Mignon Clyburn Will Kill Net Neutrality
Obama is about to nominate Mignon Clyburn to the FCC, and for those of you who want the internet to turn into a low-rent version of cable TV, dominated by Rupert Murdoch and a few other right-wing billionaires, this is very good news.
For the rest of us, it sucks.
Mignon Clyburn is a member of some obscure utilities boards in South Carolina… AND…Jim Clyburn’s daughter, and it isn’t because of those obscure utilities commissions way down in Dixie that Obama is about to put Mignon Clyburn in a position of tremendous influence over the future of the internet.
Her resume is a joke.
And yes indeed, I know she was publisher of the Coastal Times, an impressive title which is always featured prominently in her bio, but I also know that the Coastal Times was nothing but a rag that was distributed free to area churches. It only existed to give Clyburn’s otherwise unemployable daughter the shadow of an occupation, and as soon as Big Jim Clyburn hooked her up with her first commission, the Coastal Times disappeared without a trace.
In 2006, Representative Clyburn voted against H. Amdt. 987 to ensure that network neutrality clauses be added to the Title VII of the Communication Act of 1934. The amendment required all broadband service provides to “operate its broadband network in a nondiscriminatory manner so that any person can offer or provide content, applications, and services through, or over, such broadband network with equivalent or better capability than the provider extends to itself or affiliated parties, and without the imposition of a charge for such nondiscriminatory network operation.”This was a very big deal, in case you don’t remember. Chris Bowers is ringing alarms at Open Left…
There is a disturbing possibility that President Obama has put his excellent open media and network neutrality platform at risk with his latest—and last—Democratic FCC appointment, Mignon Clyburn. There are five seats in the FCC, and “only three commissioners may be members of the same political party.” For the next five years, the FCC will have a 3-2 Democratic majority, once the remaining Republican open seat has been filled. That makes this appointment by President Obama the key swing vote that will largely determine FCC policy and regulation over the next five years. The reason Mignon Clyburn is such a worrying pick is that she is the daughter of South Carolina Representative James Clyburn, who has an anti-Net Neutrality record.
Sascha Meinrath sat on Obama’s Technology, Media, & Telecom advisory committee during the campaign, and his post is carefully apprehensive… “A disaster for the public interest?”
“Behind closed doors, just about everyone I’ve talked with—right across the board—has been deeply concerned that Ms. Clyburn will be a disaster for the public interest,” he wrote. “The dominant feeling is that she is extremely tight with the telecom incumbents and that having her on the FCC will all but ensure a stalemate that will prevent any meaningful telecom reforms from being passed.”“This looks like a traditional “inside baseball” quid-pro-quo — appointing the daughter of a powerful congressman to score political points just doesn’t look good. And there’s the issue that the cable and broadcasting industry are very excited for this nominee — so much so that it has a lot of folks worried about how independent Ms. Clyburn will be vis-a-vis these incumbents’ interests.”
With nothing less than the future of telecommunications riding on the choices this nominee would be making, it leaves me deeply concerned about the future of the FCC and it’s efficacy in addressing a host of problems that have continued to worsen due to it’s lax oversight and its abdication of responsibility to adequately regulate to maximize the public interest.
But the telecoms are already celebrating…
“Mignon Clyburn would bring experience, deep policy understanding and the perspective of a state utility commissioner to the FCC,” a Sprint spokesman said in an e-mail. “Sprint Nextel has worked with her in South Carolina, where she has served on that state’s Public Service Commission, and we look forward to working with her again on any number of issues including restoring competition to the failed special access markets that are stifling broadband deployment in our country.” “Mignon Clyburn brings an insightful and pragmatic perspective to the complex policy issues that the FCC is tackling in today’s dynamic telecommunications environment,” said Kyle McSlarrow, president and CEO of the National Cable & Telecommunications Association (NCTA). “Ms. Clyburn’s extensive experience with intergovernmental groups such as NARUC will make her an invaluable asset to the Commission.” “In Mignon Clyburn’s home state of South Carolina, independent cable operators have been the leaders in delivering voice, video and broadband services to rural communities,” Matthew M. Polka, president and chief executive of the American Cable Association (ACA), which represents small cable operators, said in a statement.














