« Lt. Cmdr. Matthew Diaz: An American Hero | Richard Silverstein's Blog | Support Matt Diaz, Navy Lawyer Who Revealed Gitmo Names »

IDF: They Shoot Fetuses Don't They?


[cross-posted to Tikun Olam]

Since the end of the Lebanon war last summer, things have been relatively quiet between Israel and the Palestinians. It allowed some of us to hope that perhaps this lull would allow both sides to make progress toward final status negotiations. But as usual, the pessimists have been borne out. It only takes a week, a hail of Qassams and Hamas trouncing Fatah forces in the streets of Gaza for the entire delicate facade of the ceasefire to come tumbling down.

A few days ago the Cabinet gave the green light to the IDF to resume targeted assassinations (don't you just love the "precision" in that term, as if the IDF always hits its "target" and never kills innocent civilians in the process) against Palestinian militants. But publicly at least, those to be attacked were supposed to be members of Hamas' military wing:

The security cabinet on Sunday authorized the IDF to intensify air attacks on the Gaza Strip and targeted assassinations of senior Hamas activists. Government sources in Jerusalem said the cabinet decision called for assassinations of leaders of the military wing of Hamas, not the political wing.

With today's results of the first serious strike we can see how laughable that claim was. The home of the leader of Hamas' parliamentary faction, not a member of the military wing, was attacked by air and eight members of his family were killed:

The Israel Air Forces last night bombed the house of Hamas parliamentarian Khalil al-Haya in Gaza. He was slightly injured in the attack, but eight others including seven members of his family were killed, and 13 people were wounded.

He had just finished discussing a ceasefire proposal with Egyptian officials when his home was bombed:

Several family members and Hamas activists had apparently gathered in the yard of the home when the IAF struck, a little after 9 A.M. Al-Haya, who was lightly injured in attack, had just finished discussing a cease-fire with a Fatah leader at the Egyptian Embassy in the Gaza Strip...

Al-Haya, a former spokesman for the Hamas parliamentary faction in Gaza, is responsible for negotiations with Fatah and Hamas' future membership in the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO).

Haaretz mentions that its cabinet source declared that al-Haya's name was not on any list of those targeted for assassination. So how did he get attacked? Is it any wonder that no one with any sense of balance can believe a word coming from the IDF and intelligence agencies?

The toll of the dead:

Seven of the dead are members of the al-Haya family: Nimr al-Haya, 60; Abd al-Hamid al-Haya, 35; Bakhr al-Haya, 26; Ibrahim al-Haya, 23; Ala al-Haya, 22; Jihad al-Haya, 17; and Mohammed al-Haya, 16. The eighth man is Samakj Farauna, 27, a Hamas activist.

The IAF is killing old men and teenagers. Bravo! This is just more of that superb IDF execution which brought you last summer's Lebanon war in which the IAF seemed better at hitting civilians than hitting actual Hezbollah fighters.

Here is the IDF's "justification" for the bombing:

An Israeli Army spokeswoman, Capt. Noa Meir, said that according to the army’s initial findings, the army “identified and hit a five-member terrorist cell based on prior intelligence — they were the target of the attack.”

Does this sound like a "terror cell" to you?

Officials at Shifa Hospital in Gaza City said that the dead included seven members of Mr. Hayya’s family, including three of his brothers, and a neighbor. Mr. Hayya, 44, who arrived at the hospital surrounded by supporters shortly after the attack, said his brothers were “part of the Palestinian people” and had nothing to do with politics.

What was this? It was the Shin Bet and IDF saying (and pardon my langugage but I'm pissed) fuck the military wing--we're going after you guys where you live and we'll kill all of you if we have to. They deliberately picked a senior legislative leader to say: "we don't make any distinction between military or political. You're all scum in our book." This is yet another example of an Israeli war crime. You don't deliberately target civilian political leaders. Did this man have "blood on his hands?" Had he participated in a terrorist bombing? I don't hear the IDF making that claim. Nor can they reasonably do so. Unfortunately, the killing of innocent civilians who happen to be al-Haya's sons and other relatives is the price to be paid for the IDF sending a message to Hamas that there will be hell to pay unless they call off the current bloodbath in which they are devastating Fatah forces in Gaza. Why do the innocent have to die to make such a point??

