« Could You Do Me A Favor and Reassure Me That My Generation Won't Be Screwed? | teemunney's Blog | I'm Back On TPM And Mad As Hell! »
A First Lady Teaching Young Kids A Lesson Makes Her "Trash" In The White House...?
Yeah, I'm confused by this too.
In most of my posts, I'm either really worried about something or amazed at the ignorance of others. Today, I bring you Tammy Bruce, who must be at least a sophomore in the Ann Coulter School of Bigotry. I knew Bruce was kinda nuts, but clearly she's aced Coulter's introductory classes.
Now that we have a President of African-American descent, you will hear more and more from the right wing that racism in America is effectively over: no need for minority scholarships or affirmative action, no history behind the current gap in wealth between whites and blacks, and all barriers are broken since whites and blacks work together in harmony from 9-5 Monday-Friday. I mean, the fact that people still mostly stick with their own race on weekends doesn't matter that much, right?
Enter Bruce, who apparently doesn't get what talking "like a white girl" means in Michelle Obama's eyes, but then accuses her of talking in a "weird accent" later (which as a black person, even I can barely detect and don't really think what she said is weird). Apparently, teaching young black kids (likely black anyway) a lesson is trashy and patronizing:
Eco-socionomic categories, huh? With that vocabulary, Ms. Bruce, I'm surprised you're that high on the eco-socionomic ladder.
I'm pissed about this because I was, and still am to some, that black guy who "talks like a white boy". This happened to me as early as kindergarten, and it took me until high school to really get over it. Back then I didn't quite get it, but of course I do now. Nonetheless, it was frustrating. In the eyes of young blacks even in my generation, smart does not equal cool. In fact, perpetuating the cycle of poverty and underachievement may just be "keeping it real". After all, "white" society expects nothing of you, so why bother trying to join it? And if you didn't graduate from high school, you'd likely be proud of your daughter if she was making C's but still graduating (emphasis mine):
Hell, even after going to boarding school and college with mostly white kids, I've learned that even some whites were surprised by my demeanor. One guy I know was shocked that I like The Beatles. I mean, I'm sorry that I like more music than just Snoop Dogg and Dr. Dre. Geez. I also recall getting into a heated debate about affirmative action with a white kid freshman year that ended with him essentially saying that I didn't deserve my admission.
The fact is that a lot of things that fuel the achievement gap are psychological and/or deeply rooted in complex issues. I don't intend to go through everything in this post, but have a peep at this study that evaluated the performace of two groups of blacks on the same test (about midway through the linked page):
Of course, Tammy Bruce doesn't get this. Neither do Rush Limbaugh or the rest of the far-right smear machine. And quite frankly, they don't want to understand the complexities of our society. What Bruce likely does understand is the power that words have in pushing an agenda. She uses an example of our first lady helping the current achievement gap and addressing matters that have likely gone unnoticed since April 4, 1968 and turns it into an example of cultural elitism. While this may not intentionally be race-baiting, I have to ask how she got the word "trash" out of this...I mean, seriously? This is beyond absurd to me.
It took 40 years after Martin Luther King, Jr.'s death for some to realize that not everything is peachy in America. A lot of people woke up and smelled the coffee during last year's campaign. However, there are some that will make Rip Van Winkle's 20-year snooze session seem like a power nap.
In most of my posts, I'm either really worried about something or amazed at the ignorance of others. Today, I bring you Tammy Bruce, who must be at least a sophomore in the Ann Coulter School of Bigotry. I knew Bruce was kinda nuts, but clearly she's aced Coulter's introductory classes.
Now that we have a President of African-American descent, you will hear more and more from the right wing that racism in America is effectively over: no need for minority scholarships or affirmative action, no history behind the current gap in wealth between whites and blacks, and all barriers are broken since whites and blacks work together in harmony from 9-5 Monday-Friday. I mean, the fact that people still mostly stick with their own race on weekends doesn't matter that much, right?
