« Is Michael Savage a closet ... racist? | Bill Bowman's Blog | Michael Savage: The World's Laziest "Ph.D." »

More proof that Glenn Beck is an idiot


Man, but I do love the Internets.

With a couple of clicks on a mouse, you can find out just about anything about anything. Sometimes more than you really wanted to know.

So I'm listening to Glenn Beck on the radio one morning earlier this month, just because. And he's prattling on about how Progressives aren't trying to steer the country toward Socialism, what they really want to impose is a Fascism.

(And he defined Fascism as the government's stripping the people of rights and liberties. As if we hadn't just come through the last eight years of that. Where were your bleatings then, Glenn? Hypocrite.)

And when did this effort start? When Woodrow Wilson was president, says Beck (who, by the way, is sounding a bit unhinged.) Read the New York Times during the time Mussolini came into power in Italy (before he "threw in" with Hitler) and you'll see that American Progressives loved Il Duce, Beck says. They loved him. Loved him.

Frankly, I haven't had the time to check that out yet, but I will.

To offer more proof of the Progressive's love and desire for American Fascism, Beck offered this nugget: He noted that the symbol of Italian Fascism was a group of rods, bound together with a battle axe. The rods, he said, symbolized the people collectively brought together, while the battle axe signified the government, hacking away at anyone who got in its way.

Uh huh.

And then, Beck says, a techie on his television show staff said he recognized the symbol as being used somewhere else. Beck said he did, too, and they put their heads together.

Then, the light went on for the techie (whose dad was a coin collector), and he ran over to the computer and brought up an image of the so-called "Mercury Dime."

Son of a gun! What's on the back but the Fascist symbol!! And, Beck says, his voice getting all dark and creepy, when was the Mercury Dime put into circulation???

1916! When Woodrow Wilson was president!!!

Proof that American Progressives have been hell-bent on Fascism since the time of Wilson, according to Beck.

Beck then exhorted his listeners to Google the Mercury Dime and the Fascist symbol to find out for themselves that what he says is true.

See, Glenn, you should have done that yourself, because I did.

First, about the design. The rods Beck noted are called "fasces," a symbol of ancient Roman law.

From Wikipedia:

Believed to date from Etruscan times, the symbolism of the fasces at one level suggested strength through unity. The bundle of rods bound together symbolizes the strength which a single rod lacks. The axe symbolized the state's power and authority. The ribbons binding the rods together symbolized the state's obligation to exercise restraint in the exercising of that power. The highest magistrates would have their lictors unbind the fasces they carried as a warning if approaching the limits of restraint.

So much for Beck's initial assertion. Let's move on.

Beck suggests some nefarious plan behind the design of the often-misnamed Mercury Dime. (It's actually a representation of the face of Miss Liberty, wearing a winged hat to symbolize freedom of thought. It's actual name is the Winged Hat Dime. But don't let details get in the way of a great conspiracy theory, Glenn.)

And what about the fasces on the coin's reverse? Well, contrary to what batshit crazy Beck would have us believe (this is from BellaOnline):

With the United States impending entry into World War I, the main device on the reverse of the Winged Cap Dime was a warning to the enemies of Liberty and Freedom. It is an ancient Roman 'fasces' wrapped in what appears to be an olive branch. It has been call a representation of the iron fist in a velvet glove. The olive branch is a universal symbol of peace. Within the branches is the 'fasces.' The 'fasces' is an executioner's axe surrounded by staffs and bound together with leather thongs. According to ancient Roman law, this is the symbol of power meaning one can be dispatched mercifully with the blade, or beaten without mercy by the staff. The symbolism of the freedom of thought, peace and the power to defend them are characteristic of the American mindset. It is no wonder that this dime became an icon to the American public that carried them through World War I, the Great Depression, and World War II.

An icon to the American public. I guess they all wanted to be Fascists back then, huh Glenn? Even though the Mussolini wasn't even in power when the coin was minted.

