« DOW then and now eerily similar. | RWN's Blog | A line in the sand...political demagoguery meets nihilism »

Was David Brooks calling for the destruction of the Republican Party?


The despair seems to be permeating through the opinion-makers, leaders and commentators from the Right. I mean this goes far deeper than the urban slang offered by RNC Chairman Michael Steele when he gave the mia culpa;

"[W]e know the past, we know we did wrong. 'My Bad'".

I mean come on, your BAD? That is not going to cut it Mr. Michael "card-carrying President of the 'Stockholm Syndrome' Club of America" Steele, taking over for the absolutely looney tunes charactor Alan Keyes. By the way what do they put in the water in Maryland to produce caricatures like this but....

Back to Brooks who is a bona fide intellectual who can self examine with some objectivity, which has always made him dangerous. When Brooks reacted to Governor Jindal's "Official GOP Response", he said it was a:
 
"to come up in this moment in history with 'the stale government is the problem, we can't trust the Federal Government', is just a disaster for the Republican Party....but the idea that the government is going to have no role in this when in a moment only the Federal Government is big enough to do stuff, just to ignore all that, government is the problem, corruption, earmarks, wasteful spending is just a form of nihilism, It just is not where the country is...".

Now when you start to really think what Brooks is trying to say he offers a genuine  'self-realization' a look in the mirror so to speak, that his Republican Party of the last 30 years, has evolved to this point, where its core values and beliefs are in reality---unfounded. That the existence of the Republican Party, as it stands right now, being senseless and useless. If you extract the penetrating and revealing irony from the definition of, nihilism you have to ask yourself the question; Is Brooks beginning the discussion for the call of the destruction of the post-war conservative movement and the Republican Party that it has consumed, as the only desirable path for America's sake?

If you really look what Brooks said Tuesday off the cuff: The Republican Party at this critical time in our nation's history, lacks the ability to look at the world in any rational manner, as demonstrated in Jindal's speech, denying any objectivity as understanding basic self-evident political truths, that right now only the Federal Government can do " stuff"  

To me, it was a strange, even premeditated use of an unusual term on national TV.  Taken in that context, coupled with the comments from Olympia Snowe along with the apparent reactionary primary challenge to Arlen Specter in PA, Snowe simply stated to RNC Chair Steele when he proposed systematic primary challenges to those who broke with the the Republican Party to pass the Stimulus Bill, "that the GOP was in the majority when they had moderate members and is not in the majority now when it has but a few.

Are we seeing the collapse of the Republican Party? I will say this, some 20 months out from the 2010 mid-terms, if the Democratic Party majority expands in the Congress and correspondingly, in the state legislatures, the GOP will probably start to break up. It has happened before in our history.

I am working on a book about the Colorado and Colorado Springs and the story behind the story of the 2008 election. What has jumped out is that outside of two counties, the 2nd and 8th largest in Colorado, Barack Obama and Mark Udall carried 57% of the 2008's popular vote. This is a state where only voted for a Democratic Presidential candidate in only 5 presidential elections since 1920; (FDR in '32 &'36, Truman '48, LBJ '64, & Clinton '92) 5 out of 22 elections, and yet outside of those two hardened Republican base counties which comprises about 17% of CO's population, the Democrats have grown to polling 57% for Obama and Udall. No wonder 5 of 7 Congressional Representatives are Democats, CO has both Senators from the Democratic Party as well.

Why?  How did this come about? Well in short, it is the full outcome from the Republican Agenda that was completely played out in Colorado in the 1980's and 1990's. It has a hardened state and local government budget process than cannot respond to the Depression Era Economics and must cut government services by a constitutional statute. It has blithering idiots like State Senator Schulheis who makes statements about AIDS that are revengful and absolutely ignorant, even yesterday! And still the GOP simply offers up the same belief and values that Jindal promoted in his response speech----adjunct nihilism.

Fascinating David, fascinating self awareness of the movement you fostered and promoted.  


10 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

The GOP has become a clogged toilet bowl filled with the political waste of America. It wasn't always that, but it certainly is now. It can't be flushed. It can't be plunged. It must be ripped out tossed into a pit and burned.

user-pic

We can only hope. I bow my head in prayer.

