Two Hundred Million Missing Women
Beginning with Amartya Sen's demographic calculations in the Eighties, estimates of how many women die each year in excess of demographic projections have been gradually refined.
The term "missing women" was coined in 1990, when Indian economist Amartya Sen calculated a shocking figure. In parts of Asia and Africa, he wrote in The New York Review of Books, 100 million women who should be alive are not, because of unequal access to medical care, food and social services. These are excess deaths: women "missing" above and beyond natural mortality rates, compared to their male counterparts.His research began a flutter of activity in academic circles and by 2005, the United Nations produced a much higher estimate for how many women could be "missing": 200 million.
(Details of various methodolgies for estimating the number of "missing women" are discussed in The Elgar Companion to Development Studies, which is available online, beginning at page 389.)
Professor Siwan Anderson of the University of British Columbia is one of the principle researchers whose work supports the recent UN estimate of 200 million "missing women," and some of her conclusions are very dark.
In China, Anderson says, most of the 141,000 excess female deaths by injury were suicides, making China the only place in the world where women are more likely than men to kill themselves, often by eating pesticides used for crops.And in India, a category called "injuries" yielded ominously high figures: 86,000 excess deaths in the age group 15-29 in 2000 alone. Anderson has done extensive research in India, and says the numbers beg the question of exactly how many deaths were so-called "kitchen fires" - often used to mask dowry-related killings, the result of a new bride being tortured by her new family until her parents pay their debts.
According to an Amnesty International report in 1999, though 1,600 "bride-burnings" were reported, sixty were prosecuted but only two resulted in convictions.
The same report includes a lot of vivid details, and not much hope for progress in the foreseeable future.
The lives of millions of women in Pakistan are circumscribed by traditions which enforce extreme seclusion and submission to men. Male relatives virtually own them and punish contraventions of their proprietary control with violence.For the most part, women bear traditional male control over every aspect of their bodies, speech and behaviour with stoicism, as part of their fate, but exposure to media, the work of women's groups and a greater degree of mobility have seen the beginnings of women's rights awareness seep into the secluded world of women.
But if women begin to assert their rights, however tentatively, the response is harsh and immediate: the curve of honour killings has risen parallel to the rise in awareness of rights.
Until recently, discussion of Professor Sen's original research had concentrated on gender-based abortion and infanticide, but a growing consensus of researchers in the field has recognized that abuse of adult females also plays a significant role in the disappearance of so many women, for example in India and Pakistan, where thousands of women are burned alive every year because of problems with their dowries.
















It's really hard to comment after reading this... Just brought my mind to a screeching halt for a moment.
There is so much more going on than just these things you mention to women and girls around the world. I know I am extremely fortunate to live in the US. I could imagine myself killing myself in some of the circumstances women around the world find themselves in which is horrifying to say...as I go on with my silly, little life...
These things make me believe in evolution... because it is reflective of the how strongly the animal and instintive in humankind is still very powerful.
It also made me think for a moment about this entire tendency to make someone less and others more over sex, or color, or sexual orientation, or how much money you make or have, what level of education you have, etc.
I wrote on the Zip's blog discussing faith thanking him for acknowledging the value of intuition along with reason as it is often viewed as worthless or 'worth' 'less'. He wrote many meaningful and beautiful things about this throughout the dialogue on that post.
And well... it got me thinking about the notion of even intuition as a 'feminine aspect' being valued less and the notion of women being onsidered 'worth' 'less'... and frankly I've had to and still have to deal with notions and ideas that 'I am' worth less. Which is truly sad as I have so much more opportunity than many women in the world.
Wow, didn't expect this experience. Not sure where to go from here but thanks for jarring my thinking.
June 10, 2009 6:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
yes, as you say, we are lucky to live in the U.S., in many, many ways. and the dis"honor" killings that occur elsewhere seem to be of a different order or nature than the murders of women in the U.S.
however, in the U.S., what do you call it when hundreds and maybe thousands of women are murdered yearly by crazed men in their lives? do you think these women are not being killed because men they know can't control them?
be they boyfriends, ex-boyfriends, husbands, ex-husbands, coworkers, obsessed acquaintances, or random monsters, the women murdered in the U.S., though fewer, are still the victims of dis"honor" killings by cowards who wish to control them but can't and resort to psychotic violence against the usually physically weaker and overall more vulnerable gender.
"American Honor Killings": Don't kid yourself otherwise. To think of them otherwise is a denial of the underlying reality that stokes the misogynistic psyche.
it's time to get real about the problem and deal with its sources, including how men are indoctrinated into fearing and loathing women, and how women are portrayed in the giant mass media mirror.
if you disagree with me, that's fine. but if you do, please explain what you think will help correct the glaring problem of endemic misogyny and resultant rampant unwarranted violence.
