I found the following over on one of the Daily Kos Dairies. The author gave her permission for others to distribute it. It is a summary of the good intentions, successes and failures of both candidates in the senate. While the author now supports Obama, she had been inclined toward Hillary before doing her research. I think it is one of the most well researched, fact based pieces on both their records that I have ever encountered.
I Refuse to Buy into the Obama Hype (now a supporter) by
Grassroots Mom
Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 05:13:32 PM PST
The next President is going to have some MAJOR challenges.
I refuse to buy into the hype, on either side, but especially on
that of Obama. However the "empty rhetoric" v. "history of
accomplishments" arguments have prompted me to check it out on my own,
not relying on any candidate's website, book, or worst of all
supporters' diaries, like this one.
I went to the Library of Congress Website.
The FACTS of what each did in the Senate last year sure surprised me.
I'm sure they will surprise you, too. Whether you love or hate Hillary,
you will be surprised. Whether you think Obama is the second coming of
JFK or an inexperienced lightweight, you will surprised. Go check out
the Library of Congress Website.
After spending some time there, it will be clear that there is really
only one candidate would is ready to be the next president, even better
than Gore. If you don't want to spend an hour or two doing research,
then I'll tell you what I discovered on the jump.
I
looked up Obama and looked up Clinton. I looked at the bills that they
both authored and introduced. Anyone who has been around politics, and
is honest, realizes that there are a lot of reasons why a Senator votes
one way or another on bills or misses votes. However an examination of
the bills that each of these Senators cared enough about to author and
introduce revealed much to me: what they care about, what their
priorities are, how they tackle problems. And the list of co-sponsors
showed something about how they lead, inspire and work with others.
Finally, looking at which bills actually passed is pretty indicative of
how effective each would be at getting things done.
Before I get into the nitty gritty, let's all be honest here. It is
damn hard to get anything through Congress these days. And Obama and
Clinton care about the same issues and have obviously worked together
on a lot of legislation, whatever Sen. Clinton's campaign may imply.
She is a frequent co-sponsor on his bills, and he on hers. They are
both completely competent senators.
I started with Sen. Clinton.
I'm not a Hillary Hater, but I certainly didn't like her much
either. I didn't like her DLC history; her votes on Iraq, Iran or the
bankruptcy bill; her characterization of the years she spent as First
Lady as "executive experience." Hillary Clinton is no Eleanor
Roosevelt. Perhaps more like Lady Bird Johnson. Hillary claims to have
brought us SCHIP (with a little help from Ted Kennedy). Lady Bird
brought us Head Start as well as cleaner, nicer highways. Anyone 40 or
older probably remembers when the nation's highways were basically
disgusting garbage dumps lined with billboards. But no one thinks Lady
Bird should have been president. Might as well argue for Barbara Bush
because of her efforts on family literacy, or Nancy Reagan and the War
on Drugs.
Hillary Clinton does have a solid record in the Senate, however.
I came away from my research really knowing a lot more about what is
important to Hillary in her heart: kids and their well being. My
research changed my feeling about her significantly. About 40% of her
bills dealt with health care and/or kids. As a mom with small kids, I
like her passion for children's issues. But curiously, her big bill to
deliver health care to every child, the one she lauds on her website,
S.895 : "A bill to amend titles XIX and XXI of the Social Security Act
to ensure that every child in the United States has access to
affordable, quality health insurance coverage, and for other purposes"
had not a single co-sponsor. Not one, according to the Library of
Congress. Why is that? Is it a bad bill? Or is she not able to recruit
support for her signature issue? Or did she just submit it simply to
put in the hopper, so to speak, so she could claim she was working on
it. I honestly don't know the answer, but I find it curious and
suspicious that not even Ted Kennedy co-sponsored it. Its sister bill
in the house, H.R. 1535, introduced by John Dingell has 42 co-sponsors.
It's just weird. I honestly don't know what to make of it.
S.895 was major. But most of her other bills are much smaller in scale and scope — more targeted and more careful.