And it seems Beck isn't the first nutjob to imply a link between the dime and Fascism. This is from a 2007 article in Numismatic News:

Among the many false rumors spread about U.S. coins over the years was that the appearance of the "fasces," an ancient Roman symbol of authority, on the Mercury dime (1916-1945) was linked to a secret support of fascism in this country. cm1916b.jpg Why? Well, even though the Mercury dime went into circulation prior to the rise of fascism in Italy under Benito Mussolini, by the 1920s, some began to notice that the fasces, which was by then being used as a symbol of fascism, also appeared on the back of the U.S. dime. "Anyone who denounces Mussolini for the adoption of a battle-ax as the symbol of the Fascisti, says Representative Sol Bloomsays, better take a look at our dime," wrote the Chicago Evening Post in 1926. In 1936, a letter sent to the chairman of the House Committee on Coinage, Weights and Measures (reproduced in the October 1936 issue of The Numcm1916A.jpgismatist, the monthly publication of the American Numismatic Association), warned that: "The fasces, which is the emblem of Fascism, the present form of government in Italy, strangely enough appears on the reverse of our dime. Although it appears on this coinage as early as 1916, and although it was not adopted by Mussolini and his followers until 1919, future world historians delving into the past through numismatics, as is often the custom, are liable to draw the conclusion that the United States and not Italy was the birthplace of fascism." For the artist's part, Adolph Weinman, whose coinage designs reflected the mood of the nation as it faced the possibility of entry into World War I, the fasces on the dime's reverse were "to symbolize the strength which lies in unity, while the battle-ax stands for preparedness to defend the Union. The branch of olive is symbolical of our love of peace."

You're lazy, Glenn. Lazy and batshit crazy. What a way to live.

Keep the faith.

_________________________________________

Looking for a good read? Try my book, "Savage Lies: The Distortions, Half-Truths and Outright Lies of a Right-Wing Blowhard." The book -- which Savage fans love to hate -- deconstructs the "facts" presented by radio talk show host Michael Savage in his first three books, and is available at Amazon.com.


39 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

This another great one. When THEY lie, THEY should be confronted, point by point.

As I keep pointing out Media Matters got a bug up its jammies about rush. And so they have somebody taking three hours a day to listen to the mad hatter. And everyday for a couple of weeks, the quotes are incredible. And it is important work.
It is a dirty job, but somebody has to do it. ha

So good job. You have a stronger stomach than I do to watch this demagogue. Lazy and batshit crazy. hahahahaahahahahaha

user-pic

And this is worse than a lie, it is a fabricated myth, intended not only to deceive, but to foment violent and primal fears.

It is a MALICIOUS LIE, which seems to be Glenn Boy's latest M.O. If you can't rile em' with inuendo and implication, then you resort to malicious lies. YHe may lose another layer of listeners, but those he has encapsulated just burrow deeper into this new phenomenon of shared social stupidity, "Beckian ignorance." It is a symptom shared by "Beck's Blowhards" who we now read all across the net.

And they are so easy to spot, they reliably regurgitate Beck's vomit verbatim.

user-pic

Timely post, synching nicely with my own ruminations on Beck-drivel. Of course, what Glenn doesn't bother to mention in his weepy fulminations is fascism's obsessive preoccupation with violent social Darwinism -- a preoccupation bubbling just below the surface of the wingnuts' grab-a-gun-and-man-the-barricades bloviating.

According to historian Robert Paxton fascism is:

a form of political behavior marked by obsessive preoccupation with community decline, humiliation or victimhood and by compensatory cults of unity, energy and purity, in which a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites, abandons democratic liberties and pursues with redemptive violence and without ethical or legal restraints goals of internal cleansing and external expansion.

Hmm. I hadn't considered this angle; I was thinking of the less outwardly violent but no less benign form being practiced here in South Carolina by our monochromatic, proto-libertarian governor and his tea-bagging minions. But no matter. If the shoe fits, Glenn, wear it -- no matter how bad it smells.

user-pic

"a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites,"

Sounds like The Teabaggers and The Wall Street Book-Cookers...

History certainly does repeat itself.

user-pic

Who's Glenn Beck? Not a hero like Rachel Maddow is my guess.
Am I (((((((illuminated))))))) ?

user-pic

Who is Rachel Maddow?

user-pic

((((yikes)))) A scary guy my mother used to make me watch on t.v. instead of cartoons. I don't know anything about this Glen Beck or the Hero (n) Rachel Maddow. Mayber they're both just worthless.

user-pic

Rachel is smarter than three of you put together.

user-pic

You needed proof?

user-pic

Please take a look at C-SPAN when they are broadcasting the House of Representatives session. When the camera is showing the Speakers podium take a look at the symbols on the wall behind the podium. There are 2 HUGE "fasces" on either side and they have been there as long as I can remember.

