« mcShame campaign in a Nutshell - Update and Commentary | TheraP's Blog | Widening Gap between Rich and Poor: US cities now compare to African cities »

Obama: Transformational - but How?


So many people have referred to Obama as "transformational."  This was happening already in the Primaries. When it was mocked at times.  Now I'm seeing this more and more.  Powell referred to Obama as transformational.  And I've seen this as well in some of the newspaper endorsements this week.  The term is becoming associated with the essence of Obama.  No longer mocked. 

I'm wondering what this means to people.  To you.  To me.  It seems to address a quality in the man.  But also a quality in the man's ability to impact others.  To inspire.  To draw from us our better selves.

This thread is an invitation to search your heart and soul:  How is Obama a transformational figure?  For you.  For us.   The nation.  The world.  How do we see  this man?  And how is that "experience" transformational?

49 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Another graceful note from the grace note!

For me, it's how he talks about his ideas. One of my favorite aspects of The Audacity of Hope is that he looks at multiple sides of issues in a positive way before establishing his own position. It's a politics that at least acts as though it wants to gather the best of all ideas, rather than sticking with its own.

user-pic

Here are my thoughts. As it turns out they are in reverse order of likihood that it will happen; His supreme transformation would be to bring the country together again - no red and blue, just American. He would be a transformation in racial terms just by being in the WH, which, I believe, would make a much larger difference in racial attitudes if he did well in the office. I believe he will be able to transform the damaged image of this country and will restore honor to our name.

user-pic

Thera, do you think it's explained in part that we are at last ready for some sort of actual transformation? By that I mean if there's a group, then the group's readiness has gelled.

There's still a great deal of uncomfortable, heated discussion about how we all behave, how we exhibit/don't exhibit tolerance or predjudice towards each other, just within the TPM community or in the campaigns of both major camps in this election. The heat is still there (especially in the candidates' camps out "there") but in the comments I visit here I think I am picking up more and more recognition and acknowledgment of common ground amongst opposing views on the issues expressed.

Granted, perhaps that is only over recent days and weeks.

But there has been an increasing sense of coming together across the country as well, don't you think, over the past several months? Palpable? I am a bit scared to say it, because my superstitions aren't completely quieted.

And, yes, I do think that Barack is responsible for it because it's been his focus for so long before it became ours. So, a coming together of the intention and passion on his part and on ours. What do you think?

Been waiting such a L-o-n-g time!

user-pic

I think I agree with you. Yes, I think we're ready. And in thread a few days ago, I mentioned this zen saying that "when the disciple is ready, the teacher appears." And so I think that may be part of it. And yes, I too am sensing change occurring here on this site and hopefully within the country.

But what is it about Obama? That's what I'm after in putting up this thread.

And it's lovely to see what others are already saying here, including you.

Yes... such a L-o-n-g time waiting...

user-pic

For me, Barack Obama is transformational in that he represents the union of logic and caring in a way that is seldom seen in American politics. A politician's true mission should be to address the needs of the electorate in ways that are satisfying to the heart and the head simultaneously. To err too much on one side or the other creates discomfort and anger. It is a difficult balance and one which strikes different personality types in different ways, i.e., those who find him too "cool" and hunger for more passion.

McCain right now is trying to appeal purely to emotion in a way that is completely inauthentic to his core values, assuming he has any, thus it comes off as creepy and most people are rejecting it, thus the failure of the Ayers tactic. Unfortunately, the rhetoric catches fire for those who are receptive to it, but then there is the counterreaction of disgust from those who reject such transparently cynical charges.

I find myself feeling sorry for the "undecided" voters, especially those who are struggling with racism. At its heart I believe this election is a struggle between love and hate, the past and the future, between education and ignorance, thus Barack Obama's transformational quality is to appeal to the best within us, while simultaneously refusing to malign his opposition in all the ways that it would be so easy to do, and so tempting for a lesser mortal.

user-pic

Here is one personal example - a female campaign canvasser was assaulted by a person whose house she went to in WI. He punched her in the face and pulled her hair.

http://www.journaltimes.com/articles/2008/10/19/local_news/doc48fa891c6397b889391842.txt

Obama called her personally to comfort and reassure her. That is leadership, compassion and one reason Barack is transformtional. He is a human being who cares deeply first and foremost.

user-pic

Here is a link to a great music video and great line describing this man is that "we need a President that understands interconnecteness".

