« A 3-1 split for Dems in Texas Congressional redistricting? | socraticgadfly's Blog | Now a top-1,000 Amazon reviewer »

RIP Wilma Mankiller -- but no hagiography


A great activist for both women's and Native American rights has passed away.

That said, even Wilma Mankiller wasn't perfect. And, Salon missed a definite black mark on her record.

Descendants of Cherokee-owned black slaves remain excluded from tribal rolls, despite many of them having Cherokee blood, analogous to descendants of white-owned black slaves, and also despite many a Cherokee having a dash -- or well more than a dash -- of white blood.

Unfortunately, Salon's story says nothing about the struggle of the slave descendants for recognition, nor about Mankiller's role in denying them this status.

The story has its complexities, in that the "white father" government in Washington, after forcing the Cherokee to accept that slavery was over (in 1866! the Cherokee remained holdouts!) also tried to push them into accepting the freedmen as part of the tribe. That said, due to the amount of racial commingling already among the Cherokees, why they resisted this already back then, I don't know, other than to say this is yet more evidence that racism is not confined to Caucasians.

Leave a comment

socraticgadfly

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 5

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Website: socraticgadfly.blogspot.com
  • Party Unregistered by political party
  • Politics Skeptical! left-liberal. I wish we could have a science-based national political party, like if Union of Concerned Scientists started one. Would probably vote Socialist instead of Green if we had a Socialist party in Texas. Even more,

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs Counterpunch - real left-liberal news and analysis. Pharyngula - evolution with a bit of social snark.
  • Favorite Books "The Frozen Republic" - best argument I've read for the need for parliamentary democracy in America. A top-1,000 reviewer on Amazon, based almost entirely on non-fiction reviews: http://www.amazon.com/gp/cdp/member-reviews/A2YP7JPI48MRG8/ref=cm_cr_auth/102-4454413-4636940?%5Fencoding=UTF8
  • Favorite Quotes "There is no god and I am his prophet" - Steve Snyder

Bio

Community newspaper editor for more than a decade; unfortunately, that company folded and I am currently out in the Ground Zero of Bushland, namely, Odessa, Texas. As someone in the media biz, I can say most claims for "new media" are overrated, as overrated as Obama's change. (The proprietor of this site has staff that have written anonymously sourced stories, just like "old media," after all.) Undergraduate liberal arts degree. Graduate divinity degree. Politically? An eclectic, skeptic LEFT-liberal. Voted Green (and, no, NOT Nader) in 2004 and 2008. Atheist and supporter of efforts of most New Atheist writers.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address