BECK is a "Moeron" of the highest order and has maybe, just maybe he has actually lost it.

user-pic

Beck, O'Reilly, Maddow, Olbermann, etc, are all there to sell commercial airtime for their respective TV networks.

Each one of them wants to make a living and the size of their personal income is directly proportional to the size of the audience viewing their tabloid TV.

user-pic

Anyone who can put Beck, Orielly, Maddow and Olbermann in the same category of journalistic intent needs a brain transplant, and preferably an upgrade.

You are comparing truth warriors to liemakers, as if their commercial constraints are the only factor.

Simplistic, misleading and indicative of an undetermined, if not infantile political creed.

Go ahead, tell us who IS worthy.

user-pic

What, we need more proof? How about a post listing more reasons why the sun rises in the morning? LOL.

Glenn Beck truly is batshit crazy. You can't really say that about the rest of the nasty little freaks in the wingnutosphere -- sneaky, mean, ugly to be sure, but not crazy. Beck has that vacant hysterical look in his eye that says "don't make eye contact! step away very slowly!".

user-pic

Glenn Beck is just nuts with his comparison of progressives to Nazi's. I can't stand listening to his whiny voice. He is an angry nutcase and he shouldn't be on the air.

user-pic

Glenn Beck is showing himself more and more to be the idiot that he truly is.

Glenn Beck Is An Idiot!

www.glennbeckisanidiot.com

user-pic

I was just watching Glenn Beck and realized that he is such a moron. This guy is so far out there that I think he really belives some of the crap that comes out of his mouth. He is a FEAR MONGER.
People need to realize this guy is never right about anything he comments on. I dont know who is worse Glenn Beck or Sean Hannity....

user-pic

I can't watch him... I throw things at the TV. Whatever is handy.

If there's one idiot I'd like to make a blow-up of and sell it for people to throw shoes at, it's Beck.

But there's more than one of those idiots.

There's a great fundraiser; sell old shoes along with a Beck pinup...

user-pic

Beck is the reason I quit watching CNN. I used to tune in now and then, just to get more than one perspective, until Beck came aboard.

Seriously, Dobbs helped push me permanently off their viewer list, but Beck was the one who really sealed that deal. Their constant promotion of Beck as their own FOXhead emulation reeked of shameless greed. It is more than appropriate that Beck's been sent to the second level of Ailes hell.

I have Fox blocked, so now Beck isn't a problem.

My TV is safe again from the tomatoes, shoes and bookends that once threatened it's very existence whenever I stumbled onto one of Beck's outrageous rants.

user-pic

One other thing that wasn't pointed out by commenters or in the article...the fasces, which is where we get the word fascism from, is also a centerpiece in the House of Representatives. Not sure if that is an original decoration or if ti was added later.

user-pic

"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the Flag and carrying the Cross."
--Sinclair Lewis

Now which "side" does that sound more like? The fault, Glenn, is not in the stars but in yourself.

user-pic

May I humbly paraphraze Lewis;
"When fascism came to America, it was wrapped in the Flag and carrying the Cross."

Think Joe McCarthy and Jerry Falwell as two good examples.

There are many similar combination that illustrates what has ALREADY HAPPENED. Whatever evil influence we routed from Europe in WW2 found a new home in our Republican-managed military industrial complex.

Fascism in it's contemporary definition is just another word for monopolism, what I might call "totalitarian market economists." They constantly try to tell us they are capitalists, even as they buy our government from us to protect their market monopolies.

user-pic

Beck should know that the Junior ROTC program during the 1970s was a fascist organization as well - I received a medal (for best GPA in the cadet corps, IIRC) that had a pair of fasces on the obverse.

user-pic

While Beck is an idiot who couldn't pour piss out of a boot even if the instructions were written on the bottom of the heel he may be the epitome of the blind pig finding an acorn.