For example, she introduced one bill that offered tax credits for
building owners who clean up lead paint. Which is a very good thing.
And Obama is a co-sponsor. "S.1793 : A bill to amend the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 to provide a tax credit for property owners who
remove lead-based paint hazards."
Obama's anti-lead bill (S. 1306) directed the Consumer Product
Safety Commission to classify certain children's products containing
lead as banned hazardous substances. He had another bill prohibitting
the interstate transport of children's products containing lead.
(S.2132) And Hillary co-sponsored each of these.
In other words, they both care about protecting children from lead.
The difference is in the scope and the approach.
Obama's bill shows how he thinks big: do everything we can to make
sure that lead-painted Thomas the Tank Engine toys don't get into the
hands and mouths of millions of toddlers in this country.
Or Hillary: encourage people by offering tax credits to clean up
lead paint in old buildings. People have been talking about lead paint
in old buildings hurting kids in living in inner cities, since, well
when I was a kid — for decades. If it is still a big problem, is
offering tax credits for clean up, i.e. scrape down the walls and
repaint, the best way to protect kids from lead?
How many of you parents have lead paint problems? How many have (or
had) toxic Thomas the Tank Engine Toys? They are everywhere. The local
bookstore and kid's shoe store and the doctor's office and the
preschool and the toystore all have train tables. There is nowhere you
can go anymore with toddlers that doesn't have a Thomas the Tank Engine
train table covered with toxic toys. But that's just my feeling.
Obama's bills risk pissing off the toy industry and the Chinese. Hillary's risks nothing.
A lot of Clinton's health bills focus on children. Or women. She
introduced a billl for research in the causes of gestational diabetes,
for more pediatric research (S.895) and a rural agriculture bill to get
farm-fresh veggies into schools (S.1031).
Her bill dealing with the crisis in foreclosure is actually S.2114 :
"A bill to amend the Truth in Lending Act, to provide for enhanced
disclosures to consumers and enhanced regulation of mortgage brokers,
and for other purposes." Again, no co-sponsors. Obama also introduced
a bill in the face of the mortgage foreclosure crisis: S.1222 : "A bill
to stop mortgage transactions which operate to promote fraud, risk,
abuse, and under-development, and for other purposes." Sponsor: Sen
Obama, Barack [IL] (introduced 4/25/2007), co-sponsored by Dick Durbin.
In her ads and speeches, Clinton claims that she's fighting to stop
foreclosure while implying that Obama is empty rhetoric. Actually,
Clinton is calling for "enhanced disclosures to consumers and enhanced
regulation", while Obama's bill will "stop mortgage transactions which
operate to promote fraud, risk, abuse, and under-development." After
looking at the two bills, Obama's appears to be tougher, more directly
addressing the problem.
Speaking of Obama, here's a list of some of his proposed legislation.
Four bills on energy including
• S.1151 : A bill to provide incentives to the auto industry to
accelerate efforts to develop more energy-efficient vehicles to lessen
dependence on oil;
•S.115 : A bill to suspend royalty relief, to repeal certain
provisions of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, and to amend the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 to repeal certain tax incentives for the oil and
gas industry; and •S.133 : A bill to promote the national security and
stability of the economy of the United States by reducing the
dependence of the United States on oil through the use of alternative
fuels and new technology, and for other purposes.
Clinton had only one bill that I could find that addressed the same
issue, S.701 : A bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to
impose a temporary oil profit fee and to use the proceeds of the fee
collected to provide a Strategic Energy Fund and expand certain energy
tax incentives, and for other purposes.
Obama wants to "repeal certain tax incentives for the oil and gas
industry". Clinton sees the answer in a "temporary oil profit fee" and
to "expand certain energy tax incentives" for alternative energy.
Obama's alternative energy bill (S.133) was co-sponsored by Harkin,
Lugar and Salazar. Clinton's bill again had no co-sponsors.