And here is the much vaunted "brilliance" of Israeli military intelligence at work (here quoting from Jonathan Fighel, an Israeli intelligence analyst):

Israel should “hit the Palestinians in a different dimension, to restore deterrence.” Israel, he said, had other options such as cutting off electricity and water supplies to Gaza and killing high-ranking Hamas members, “including ministers,"...said Fighel, a colonel in the reserves who follows Palestinian movements at the Institute for Counter-Terrorism in Herzliya.

"Restore deterrence?" How would killing al-Haya have done that? More likely it would've speeded up the process of getting IDF officers into the dock at the Hague. And how will cutting off water to a million Palestinians "restore deterence?" I swear, sometimes I think these people are living on another planet than the one the rest of us inhabit. Are they for real? Do they really find these bankrupt ideas in the least credible? Woe unto Israel if this is the best its best minds can produce.

Why Do Babies Have to Die?

Gideon Levy writes another one of his heartbreaking profiles of Gaza suffering in today's Haaretz. This story concerns an IDF patrol that nightly invades a Palestinian refugee camp to shoot up the place. Snipers on a roof targeted the home of a Palestinian family when the mother arose to comfort her sleeping babies in the next room who were frightened by the firing:

Last Wednesday was an ordinary day in the Katouni household. The father [Rifat] went to work, the kids went to school, and in the evening everyone went to bed - the parents in their bedroom and the three children in their room in the third-floor apartment. Shortly after two in the morning, Maha [Katouni, the mother] was startled awake by the loud sounds of gunfire from the street. She didn't even manage to turn on the light when she got up to run to the kids' room next door, to reassure her three little boys and keep them from getting scared. The gunfire was very heavy. The window of her room was open and her bed was close to the window.

Maha got out of bed, took one step, and then the bullet struck her in the lower back. She fell onto the nightstand...Soldiers from the Nahal patrol battalion were standing on the roofs of the surrounding buildings. "Wherever we are sent - to there we go," the poet Yaakov Orland once wrote in "The Nahal Anthem," sung by the Nahal entertainment troupe, which also sang "The Song of Peace."

Rifat rushed to call an ambulance. The children, who had awakened, were hysterical, especially the youngest, 3-year-old Jad, at the sight of the blood trickling from the front and back of their pregnant mother, who lay wounded on the floor. The bullet had struck her from behind, passed through the fetus' head and the mother's intestines and exited through the abdomen...

One of her brothers somehow managed to cross the line of fire and get to her house; he tried to stanch the gaping wound in her stomach with a towel. Her husband, Rifat, was paralyzed with shock. Umm Ibrahim says that her son, who tended to Maha, could see through the hole in her abdomen that the fetus had been wounded in the head and was dead...

The hospital staff, so inured to suffering by all the previous deaths and wounds it has tended to, still manages to stir a sense of outrage at this latest travesty brought to you by the Israeli Occupation:

Memorial posters decorate the walls of the Rafidiya government hospital in Nablus, covering earlier posters of countless young people who have been killed. But this poster is like nothing we have seen before: a fetus covered in its own blood, its tiny head blown up by the bullet that struck its mother, and the caption - "Who gave you the right to steal his life?"

...The anesthesiologist, Dr. Iyad Salim, a resident of nearby Hawara, roams the hospital corridors. On his cell phone camera is a video of the operation and the removal of the fetus. So close to being a fully developed baby, with a bullet wound to the head. The memorial poster shows the fetus bleeding from the head. The image is unbearable.

We always tend to lose sight of the real people who suffer in conflicts such as this. What were their hopes and dreams? Lest we forget, this family had similar emotions for the new life they were about to bring into the world:

They were going to call him Daoud, after an uncle, and also after a resident of the camp who was killed. At home they had everything ready: new clothes, diapers and a crib passed down from his older brothers. Daoud was buried in the camp cemetery. Only a few close family members attended the funeral of the unborn baby.

At press time, no response had been received from the IDF Spokesperson's Office.

And what could they say that would mean anything and not make an even greater travesty??


5 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Some comments on your posting.