Rooty, Can't you stick to writing depressing posts about out imperial overreach? Do you have to bring it home?
Good find, great picture, and did Jim Clyburn really name his daughter 'cute'?
May 6, 2009 11:50 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yeah I agree with saladin.
Seriously, I don't agree with all your postings, but that a great pic you found of Mignon.Big and clear.
May 7, 2009 12:58 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for the heads up rooty. The FCC has been a joke and not a good one for the past 8 years. Another 5 years of industry biased stewardship is all we need to lock in the Murdoch's, Malones, et al positions of media dominance. Do you know if this is this the subcommittee responsible for approval of the nomination, (for those of us who would like to go the distance, and write letters)?
May 7, 2009 12:56 AM | Reply | Permalink
I think the FCC nominees will appear before the full Commerce Committee.
This is more or less confirmed by the Wall Street Journal.
May 7, 2009 1:16 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for this
Mike Copps is the acting Director and should be given the courtesy of the title.
When Michael Powell, another darling of the telecoms, wanted to loosen the FCC rules, Copps, and commissioner Adlestein objected to the lack of public forums to discuss such a sweeping change. Powell refused to consider public forums. So Copps and Adelstein went around the country on THEIR OWN DIME to tell people of the impending rules changes and a remarkable thing happened.
Not only were Liberals outraged, but Conservatives were, too. (The real ones, I mean). You had Code Pink marching alongside the NRA and all of us writing and calling out Congresspeoples.
We won.
I'll never forget that, or them.
If you value free communication, write President Obama, and ask him to reward the heroism and valor of Michael Copps and John Adelstein. They are the change we have been waiting for, and that they themselves have been waiting for.
May 7, 2009 1:00 AM | Reply | Permalink
I totally agree about Copps and Adelstein.
May 7, 2009 1:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
This really does suck, blue vege. I've written and phoned. I hope everyone else does, too.
May 7, 2009 9:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
You brought up Malone, thst's a blast from the past because bsck in the 80's and 90's when cable was just really coming around, John Malone (then owner of TCI cable) was the king of TV. Now anyone of course because that belongs to Murdoch but it was a intrestring name to bring up.
May 7, 2009 1:02 AM | Reply | Permalink
Noooooo!!!
Why does it have to be like this, South Carolina? You give us Jim DeMint, Mark Sanford, Gamecock football, and now this!? What did we ever do to you?
May 7, 2009 10:11 AM | Reply | Permalink
Hey that's not fair! I'm from SC and you left out Clemson football, Clemson basketball, Lindsey "Buckingham" Graham, state police who harass and kill people of color and last but not least - friggin blue laws- no liquor for sale past sundown or sundays. Good ol South Carolina, where they're too religious to drink in the dark or on the fake sabbath but they're always ready to lynch.
May 7, 2009 11:10 AM | Reply | Permalink
One of these days, I'm convinced, South Carolina is going to deliver a Great American Hero, perhaps even a first-rank liberal president, Sweatman's BBQ will be served in the White House, and people will stop saying, "Oh, that's where you guys kept voting for Strom Thurmond over and over again."
Sigh...
May 7, 2009 11:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
The greatest South Carolinian who ever lived walks amongst us right now:
Stephen Colbert!
May 7, 2009 3:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
Very important catch Ruta, and how so disappointing if daughter is indeed like father. I'd expected better than another anti-neutrality zombie.
May 7, 2009 12:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
Is the FCC some sort of daycare center for politicians' kids?
May 7, 2009 1:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's worse than daycare, according to Sascha Meinrath...
Harharharhar!
The rest of us can't even catch swine flu, much less a break, and Mignon Clyburn gets the FCC as a booby prize!
May 7, 2009 2:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
It was for Colin Powell's son, Michael, during the last two administrations.
May 7, 2009 5:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
I am all for net nuetrality and this post is alarming on that score. However, I'm much more alarmed and disturbed that the FCC which is such an enormously critical and consequential regulatory body would be a place the Obama administration finds appropriate to practice open political hackery with.