On health care he introduced ten bills/amendments, including one
amendment that passed: S.AMDT.1041 to S.1082 To improve the safety and
efficacy of genetic tests. Other issues addressed in his proposed
health care legislation were AIDS research (S.823 ), hospital report
cards (S.692 — the V.A., and S.1824 — Medicare), better emergency care
(S.1873), and drug price controls (S.2347).
Clinton's health care bills, for the most part, didn't impress me
much, although she introduced many more bills in this area than Obama
did:
S.CON.RES.63 : A concurrent resolution expressing the sense of the
Congress regarding the need for additional research into the chronic
neurological condition hydrocephalus, and for other purposes.
S.RES.176 : A resolution recognizing April 30, 2007, as "National Healthy Schools Day".
S.RES.222 : A resolution supporting the goals and ideals of Pancreatic Cancer Awareness Month.
S.201 : A bill to establish a grant program for individuals still
suffering health effects as a result of the September 11, 2001, attacks
in New York City and at the Pentagon.
S.907 : A bill to establish an Advisory Committee on Gestational
Diabetes, to provide grants to better understand and reduce gestational
diabetes, and for other purposes.
S.993 : A bill to improve pediatric research.
S.982 : A bill to amend the Public Health Service Act to provide
for integration of mental health services and mental health treatment
outreach teams, and for other purposes.
S.1065 : A bill to improve the diagnosis and treatment of
traumatic brain injury in members and former members of the Armed
Forces, to review and expand telehealth and telemental health programs
of the Department of Defense and the Department of Veterans Affairs,
and for other purposes.
S.1075 : A bill to amend title XIX of the Social Security Act to
expand access to contraceptive services for women and men under the
Medicaid program, help low income women and couples prevent unintended
pregnancies and reduce abortion, and for other purposes.
S.1343 : A bill to amend the Public Health Service Act with
respect to prevention and treatment of diabetes, and for other
purposes.
S.1712 : A bill to amend the Public Health Service Act to improve newborn screening activities, and for other purposes.
and on and on. Plenty of these have plenty of co-sponsors.
Obviously, Hillary Clinton really knows her stuff on the issues of
health care. None of them passed, however. On Obama's side, one of his
health care initiatives passed in the Senate, the aforementioned
amendment to Kennedy's S.1082, the FDA Revitalization Act.
Truth be told, it was very depressing doing this research to see all
these great ideas and how little actually gets done. Looking at the
legislative history of Kennedy's bill is a good example. It finally
passed but its sister bill in the House, H.R.2900, was the one that was
finally enacted, and with it, Obama's amendment for safe and effective
genetic testing. Clinton submitted two amendments to this bill, one of
would have eliminated the sunsetting of pediatric data collection; the
other would have begin the process to approve generic versions of
complex and expensive drugs called biologics or biotech drugs. Neither
were adopted.
Now let's look more closely at Obama.
I was blown away as I started going through his record. I've
already mentioned his bills on health care and energy. In addition he
had introduced bills on Iran, voting, veterans, global warming,
campaign finance and lobbyists, Blackwater, global poverty, nuclear
proliferation, and education.
On Iran: S.J.RES.23 : A joint resolution
clarifying that the use of force against Iran is not authorized by the
Authorization for the Use of Military Force Against Iraq, any
resolution previously adopted, or any other provision of law.
On votingPassed out of Committee and now on the Senate Calendar for Feb. 22, 2008
S.453 : A bill to prohibit deceptive practices in Federal elections
Please check this out! This is a great bill. We need this. I can't
believe that this time voter intimidation is not already illegal.
On veterans and military personnel: S.1084 : A bill to provide housing assistance for very low-income veterans;
On global warmingS.1324 : A bill to amend the Clean
Air Act to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from transportation fuel
sold in the United States;S.1389 : A bill to authorize the National
Science Foundation to establish a Climate Change Education Program;
S.AMDT.599 to S.CON.RES.21 To add $200 million for Function 270
(Energy) for the demonstration and monitoring of carbon capture and
sequestration technology by the Department of Energy. (This last one
passed both the House and the Senate as part of the budget bill.)