"A Brighter Day"

http://www.politicalbase.com/profile/jnail/blog/&blogId=4940

user-pic

What is it about Obama? He leads by example. He is the change he wants to see in the world, to paraphrase Gandhi. He has shown confidence and wisdom and has kept himself centered and focused. He's shown the way for the rest of us to do the same although I have to confess it's been hard for me to keep my cool at times.

I can't say I feel it coming together across the country, though. I live in a completely red state where there is no hope of seeing purple much less blue. I'm still very nervous.

user-pic

I entered a doctoral program of Leadership Studies in the summer of 1989. At that time the definitive book about Leadership was by Burns, 1978. I suppose it's still the "bible" on the subject. The words "transformational leadership" were new to me and my colleagues. The concepts of leadership fostered a vigorous study in the areas of business, organizations, sociology, psychology, and education -- areas where we were enlightening a whole new generation of leaders. The idea that we could change the world by being change agents; that we could flatten the organization (Peters); that we could be leaders and not managers; that we could be moral in our actions and plans for our employees and followers; that we could bring service and community into the world as viable aspects of any organization -- quite an amazing set of ideals for leaders to embrace. And maybe this study was a step before its time, although we worked through several non-profits organizations in small ways to bring about as much change as we could in those early years.

I must say, Barack Obama is the first transformational leader I have followed since I read Burns. The minute I heard him speak in Boston, I turned to my husband and said, "You just heard the first African American president of the United States." Actually, he could have been purple and the outcome would have been the same -- he has transformational leadership qualities that those of us who study leadership have been attempting to define all these many years. It's not just charisma, although that's a part of the picture. For example,I can see he knows that we, the followers, want viable renewal energy -- especially for transportation; so he will speak, he will move us to action as he states the "in ten years we will" program initiatives, and we will jump to perform and involve ourselves in that dream. I can see that.. and much more.

Obama is not a bureaucrat or a transactional leader. He will not lead from the top down; he firmly believes in the value of others' opinions and ideas. And by his example, Obama is a moral leader -- one who leads with strength and does not use power to take down his opposition, but uses power to build up his followers.

Most of what makes a good leader is the relationship between his or her followers and him or herself. We notice the nuances and the intelligence with which Obama struggles for answers. He isn't locked into one way to proceed. He listens, he asks, and he is not afraid to be his own person. Followers can trust that he will consider them in his decisions. And his decisions and actions will bring his followers along on the journey.

What we have missed in the last eight years, among other attributes of leadership, is the connection of leader to follower -- of openness, inclusion, consideration, communication, and inspiration.

Transformation is a two way street. We can see the best of ourselves in Barack Obama and he can see the best of himself in us. And together, we really can change the country, if not the world, one step at a time.

user-pic

Fantastic discussion Dr Zee. I got into a much simpler version of that leadership versus managing philosophy and it has not let me down. I hear it in the idea of 'enlightened self interest' as a way of running companies in recent years.

I think some of my thought has been alluded to elsewhere. I expected this 'perfect storm' of problems to surface during my lifetime - when I was a teenager in the late '60's. The consequences of our overpopulation, overconsumption, pollution and religious dogma was inevitably going to create big problems nationally and globally.

So the people have finally awakened to the reality and someone who sensed his capacity to coalesce that awareness and organize it into a functional movement came forward.

What has happened, and what will follow, will go down in history as one of the most transformational periods in human history, or as an opportunity that we did not take full advantage of.

user-pic

I think Obama is transformational because he represents to us what we as a country could be and what we will reflect to the rest of the world if he is elected.

Valuers and preservers of our laws and constitution v. perpetrators of unjust wars, executive branch immunity, and domestic espionage.

Fair-minded, intelligent listeners v. stubborn, unblinking deniers.

Respecters and protectors of human rights across the world v. torturers refusing the-innocent-until-proven-guilty trials.

If Obama is elected, I hope we give education and science a chance to prosper us.

I hope we give economic and racial justice/equality a chance to prosper every American, especially ignored rural towns and inner-cities.