June 10, 2009 8:59 PM | Reply | Permalink
I appreciate your point... while it wasn't one I was making... my mind took me to the point that even an 'aspect' of the feminine is often discounted as worth 'less' and reason worth 'more'. A general devaluing or ignorance of the feminine...
I grew up in an abusive home of abused parents and I am part native american so I don't feel the need to defend my lack of mention of the fact that things are not so 'perfect' here in the US and I did not mean to imply that. But I do recognize that because of MUCH effort things are better here than many places in the world for women.
I have experienced many things that demonstrated that it is the responsibility of both men AND women to have healthy respect for all feminine and masculine aspects regardless of whether found in a man or woman's form. However, I caution that I don't believe everyone is supposed to be 50/50 balanced in masculine and feminine energy etc. I believe strength comes from being true to who we are.
Even in the aspects of spiritual growth.. I learned early on that there were men who believed it was more difficult for women to become enlightened because of their emotions and differences. Of course, eventually I came to understand that this was because they approached enlightenment 'as men'. Andrew Cohen is a spiritual teacher with his Enlightenment magazine has often expressed this thinking.
I however feel that this issue is one of the strengths of the feminine in embracing higher understanding being different than those of the masculine.
I do think it will take more concerted effort from both men and women to continue to move the tide toward healthier embrace of both the feminine and masculine. This is something that requires long term investment of my hope and courage.
On this blog however, I give pause and feel humility in knowing that while there are still great challenges here for women, how much harder it can be elsewhere for women, and in witnessing the greatness of the task at hand.
June 10, 2009 9:42 PM | Reply | Permalink
Speechless.
June 10, 2009 6:49 PM | Reply | Permalink
Freeze, I don't always agree with your thinking or manner of presentation. But what you lay out here is...well, it's completely sobering, not to mention beyond rational dispute.
Cross-post this as much as possible. Highly rec'd.
June 10, 2009 6:52 PM | Reply | Permalink
What he said. Thanks for writing this.
June 10, 2009 8:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
Heinous, despicable, nauseating, just the first few words that come to mind.
Thanks for posted. Rec'd reading to increase awareness and outrage. Can we send Pro-Lifers here?
June 10, 2009 9:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
I had no idea. Not that I do not admit to ignorance every day on some fact.
BUT THIS!!!
Yes, thank you so much for the information.
The numbers are incredible. What sadness. What grief. What fear must be in the hearts of minds of three times the figure you give us.
June 10, 2009 9:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ok,
after reading this, after crazies shooting people and all the other inane BS I've taken in the last few days...
Here's a bit of sappy feminine response. I love everyone (yes even the ones who have done their worst... despite their actions (with very strong boundaries for the inappropriate and criminal)
If you've never heard the song I invite you to check out this Stevie Wonder song:
"Love's In Need Of Love Today'
Good evening my dear friends
Here's your friendly announcer
I have serious news to pass on to every-body
What I'm about to say
Could mean the world's disaster
Could change your joy and laughter to tears and pain
It's that
'Love's' in need of love today
Don't delay
Send yours in right away
Hate's goin' round
Breaking many hearts
Stop it please
Before it's gone too far
The force of evil plans
To make you its possession
And it will if we let it
Destroy ev-er-y-body
We all must take
Precautionary measures
If love and joy you treasure
Then you'll hear me when I say that
'Love's' in need of love today
Don't delay
Send yours in right away
Hate's goin' round
Breaking many hearts
Stop it please
Before it's gone too far
People you know that
Love's in need of love today
Don't delay
Send yours in right away
It's up to you cause
Love's in need of love today
Don't delay
Send yours in right away
June 10, 2009 9:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
Very good, eye-opening post, Jacob...I knew it was bad, but not HOW bad. Makes me glad to be a woman born in the U.S. (for all it's faults) but it also makes me feel a little helpless in knowing how to bring awareness to the forefront of global thinking.
June 10, 2009 9:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thank you for posting on this. I read the articles as well, and the numbers are stunning. However, these numbers are not global. They are primarily from Asia and Africa. It leaves out, the Middle East, Europe and the Americas. It also leaves out those countries who don't keep (or release) records - such as Burma. In other words, this "invisible" problem is likely even larger than these numbers reflect.
June 11, 2009 12:42 AM | Reply | Permalink
Rutabaga:
I maligned you, in error; after I posted (3) links of supporting documentation, I received a notice that "the blogger is holding your comment for review."
Well. I erroneously assumed that you were holding a grudge. But that is apparently not true. Rather, I offered three links rather than the two allowed. So. My apologies. You have written a post that is really important and which deserves all the attention it can get.
So allow me to link to (2)rather than (3) articles that substantiate your point:
http://www.alternet.org/blogs/reproductivejustice/100860/when_men_murder_women:_new_report_details_homicide_rates/
and
http://www.benbest.com/lifeext/murder.html#canada
The second was not the comparative international chart I found the first time, but it will do.
Thank you for this post.
June 11, 2009 3:27 PM | Reply | Permalink