Would "Less" Be So Bad?
There have been a few posts lately about the potential for some some huge changes in our country with the election of President Obama and the horrific downturn in the economy. Most people are scared, and I think there is much to be scared of. No one wants to contemplate what 10%, 20% unemployment is going to look like. A lot of people go to bed every night wondering if they will be included in the next round of lay-offs. Many people are beginning to wonder what a post-consumer driven economy is going to look like.
But, I'm wondering if, just possibly, that this downturn, this wake-up call, might just be a good thing, albeit a heavily disguised one at the moment.
I know that the poor and the lower middle class are going to feel the pain disproportionately during the process, and that thought deeply saddens me. But I'm beginning to think that in the long run, it may turn out to be a good thing.
What if we are able to come out the other side with some better values as a country? Like a greater respect for those who don't have a lot of money. Like a realization that "stuff" doesn't bring happiness. Like doing the "right" thing is far better than doing the convenient thing.
What if housing prices go down enough, and everyone has health insurance, so that only one person in the family needs to work, and now one parent can stay home and raise the kids? Not only would kids be raised by people who love them instead of strangers, BUT, the need for so many jobs would go away.
What if families started living in these big ol' houses together...Mom, Dad, the kids, AND Grandma/Grandpa, instead of one family in a house they can barely afford and the other several states away?
What if we decided that one television per household was enough, that we don't need a land line and cells phones, that everyone in the family doesn't need their own computer, that we don't need to "own" every DVD or CD ever produced? What if we went back to giving ourselves pedicures, mowing our own lawns, cooking our own dinners, cleaning our own houses? What if we lightened our loads a bit so that all our "extra" stuff didn't need to go into "storage" and we actually had enough room in the garage to park our cars? And that we could reduce our insurance premiums because we didn't have so much to insure? What if we started wearing our clothes until they wore out, instead of until the "fashion police" told us we were behind the times? Would life really suck that bad?
What if kids started playing outside again, reading books instead of playing meaningless and violent video games? What if mom (or dad) taught them their ABCs and 123s and they started school in kindergarten instead of spending four years in preschool? What if libraries and city parks once again became places of wonder?
What if the reduced stress in our lives made it so we could better manage our marriages and divorce was the exception rather than the rule? What if we hiked and rode our bicycles instead of going to the gym? What if going out to dinner and movie was a real "treat" again?
Would the "less," the "lower" standard of living we are all so afraid of, be such a bad thing? I'm just wondering...
But, I'm wondering if, just possibly, that this downturn, this wake-up call, might just be a good thing, albeit a heavily disguised one at the moment.
I know that the poor and the lower middle class are going to feel the pain disproportionately during the process, and that thought deeply saddens me. But I'm beginning to think that in the long run, it may turn out to be a good thing.
What if we are able to come out the other side with some better values as a country? Like a greater respect for those who don't have a lot of money. Like a realization that "stuff" doesn't bring happiness. Like doing the "right" thing is far better than doing the convenient thing.
What if housing prices go down enough, and everyone has health insurance, so that only one person in the family needs to work, and now one parent can stay home and raise the kids? Not only would kids be raised by people who love them instead of strangers, BUT, the need for so many jobs would go away.
What if families started living in these big ol' houses together...Mom, Dad, the kids, AND Grandma/Grandpa, instead of one family in a house they can barely afford and the other several states away?
What if we decided that one television per household was enough, that we don't need a land line and cells phones, that everyone in the family doesn't need their own computer, that we don't need to "own" every DVD or CD ever produced? What if we went back to giving ourselves pedicures, mowing our own lawns, cooking our own dinners, cleaning our own houses? What if we lightened our loads a bit so that all our "extra" stuff didn't need to go into "storage" and we actually had enough room in the garage to park our cars? And that we could reduce our insurance premiums because we didn't have so much to insure? What if we started wearing our clothes until they wore out, instead of until the "fashion police" told us we were behind the times? Would life really suck that bad?
What if kids started playing outside again, reading books instead of playing meaningless and violent video games? What if mom (or dad) taught them their ABCs and 123s and they started school in kindergarten instead of spending four years in preschool? What if libraries and city parks once again became places of wonder?
What if the reduced stress in our lives made it so we could better manage our marriages and divorce was the exception rather than the rule? What if we hiked and rode our bicycles instead of going to the gym? What if going out to dinner and movie was a real "treat" again?
Would the "less," the "lower" standard of living we are all so afraid of, be such a bad thing? I'm just wondering...
Advertisement












I'd love a society-wide migration toward fewer, better things. We'd all be better off, and many, many people would learn the difference between quantity and quality.
I'm trying, but I'm a poor example, I've always lived modestly. And kept to the notion that I'd rather drink one good beer (as an example) than five Budweisers.
Sooner or later, none of us is going to be rich enough to keep buying cheap stuff.
February 28, 2009 9:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Since austerity was imposed on me since the Reagan years; I'm perfectly positioned for this recent downturn!
March 1, 2009 12:45 AM | Reply | Permalink
Would love to hear your story some day, Justice...
March 1, 2009 12:59 AM | Reply | Permalink
I was kind of kidding; I've lived aboard a few boats in my time and I've become accustomed to living small; and still do.