Here is what I hope, paraphrased from a recent song about Obama by MC Yogi:

Ladies and gentlemen, beautiful intelligent
friends of all ages, races and measurements
US citizens, worldwide residents
whatever your religion is or sexual preference

There's no separateness, there's one thing connecting us
that's the planet we inhabit plus all its different elements
that's the reason why we need a new President
someone who understands interconnectedness

And won't go to war based on false evidence
who's not addicted to oil and aggressiveness
who believes in global warming and will fight pollution
instead of shredding and abusing our constitution

Let's get involved and offer all our contributions
Vote for hope, join the movement of this revolution
A brighter day will come
A brighter day will come

Change comes when we believe
in a brighter day a better way to succeed
together we can make it better, you and me
together we can be safe, prosperous, and free
...

We gotta make it happen- time for some action
it don't matter if you're black, white, Asian, Latin
We gotta vote for hope and steer clear of fear
Regardless of the garbage they put in our ears

Talking heads on the radio, television
spinning the facts, treating us like we're little children
but even with the propaganda they can't stop us can they?
Because we know in our souls that we're gonna stand up

And let our voices be heard word to the people
let's make sure this election is fair and equal
no more illegal war, dying on a distant shore
that's the reason why Obama's who we're voting for

"There is not a liberal America and a conservative America, there is the United States of America. There is not a black America and a white America, a Latino America, an Asian America, there is the United States of America."
-----------

Throughout the song, he splices quotes from Obama's 2004 DNC speech and Obama saying the words, "Safe, prosperous and free." It made me cry the first time I heard it- Obama reading our constitution: all people created equal, with the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. He then says that is God's greatest gift to us, the true genius of America.


user-pic

" . . . all people created equal, with the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."

That is not in the Constitution.

user-pic

Sorry- Declaration of Independence. :)

user-pic

P.S. That is the same song referenced above by J. Nail.

user-pic

Well, on that point I can't defend his merits because that will lead to argmentation for sure.

It's time for the man and the movement, you know? It can't be luck. God, can I say this? He's just the right person for this time. That is what I think needs to be explained by someone and I'd like your opinion, Thera.

Because it's not all about his race. And it's not all about his intellect- at least not in the sense of Adlai Stevenson "eggheadedness"- and A.S. was a good man. And it's not about his being a product of the American culture because so many are wont to say he absolutely isn't that! I don't think it's about his wonderful good looks, though that may be part of what bothers his opponent. (Hint: Palin seemed good looking and charming at the time she was picked. And to some the Maverick in charge seemed brilliant then.)

Maybe it's his tolerance of things we all ought to tolerate a lot more than we are able? You can't find much of THAT in the opposition and if this sounds like circular argument, notice how McBlame carps against doing something and then does it himself. OK, enough about him.

Maybe it's his forebearance. This guy has a lot of 'self' control! Isn't that the main reason I just plain preferred him to Hillary in the primaries? I think so. And I must say I've LIKED her a lot more since she's lost the need to grate and rasp at us.

And his considered judgement. You just know he's going to seek opinion from experts and use his smarts to review it, he's going to think before he acts.

For lack of better phrasing I want to say his heart is in the right place- but you know what? it sounds like hero worship. Yet I do think that. And maybe Michelle has a good deal to do with nurturing his heart and his good ideas. I like her a lot too. :)

We can have a lot of Hope now. Let's not forget that we can also be responsible.

user-pic

For me, it’s his overall demeanor.

Transformational is a relative term for me.

The American people have longing for a charismatic PERSONALITY. We’ve had such leaders in the past. Clinton, Reagan, Kennedy, FDR.

As Colin Powell basically said, Obama is for this generation.

To me, Obama is inspiring and in a time of self-reflection and seeing the failures of the last decade. We are fortunate that at this moment, he has a message of hope and has the ability to move others to not despair, but inspires us to turn around, and be saved from our errors.

I believe it’s due to his Christian heritage; he seems to be guided by this strength. The power it supplies. He has put on the personality of his faith.

(Colossians 3:6-10) . . .On account of those things the wrath of God is coming. 7 In those very things YOU, too, once walked when YOU used to live in them. 8 But now really put them all away from YOU, wrath, anger, badness, abusive speech, and obscene talk out of YOUR mouth. 9 Do not be lying to one another. Strip off the old personality with its practices, 10 and clothe yourselves with the new [personality], which through accurate knowledge is being made new according to the image of the One who created it,

Did you notice on CNN, Obama walks past his security detail, and enters the SUV, and then he peeks his head out the door, and with a big smile on his face he looks into the camera, as if to say, Thank you and I really look forward to being on your side.