Enter Bruce, who apparently doesn't get what talking "like a white girl" means in Michelle Obama's eyes, but then accuses her of talking in a "weird accent" later (which as a black person, even I can barely detect and don't really think what she said is weird). Apparently, teaching young black kids (likely black anyway) a lesson is trashy and patronizing:
Man, oh, man. That's who he's married to, what does that tell you? This is what we've got -- you know what we've got? We've got trash in the White House. Trash is a, is a thing that is color blind, it can cross all eco -- ecosocionomic kind of categories, you can work on Wall Street or work at the Wal-Mart. Trash are people who use other people to get things, who patronize others, who consider you bitter and clingy.
Eco-socionomic categories, huh? With that vocabulary, Ms. Bruce, I'm surprised you're that high on the eco-socionomic ladder.
I'm pissed about this because I was, and still am to some, that black guy who "talks like a white boy". This happened to me as early as kindergarten, and it took me until high school to really get over it. Back then I didn't quite get it, but of course I do now. Nonetheless, it was frustrating. In the eyes of young blacks even in my generation, smart does not equal cool. In fact, perpetuating the cycle of poverty and underachievement may just be "keeping it real". After all, "white" society expects nothing of you, so why bother trying to join it? And if you didn't graduate from high school, you'd likely be proud of your daughter if she was making C's but still graduating (emphasis mine):
My parents expected a lot from me early on, but backed off and seemed okay with me even when I had a rocky semester or two in college (this included C's and D's). At the time I never understood why my folks were still relatively pleased, but this may be why: my dad has a GED and my mom never finished high school.Students from all backgrounds told the Mercury News that their parents value education and expect good grades. Many get rewards, such as a dinner out or iTunes cards, for good performance. They're punished - no text messaging, restricted computer access or grounding - for bad grades.
But families' definition of "good grades" varies. It means "higher than a C," said Victoria Mendoza, a Latina and an eighth-grader at West San Jose's Monroe Middle School who nonetheless gets mostly A's.
Thoa said her parents expect A-pluses, although she said she doesn't meet that standard. "I have to bring it down a notch to be real," said Thoa [a Vietnamese girl], who has a 3.6 GPA and is taking two advanced-placement classes this year.
Hell, even after going to boarding school and college with mostly white kids, I've learned that even some whites were surprised by my demeanor. One guy I know was shocked that I like The Beatles. I mean, I'm sorry that I like more music than just Snoop Dogg and Dr. Dre. Geez. I also recall getting into a heated debate about affirmative action with a white kid freshman year that ended with him essentially saying that I didn't deserve my admission.
The fact is that a lot of things that fuel the achievement gap are psychological and/or deeply rooted in complex issues. I don't intend to go through everything in this post, but have a peep at this study that evaluated the performace of two groups of blacks on the same test (about midway through the linked page):
The researchers told half the students that the test did not assess ability, but that the research was aimed at "understanding the psychological factors involved in solving verbal problems." The others were told that the test was a valid measure of academic ability and capacity. African-American students who were told that the test was a true measure of ability scored significantly lower than the white students. The other African-American students' scores were equal to the white students'. Whites performed the same in both situations.When you're a kid, you want to be respected by your peers. And when you don't have parents to teach you what is truly important in life, you go to drastic measures to get that respect. Gangs and participation in violent activities are ways in which 16-year olds with no guidance earn this respect. And warranted or not, the white man gets the blame for the continuation of the vicious cycle.
Of course, Tammy Bruce doesn't get this. Neither do Rush Limbaugh or the rest of the far-right smear machine. And quite frankly, they don't want to understand the complexities of our society. What Bruce likely does understand is the power that words have in pushing an agenda. She uses an example of our first lady helping the current achievement gap and addressing matters that have likely gone unnoticed since April 4, 1968 and turns it into an example of cultural elitism. While this may not intentionally be race-baiting, I have to ask how she got the word "trash" out of this...I mean, seriously? This is beyond absurd to me.
