'Jon & Kate Plus 8' : Reel Tragedy
Christof: We've become bored with watching actors give us phony emotions. We are tired of pyrotechnics and special effects. While the world he inhabits is, in some respects, counterfeit, there's nothing fake about Truman himself. No scripts, no cue cards. It isn't always Shakespeare, but it's genuine. It's a life.
The Coogan Act (AKA California Child Actor's Bill) was first passed in 1939 in response to the plight of Jackie Coogan, who earned millions of dollars only to discover, on reaching adulthood, that his parents had spent almost all of it. To date, neither The Coogan Act, or any other laws protect the children of today's reality television programs from the emotional scars that are sure to form. With the help of 'Jon & Kate' hopefully this will change, and soon.
'Jon & Kate Plus 8' is a reality television program about the Gosselin family, consisting of parents Jon and Kate and their eight children--a set of fraternal twin girls and a set of sextuplets (three girls and three boys, all fraternal). The show follows the family through their daily lives, focusing on the day-to-day challenges of raising multiple children.
The Gosselin home has been converted into a production studio:
Recently there has not been much joy and light in the Gosselin house. First, the tabloids headlined Jon's indiscretions, then it was Kate's turn. Then, the inevitable rumors of a split followed by blame the media, and what a bad person she is, all leading up to the season premier, where of course the not so loving couple, blame the media. Of course the ratings were through the roof. The critics weren't very kind:Between the specials and the series, permanent light fixtures were installed in the Gosselins' home to facilitate filming, and prevent the children from tripping over the wires and cables of temporary lighting. Jon & Kate Plus 8 is filmed three days a week, with one day set aside for the interview sessions where Jon, Kate, and occasionally the children, discuss the events which take place in each episode. In the house that the family lived in before their move in late 2008, the "interview corner" was located in the basement, and was transformed from the playroom when needed. It was painted green, unlike the rest of the playroom. In their new house, the interview set was reproduced and constructed in an unfinished area of the basement. At the conclusion of season four's finale, Jon and Kate said they will be making a new set for season five.
Jon and Kate also work closely with producers to decide what themes will be presented in each episode. Jon and Kate have remarked that over the years the production crew has become part of the family. (WikipediA)
At one point in the show, Kate complained that her life was "just so hard" due to media attention and pressures on her marriage. "Is it really, Kate?" sniped the Baltimore Sun's David Zurawik. "Tell that to a family in which the breadwinner has just lost her or his job, you silly, self-absorbed fool."There was a lone blogger asking viewers not to watch the show, Kate's sister-in-law Julie. In her blog she exposed the inner workings of the show:
"When the show first started, Kate made a wishlist of things that she wanted, and that became the theme of each episode--the carpet, twin's room, bunk beds, cow, hairplugs, teeth whitening, trips, etc. EVERYTHING that you see them do or buy is completely paid for out of the budget for the show or traded for free advertising. Kate went on and on about saving up for special days, you saw her paying for things, she talked about budgeting, etc. It is all for the appearance that they are a struggling family with 8 children. They needed to be relatable. They didn't pay for any of it.And, would you believe it's scripted?:
"The episodes are also staged. Here's how it works...there is a staff of people reading these blogs and they base the shows around what people are talking about. I haven't watched many episodes, but I do know some of the behind the scenes events.
"The Christmas episode from 2007. Producers told Kate that the viewers wanted to see her show appreciation to their helpers. They told her what the episode was going to be. I think they baked cookies and then went caroling (of course this was probably one of their many 'traditions"--those are all fake too). Kate threw a fit. She didn't want to do it, but she did...because they were trying to pacify the viewers.
"Don't believe everything you see. The children are also being prompted to say or do certain things. They signed their lives away to TLC and they will continue to spin the show to keep the viewer's interest. I don't believe this show will go away until the viewers decide that they don't want to be played anymore.Through all this there has nary been a mention of the real victims here, the children. Today, that changed when Kate's brother and sister-in-law, Kevin and Jodi Kreider, appeared on the "The Early Show" to tell Co-Anchor Harry Smith that they believe "Jon & Kate Plus 8" is child exploitation:
During the interview Kate's brother became emotional, wiping away a tear:SMITH: This is very interesting because over the weekend a lot of people were saying, I don't even know who these people are, and suddenly they have really exploded into the American consciousness. And years ago, when this reality show started, you all were sort of involved in it, weren't you?
K. KREIDER: yes, we were.
J. KREIDER: We were.
SMITH: And what was the idea initially? Here's this family. They have eight children. We'll do a reality show. Was it almost like a -- sort of a documentary process?
J. KREIDER: Exactly. It started out that way. And that was a really neat thing to be a part of, thinking that, you know, the children are -- a little bit of their life is being captured, but it quickly -- we thought it was very innocent at the time.
And it -- the first season started, I think, eight episodes. And it quickly turned into more and more demand from Jon and Kate from the network, and it turned into 40 episodes in a six-month span. And also it -- there were cameras in the children's bedrooms at one point. And they were filming all year around. And these were very huge concerns for us.
