Now, About Those Jobs. . .
We have spent the better part of a year locked in a tedious and unenlightening debate over health care while the jobless rate has steadily surged. It's now at 10.2 percent. Families struggling with job losses, home foreclosures and personal bankruptcies are falling out of the middle class like fruit through the bottom of a rotten basket. The jobless rate for men 16 years old and over is 11.4 percent. For blacks, it's a back-breaking 15.7 percent.
We need to readjust our focus. We're worried about Kabul when Detroit has gone down for the count. Bob Herbert, NYT, 11/10/09
____________________________________________________________
Why are we skirting the issue of joblessness these days? There will be no recovery without jobs. None. We need to get cracking on that promised jobs creation program. But first we need to get past the notion that creating multitudes of low-wage jobs accomplishing nothing more than servicing the upper class is going to get us out of this mess.
We need to re-build and re-tool factories and we need to produce our own goods. Without the majority of the population employed again in meaningful, productive work, we might as well resign ourselves to serfdom and the lives our people led pre-Industrial Revolution.
We need to stop pretending that we need those cheap goods from China and other slave-trade countries. For one thing, they're not all cheap. Have you looked at the price of athletic shoes lately? With the exception of one company, New Balance, they're all made by human beings working long hours for mere pennies outside of the U.S. Do the prices reflect that? Would those ridiculous shoes cost a ridiculous $300 instead of the ridiculous $80 they now cost if they were made here? Of course not. I defy anyone to show me how a shoe company in the U.S couldn't produce an $80 pair of running shoes without making a profit.
Almost everything we buy in this country is made somewhere else by people who work under unconscionable conditions for embarrassingly paltry wages. Do the prices reflect that? Of course not. Every year the cost of everything rises, no matter where the goods are produced. Our new refrigerator was make in Mexico. I haven't had a new refrigerator in 18 years, but if that was a low, low, non-USA made, non-union made price just for me, I'm not impressed.
Food, clothes, shoes, tools, appliances, office goods, computers--you name it. They could all be made here by people earning decent wages under conditions that celebrate humanity while still keeping the company in the black. For most mid- to high-end items, the prices couldn't be much worse.
It can be done. We all know it can. It must be done. There will be no prosperity without a middle class, and there will be no substantial middle class unless we go back to MAKING things. We have to go back to making quality goods better than anyone else at a price that American workers can afford. That used to be our claim to fame. American-made goods were the best. American wages were the best. When we were the leaders in manufacturing, we lived in an era of exceptional prosperity, and nearly everybody benefited. The Good Life was here in America.
We can do that again, and we can do it without breaking the bank. But first things first. The Fat Cats need to go on a diet. The hard part will be convincing them that their present way of life is killing them--along with the rest of us. Their King Midas approach to economic stability looks good when they're viewing it from their hog-laden banquet tables, but they need a Marley's Ghost to drop in and show them how they're going to look selling apples on the street corner.
We can't go on like this. Unemployment has surpassed that magic number--a national average of over 10 percent. All hell was supposed to break loose if that ever happened, but of course it only affects the unemployed, so watching the stock market go up, even in the face of it, shouldn't surprise us. But could it at least infuriate us?
Health care is important. Getting us out of two wars is important. Climate change is important. But there is nothing more important today than creating the kinds of jobs that will bring this country back. Let's get over the idea that such a colossal undertaking can be done without initial governmental/taxpayer help. We need a WPA-like program and it should have started on Obama's first full day in office. Congress should have been prepared to sign into law a jobs program that exceeded even our wildest dreams. Every able-bodied unemployed person should have been ready to flex every muscle when the time came and we should, all of us, have been pushing that enormous, expensive project from day one and working toward making it the most efficient, effective project this country has ever seen.
CCC Crew, Senatobia, MS 1938
So let's say we work on getting that done. Now we need to go after the off-shore "American" companies and give them the bad news. They're no longer a part of us. They get what they've wanted, including all the benefits of being a foreign company. Cheap goods, low wages, tariffs. . . Enjoy--somewhere else.
So. If Americans want to build a strong America we have to do it the American way: Honestly, righteously, willingly. Working hard. Together. For the common good.
Ramona
(Cross-posted at Ramona's Voices here.)


















I couldn't agree more. It's so obvious, I do not understand why people aren't screaming it.
I guess we're all just fearful, eh? Too scared that we'll be next, so we keep our heads down and plow away, and wonder why it is we aren't sleeping well. This has been going on in the middle of the country for years and years. I am so ashamed I ignored that.
Turn off the T.V. and tune into humanity. Demand jobs for your neighbors.
It's long past time. Jobs will cure all that ails us.
November 12, 2009 5:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
I can haz job?
November 12, 2009 5:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yez, maybe two. Keep the writing gig.
=D
November 12, 2009 5:45 PM | Reply | Permalink
Lordy, Lis, I hope so.
November 12, 2009 6:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Bwak, it's incredible that so many people ignore the impact joblessness is having on this country. How do they think we'll get healthy again? We can't dream ourselves out of this fix.
November 12, 2009 6:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Here's an impact!
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/nov/12/un-investigator-us-neglect-homeless
It is a national disgrace that this country puts GDP (or whatever they call it now) ahead of people. That jobs and homes and healthcare are neglected so rich people can get richer!
Ramona, your voice here is so powerful, so necessary. I just want you to know how grateful I am.
November 13, 2009 11:17 AM | Reply | Permalink
TheraP, sorry I'm so late getting back to you. Thanks for your kind words. I hope you know how much you're appreciated here. Your goodness shines through. There are so many people here on this forum who work hard at making our country better. It's inspiring, and it's what keeps me going.
