did not occur, although slavery did; still horrible. But, due to popular belief and war propaganda making its way into the history books, these people are labeled as holocaust deniers and racists. Then they mysteriously disappear.

Its simple to understand how the US Governments constant backing of Israel has earned the US citizen the hate of the Arab world.

Can anyone explain how the Israeli Gov't deserves billions of dollars from the US while it continues to slaughter out of hate?

user-pic

Funny, but I do not recall any significant black group calling for the white Americans to return to Europe, nor do I have in mind at the moment any nearby black country firing rckets at American cities or blowing up its cafes.

Once again you are confusing a national or ethnic conflict with a racial on. The cnflict in Israel is not between two races - the Jews and Arabs are both Semitic people and if you insist on inserting race into he matter (although I honestly do not see the releveance) - then they are all of the same race.

Since the US does have a conflict with some Arab states - How long do you think it will take for th US to have an Arab president or a Muslim one? Not in quite a while I assume?

user-pic

Worthy post. Mostly unworthy comments.

user-pic

The increasing fascism of youth is a sign of a very troubled society with a very ugly future. In Israel of course the endless war footing and horrific bloody massacres of neighboring people leaves the easily influenced minds of young citizens ripe for the picking of fascist politicians. Just like the American Republicans have profited for generations on the hate they can generate for minorities (black, muslim, hispanic, gay) the Israeli politicians who advance their power by hate are winning the day and with the youth vote, the future. I was so happy in California and the US in general that young people recently voted overwhelmingly for a minority president and for equal rights for gay Americans. It is a good sign here that we are headed in the right direction. Israel needs to quit slaughtering it's neighbors and stealing their land before they turn their children into a Jewish Hitler Youth Corps.

user-pic

the children are just representing what they have taught.

just another obvious sign of what the real israel is like.

even though you still love it.

user-pic

Self-centered talking about themselves yet again.

More of the same, please.

Leave a comment

Zahav

user-pic

Following: 0
Followers: 3

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Chicago

Favorites

  • Favorite Books A Tale of Love and Darkness by Amos Oz

Bio

Lawyer

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address