To me that captured the essence of who he is as a person, Humble as compared to self-assuming.

user-pic

People have brought up many good examples of Obama's person and character as being "transformational", but how about his campaign and their utilization of the Internet and grassroots and guerilla marketing to create the most formidable fundraising and community-networking machines in the history of the world.

That's transformational. They get it. He gets it.

user-pic

We have seen and we have heard, about the one they call OBAMA, and his message of hope. Let us help him.

No I'm not implying he's some messiah.

But it is not a new phenomenon, of how people, react when they find a cause, they can believe in and then back it up with action. It is like a ministry to some.

Knowing that Obama is not perfect, should not mean that we shouldn’t strive to make others lives better.

Obama applies the principle: “The greatest among you will be your servant. For whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted.” (Matthew 23:11-12)

Unlike McCain, who reminds us of his scars, as though that grants him the right to exalt himself.

Obama displays no wrath, anger, badness, or abusive speech, those qualities recommend themselves to our consideration.

user-pic

Hard to pin down cause and effect at the start of Obama's campaign, because we have to start in Springfield, Illinois, or Hyde Park, Chicago, or Harvard.

But we can point to his awareness of opportunity, and his careful use of it, which imply exquisite judgement. He was offered a book contract after he took over the Law Review. He used the opportunity with deliberation and care, eventually yielding up a fine book. He chose an avocation that would both achieve results and give him opportunities to learn, when he went into community organizing.

He used opportunity when he took care to have an excellent speech at the convention. He was deliberate about developing a campaign organization (the community organizer!).

All this adds up to many people with a stake in his success. How does that percolate through the operation, the country, the media? His administration will have, aside from the hate of a small faction, the warm wishes and actual, on the ground, efforts of millions of people.

That's a transformation. It approaches a revolution.

user-pic

It is so moving to read these comments. You're bringing tears to my eyes, people! I'm so glad I put this up as way for all of us to share ourselves and our experience of Obama and our hopes and dreams that he inspires us to speak aloud.

If you haven't read it, this essay by Alice Waters in The Guardian voices what some of you have referred to - a leader who loves us:

What our country desperately needs is a leader who loves us

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2008/sep/20/uselections2008.barackobama

John Nail refers to this. And thegirlfromoklahoma gives us the poem. But others seem to be moving in the same direction.

I can't help but think that Obama is like a good therapist. Who genuinely cares. And wants to empower the person to be him or her best self. But I've honestly never seen it in an American leader before. Not even JFK had this.

I appreciate the long explanation of Dr. Zee as well.

Please, weigh in here. Let's have more thoughts. This is so beautiful!

user-pic

He will transform us from the 43rd presidency to the 44th presidency, and hopefully implement some good policies along the way.

user-pic

And if he does, I for one will be quite happy.

user-pic

You asked for it TheraP...

First of all having studied typologies, he has some rare, innate, natural leadership skills that help him to launch such a successful, large-scale campaign, to choose such competent people to work with him and to be a reflection of his values and wisdom in running a campaign. He is able to sense a great deal about a person and this allows him to see how that person might serve or how he might serve that person.
He has reached a higher level of consciousness than most americans and he has learned the skill to be gracious and caring in how he engages others, accepting the responsbility of what it means to be better able to 'respond'.

When you reach a certain level of development you develop the real capacity to love everyone and to understand as Ken Wilber says' the human brain is incapable of being 100% wrong' and therefor everyone is bringing 'some' truth and perspective that has value.

He has learned to integrate perspectives, include paradoxes, instead of simply being polarized by them...(at least he has demonstrated this capacity even if it is not constant).

He sincerely desires to serve and I feel certain that he is fighting hard to become our president because he can truly see that he is the best person for the job at this time. I asked him to run as I am sure many of you did. And my sense is he said yes to becoming our president
not to serve himself... but because we needed him.

The first time I saw him and heard him speak on Cspan I saw all of these things about him and I literally thought 'I wish this man was our president'. I went to my computer and wrote to him to ask him to run. I mean when does something like that happen?? It never happened to me before. I don't want to get too over the top about this and much of this I generally keep to myself because I think my understanding might not be too helpful to the general electorate.

