« The Other 912 Rally at the National Mall | rmrd0000's Blog | Obama Better For The Country Than McCain says Glenn Beck »
Carter's Little Liver Pill
Jimmy Carter told Brian Williams that much of the hardcore dissent against President Obama was race-based. This sentiment was not uncommon in the African-American community. No one seemed to recall armed protesters arriving at Clinton or GW Bush meetings. One expects much fury on both sides of the issue to be heard in the MSM today.
I generally don't watch "Morning Joe" because I don't learn anything new. But today, following Carter's comments, I was ready to be entertained. I wasn't disappointed. Joe Scarborough's panel consisted of by Mika B, Maria Batiromo, Mike Barnacle and Jonathan Capehart. What I have come to expect from "Morning Joe" is a detailed rationale of how crazy lefties had screwed something up. The segment I saw followed the expected pattern.
Joe told of being from the South and having been on an elevator when someone made a racist comment, all heads, presumably White, turned towards the offender in disgust. According to Scarborough, Carter lives in a bubble and does not know the modern South. I should point out that Carter did say that the racism was not just in the South, but throughout the country.
Mika B chimed in that Carter's comments turned back the clock on race relations and that discussion of race had no place in the political dissent that we were witnessing. It is amazing how fast the post-racial clock can go in reverse because one person's statement. The timing mechanism on the race clock must be pretty weak.
Maria Batiromo was visibly upset.. The financial reporter almost yelled while stating, "It's obvious that you can disagree with the President and not be racist. This is ridiculous". Capehart could borrow some of Bartiromo's passion.
Barnacle put on his sad face and said, "Am I the only one who is depressed that we are discussing race?"
Patrick J Buchanan's name came up during the discussion, reminding me of his "Thank Whitey column, his apology for Hitler's going to war, and the grief he feels because Robert E Lee is not as revered as MLK Jr. I'm supposed to take show that employs Buchanan as a guidepost for disccusns on race. sorry for the sidestep, but I truly don't see how Buchanan remains employed by MSM.
Capehart, the only African-American on the panel used the calm indoor voice of a reporter and briefly noted that Carter was talking about a small vocal group of Obama protesters. Capehart then moved on to discuss how the politics of the issue would play out for President Obama. None of the passion shown by fellow MSM denizen Maria Bartiromo was present.
This segment confirmed my impression of how MSM is rigged against serious discussion of race. One, there was a lone black voice against four White voices. Two, Capehart is a reporter who appears dedicated to seeing both sides of an issue. Scarborough, Mika B, Bartiromo and Barnacle have no problem giving you their opinion.
Black reporters insist on being reporters and are reluctant to give personal opinions. Placing black reporters in a situation where personal opinions are being requested, means that the viewpoint of members of the African-American community are not going to be heard. Thus, a number of black viewers are going to lose any sense of connection to parts of MSM..
I went from Scarborough to listening to "The Tom Joyner Morning Show" on radio. Joyner serves a largely African-American audience.In the segment I heard, there was a brief mention of Carter's observation followed by a comment by a co-host, "I'm glad Cater finally put that out there." No more needed to be said during the town halls there had been discussion of just how outrageous some of the behavior had been, including the destruction of a Rosa Parks sign being held up by an African-American women. A White male at the town hall came over and snatched the sign from her hands, when the woman responded, she was escorted out of the meeting. The initial video of the episode just showed an upset black female being led from the audience. "Why are black people so angry all the time?", the camera appeared to be asking.
The MSM simply does not have enough on air minority voices to really let the country know how other ethnic groups feel about a given issue. It is not the job of black reporters to relate opinion, doing so would give rise to charges of bias. Reporters like Bartiromo do not face that type of pressure. In the case of the woman with the Rosa Parks sign, the images were selected to reflect a story the news producer had in mind. The producer felt no need to delve into the facts of the case. The audience as a whole is not given the full story and African-American opinion in particular is stifled.
The image of the Black woman being escorted out of the town hall did not tell the full story. The images coming out of the Obama protesters may not be telling the full story, but the solution is to actually ask why they bring a weapon to an Obama meeting, but didn't to Clinton or Bush? Carter just said what many are already thinking about protest on the Right,
Let the media actually talk to black people and the protesters.
I generally don't watch "Morning Joe" because I don't learn anything new. But today, following Carter's comments, I was ready to be entertained. I wasn't disappointed. Joe Scarborough's panel consisted of by Mika B, Maria Batiromo, Mike Barnacle and Jonathan Capehart. What I have come to expect from "Morning Joe" is a detailed rationale of how crazy lefties had screwed something up. The segment I saw followed the expected pattern.
Joe told of being from the South and having been on an elevator when someone made a racist comment, all heads, presumably White, turned towards the offender in disgust. According to Scarborough, Carter lives in a bubble and does not know the modern South. I should point out that Carter did say that the racism was not just in the South, but throughout the country.
Mika B chimed in that Carter's comments turned back the clock on race relations and that discussion of race had no place in the political dissent that we were witnessing. It is amazing how fast the post-racial clock can go in reverse because one person's statement. The timing mechanism on the race clock must be pretty weak.
Maria Batiromo was visibly upset.. The financial reporter almost yelled while stating, "It's obvious that you can disagree with the President and not be racist. This is ridiculous". Capehart could borrow some of Bartiromo's passion.
