Moral Hazards (updated)
I venerate every one who sincerely follows a faith or no faith - anyone who seeks to live out/embody ethical values such as compassion, justice, and mercy.
For the word "god" in the post, you can substitute: Holy Mystery, Sacred Presence, Cosmic Heart - whatever you view as deepest, truest, most compassionate, just, merciful.
Moral Hazards
She was a professional woman. Raised in a strict, churchgoing and dysfunctional family. And she was gay. That's what brought her to my doorstep. Seeking a way out of her dilemma. Seeking, but not finding, something I could not give her. Because she was also trapped in her own mind - her beliefs and her self-evaluations and her view of God so powerfully stuck, so resistant to change.Her church was telling her that what her mind and body felt were sinful longings. As to behavior, she really hadn't done much of that. Too much rejection from family the one time she briefly lived with a woman. Church was important to her. Her main source of social interaction outside her family of origin. But God was, for her, a demanding judge, someone to fear. And the bible hadn't seemed to help either - as she tended to focus on those passages which, she feared, would be in waiting for her when her behavior came to "Judgment" one day.
She really didn't make much progress, I think. As her mind was so fixed - like concrete that had set long ago. And she finally stopped coming. Still depressed, but no longer suicidal.
But though she left therapy, her therapy did not leave me. Her plight was not just one of being rejected for being gay. Though she had been. More than anything it was related to a failure of religion to be there for her. A failure of her faith community to provide solace or even a chance to open up. A failure of her church to reassure her of God's care and protection and love; God's ultimate delight in her and fervent wish for her well-being. But it wasn't only that. Our image of God is powerfully affected by the image we form, based upon our parents. Our conscience is formed from interaction with parents. And she just couldn't take the risk of "giving up" her long-ago cemented ideas about God, sin, faith, religion, and the parental rejection they all symbolized.
Somehow she could never chip away at that cement: For the Bible told her so. And she was so closed-off, from having to hide so much of herself, feeling so ashamed - that it prevented her from forming a close enough bond with me. A bond that might have given her enough "security" and "safety" to risk letting go of what kept her imprisoned, unhappy, unfulfilled, isolated.
She needed to protect herself. But in doing that she was also (unwittingly) hemming herself in. She was too fearful of parental disapproval, church disapproval, bible disapproval, God disapproval. So what did it matter if I was OK with it? She herself disapproved.
One thing about being a therapist. So many people get better, move on. There's a sense of completion. But you never forget the people you couldn't help. That thought nags at you. Especially when, like this person, part of the problem lies in society and in religion. You get concerned about the many ways churches hurt people, rather than helping them. You cringe at so many ways that society hurts and fails to help. Of course you knew that before, but that was before you knew this person. (And naturally, it's not just one person I'm thinking of. I just picked the one that's nagged at me - about this - the most.)
That's why civil unions alone will never be enough. People like my former patient need compassionate pastoral and communal care as well. God is Love. Love is of God. So long as we are faithful to the one we love, how could that love possibly displease the One who first LOVED us? Who literally loved us - into BEING?
Long ago I decided that if I had to choose between moral hazards, I would prefer to err on the side of love.
Seems to me I picked that up from an itinerant Jewish Rabbi "who spoke with authority" and whose actions, according to his own testimony, were meant to reveal his Father's Love - love especially for the lost and forsaken, the excluded and the outcast.
.................................................................
Update:
Well, well, well, well, well..... I have just come across an address by an ELCA Lutheran Bishop Emeritus, apologizing (just 5 days ago!) for his former rejection of homosexuality - in a public context - which was reported by Minnesota Public Radio. You can read the brief text here. (I am profoundly moved by this.)


