I have been very blessed in my life to have worked for Ken Wilber and sat with many, many spiritual teachers from around the world of a variety of persuasions and levels of devlopment.
One of the strongest things I can say is that Senator Obama has the capacity to transcend polarities... including democrat and republican. I am not talking about reaching across the aisle. I am talking about being able to hold the perspectives of all varieties within the polarity of 'liberal' and 'conservative'. This is very powerful because it will allow new solutions and truth to arise.

There is a point in our growth where we have learned enough that we just have to be present in the moment to know how to handle any given situation. The 'rules' and 'exceptions' are then only guidelines to apply. This frees one to make the most appropriate decision in the moment rather than sticking to a particular framework of belief.

Example, I was at a talk with a spiritual teacher and KW and a member of the audience said, 'how do I know when to serve, how to serve'.
The teacher replied 'you must be present in the moment to know'. The teacher continued 'for example in one moment it may be appropriate to give $1 to 100 men and in another it may be most appropriate to give $100 to one man. To know what to do requires the ability to be fully present in your heart, mind, body, and soul and to know your personal desires separate from what is best for all and to be able to put all of this together in your decision.

Senator Obama is not a messiah or super natural person but he is more evolved than many and this is where we are heading as human beings. And honestly, it is very natural for those who are farthest away from his level of development to find him threatening, confusing, and hard to understand or relate to. They are sincerely living according to belief structures that make sense to them and to many of them he is as foreign as an alien and they can't explain why that is so. This is why compassion, while still being vigilant, with those who are the most afraid and most angry is appropriate. For those in our country who are closer to Senator Obama's level of development of course we can relate to him, we are relieved by his awareness and flexibility, it is much easier and more natural for us to trust him.

And honestly just the possiblity of President Obama demonstrates to me that we can trust. We must be active, and vigilant but who could be more perfect to help our country at a time like this, than Senator Obama... and he's asking for the job. How perfect.

As he has said... he is very fortunate because here is a leader ready to serve and 'he has US' and we are very fortunate because 'we have HIM'.

We just have to find enough people and help them feel comfortable enough with him to vote for him in two weeks!!!

user-pic

As they say: Ask and you shall receive.

I am honored that you gave such a heartfelt response. I'm in total agreement. Transcending paradox leads to transformation, I agree. But what a response you put together there!

user-pic

I tend to chalk up his empathic abilities to his exposure to many different cultures and environments for significant periods of time. African father. White mother. Indonesian step-father. Half-indonesian sister. Chinese brother-in-law. African-American wife.

Growing up in culturally diverse Hawaii, conservative Kansas, foreign Indonesia.

Being exposed to a working-class, blue-collar lifestyle, followed by education in an elite Ivy League school, ending up full circle in down-trodden communities as an organizer.

When you have as broad an exposure to as many different cultures and people as someone like Obama has, rather than just noticing the differences amongst people -- as most are prone to do -- you start to see the similarities between different people.

I think he utilizes this ability to "weave" peoples together through this "web of similarities" that he innately notices.

user-pic

It's easy to forget, following two years of campaigning, but to me, Obama is transformational because he represents a truly bottom-up way of thinking. In many ways, his campaign is a continuation of the "power to the people" approach of the civil rights years. And it isn't just a campaign slogan either. Obama's own campaign is proof that he walks the talk. They put enormous trust in their volunteers, and give them enormous responsibility. And President Obama, in my opinion, will lead this country with the same generous spirit of volunteerism and personal responsibility. In the best way possible, Barack Obama is a true insurgent.

user-pic

For a kitty-rabbit, you have some power for thought and words!

(I hope you never change your avatar - I really love it!)

user-pic

Transformational because able to transcend. Emerson would love him!

user-pic

I see transformation of atmosphere. We have been told for the last 8 years (and certainly every day since 9/11) to "be afraid... be very afraid." Obama has never once used those words or intimated that we have anything to fear but fear itself.

This is weird because Barack Obama is a good deal younger than I am, but I feel when he speaks the same kind of comfort and everything-will-be-all-right security that my father gave me when I was a little girl.

His calm manner of speaking, his expressive and soft hands, his ability to express himself with great clarity and without previous preparation. Extemporaneous speaking is a gift!

Speaking of my father - my parents lived in Illinois until 2 years ago, and they kept me current on him well before he hit the presidential campaign trail. So I was already inspired and amazingly become more so each time I hear him speak.

