The Democratic silence continues to be baffling. I have seen it argued that this silence is a canny political move, as the Supreme Court will likely strike down the torture legislation and its elimination of habeas corpus.
Waiting for the "Supreme Court" to strike it down is unconscionably risky for several reasons. First, the fact that legislation might be constitutionally permissible (for example, providing unrestricted federal grants to individuals making over ten million per year in capital gains income) does not make it wise or morally defensible. Second, each branch has an obligation to interpret the Constitution--not just the Courts. The president is certainly "interpreting"--with a large red pen that strikes out the sections that he doesn't like. This Supreme Court will not be shy--For god's sake, Justice "plain Language" Scalia signed onto Alito's elevation of signing statements. That's two votes for anything that W wants to do--roberts and thomas makes four for everything except ignoring a statute. Even putting aside the fact that Justice Stevens is 86 years old, the vote balance is different than it was, as Kennedy is friendlier to executive power than O'Connor. In other words, the Supreme Court may, in its current formulation, bless legislation that most of the country finds outrageous. It is far easier to kill legislation than it is to pass it, and any amendment will be portrayed as "soft on terror." That's a far bigger political risk. And what if Stevens dies?
These superficial and, frankly, ill-advised political calculations do not and cannot excuse incumbent legislators from their civil and moral duty to stand up and be counted. These politicians are asking us to stake the freedom of ourselves, our friends and our families on a series of highly questionable probabilities. This legislation is not that of a tough democracy--it is that of a cowed military dictatorship. Stand up and say so. Litigation should be a last resort. For god's sake, watch Clinton's response. He's had the entire Bush administration in damage control for the last several days and it's only getting worse for them.