urban policy wonk's Blog | A History Lesson »

The Content of History


I originally posted this as a comment, in response to Bernard Avishai's article, The Content of His Character.


I appreciate the pragmatism in this piece by Avishai. I understand the sentiment that, while it's great we finally got around to electing a minority to high office, there are much larger immediate issues at stake, and there were countless better reasons to vote Obama into the White House than anything to do with the color of his skin. I do appreciate that.

But, look. There will be plenty of time for such pragmatism.

Quite frankly, the "well it's about time" attitude, and the notion that if Cosby and Oprah and Tiger can win popularity contests, it only stands to reason that, ho hum, we're bound to elect a black president one of these days too, are a deep and profound insult to the moment at hand.

Fifty years from now, a hundred years from now, there will have been many mundane details already filled in. But what will stand out, what our children, our grandchildren, our great-grandchildren, will highlight in their history lessons and commit to memory, is what happened yesterday.

I'm white and privileged, born and raised in a comfortable middle-class suburban setting. But I do know a little about the historical weight of this moment in the story of America. I have not borne its often iniquitous burdens and legacies. But I do know enough of it to know that this moment in that story is nothing to be diminished, for any reason.

Witness the streaming tears of ecstatic disbelief, the joyous celebrations all across the country. The last eight years notwithstanding, this is not the stuff of presidential election results. This is something different. This is something momentous, in a much broader scheme of things than whatever the next presidential term or two will bear witness to.

Yes, of course it was bound to happen sooner or later. But it happened now. Right now. We should not make haste to lose sight of this moment and what it means.



2 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Avishai's post, prominently featured on the front page, was really just silly. It's what I call linear logic, that is Avishai basically asserted that one could not recognize the historical significance of President-Elect Obama's victory without detracting from the man's fundamental qualifications to be president. Oy. It was a ridiculous thesis and I'm glad you posted this and I hope it gets the attention it deserves today.

user-pic

Agreed, Bslev.

Leave a comment

urban policy wonk

user-pic

Following: 1
Followers: 3

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address