« Tripp Palin news rollout adds mystery to birth | socraticgadfly's Blog | Anchorage Daily News busted on chickensh*t Palin birth coverage »

Some historic context on "worst since Depression" claims, please


Josh posted reader LG's comments about this earlier today, and I agree.

Can the MSM, like CNN in this case, talking about 2008's job losses being the worst since 1945 put the job-loss figures into some historical context? The 1945 population was about half of today. In fact, it's not as bad as 1982, even.

See my blog link for more about this vs. 1982, if you're under 40, and for concerns about the "worst since Depression" line becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Now, it is true, as Kevin Phillips has so well noted, that unemployment calculation methodology has been, to be blunt, "fudged" since 1982. That said, some of the fudging had been done before then, as Phillips has also written.

That said, as I note, there's a full percentage point difference between 2008 job losses and 1982. Even with allowance for fudging, I don't think you can say problems now are significantly worse than they were then.


We now have more evidence that 1982 was worse. I know that under-35s, and perhaps to some degree, even those in the 35-39 range don't grasp this, or else aren't old enough to remember, it, but 1980-82 was a real recession, not like the Poppy Bush recession that got Clinton elected, or the Clinton/Shrub Bush recession.


2 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

The difference is that while the 1982 figures represented the bottom, the 2008 figures may not be anywhere near the bottom of the slump. Hence, the gloom and doom.

user-pic

The news propaganda machine began touting recession eighteen months before it began. As soon as we had an official recession, they began shouting depression.

It's part of the talking points put out creating a sense of crisis to get the public to accept a socialist takeover of our lives.

Leave a comment

socraticgadfly

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 1

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Website: socraticgadfly.blogspot.com
  • Party Unregistered by political party
  • Politics Left-liberal. Would probably vote Socialist instead of Green if we had a Socialist party in Texas.

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs Counterpunch - real left-liberal news and analysis. Pharyngula - evolution with a bit of social snark.
  • Favorite Books "The Frozen Republic" - best argument I've read for the need for parliamentary democracy in America.

Bio

Community newspaper editor for more than a decade; currently in suburban Dallas. Undergraduate liberal arts degree. Graduate divinity degree. Politically? An eclectic, skeptic LEFT-liberal. Voted Green (and, no, NOT Nader) in 2004 and 2008. Atheist and supporter of efforts of most New Atheist writers.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address