Barnacle put on his sad face and said, "Am I the only one who is depressed that we are discussing race?"
Patrick J Buchanan's name came up during the discussion, reminding me of his "Thank Whitey column, his apology for Hitler's going to war, and the grief he feels because Robert E Lee is not as revered as MLK Jr. I'm supposed to take show that employs Buchanan as a guidepost for disccusns on race. sorry for the sidestep, but I truly don't see how Buchanan remains employed by MSM.
Capehart, the only African-American on the panel used the calm indoor voice of a reporter and briefly noted that Carter was talking about a small vocal group of Obama protesters. Capehart then moved on to discuss how the politics of the issue would play out for President Obama. None of the passion shown by fellow MSM denizen Maria Bartiromo was present.
This segment confirmed my impression of how MSM is rigged against serious discussion of race. One, there was a lone black voice against four White voices. Two, Capehart is a reporter who appears dedicated to seeing both sides of an issue. Scarborough, Mika B, Bartiromo and Barnacle have no problem giving you their opinion.
Black reporters insist on being reporters and are reluctant to give personal opinions. Placing black reporters in a situation where personal opinions are being requested, means that the viewpoint of members of the African-American community are not going to be heard. Thus, a number of black viewers are going to lose any sense of connection to parts of MSM..
I went from Scarborough to listening to "The Tom Joyner Morning Show" on radio. Joyner serves a largely African-American audience.In the segment I heard, there was a brief mention of Carter's observation followed by a comment by a co-host, "I'm glad Cater finally put that out there." No more needed to be said during the town halls there had been discussion of just how outrageous some of the behavior had been, including the destruction of a Rosa Parks sign being held up by an African-American women. A White male at the town hall came over and snatched the sign from her hands, when the woman responded, she was escorted out of the meeting. The initial video of the episode just showed an upset black female being led from the audience. "Why are black people so angry all the time?", the camera appeared to be asking.
The MSM simply does not have enough on air minority voices to really let the country know how other ethnic groups feel about a given issue. It is not the job of black reporters to relate opinion, doing so would give rise to charges of bias. Reporters like Bartiromo do not face that type of pressure. In the case of the woman with the Rosa Parks sign, the images were selected to reflect a story the news producer had in mind. The producer felt no need to delve into the facts of the case. The audience as a whole is not given the full story and African-American opinion in particular is stifled.
The image of the Black woman being escorted out of the town hall did not tell the full story. The images coming out of the Obama protesters may not be telling the full story, but the solution is to actually ask why they bring a weapon to an Obama meeting, but didn't to Clinton or Bush? Carter just said what many are already thinking about protest on the Right,
Let the media actually talk to black people and the protesters.
Advertisement
















You absolutely nailed one of the very real underlying problems above: Too many pundits, too few reporters.
Good reporting gives facts in context, which lets a reader or viewer form a solid conclusion. Punditry, on the other hand, picks a few isolated factoids and bends them in a near-Procrustean quest to buttress an already-arrived-at conclusion.
September 16, 2009 10:57 AM | Reply | Permalink
The media is afraid of the truth because America is afraid of the truth.
September 16, 2009 2:39 PM | Reply | Permalink
Too true.
September 16, 2009 2:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
Mika is a brainless wonder, simply a yes-yes, mmm-hmmm girl for Joe. (He's going to run for office again soon, isn't he?) Bartiromo says some of the most outrageous right-wing things, and why the **** do we care what some CNBC babe-a-thon thinks of current events???
Gwen Ifill always plays nice; it's her job. But once, just once, she took off on racial issues and Obama, and she was so eloquent and wonderful! I love her now, even though she has her muzzle back on. The best person on teevee on racial issues is Melissa Harris Lacewell; she nails it every time, and speaks with authority, equanimity, and certainty.
Bay and Pat Buchanan are old-style bigots, always have been. But Pat has come completely unhinged lately. He left the Mclaughlin program, only to replaced by the cruel and unusual Monica Crowley, who may outstrip Ann Coulter (but McLaughlin likes her 4-inch spike heels...)
September 16, 2009 4:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
Joe S. was *really* whirling and shaking big time. He acted like someone held up his mother at gunpoint or something! At one point Mika was giving the news with the latest jobless numbers and he jumped in, apropos of nothing, and said "You know, I bet most of those people are staying out of work just so Obama will look bad because, you know, they are such racists." ??????? He was on a tear - even for him. Thank goodness for TiVo and fast-forward.
Oh, and don't dump on J. Capehart ... He did speak up and bring a little sanity into it - and don't you know that if he had show equivalent passion he would have suddenly become an "angry young black man" and reinforced all the stereotypes that they are so quick to assure you they don't have?
September 16, 2009 4:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
Capeheart is a reporter, thus he tries t go for balance. My problem is that Morning Joe does not have advocates for minority positions. If Bartiromo, Barnacle, and Buchanan don't give you much range of opinion. When Harold Ford Jr appears, he is also more middle of the road.
September 16, 2009 10:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
Harris-Lacewell does an excellent job. Unfortunately, she is a relatively on MSNBC. Barnacle and Buchanan are mainstays on Morning Joe.
We also don't get to here what the Latino or Asian communities feel on given issues, so we wind up with very limited perspectives if we just use television.
September 16, 2009 4:48 PM | Reply | Permalink