Clyburn's daughter can be rewarded with a cushy, well paying and even prominent job in DC without handing her such an important post and one that is so critical to democracy's future. It's really pathetic to see that Obama would allow this sort of thing so quickly. Wasn't the FCC used to award Colin Powell by putting his hack of a son on it as Chairman and then he did all kinds of damage? Why repeat the same sort of easily avoidable mistake? Hackery cannot be totally eliminated, but it has no place at the FCC.
May 7, 2009 3:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
I basically agree with your post, but still...
While we're comparing Mignon Clyburn to someone with a reasonable resume for the FCC, like Michael Copps...
It's also worthwhile to compare Barack Obama to someone with a reasonable resume for President, like Adlai Stevenson...
That is a reasonable resume for a candidate for President.
The difference between Mignon Clyburn and Michael Copps isn't much greater than the difference between Obama and Adlai Stevenson, and Mignon Clyburn probably won't be any more clueless at the FCC than Barack Obama in the White House.
To put it another way, what can Mignon possibly do at the FCC that would be any stupider than appointing her in the first place?
It's like a riddle...
May 7, 2009 4:37 PM | Reply | Permalink
That's an alright post, except the fact that I don't have hatred towards the President and don't find him clueless like you do.
Also I agree with NC Steve on his remarks towards this post.
May 7, 2009 7:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
I don't hate the President.
I hate Dick Cheney.
Dick Cheney is a torture-pig and pervert.
Obama is just a hypocritical con-man.
May 7, 2009 8:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
But of course, that is the problem with hack appointments to begin with. Go ahead and make them, but not in key positions. That's what the Bush people did (and Republicans generally do) and it always ends badly. Obama's biggest strength was his reputation as not being that kind of hack oriented pol. I had hoped he could at least keep that impression going for longer than a few months, but once again I was apparently wrong.
May 7, 2009 9:38 PM | Reply | Permalink
Obviously, anyone who went to UNC is going to be better at just about anything than someone from South Carolina. That goes without saying.
I really don't know much about this lady, but I'm not really clear on why you're 100% certain she'll be out to kill net neutrality and I find that noteworthy because the stated reason for Bowers' alarmism is conspicious in its spuriousness (hardly a first for him, admittedly):
Please. Her daddy voted against a net neutrality amendment so she's certain to vote just like him? That's it? That's what you got? Oh, wait, I forgot, she's "cozy" with industry. Well, okay. That's certainly reason enough to push the drama button.
May 7, 2009 6:03 PM | Reply | Permalink
What have you got, you artless ape from the Tarheel State?
What has Mignon Clyburn got, you hurling pest from Murphy in the West, you cheezy ant from Manteo in the East?
You got nothing!
And Mignon Clyburn is almost nothing except Big Jim Clyburn's daughter.
Compared to her, there was nothing nepotic about Michael Powell at the FCC...
Sure, Michael was Colin's son, but he was also a severely disabled veteran only held together by twine and super-glue, and he already had a stint at DoJ and a clerkship for a federal Appeals Court judge on his resume.
Mignon Clyburn's "resume" is a made-up job delivering newspapers to churches and membership on some SC utilities commissions.
She got nothing!
Obama got nothing!
You got nothing!
Mignon owes everything, (and yes I do mean everything) to Daddy.
And now we're supposed to give the con-man Obama the benefit of the doubt again, because instead of nominating a strong advocate for net neutrality...
Obama paid off a political favor with a seat on the FCC?
Harharharhar!!!
You koolaid huffing Obamabots just get weirder all the time!
May 7, 2009 8:01 PM | Reply | Permalink
Obviously, anyone who went to UNC is going to be better at just about anything than someone from South Carolina. That goes without saying.
I really don't know much about this lady, but I'm not really clear on why you're 100% certain she'll be out to kill net neutrality and I find that noteworthy because the stated reason for Bowers' alarmism is conspicious in its spuriousness (hardly a first for him, admittedly):
Please. Her daddy voted against a net neutrality amendment so she's certain to vote just like him? That's it? That's what you got? Oh, wait, I forgot, she's "cozy" with industry. Well, okay. That's certainly reason enough to push the drama button.
May 7, 2009 6:05 PM | Reply | Permalink