Wiki: Palmer Raids

Labor and political tensions were already high before the beginning of World War I, with government repression of radical left-wing political groups beginning even before American entry into the war. But after a series of labor conflicts and violence - including bomb attacks of court buildings, police stations, churches, and homes of government officials attributed by the authorities to violent immigrant anarchist groups - the Department of Justice and its small Bureau of Investigation (BOI) (predecessor to the FBI) had begun to track their activities with the approval of President Woodrow Wilson.
In 1916, Wilson warned of:
"Hyphenated Americans (who) have poured the poison of disloyalty into the very arteries of our national life. Such creatures of passion, disloyalty and anarchy must be crushed out."
. Hmm 'hyphenated Americans'. Sounds like it would be pretty hard to shove a Mercury dime between Wilson and Lou Dobbs in his CNN days.
On June 15, 1917, Congress passed the Espionage Act. The law set punishments for actions interpreted as acts of interference in foreign policy and espionage - including many activities that would be seen by contemporary standards as dissent, such as the publication of magazines critical of the government. The act authorized stiff fines and prison terms of up to 20 years for anyone who obstructed the military draft or encouraged "disloyalty" against the U.S. government. After two anarchist radicals, Emma Goldman and Alexander Berkman, continued to advocate against conscription, Goldman's offices at Mother Earth were thoroughly searched, and volumes of files and detailed subscription lists from Mother Earth, along with Berkman's journal The Blast, were seized. As a Justice Department news release reported:
A wagon load of anarchist records and propaganda material was seized, and included in the lot is what is believed to be a complete registry of anarchy's friends in the United States. A splendidly kept card index was found, which the Federal agents believe will greatly simplify their task of identifying persons mentioned in the various record books and papers. The subscription lists of Mother Earth and The Blast, which contained around 10,000 names, were also seized.
And equally hard to shove that dime between the 1918 Espionage Act and the Patriot Act.

Luckily Wilson was committed to the principle of democracy. Because that was about the only thing that prevented America under the likes of Attorney General Palmer and starting in 1919 J. Edgar Hoover from crossing the bounds to what would be known as Fascism

In 1919, J. Edgar Hoover was put in charge of a new division of the Justice Department's Bureau of Investigation, the General Intelligence Division. By October 1919, Hoover's division had collected 150,000 names in a rapidly expanding index. Using this information, starting on November 7, 1919, BOI agents, together with local police, orchestrated a series of well-publicized and violent raids against suspected "radicals" and foreigners, using the Espionage Act of 1917 and the Sedition Act of 1918. Palmer and his agents were accused of using torture and other illegal methods of obtaining intelligence, including informers and wiretaps
I'll bet a $100 that Beck has not a single clue about the particulars of the political events on each side of WWI, but that doesn't mean there weren't some rotten acorns lying around at the time.

user-pic

Beck's "acorn" is a poison pill.

Because while he may rightly recognize a movement of fascist-style political corruption to our country in the 20th Century, he fails to point out it is his own political heroes of the right, not "The Left", who picked up that power-mongering infection.

It is the right wingers who and have been driven by that power-hunger infection to create unspoken, government-protected monopolies that far outstrip the kinds of "trusts" Roosevelt broke up a century ago in their pernicious prevention of healthy competition.

(Think "industrial hemp, for one obvious example.)

Beck may have stumbled onto an acorn, but he's become a blind, babbling, blubbering tool of those who are most guilty of the ideological sins he seems so concerned with.

user-pic

Am I missing something, or isn't "supply side economics" something of a toehold into fascism, if not a whole foot in the door?

user-pic

And, in an earlier reference, couldn't Eisenhower's admonition to "guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence ... by the military/industrial complex" be quite easily translated into "we must guard against fascist influences gaining power here in the USA."

I don't pose these just to pprovoke argument, to me it seems we have been warned repeatedly, by some of our most reliable and non-partisan heroes, about the impending fascist influence.