On campaign finance and lobbyists S.2030 : A bill
to amend the Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971 to require reporting
relating to bundled contributions made by persons other than registered
lobbyists; and S.AMDT.41 to S.1 To require lobbyists to disclose the
candidates, leadership PACs, or political parties for whom they collect
or arrange contributions, and the aggregate amount of the contributions
collected or arranged.
On Blackwater S.2044 : A bill to provide procedures
for the proper classification of employees and independent contractors,
and for other purposes, and S.2147 : A bill to require accountability
for contractors and contract personnel under Federal contracts, and for
other purposes.
On global poverty S.2433 : A bill to require the
President to develop and implement a comprehensive strategy to further
the United States foreign policy objective of promoting the reduction
of global poverty, the elimination of extreme global poverty, and the
achievement of the Millennium Development Goal of reducing by one-half
the proportion of people worldwide, between 1990 and 2015, who live on
less than $1 per day.
On global nuclear proliferation S.1977 : A bill to
provide for sustained United States leadership in a cooperative global
effort to prevent nuclear terrorism, reduce global nuclear arsenals,
stop the spread of nuclear weapons and related material and technology,
and support the responsible and peaceful use of nuclear technology.
I counted nine education bills, but it's getting late and I've got to get my kids ready for bed.
As I mentioned earlier, Clinton is a frequent co-sponsor on many of
Obama's bills. So is Ted Kennedy. So are a number of Republicans.
Finally, Obama appears to have a better record last year in the
Senate on getting his bills and amendments passed than does Clinton.
I've listed everything that passed the Senate for each them at the end
in boxes. But check out Thomas.loc.gov for yourself. I may have missed
something.
In my eyes Obama is the superior choice in every way. He cares about
more of the issues that matter to me. Kids and health care are
important but so is the issue of global warming, on which Clinton
introduced not a single bill last year.
Obama is a leader. With bigger majorities in Congress, much of his
agenda should sail through. He can inspire this country to change
course on so many things, from health care to global warming, where
attitudes have to be changed first. I remember Bill Clinton's endless
laundry lists of small, focus group approved initiatives. For those who
say Hillary will not govern like Bill did, I respond that the people
who were doing the market testing of his proposed policies were Dick
Morris, of course, and Mark Penn, who is now running Hillary's campaign.
It's Obama for me! I just sent him $100. My first donation this election.
Yes, We Can!
Clinton's Successes:
S.694 : A bill to direct the Secretary of Transportation to issue
regulations to reduce the incidence of child injury and death occurring
inside or outside of light motor vehicles, and for other purposes.
(This is currently in conference committee to reconcile difference with
the House bill)
Passed in the Senate:
S.CON.RES.27 : A concurrent resolution supporting the goals and ideals of "National Purple Heart Recognition Day".
S.RES.21 : A resolution recognizing the uncommon valor of Wesley Autrey of New York, New York
S.RES.92 : A resolution calling for the immediate and unconditional
release of soldiers of Israel held captive by Hamas and Hezbollah.
S.RES.141 : A resolution urging all member countries of the
International Commission of the International Tracing Service who have
yet to ratify the May 2006 amendments to the 1955 Bonn Accords to
expedite the ratification process to allow for open access to the
Holocaust archives located at Bad Arolsen, Germany.
S.RES.222 : A resolution supporting the goals and ideals of Pancreatic Cancer Awareness Month.
S.AMDT.666 to H.R.1591 To link award fees under Department of
Homeland Security contracts to successful acquisition outcomes under
such contracts.
S.AMDT.2047 to H.R.1585 To specify additional individuals eligible
to transportation for survivors of deceased members of the Armed Forces
to attend their burial ceremonies.
S.AMDT.2108 to H.R.1585 To require a report on the planning and implementation of the policy of the United States toward Darfur.
S.AMDT.2390 to H.R.2638 To require that all contracts of the
Department of Homeland Security that provide award fees link such fees
to successful acquisition outcomes.