(1) You comment "you don't deliberately target civilian political leaders" and "he didn't have any blood on his hands". I don't know who this fellow that was the target was, but I don't see any basis for your statement. When one is involved in a shooting war, why NOT target "civilian political leaders"? They are conducting the war, why should they be immune from its effects? HAMAS deliberately targets civilians on our side, so why should their leaders be exempt? Regarding the claim "he didn't have any blood on his hands", well, most of those executed at the Nuremberg trials of the "civilian" and military leaders of the Third Reich didn't have any blood on their hands, either. Hitler, Goebbels, Sauckel, Streicher, Frick, none of them killed a single Jew or other dissedent with their own hands. Eichmann didn't kill any Jews with his own hands.

One of the Left's favorite terrorists, Marwan Barghouti didn't kill anyone (at least since 1993) with his own hands either, but he was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder anyway.

(2) Regarding Ha'aretz journalist Gideon Levy, it is important to remember when reading his tragic stories, that he doesn't speak Arabic. I am not saying that he is deliberately fabricating his stories, but many people view his stories as propaganda.

In any event, the suicide terrorist who blew up mothers and babies waiting outside the synagogue in the Beit Israel bombing, or the one who did the bombing that killed Dr Applebaum who did so much to treat victims of other similar atrocities, and his daughter who was to be married the next day who treated are now considered great heroes in the Palestinian world, honored by their leaders, have streets named after them, praised in their official media. Gideon Levy, Shimon Peres, and the rest of the Oslo Gang have never said one word of sympathy for their victims. Peres even referred to these victims as "victims of peace" (how's that for an Orwellianism?).

(3) Regarding "deterrence", the idea is that the response will be so painful that the other side will refrain from attacking in the first place. This "cease fire" which has broken down allowed the the Palestinians to launch rockets at Sederot, but prohibited Israel from responding. What kind of a "cease fire" is that? This government in power is the MOST Leftist in the history of Israel. It contains a Prime Minister who said Israel is sick of winning wars and who has behaved in a way commensurate with that belief. One of his chief deputies was the author of the Oslo Agreements. Almost all the cabinet ministers would be happy to get rid of the Judea/Samaria "settlement". Yet they are under pressure to defend the population of Israel, as much as they might want to simply roll over and play dead. No conceivable gov't in Israel is going to do that because the FIRST priority of a country is to defend it citizens. You can't expect otherwise.

user-pic
When one is involved in a shooting war, why NOT target "civilian political leaders"?

First, because that's a war crime. Second, because al-Haya is not a member of Hamas' military wing & hence is not directing military operations against Israel. Other than that, he's a perfectly justified target.

Regarding Ha'aretz journalist Gideon Levy, it is important to remember when reading his tragic stories, that he doesn't speak Arabic. I am not saying that he is deliberately fabricating his stories, but many people view his stories as propaganda.

You don't speak Arabic either I presume. So why should yr word count for anything. Name me one CREDIBLE source who views his stories as propaganda.

Gideon Levy, Shimon Peres, and the rest of the Oslo Gang have never said one word of sympathy for their victims.

You're a liar. Either you know what you are writing is wrong & say it anyway which is despicable. Or you believe what you are saying is right, in which case you are merely deluded. In any event, you spread lies & hate against decent, peace-loving Israelis, which is pathetic.

This government in power is the MOST Leftist in the history of Israel.

Only a poor, deluded Kahanist could call Ehud Olmert's government "the most leftist in the history of Israel" with a straight face.

Almost all the cabinet ministers would be happy to get rid of the Judea/Samaria "settlement".

As would I, 50%+ of Israeli voters & 75% of American Jews. Yr point is???

Richard Silverstein

Tikun Olam>

user-pic

(1) What is your source for saying that it is a "war crime" to target civilian political leaders? He is a member of a "government" that supports indiscriminate terror against civilians. If he opposed this, he would not be in HAMAS and serving in their regime. This makes HIM a war criminal, regardless of whether he wears a uniform or whether he signs documents authorizing attacks or not.

(2) Many of the list of Nazis executed at Nuremberg I included were "civilian political leaders" are were totally uninvolved in the military realm, e.g. Sauckel, Streicher. Goebbels would have

been executed if had been captured, yet he was a civilian leader, i.e. Propanganda Minister and Gauleiter of Berlin. What right did the Allies have in executing them if they were not involved in "war crimes"

in a " military sense"?

(3) Peres and the others of the Oslo Gang called terror victims of their policies "victims of peace". Please give me a source saying Peres is sorry that he brought such suffering on the people of Israel. He has NEVER expressed ANY remorse or regret for what he did. He still justifies it and says "things would have been worse (?) if he hadn't done it.