It took 40 years after Martin Luther King, Jr.'s death for some to realize that not everything is peachy in America. A lot of people woke up and smelled the coffee during last year's campaign. However, there are some that will make Rip Van Winkle's 20-year snooze session seem like a power nap.
Advertisement













When I started reading this, the first thing I asked myself was "Who is Tammy Bruce?"
So I googled her. She's plainly unhinged.
March 23, 2009 6:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
One more sign that we are not yet "post-racial" and have some distance to travel.
March 23, 2009 6:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
Can we all take a moment and send Megan McCain's message to Bruce AND Laura I? Ready>>>
YOU CAN KISS MY FAT ASS!
But wait, never mind - becuase I'm sure are asses are way to good to be anywhere near their mouths!
Terrific Post T - but now I am so livid, disgusted, pissed....
Appreciate a finely written and factual post.
Rec'd.
March 23, 2009 6:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
correction: should be OUR asses. (Should never try to type when so angry.)
March 23, 2009 6:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh Auntie, don't be an ass!!! hahahahaha
March 23, 2009 7:19 PM | Reply | Permalink
Good reminder of what is. I watch out for 'signs'. They appear everyday in some conservative blog or in some wording by a right wing pundit.
Racism is still here. But we are talking a 'minority' position here. A little ironic but the racists have reached a point where they are in a minority.
Whenever I hear 'it' or see 'it' I sign the alarm.
March 23, 2009 7:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
We will never get rid of racism, as long as there are those that will play the race card on both sides of the political spectrum.
The hope is that we marginalize the people that do play the card.
March 23, 2009 8:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
Several blogs today about racism....makes me very sad. Weary. Resolved. I have gotten past the angry. I have such deep feelings about this issue of racism. I cannot write more right now...it would go on and on.
March 23, 2009 8:40 PM | Reply | Permalink
It makes me a little sad too. I didn't want to post this at first, but I was so infuriated that I had to.
I don't like talking about race, but I feel like it has to be done. I also think it's one of the best ways I can contribute to TPM (or any community, online or not) because of my own experiences. We may not be sure if racism will ever end, but I want to do my part in trying to stop it.
March 23, 2009 8:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
I am glad you did post, T. Shining a light is one of the best ways to show the ignorance of racists. Shine it in every corner.
Again, I cannot write more. I have sat here for 20 minutes wanting to say so much and I just can't get it out.
March 23, 2009 9:45 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for posting teemunney. Your take is so cogent. It's hard to not want to tear somebody's hair out, (not mine), when you see this sort of drivel in media coverage.
March 23, 2009 10:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
GREAT post, T! I hadn't heard about it and I'm flaming pissed that anyone would be so crass...
Both the President and his wife are shining examples to the world that class comes in all colors and the very idea that some ignorant idiot would be given a forum to spout that filth really upsets me.
Mrs. Obama is owed an apology. Big time. From Tammy Bruce, and from Laura Ingram.
March 23, 2009 8:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
I am so tired right now that I don't make sense. But that's Ok. Because, Teemunny, you make sense.
Our first lady is owed an apology. And, of course, you are owed an apology... for all the years you paid your dues (and who established the criteria?) and were disparaged, by anyone, for anything untoward and unfair, along the way.
Thank you.
I think this thread is one of the most important I have read on TPM in the ten months I have been here.
March 23, 2009 9:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
GREAT post, T! I hadn't heard about it and I'm flaming pissed that anyone would be so crass...
Both the President and his wife are shining examples to the world that class comes in all colors and the very idea that some ignorant idiot would be given a forum to spout that filth really upsets me.
Mrs. Obama is owed an apology. Big time. From Tammy Bruce, and from Laura Ingram.