My blood pressure drops about 20 points when I visualize an American with President Barack Obama.

user-pic

I think it's worth considering what Powell said today about Obama representing a 'generational change'. The battles of the previous generation of politics have played out long enough. As enough new people enter the political arena who simply weren't born yet in the 60's or 70s (like me), it becomes necessary to adjust the political dynamic accordingly. Obama was born in 1961. He says he was only 8 when Ayers committed those despicable acts, and it's a reminder that the new generation, though shaped in some ways by the 60s and 70s, cannot be held responsible for it's failings.

The hippies attacking the soldiers hasn't really been happening in any of the wars in my memory, but the GOP instinct is still to attack on that premise, and the left is way too oversensitive to these attacks.

There aren't any lefty domestic terrorists to speak of anymore. Since I can remember, all we've had are crazy right wing meth addict bombers. But the political dynamic is stuck in the 60s with the right still attacking as though there has been a major left-wing bomber in the last 30 years.

I'm sure you guys can think of some other political dynamics that were set in place 30 or more years ago, and seem somewhat absurd in the real world as it exists today. Obama can be transformational by changing some of these dynamics and starting a new generation of politics.

user-pic

Transformational...

For too many years, politicians have been following the same old formula: "here's what I will do for you."

Obama's formula: "here's what we will do together; here's how you can help yourself."

That is transformational. It takes us straight back to "we the people."

And it is very welcome.

user-pic

There are many moving and real comments here on how and why Obama will be a transformational leader. I fully agree and am hopeful and proud of his election.
The challenge that remains however is 'will a transformational leader be able to deliver transformation.' Electing Obama will send a spike of hope throughout the world, not just our country. But as Barack has said on many occasions, real change comes from the ground up. Where will you be and what will you be doing in February after President Obama is inaugurated?
FDR and John Kennedy are sometimes cited as previous transformational leaders. I think Obama has a much greater potential than either of those presidents, but both benefited from the existence of independent movements -- for labor and for civil rights -- that preceded and continued through their presidencies. There are certainly many progressive organizations and thinkers around today, but until the Obama campaign organization there was little in the way of a coherent national presence that could reach out to others.
For Obama to be successful in delivering transformation, we need to harness the hope he brings into real continuing action -- organizing, contributing to progressive causes, and speaking out -- after the inauguration.

user-pic

I just have to say it. So many moving comments on this thread. And honestly so many reflective posts today. And that makes me feel that something transformational is happening already. Right here at TPM. I'm not sure if it's this sense we have of the coming election. And our great hope for an Obama presidency. And the kind of change we're all longing for. And so maybe we're beginning to be more quiet and reflective. And such beautiful writing is emerging.

We The People. Yes. WE. Can.

Big smile here! :)

user-pic

You are very skillful TheraP.

user-pic

Thanks TheraP.
Your question, and its respondents, makes me
consider a social spirituality that, most times, gets lost in the noise, buried under the rubric of a social responsibility, driven by fear. And we have seen how that plays out through the 'transformation' inflicted on the American people over the past 8 years.

user-pic

TheraP, thanks for the thread. This is what happened to me. When I voted for Obama in the primary I had the strongest feeling that I had just embraced the future. It was so strong that I can still feel it when I focus on that place and time.

In the primary season I wanted Biden to win - I'm from Delaware first but Biden's honesty attracks me. I think it is fitting that Obama choose Biden as his running mate. When it came down to Edwards, Clinton and Obama, once again it was the sense of honesty that attracted me to Obama. Then I heard the I want change song - that was good but I also went to the speech that song came from. That was the speech from when he lost to Clinton in New Hampshire. I was blown away by it. He told me how I could use the positive energy of the past to ride into the future.

I think that Obama's life of blending and mending is what helps make him transformational. Dr Xee above used the words to describe Obama's MOO - openness, inclusion, consideration, communication and inspiration. I also believe the Bush years were the set up for Obama.

user-pic

I think Barack Obama is transformational because he has hooked into an immense desire in so many Americans to be transformed and is riding it straight to the White House.

Alone among the nations one of America's greatest industries is the motivational or "self help" method, book or dvd.

Obama is like the mother of all self-help books... imagining the future will make it so. Much of the language of the posters to this thread is in that vein and it forms part of the mentality that produced the subprime bubble: "I want this house and although I don't have a job or any savings, if I wish hard enough, if I visualize well enough the money will magically appear.