(4) I would appreciate it if you would stop

calling me a "liar" and "deluded". You are welcome to say I am wrong if you think I am. Incendiary language like that is not conducive to dialogue.

(5) Like I told you before, I am NOT a "Kahanist". I am more opposed to them than you are, because coming from the "right-wing religious pro-settler" camp, I see how much damage Kahanist philosophy has done to us. I oppose any violence against individual Arabs or their

property and oppose suggestions to expel them from their homes, like what Sharon and his gang did to the Jews of Gush Katif.

(6) Please bring me an example of a more Leftist government. Rabin and Peres' 1992-1996 government, while it will never live down its crime of making the Oslo Agreement did not dismantle a single community in Judea/Samaria. Neither did Barak's 1999-2001 gov't. Settlements expanded during their tenure and they expanded much infrastructure in Judea/Samaria, particularly the road system.

Rabin particularly was a supporter of Gush Katif, which he was the main initiator of and the settlments their thrived under him. It was under the "right-wing" Likud goverments that Yamit (the Sinai settlments) were destroyed, and then Gush Katif. Olmert promised during his election campaign to destroy most of the communities of Judea/Samaria. Defense Minister Peretz was a founder of Peace Now and has always denounced the settlments. Don't forget that it was Olmert who carried out the pogrom at Amona just before the last elections, where he turned the police and army loose in order to demolish 9 houses and they injured HUNDREDS of protestors, many of whom were "dangerous" teenage girls from religious seminaries, also including senior army officers, among them an Aluf Mishne (Colonel). The Police Commander Karadi who was forced out as a result of the Piranian Organized Crime (Zeiler Commission) scandal admitted recently that his setting off this "police riot" (Chicago 68-style) was the biggest mistake of his career. Olmert was obviously convinced that beating up religious/settler protestors would make him popular but it backfired, and Kadima dropped sharply in the polls immediately afterwards. Only a leader with real hate for his political opponents could do something like this, so as far as the anti-settler Left is concerned, his heart is definetely in the right place. Barak and Peres never did anything remotely like that.

My point is that this government has the largest percentage of ministers who are openly hostile to the whole settlement enterprise in history. YET THEY DROPPED THEIR PLANS TO DO IT. Why? Because they can't , for both internal and external security reasons. Too many Israelis oppose it (50%, the number you supply, are a lot), and they realize that doing it undermines Israel's security and its whole moral position.

user-pic

Regarding my comments about Gidon Levy, I don't know why it is inconceivable to you that the Arabs would use him as a vehicle for spreading their propaganda, or perhaps you don't think they would ever do such a thing. If he doesn't speak Arabic he doesn't really know what the person who is giving the sob story is saying, just what the translater wants him to hear.

Again, I don't know if Levy is deliberately spreading false progapanda, but it wouldn't surprise me if he was. You impugned the honesty of Yigal Carmon and MEMRI (and they DO speak Arabic). I have, on numerous occasions where I have direct personal knowledge about what happened in an event reported by the media, seen outright falsehoods spread by Ha'aretz and Yediot Aharonot. They certainly have a clear political agenda, just as MEMRI does, and it certainly affects the way they report the news. The fact is that few Israelis pay much attention to Levy's reports. They are controversial even among Ha'aretz's readership.

user-pic

A propos to this discussion about whether HAMAS "political leaders" should be immune to the effects of their policies, below is a short item from Ha'aretz. Many in the so-called "peace camp" have advocated ending the boycott of the HAMAS regime and giving them money. I am not sure what he expects them to do with it.

w w w . h a a r e t z . c o m

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Last update - 11:58 21/05/2007

Hamas figure: Fight the Jews 'til last of them leaves Palestine

By Haaretz Service

A senior Hamas figure in Gaza was quoted Monday as urging Palestinian factions to "continue to fight the Jews until the last of them is gone from Palestine."

In an interview with Hamas Television quoted on Israel Radio, Nizar Riyan, a leading member of the Islamic group's political wing, said:

"It is a definite decision within the organization that Israel will be removed from the map, to be replaced by a Palestinian state."

Riyan was also quoted as urging armed Palestinian factions to "Shell Ashkelon until its residents clear out, as did the residents of Sderot."

Leave a comment

Richard Silverstein

user-pic

Following:
Followers:

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address