Maybe Eisenhower called it a "complex influence" rather than "fascist power", but a rose by any other name could never stink any worse.

user-pic

Actually, it's even more sinister than Beck thinks. The axe and the rods ... the axe and the rods ... hmmmm ... where can we find the axe and the rods today??? Hmmm That's it!!! In the West Wing: David Axelrod: "top political advisor to President Obama. Oh my God!!! The Fascists have taken over!!!

user-pic

Please take a look at C-SPAN when they are broadcasting the House of Representatives session. When the camera is showing the Speakers podium take a look at the symbols on the wall behind the podium. There are 2 HUGE "fasces" on either side and they have been there as long as I can remember.
Thanks
seo service india

user-pic

Glenn Beck is just nuts with his comparison of progressives to Nazi's. I can't stand listening to his whiny voice. He is an angry nutcase and he shouldn't be on the air.
Thanks
Make money

user-pic

I was just watching Glenn Beck and realized that he is such a moron. This guy is so far out there that I think he really belives some of the crap that comes out of his mouth. He is a FEAR MONGER.Thanks
free online dating

user-pic


Glenn Beck is just nuts with his comparison of progressives to Nazi's. I can't stand listening to his whiny voice. He is an angry nutcase and he shouldn't be on the air.
Thanks
garden treasures gazebo

Facebook

Please take a look at C-SPAN when they are broadcasting the House of Representatives session. When the camera is showing the Speakers podium take a look at the symbols on the wall behind the podium. There are 2 HUGE "fasces" on either side and they have been there as long as I can remember.
shoe storage

Facebook

Glenn Beck is just nuts with his comparison of progressives to Nazi's. I can't stand listening to his whiny voice. He is an angry nutcase and he shouldn't be on the air.Thanks
Paradise In-Home Care

Facebook

I'll bet a $100 that Beck has not a single clue about the particulars of the political events on each side of WWI, but that doesn't mean there weren't some rotten acorns lying around at the time. Thank you
outdoor dining furniture

user-pic

Just watching Glenn Beck and realized that he is such a moron. This guy is so far out there that I think he really belives some of the crap that comes out of his mouth
London Escorts

Facebook

Please take a look at C-SPAN when they are broadcasting the House of Representatives session. When the camera is showing the Speakers podium take a look at the symbols on the wall behind the podium. There are 2 HUGE "fasces" on either side and they have been there as long as I can remember.
Thanks
swimwear

Facebook

Please take a look at C-SPAN when they are broadcasting the House of Representatives session. When the camera is showing the Speakers podium take a look at the symbols on the wall behind the podium. There are 2 HUGE "fasces" on either side and they have been there as long as I can remember.Thanks
Cocktails

Facebook

I was just watching Glenn Beck and realized that he is such a moron. This guy is so far out there that I think he really belives some of the crap that comes out of his mouth. He is a FEAR MONGER.Thanks
Hugo Boss Jeans

Facebook

Glenn Beck?? "The Man is nuts! Grab em!"

Leave a comment

Bill Bowman

user-pic

Following: 40
Followers: 28

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Website: www.bbowman.net
  • Location Central New Jersey
  • Party Not as often as I used to
  • Politics I call myself a pragmatic Progressive. Idealism of my youth tempered a bit by life experience.

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs theopinionmill.com | talkingpointsmemo.com | mediamatters.org
  • Favorite Books Any of the Spencer novels by Robert B. Parker | Les Miserables by Victor Hugo | Anything by Lawrence Sanders | Anything by Elmore Leonard | Anything by Raymond Chandler | "Savage Lies: The Half-Truths, Distortions and Outright Lies of a Right-Wing Blowhard by ... me!
  • Favorite Quotes "Let them call me rebel, and welcome, I feel no concern from it! For I should suffer the misery of devils were I to make a whore of my soul." Thomas Paine.

Bio

I’m a journalist working at the New Jersey Shore but based in Central New Jersey, where I live with my wife and our dog and cat. During my career, I've been responsible for two pieces of legislation enacted in New Jersey: one that allowed every fire department and fire academy in New Jersey to receive, free, a thermal imaging camera, and the second, which created a searchable Web database through which consumers could research nursing homes and their owners, and have access to reports of violations and other information. My reporting also led to the requirement that Supreme, Superior and Tax Court justices and judges file the same kind of financial disclosure forms as every other elected and appointed official in New Jersey. I was also part of a two-reporter team that exposed massive increases in the cost to close the U.S. Army's Fort Monmouth. I have also written a book, “Savage Lies: The Half-Truths, Distortions and Outright Lies of a Right-Wing Blowhard,” which deconstructs the first three books written by right-wing talk radio host Michael Savage. The book is available at Amazon.com, Barnesandnoble.com and can be ordered wherever books are sold.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address