Hardly Worth the Effort
Why recommend posts? So they can be shared. But they still go away too fast. I don't feel much incentive to say something requiring much thought or research.
We went from recommended blogs staying up permanently, blocking progress, to having them drop away after 24 hrs., which I feel is way too short. Drive-by commenting achieves little. Why be just another blog?
Jim Sleeper had this to say: "Probably the greatest downside of posting, even on a blogsite like TPM, is that we lose the sense of an ongoing conversation that might actually build on its insights."
I can often remember the title of a post I liked, or at least an approximation of it, but am less likely to remember a random username like turtle1234. So search is out. One is reduced to wading through the archives.
Sleeper also said: "One can't expect anyone who comments on a current post to have checked the earlier ones, right here in TPM, on the same subject, in the past couple of weeks. But that's what makes blog comments a big cut below actual deliberation or even just conversation."
It used to be easy to know where a conversation stood. A small fix might be to have a list of users. A name would look familiar, and one could go to that user's blog. Another incentive would be the chance to end up on the front page of the Cafe. That would hold position, only being pushed down by new guest contributor posts.
I've found some perceptive and stylish writing by readers here, in the old days, and several now. But the good writers are not being rewarded.