March 24, 2009 2:11 AM | Reply | Permalink
Dang... so I go to the link to find out what the First Lady (who so far in my opinion is a nice blend of down to earth and fashionista) could possibly have done for ANYONE to call her trash.
That Bruce chick is incoherent and at best I guess she is saying Michelle is 'trash' because she isn't sufficiently genuinely 'black' enough to sound black (trashing being ill-defined as using someone else in false manner) - but at the same, Bruce doesn't understand what is meant by 'sounding white'?
Well, if she doesn't know what is meant by 'sounding white' and the social stigma attached to sounding well educated, than how can she judge that M.O. is putting on a 'fake' accent.
DAMN... that chick gets PAID to be that incoherent? Where can I get a job like that.
March 24, 2009 2:27 AM | Reply | Permalink
I KNOW, right?! That is such total nonsense. And I've played the clip to a few of my white friends and they don't hear any sort of "fake weird accent" anywhere. This woman had to be on some drug while on the air. Not to mention that I'd rather hear nails scratching a chalkboard for eternity than hear her speak for 2 minutes.
March 24, 2009 1:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
I like Ms. Obama! I like it that she took the time to do some gardening with schoolkids. What a good, sane, wholesome thing! Some people have a lot of hate in them, they just direct it here, there, they can't find it in them to say positive things, even in the face of someone involved in good deeds. I'm sure Ms. O. was also criticized for visiting injured GI's and showing support for their families -- which was also a beautiful and positive thing. Go forth, Ms. O! Keep on showing Americans what a person with a true sense of self-respect and intelligence can do. The President found a wonderful person with whom to share his life. He's a lucky man.
March 24, 2009 12:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's pretty simple. It's classic Republican-speak to accuse their opponent of what they are. They're like kids whose faces are covered with powdered sugar screaming they did NOT touch your doughnut!
Trash? Like the Princeton cum laude kind of trash? Or is Bruce referring to Ms. Obama's Juris Doctorate at Harvard Law School? The accusation is absurd and really makes Bruce seem delusional.
While I cannot apologize for Bruce's remarks, I am saddened that, even with The Obama's in the White House, her nasty comments can touch people so deeply. I am hopeful, though, that younger generations will not feel this insult as deeply, because their personal experiences are not as graphic as yours. I am hopeful that each generation will see this come into being until these remarks are not made simply because no one takes them seriously. It is tragic that some people feel this is entertainment, which is prettu much what the FOX News Channel is anymore, an emotional fix for people addicted to blind rage.
March 24, 2009 2:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
teemunney, now *that's* Cahokia writing I can believe in. :-)
I was going to do a piece on Bruce, but I got overloaded with work yesterday and couldn't do it. I'm glad I didn't - yours was excellent.
March 24, 2009 2:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
In the eyes of young blacks even in my generation, smart does not equal cool. In fact, perpetuating the cycle of poverty and underachievement may just be "keeping it real". After all, "white" society expects nothing of you, so why bother trying to join it?
_____
Damn, that's familiar. I grew up in the late 1950s-early 1960s, in a white neighborhood (I fit Zappa's comment: "I'm not black, but there's a whole lot of times I wish I could say I'm not white"), and I had to contend with that exact same thing. Stupidity as the peer-pressure-enforced norm.
Michelle Obama, by contrast, is wonderful, an inspiration.
March 24, 2009 3:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
I'd stop listening to her, or watching her, or whatever, but I've never even heard of the woman....
All we are doing is giving her a platform. Screw her. Don't pay attention, she's doing plenty of damage to herself....
March 24, 2009 4:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
I went to her site and tried to log on, but they ask you to publicize your email address...probably not the best idea if I'm about to smack her down about the Michelle thing. Last thing I need is my inbox full of wing-nut hate mail.
She really is her own worst enemy. Anyone with basic decency can plainly see that Michelle Obama is a mensch. The rest are afraid, ignorant, lost causes.
March 24, 2009 4:21 PM | Reply | Permalink