It's about the children:K. KREIDER: Well, I think we're speaking out now because we want to be the voice of our nieces and nephews. And we're seeing it turn tide that they're being viewed as a commodity, that -- I'm sorry. That they...
SMITH: This is clearly an emotional issue for you. Do you want to go ahead?
J. KREIDER: They're being exploited. And it's time for America to see the situation for what it really is, which is unfortunately, there are to laws protecting children in reality TV shows. And it's time for the public to be aware of this.
And that these children are very aware of the cameras in their homes. Their home is their workplace. And this is not a healthy environment for kids to be raised in.
Just as there are laws on who can drive a car there needs to be laws on the exploiting of children on reality television. With Octomom, Nadya Suleman out there pitching scripts, and heaven knows how many woman artificially inseminating as many eggs as possible, who knows where, or how this will end. Hopefully without more innocent children being exploited, and damned to a life of endless therapy, or worse. A childhood is a terrible thing to lose.J. KREIDER: Like they don't want the cameras around. They have told me personally, I don't like...
SMITH: Your nieces and nephews.
J. KREIDER: Of course, yes. We watched them quite a bit about a year ago and further back. And, you know, they would say, Aunt Jodi, I don't like the cameras on every vacation with us. I don't like them, you know. And, too, you know, kids have bad times, bad moments, they cry, and having the camera zoom in on a crying child. I mean, this is just -- this is -- this should not be a form of entertainment.
















Many moons ago and long before the concept of "reality" tv (an oxymoron if there ever was one)PBS put camera in the home of a family. I think their surname was Loud. For some extended period of time (at least for then) the cameras documented pretty much everything that went on in that home. The footage aired as a tv show call An American Family. It was pretty controversial at the time for any number of reasons not the least of which was an openly gay son. The story of the family then and since was nothing but tragedy after tragedy. Don't know if it would have ended up that way regardless but ya have to wonder. I wonder if these strange people with 8 kids have any sense of the potential impact on their kids? They may be getting a taste of it due to their own weirdness and the negative publicity it attracts.
May 28, 2009 2:23 AM | Reply | Permalink
I remember An American Family, it aired in 2002, and was listed at #32 on TV Guide's 50 Greatest TV Shows of All Time list. It was also an impetus for Albert Brooks's 1979 film 'Real Life.'
The big difference between the Loud children and the Gosselins' is the youngest Loud was 14 at the time. Also the show was not scripted as so-called reality is today.
There was a sad follow up:
WikipediA
There was also a famous British series which I believe inspired 'An American Family' but it's 4am and I can't remember the name.
May 28, 2009 7:47 AM | Reply | Permalink
Having bloggers script your life is a little spooky.
May 28, 2009 9:38 AM | Reply | Permalink
Fake or real - no difference whatsoever. These kids (and their parents) are performers, like it or not. Think of the Brady Bunch. Do you think little Cindy Olsen at 5 years old made the decision to accept the role? How about Mary Kate and Ashley? All of those kids were in the public eye..all of the time...constantly. Even when they weren't on the set. No difference. Kids have been pushed to perform by their parents since the days of Shirley Temple.
Their privacy is not being invaded because every shot is scripted ahead of time. They decide what they do.
It is only those who believe this show is "reality" that are outraged by the invasion into the "real lives" of these kids.
May 28, 2009 3:41 PM | Reply | Permalink
Cindy Olsen had her own home to go to at the end of the day. There was a very clear delineation between the Brady home - a Hollywood set - and the Olsen home where her real family lived.
No such luck for the Gosselin kids. Anyone who's ever watched the show has seen the potty training, the emotional meltdowns, and the spontaneous moments that can't be scripted and can't be faked by toddlers.
There are laws that protect child actors like Cindy and Mary Kate and Ashley - the laws dictate how many hours they can spend on the set, what kinds of things they can be asked to do, and how their money will be spent. No such protections for kids on reality shows.
The Gosselins have no legal obligation to set up any kind of trust fund for their kids as the parents of child actors are required to do. They can keep the kids in front of the camera 24 hours a day if they want.
May 28, 2009 5:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
"They can keep the kids in front of the camera 24 hours a day if they want."
You hit the nail on the head, debbie - there needs to be laws, now.
May 28, 2009 5:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ok, I'll give you the fact that they must be covered by the same laws as child actors. But heck, the TV crew does go home daily. It is not the truman show, they do not have a crew taping 24/7. Unlike the parents of regular actors, these parents decide what gets shot and what doesn't (as referenced in this post).
Your quote:
"Anyone who's ever watched the show has seen the potty training, the emotional meltdowns, and the spontaneous moments that can't be scripted and can't be faked by toddlers."
Mary Kate and Ashley were infants. The live studio audience got to see their tantrums. So I guess it boils down to editing doesn't it? They carefully craft what we see. It it hardly reality.
May 28, 2009 8:40 PM | Reply | Permalink