We were also raised to not define ourselves by our possessions and I tried to raise my son to not be a little comsumer as well.
My idea of spoiling the grandkids are memberships to the museum and lots of books; well, my grandaughter just turned five and I did ger her a child-sized ceramic tea set.
One can live austerely but not be cheap, eh?
March 1, 2009 4:36 AM | Reply | Permalink
My grandchildren are my downfall as well! Just got through going through some old posts from the time I was away from TPM and realized I miss several posts of yours, where you told quite a bit of your story...sorry I missed it at the time!
March 1, 2009 5:04 AM | Reply | Permalink
It's all good... thanks for reading...
March 1, 2009 5:14 AM | Reply | Permalink
Been there done that, doing that. hahahahaha.
Stilli, you make one think.
March 1, 2009 8:40 AM | Reply | Permalink
Nice post Stilli! Just a little science anecdote you might like:
They took a survey of Harvard students, asking them which of the following scenarios they would prefer -
1. they earn $100.000 while their peers earn $200.000, or
2. they earn $50.000 while their peers earn $50.000.
A vast majority preferred the latter. Basically most or much of what we work to achieve now is a matter of getting ahead/keeping up with the Joneses. To me it's a nice encapsulation of insanity.
I remember a story about Margaret Thatcher, who said that if she saw a man over 30 taking the bus, she considered him a failure. That's a bizarre ethos, but its one we've been living by for a long time now...
March 1, 2009 8:51 AM | Reply | Permalink
Stilli - just in case you're interested in how academics are starting to get around to these questions, take a peek here:
http://isites.harvard.edu/icb/icb.do?keyword=k13943&pageid=icb.page224311&pageContentId=icb.pagecontent462379&state=maximize
very jargonny 'theory-theory' stuff, I realize (but if you want the underlying draft papers, let me know). I was going to post something on just this topic, but not enough time these days to do it properly.
March 1, 2009 9:32 AM | Reply | Permalink
You are free to live as you choose, if you prefer to live simply, do so. After a few more months of Obama I doubt anyone will have the choice, we will all be living in cardboard boxes. I guess that will make the true leftists happy, because everyone will be equal.
March 1, 2009 9:20 AM | Reply | Permalink
Interesting how you lay the blame as his feet. He's just trying to clean up the burning bag of dog doo doo left on his doorstep...Your peeps left it there...blame them for your cardboard box!
March 1, 2009 1:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Burning bag of dog's leavings, cardboard box, I see a golden opportunity here.
Roast bulldog, anyone?
March 1, 2009 4:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
What if less really was more? More depth. More efforts to care and understand what really matters. Things like that!
March 1, 2009 1:19 PM | Reply | Permalink
Good post. I've been thinking about that approach to life for a while.
To that end, I've moved from the townhouse I was renting to a large master bedroom in a shared house I found on craigslist. I'm in the process of selling all the unused items I have via craigslist, ebay & garage sales. No more bookstores, the library is more enjoyable anyway... Netflix is better than buying DVDs.
Luckily, I still have some IT contract work from my former company that lets me telecommute, so gas use is reduced and I can ride my bicycle to the store.
Oh, and I'm very close to dropping cable TV outright in favor of just an internet connection.
Simplify... all the rest of it is just clutter.
March 1, 2009 2:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
To evaluate whether less wouldn't be so bad, we'd have to include the poor in the conversation. The poor were last discussed about 1976, I think.
March 1, 2009 3:03 PM | Reply | Permalink
Agreed.
Somehow these discussions all revolve around how people can make do with only one plasma TV as the benchmark of doing with "less."
We also need to discuss the people who don't have enough to eat, or a place to sleep, when we go on about the virtues of doing with less.
The discussion also tends to focus on how the upper middle-class should cut back, with little discussion of how the upper class should cut back. That's where most of the "stuff" is. (Insert obligatory Willie Sutton reference here.)
Reducing our materialism may make us feel better is some ascetic way, but it does virtually nothing towards helping those who truly suffer for the lack of "stuff" (food, housing, etc.). To do that we don't need to "cut back," we need to "take back."
March 1, 2009 4:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
You bring up a good point, and I'm hoping that in the process of all this change we reexamine our views and do a better job of caring for those who can't care for themselves.
I do understand the view of those who don't want the fruits of their hard work to go to people who "won't" care for themselves, but compassion in a wealthy society demands that we care for all, whether we feel they "deserve" it, or not. Just as our justice system says that it is better to let many of the guilty go free to avoid having an innocent be punished, sometimes you have to feed some of the able, to make sure the disabled don't starve.
This is one of my biggest complaints about the Christian Right...our religion DEMANDS this of us, yet so many try to avoid it...
March 1, 2009 4:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
I have been trying to state this very thing, but not nearly as poetic. Great post. I concur 100%.
I am probably one of the few here old enough to remember when life was pretty much like how you described. And for me, at least, a pretty fun time to be a kid. Spent most of my summer playing in the woods behind our house. The winter was school but weekends and after homework playing in my room. TV was Saturday morning cartoons or rarely some afternoon kids show.
And I don't remember anyone ever having a theropist.
C
March 1, 2009 3:59 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh and a very wise person, wise beyond his years said to me. "The more you have, the more you become slave.
C
March 1, 2009 4:03 PM | Reply | Permalink