Frankly all of this reeks to me of Mary Baker Eddy.

BTW. This is an invitation to abstain and not an endorsement of John McCain.

user-pic

I think I am echoing Mr. Seaton above, albeit from a more positive angle:

No-one is "transformational," barring that which can be achieved by exploiting the organic mechanisms of the human body.

As such, "transformation" is merely the manifestation of a latent ability or tendency.

OK, well, it is a fairly cynical view.

With apologies to Death, is there such a thing as a perky nihilist?

user-pic

Jesus, David, you'd piss all over yourself just to keep things looking bleak. I mean, I find some of the adoration on this thread a little much, but all the evidence so far indicates Obama will be a better president than we've had lately. OK, maybe you lost the 1960s, but 40 years of self-indulgent despair is a little much.

user-pic

It would be hard to be worse than Bush.
But Bush has left a situation
that makes success almost impossible for his successor. What might make an Obama tragic would not be any major blunder The One might make, but that he simply might get to the bank of the Rubicon and instead of crossing it, pull out a poll and fish... if you catch my drift.

user-pic

I'm afraid what we might be seeing is a tanned version of Jimmy Carter.

user-pic

I think pundits started talking about Obama being transformational in a political sense, in the way FDR and Reagan transformed (realigned) the political landscape. Powell has moved beyond this to the meaning many others have adopted: that Obama will transform politics generally, e.g., by being more reasoned, bipartisan, and civil than we've seen in the past 20 years. In Audacity of Hope, Obama himself hints at this meaning: in setting forth what he believes in, he doesn't go too much further into "liberal" orthodoxy than saying he believes in a social safety net, but what he does strongly believe in is restoring civility to public discourse. This was the sense in which Powell was surely using it, as his remarks on Meet the Press were directed at McCain's very un-civil campaign.

user-pic

May I express a more pedestrian wish?

I'd like to see him shatter the traditional mold of liberal / conservative by being a confounding mixture of the two. I think we see some of that in his economic outlook and his social perspective.

user-pic

I think that's his objective. To be inclusive and pragmatic, while making sure everyone gets a fair shake.

user-pic

When I first heard Obama speak it was like the world suddenly opened up and the dirt of the last eight years was washed away in an instant. I saw the hope of America on my television screen. I saw what America has always striven to be, and I caught more than just a glimpse of what we could be.

Obama cannot only transform America, but the world. He is that ultimate rare leader that comes along only once a century (I also see some of this in the French president Sarkozy). Obama has transformed himself beyond the most advanced of us and offers a light, that if we reach far enough, can be ours to have.

I have a profound new hope now, where I see the US as one. A proud and important nation capable of being put back on the track to greatness.

user-pic

Well, he's transformational because he is Democratic candidate who is ahead in the polls at 2 weeks out and therefore, by judging from past elections, has the best chance of winning this election.

I think a lot of people imbue his candidacy and successful campaign as transformational because he is black. Umm ... not so much. If he had been campaigning in the primaries against a competent, well-heeled white man, instead of against a competent, well-heeled woman, he would not be sitting in the catbird seat right now. I'm sorry to say that, IMO, for a large-enough portion of the electorate, it came down to voting for a man vs voting for a woman; and color of skin was secondary to gender.

Overall, I don't expect much from him as President. I expect he'll be competent and up to the task. Anything beyond that will be good-tasting gravy.

Thanks.

mp

user-pic

There were a number of competent, well-heeled white guys in the primary, none of whom got any traction against the black guy or the white woman even at the beginning.

user-pic

I disagree strongly.

I first heard Obama (as did many people) at the Democratic Convention in 2004.

His worldview is transformational, and it doesn't matter a damn whether he's black, white, Asian, Hispanic, or a combination of all of the above.

People respond to him because of the way he looks at problems, and because he includes them as part of the solution.

user-pic

It's about leadership. My Dad used to say when sizing someone up, "If I have to be in a foxhole, that's the kind of person I would want with me."

Leave a comment

TheraP

user-pic

Following: 219
Followers: 137

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

  • Favorite Quotes "The only wisdom we can hope to acquire is the wisdom of humility. Humility is endless." TS Eliot: Four Quartets ♪♪♪♪

Bio

Long and Interesting

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address