RWN, really fine take on this. Brooks was just shaking when delivered this message. Shaking his head.

It is ironic when you see old George Will going right down the right wing s hole.

I have no pity whatsoever for these people. When I think of guys like Frisk, cheney, Allen, Hastert,..
lording it over everyone, and they are gone.

hahahahahaha

user-pic

40 years ago, as a Liberal Republican, I realized that the Republican Party had turned its back on my values and that the Democratic Party represented them. Since then, my principles have never changed. Since then, I have never voted for a Republican.

From that day to this, I have never understood how people like Brooks, or like Susan Collins and Olympia Snowe for that matter, could stay tied to a party whose political, social, moral, and ethical values are so antithetical to their own. I suspect that Brooks now, like me in 1968, is asking himself the same question.

user-pic

Perhaps because it makes more sense to stay and fix a party rather than let it remain in the hands of ideologues? The reason the republican party is crazy is because all the progressive conservatives left. It's also why the democratic party today isn't a stark-raving mad left equivalent of the Rabid Right.

user-pic

No need for Brooks to worry. Sarah Palin is already working on the destruction of the Republican Party.

user-pic

For the last 40 years, right up until Obama, the democratic party has marched in lock-step with the crazy corporate-controlled government experiment we are seeing go down in flames right now. They may have thrown bones to their progressive roots here and there with things like SCHIP, but both parties have been practicing corporate-influenced policy making for decades.

I think a better question to be asking is how can liberals better help conservative moderates reclaim ownership of the party? To hope that the republican party is going to go the way of the Whigs is wishful thinking at best. The party may get more insular and crazier, but it is too big to simply disappear, It can continue to be a huge thorn in all of our sides.

Or, alternatively, it can restructure and reform from the grassroots upward. That usually takes a couple of election cycles as incumbents are replaced, but as the democrats have seen since 2004, a party can be totally changed if the rank and file members start voting in larger numbers and with greater clarity.

All you have to do is look at the percentage of turn-out for the primary elections these last 40 years to see how we became so divided along party lines. Most members of Congress have been there for decades. The only people that turnout for primaries are far left or far right "wackos" who actually care enough to be involved. Once we get to the general election, the status quo dice has already been cast.

The true center of this country abdicated its responsibilities a long time ago, on the left and right.

user-pic

Your arguments about why the dems have been moderated and the republicans are becoming isolated kind of cuts against the demise of the republican party. They are not that big right now and there is a slow bleed, that is becoming a tidal wave, of moderates out of the party. If they don't do a 180 on where they are as a party, I wager that they will cease to exist, like the whigs. You can't be a national party with a handful of states in the deep south and the mormon west, without any appeal to 4/5ths of the country. It's not possible.

user-pic

"They're not that big right now..." That statement alone makes much of what follows not true at all. The republican party is still roughly a third of the electorate. Of the independents who make up the non-democratic third, half of them identify as politically conservative.

The death of the republican party is greatly exaggerated.

Further, the "moderates" you speak of fleeing the party just isn't true either. Most of the grassroots of the republican is moderate. The wing-nuts on the far right are not the majority of the party, notwithstanding its current crazed positioning. The party leadership may ride this failed ideology to its ultimate demise, but the voters will start sending better representatives at some point and get rid of incumbents.

I don't think the situation is as simple and straightforward as you are making it sound.

user-pic
Back to Brooks who is a bona fide intellectual
I haven't closely followed Brooks' writing over the years, so I may have too small a sample to have a genuinely informed opinion, but I simply can't swallow that statement. There's a good reason that a large number of the leftish humor/snark/verbal abuse blogs refer to him as "Bobo".
user-pic

Oh, come on, he isn't that bad. I've read alot of his columns and may not agree with the politics, but he is definitely not a liar and he doesn't make up facts, like the kristols and couters of the world. He actually is pretty smart and calls it like he sees it. His comments on jindal and the speech were spot on.

Leave a comment

RWN

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 3

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address