S.AMDT.2474 to H.R.2638 To ensure that the Federal Protective Service has adequate personnel.
S.AMDT.2823 to H.R.3074 To require a report on plans to alleviate
congestion and flight delays in the New York/New Jersey/Philadelphia
Airspace.
S.AMDT.2917 to H.R.1585 To extend and enhance the authority for
temporary lodging expenses for members of the Armed Forces in areas
subject to a major disaster declaration or for installations
experiencing a sudden increase in personnel levels.
Obama's Success:
S.AMDT.1041 to S.1082 To improve the safety and efficacy of genetic tests.
S.AMDT.3073 to H.R.1585 To provide for transparency and accountability in military and security contracting.
S.AMDT.3078 to H.R.1585 Relating to administrative separations of members of the Armed Forces for personality disorder.
S.AMDT.41 to S.1 To require lobbyists to disclose the candidates,
leadership PACs, or political parties for whom they collect or arrange
contributions, and the aggregate amount of the contributions collected
or arranged.
S.AMDT.524 to S.CON.RES.21 To provide $100 million for the Summer
Term Education Program supporting summer learning opportunities for
low-income students in the early grades to lessen summer learning
losses that contribute to the achievement gaps separating low-income
students from their middle-class peers.
S.AMDT.599 to S.CON.RES.21 To add $200 million for Function 270
(Energy) for the demonstration and monitoring of carbon capture and
sequestration technology by the Department of Energy.
S.AMDT.905 to S.761 To require the Director of Mathematics,
Science, and Engineering Education to establish a program to recruit
and provide mentors for women and underrepresented minorities who are
interested in careers in mathematics, science, and engineering.
S.AMDT.923 to S.761 To expand the pipeline of individuals entering
the science, technology, engineering, and mathematics fields to support
United States innovation and competitiveness.
S.AMDT.924 to S.761 To establish summer term education programs.
S.AMDT.2519 to H.R.2638 To provide that one of the funds
appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be used to
enter into a contract in an amount greater than $5 million or to award
a grant in excess of such amount unless the prospective contractor or
grantee certifies in writing to the agency awarding the contract or
grant that the contractor or grantee owes no past due Federal tax
liability.
S.AMDT.2588 to H.R.976 To provide certain employment protections
for family members who are caring for members of the Armed Forces
recovering from illnesses and injuries incurred on active duty.
S.AMDT.2658 to H.R.2642 To provide that none of the funds
appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be used to
enter into a contract in an amount greater than $5,000,000 or to award
a grant in excess of such amount unless the prospective contractor or
grantee makes certain certifications regarding Federal tax liability.
S.AMDT.2692 to H.R.2764 To require a comprehensive nuclear threat reduction and security plan.
S.AMDT.2799 to H.R.3074 To provide that none of the funds
appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be used to
enter into a contract in an amount greater than $5,000,000 or to award
a grant in excess of such amount unless the prospective contractor or
grantee makes certain certifications regarding Federal tax liability.
S.AMDT.3137 to H.R.3222 To provide that none of the funds
appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be used to
enter into a contract in an amount greater than $5,000,000 or to award
a grant in excess of such amount unless the prospective contractor or
grantee makes certain certifications regarding Federal tax liability.
S.AMDT.3234 to H.R.3093 To provide that none of the funds
appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be used to
enter into a contract in an amount greater than $5,000,000 or to award
a grant in excess of such amount unless the prospective contractor or
grantee makes certain certifications regarding Federal tax liability.
S.AMDT.3331 to H.R.3043 To provide that none of the funds
appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be used to
enter into a contract in an amount greater than $5,000,000 or to award
a grant in excess of such amount unless the prospective contractor or
grantee makes certain certifications regarding Federal tax liability.
Senate Resolutions Passed:
S.RES.133 : A resolution celebrating the life of Bishop Gilbert Earl Patterson.
S.RES.268 : A resolution designating July 12, 2007, as "National Summer Learning Day".