Bill Frist vs Bill Mahrer on H1N1 Vaccine
Bill Frist, a cardiothoracic surgeon, made a fool of himself by diagnosing intact brain function in Terry Shiavo because of an old video recording. Frist ignored the brain imaging documenting sevee cerebral tissue loss. Bill Mahrer does not trust Western medicine and has apparently come across a dietary, exercise and marijuana coonsumption regime that keeps the satirist healthy.
During the SARS outbreak, Mahrer essentially said that those who had fallen ill became ill because of a lack of adnerence to the Mahrer dietary regime. The science indicated that the risk of infection during air travel was based upon seaing arrangement. Sitting in the row with a SARS infected person or three rows in front or three rows in back of a SARS infected person on an airplane created the greatest risk of infection. Mahrer chose to ignore the science in favor of his personal belief system.
On his most recent show, Mahrer discussed the H1N1 vaccine with Bill Frist. Frist pointed out that the science indicated that pregnant women were at high risk of death if they contracted the H1N1 virus. Mahrer stated that he would not advise a pregnant woman to get vaccinated. To defend his position, Mahrer quoted a decades old statement about live vaccines from the late Jonas Salk.
The data suggests that a pregnant woman who becomes infected with H1N1 is more likely to die of her illness than a person undergoing triple bypass surgery for coronary artery disease. It is curous that on some scientific issues, Mahrer is as much of a Luddite as some religious Fundamentalists.
Mahrer made Frist appear to be the only rational person in the interview..
http://crofsblogs.typepad.com/h5n1/2009/10/extraordinary-death-toll-of-h1n1-in-pregnant-women.html
During the SARS outbreak, Mahrer essentially said that those who had fallen ill became ill because of a lack of adnerence to the Mahrer dietary regime. The science indicated that the risk of infection during air travel was based upon seaing arrangement. Sitting in the row with a SARS infected person or three rows in front or three rows in back of a SARS infected person on an airplane created the greatest risk of infection. Mahrer chose to ignore the science in favor of his personal belief system.
On his most recent show, Mahrer discussed the H1N1 vaccine with Bill Frist. Frist pointed out that the science indicated that pregnant women were at high risk of death if they contracted the H1N1 virus. Mahrer stated that he would not advise a pregnant woman to get vaccinated. To defend his position, Mahrer quoted a decades old statement about live vaccines from the late Jonas Salk.
The data suggests that a pregnant woman who becomes infected with H1N1 is more likely to die of her illness than a person undergoing triple bypass surgery for coronary artery disease. It is curous that on some scientific issues, Mahrer is as much of a Luddite as some religious Fundamentalists.
Mahrer made Frist appear to be the only rational person in the interview..
http://crofsblogs.typepad.com/h5n1/2009/10/extraordinary-death-toll-of-h1n1-in-pregnant-women.html
Advertisement
















Unfortunately, the US government does not have a particularly good record on vaccine safety, between live vaccines and thimerosol. I'll go with Maher, here. Sorry. And my dad was a doctor and my mother a nurse.
October 12, 2009 11:23 AM | Reply | Permalink
So you would instruct a pregnant woman not to take the H1N1 vaccine?
Do you believe thimerosol causes autism?
October 12, 2009 11:51 AM | Reply | Permalink
I hate when someone makes me admit that I agree with Bill Frist about anything.
October 12, 2009 5:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
I know, it was depressing for me to agree with Frist as well. Mahrer was late to accept the internet. Mahrer considered (considers?) bloggers to be losers.
In some areas Mahrer is simply out of touch
October 12, 2009 6:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Counseling people to not get the H1N1 shot is irresponsible, in my opinion. You might be willing to take your chances, and if you get the flu, you might get over it with no complications. But if you get it, you'll give it to others. They might not be so lucky.
October 12, 2009 9:42 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's ironic that there are individuals who become outraged to the point of fury to read about a couple who allowed their 11-year old daughter to die, because their belief in faith healing forbid them to call the doctor, but at the same time put their own children at mortal risk by refusing to have them vaccinated. The delusional worlds of conspiracy theorists and believers in faith healing are equally irrational, but the dangers to humans imposed by the vaccine deniers are far greater than those posed by the occasional faith healing believer.
One additional similarity - each group justifies its irrationality by calling on testimonials consisting of anecdotal information. The validity is bogus in each case, but it allows the denier to pretend he or she is acting on the basis of evidence rather than psychopathology.
October 12, 2009 10:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
I do need to qualify my above comment slightly. A recent poll showed that 60 percent of individuals reluctant to participate in H1N1 vaccination stated that they would be willing to change their mind if they had further evidence supporting the vaccination program. This implies a responsibility on the part of knowledgeable members of the scientific and public health community to expand their educational efforts as the H1N1 epidemic heats up.
October 12, 2009 10:35 PM | Reply | Permalink