« Would Steven Hawking Survive the U.S. Health Care System? | Sabo Pike's Blog | Solidarity in the Rest of the World »

Greatest Canadian and the Shoulders He Stood On


The Greatest Canadian, according to a CBC poll in 2004, is  Tommy Douglas, the creator of Canadian Medicare. I learned this when a friend sent me a quote from a column by Gail Pettett. Having a habit of not believing everything I am told I looked it up.

Yep, he was No. 1. Douglas started his health reform program in Saskatchewan and then brought it to the nation as a whole, which may explain the differences in wait times, etc., between provinces. His job was probably made easier because Canada was a British Commonwealth and many people had been exposed to the British National Health System.

After admiring the fact a Baptist minister could get the social gospel (Can't you imagine Richard Land of the ironically named Baptist Ethics group fainting over that?), I wandered over to the Great Britons.

Sadly, Aneurin Bevan, credited with beginning the British national health system, only made it to No. 45 in the Great Britons' list. Despite the landslide Labour victory in 1945, it took Bevan 18 months to get the participation of the British Medical Association (which appears to have been as obstructive as the American version), according to Wikipedia. The article says, "Bevan finally managed to win over the support of the vast majority of the medical profession by offering a couple of minor concessions, but without compromising on the fundamental principles of his NHS proposals."

You have probably heard Bevan's quote on the process, "I stuffed their mouths with gold." Unfortunately, it looks like that may be what will have to happen with health care reform and the insurance companies, big pharma, etc., today.

Since, T.R. Reid calls the British system the Beveridge system, I wandered over to check out Mr. William Beveridge, the author of the Beveridge Report. In 1941 (1941!) England commissioned a report on how to rebuild after World War II. Even more amazingly, they actually used it to guide policy!

I was struck by Beveridge's use of one of my favorite arguments for health reform to promote his plan. Again to quote Wikipedia,
One of its most remarkable assets was the convincing manner of Beveridge's argument which made it so widely acceptable: Beveridge appealed to conservatives and other doubters by arguing that the welfare institutions he proposed would increase the competitiveness of British industry in the post-war period, not only by shifting labour costs like healthcare and pensions out of corporate ledgers and onto the public account, but also by producing healthier, wealthier and thus more motivated and productive workers who would also serve as a great source of demand for British goods.

How can American companies compete with those from countries that don't have to pay a significant percentage of their personnel costs for health care? How can small businesses, who pay an even higher percentage of their costs for health care compete with anybody?

Also on the Canadian list was Sir Frederick Grant Banting, the discoverer of insulin. In 1923, 40 years before the invention of Canadian Medicare, the Canadian government honored his  winning of the Nobel Prize  by giving him a annuity to support his research. A good way to get innovation, right.

I bet you thought an American discovered insulin. Earlier, I was trying to think of a major American health innovation: Heart transplant? No, South African. Test tube baby? Nope, England. It was pointed out to me an American invented the artificial heart. Of course, in American we invent things we can sell at a profit!



8 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Well it kinda dispels the myth that Canadians hate their government run health care.

And I think Beveridge's arguments, as the Brits say, were spot on. It is all about competition, it will give real competition to a market that is sadly lacking in it right now, and will help vast amount of businesses grow by removing the anchor of health care costs which is holding them back.

user-pic

I just wanted to add personally, competition in the marketplace and companies being able to be more profitable is a justifiable by-product if everyone gets free health care. I am comfortable with that trade-off. ;)

user-pic

Freddy Banting was almost my godfather. Canada is still part of the Commonwealth. Hockey is good. It's okay. There is some civilization outside these Borders.

user-pic

Maybe we could check in with Canadian hockey players about how they like their medical treatment after a game.

user-pic

Great blog. I'll be saving this as ammunition to be used later. I doubt if it'll be languishing for long!

My dad was Canadian. I remember the days when we Yanks used to laugh at those Canucks and their provincial ways.

Now my cousins are giving it back to me. . .and I'm fresh out of arguments as to why our health care system is better than theirs. They've got me there.

user-pic

Canadians grouse about our health care system but we love it. It's a hobby like the weather and hockey. A Canadian politician attacks it as his peril as do Americans. Conservative Americans don't understand when they distort anecdotal comments about our health care system they assume there is no support for our system in the electorate. Au contraire! We see through that crap in a nanosecond. I mean our football fields have an extra 10 yards and we have three downs. I rest my case. Vive la difference!

user-pic

We have nothing to teach you. But you haven't got it right yet. Yours is too expensive per capita and the US has poor statistical indicators of good health. We're happy to go our way with a happier population and businesses with a competitive advantage over yours. Figure it out for yourselves and leave us out of your angst. We're not into penis envy.

user-pic

p.s. Stop exporting handguns into Canada for our gangs to kill each other and innocent bystanders.

Leave a comment

Sabo Pike

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 2

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address