Blacks Disrupt GOP Town Halls : A Harry Turtledove Novel
Harry Turtledove writes alternative history novels that are always entertaining. Watching the disruption of Town Hall meetings and noting the death threats some Democratic members of Congress received, my own version of altered history story came to mind. Suppose that during the GW Bush Presidency it had been decided that since government intervention was bad. Medicare and Medicaid would be dropped. Suppose that ACORN was as influential as the insurance and BigPharma backed anti-health care organizatons. Imagine that Black radio stations were telling their listeners to get in the face of the GOP legislators supporting the change in health care. Black radio hosts would charge that the GOP was trying to kill Grandma and Grandpa, Black activists would be enraged..
Would MSM characterize those Black protestors as grass-roots people with legitimate concerns about the impact on their health care, or would the protestors be dismissed as unpatriotic people who shout down other citizens trying to have a civil discourse? If Black militias were forming, how much time would MSM devote to educating the country about the threat?
If an African-American man arrived outside a GW Bush town hall with a visible weapon would the Secret Service have allowed him to remain, even if the state law said the act was legal?
I'll let you write your own stories.
Would MSM characterize those Black protestors as grass-roots people with legitimate concerns about the impact on their health care, or would the protestors be dismissed as unpatriotic people who shout down other citizens trying to have a civil discourse? If Black militias were forming, how much time would MSM devote to educating the country about the threat?
If an African-American man arrived outside a GW Bush town hall with a visible weapon would the Secret Service have allowed him to remain, even if the state law said the act was legal?
I'll let you write your own stories.
Advertisement
















Foe get the gun. How about a woman with a poster of Rosa Parks?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qE13QObAUn4
August 13, 2009 5:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Forget
August 13, 2009 5:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
One persons grassroots is another persons terrorists.
I was standing in line at the supermarket. And this dude was having problems with the cashier and customers in the line. One of people in the line yelled at the man in front of the line to get off crack, crystal meth and any other drugs he was on. The man alleged to have been on drugs replies--no, he was shouting--that he is on drugs and dares anyone to do anything about it.
I was two lines over. In the next line between my line and the self-identified drug user, there stood an elderly African American woman. She busted out laughing because this scene reminder her of the Town Halls.
I was wondering, if this was me, admitting--not that I do--that I am high and I am making a scene in the store would they have tolerated such behavior? Would they have told the security to put me out? Would they have called the police?
I am just wondering? And I wasn't the only person wondering.
August 13, 2009 6:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
The initial response of the MSM if African-Americans behaved like the anti-health care folks behaved would have been to call the protesters crazy. There would have been no reflective question of why these "good" people were so upset.
The travesty that johnnienohands points out about the video snippet of the angry African-American woman being escorted out of the McCaskill town hall brings back the bias shown by the MSM during Katrina. Whites were getting provisions, Blacks were looting. The woman at the town hall was responding to someone who snatched her sign.
It is appalling.
August 13, 2009 8:25 PM | Reply | Permalink