November 14, 2009 1:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
So, what can a bill do to manufacture jobs? What kind of incentives for job creation? And how can one really go after those who outsource? How would we encourage more manufacturing, more production of goods and services? How could that happen without tariffs? How can we be sure that jobs created will balloon into a self-sustaining situation? And will jobs recover as the economy recovers by itself?
I guess I just want to know if a jobs bill can create jobs that actually last would be just another thing that boosts the deficit, which coincidentally sucks again.
November 12, 2009 5:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
Read about the New Deal. It CAN be done. It'll take an extraordinary amount of money, but getting rid of waste and fraud should fill those coffers pretty quickly.
It has been done, even in the face of the same kind of opposition from the Fat Cats that we're experiencing today. The Fat Cats want to stay fat. They think the way to stay fat is to keep everyone else lean. One thing wrong with their approach: They can't stay Fat without sustenance from the rest of us. We can't give it to them if we're starving and dying.
Incentives for jobs? How about a healthy country where everybody who wants to work is working and earning wages that can actually keep a body going. Is that incentive enough?
Remember the war effort during WW2? Probably not, but I do. I was a child, but I bought Savings Stamps for a dime in school and felt exceedingly proud to be helping. As a country, we re-tooled factories, saved metal, bought war bonds, planted Victory Gardens, and did without in order to put every penny into an effort we thought was worthwhile. We're in a state of emergency again, but you wouldn't know it by looking around. It will take all of us changing our ways of thinking, our ways of doing, but it CAN be done.
Outsourcing? You make laws that state if a company is producing, say, more than 50% of their product outside of the U.S, they're no longer an American company.
We start building things again. That's how jobs become self-sustaining. We build things people will buy; people buy things we build. It's been done.
As Bwak says, we need to stop being afraid of our own power. We really can do this is we all work together.
November 12, 2009 6:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
I know, I'm torn. I was in the middle of writing a federal debt blog, here, when I read your blog. I'm fixated and alarmed about how the Fed's debt is growing.
But, as you point out, people are hurting too. We need to start building things again. In short, it's time to think long term.
November 12, 2009 7:59 PM | Reply | Permalink
Matyra, your link isn't working. Sorry.
I understand the fears about our out-of-control debt, but we can't let that stop us from building an infrastructure of sustainable, wealth-producing jobs. It's how we built the middle class before. There are no quick fixes and there is no way we can build a workable economy without putting massive amounts of government money behind it.
If the richest among us suddenly decided to share their wealth, we might make it without taxpayer money. But you and I both know that's not going to happen.
November 12, 2009 8:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
Here's the old fashioned way: http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/matyra/2009/11/our-own-shopping-spree.php
Of course the rich could be, um, influenced to share their wealth. Weird, no, that so many in Congress would be amongst those sharing a greater proportion of their salary.
November 12, 2009 8:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
The fact that congress can be bought is not one I've come to with any sense of triumph. It sickens me, as it does everyone else. I wouldn't have believed it could happen here, but the evidence is too overwhelming. Every choice they've had to make as regards the common good is tempered by their alliances with the very people who stand in the way of health, wealth, and the pursuit of happiness for the rest of us.
The numbers of people in congress who have been bought and paid for is astounding. The fact that we're just shaking our heads in wonder instead of taking to the streets is equally astounding. We've had hundreds of wake up calls and it seems we're still asleep at the wheel. I'm not sure we deserve the country we're dreaming about.
November 12, 2009 10:36 PM | Reply | Permalink
The fact that we're just shaking our heads in wonder instead of taking to the streets is equally astounding.
You and me both.
The pessimist in me fears that the country may be too asleep from mindless, pornographic entertainment and the decayed remains of the Fourth Estate to care much about the potential utter ruination of America as a Republic. Maybe the Powerful in America have figured out that you don't need to be a formal autocracy to rule the world and your citizens as an empire; you just need to keep the plebes busy with porn and "When Planes Crash" -style "reality" television and gladiatorial contests and bread and circuses. Just keep their reptilian brains busy and stimulated enough so they don't notice their increasing powerlessness and slavery - they just feel free because they vote every four years for candidates, none of whom pose any real threat to the lever-pullers controlling the Machinery of Night (to borrow a phrase from Ginsberg) that binds their souls and enacts their slavery.
Or, maybe Americans will begin to talk to one another one-on-one about the danger posed to their freedom by ceaseless propaganda-in-service-of-empire, and turn off their televisions and porn and stop eating themselves into gaseous stupors, so they can look hard enough to actually see what's really going on all around them.
November 13, 2009 5:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's called tax cuts!
November 13, 2009 10:58 AM | Reply | Permalink
Not exactly manufacturing, but how about a subsidy for making our homes more energy efficient. Put some small contractors back to work replacing old windows and doors, insulating, etc. Small contractors get jobs, and homeowners save money, while the country reduces its' dependence on imported energy.
November 12, 2009 6:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
Good ideas, Miguelito. I think there are tax incentives for those kinds of things, but I don't know how far it goes toward getting people working again.
November 12, 2009 6:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
I agree with you, Ramona, but to a new WPA-like program let's demand a substantial boost in the funds available through the SBA or something similar. Because most building and many manufacturing jobs still go primarily to able-bodied men, not to women. Yet women have a proven track record of achievement in cottage industry goods and services. Think not only Mrs. Fields but also The Women's Bank.
November 13, 2009 11:06 AM | Reply | Permalink
Absolutely. The small businesses are such an asset, and they do get short shrift. And yes, women can do it, too. We need to build up the businesses that understand their obligations as well as their abilities, and at the same time we need to say bye-bye to those businesses that are willing to sacrifice our way of life to their own self interests.
To me, it just makes sense. We don't need those greedy bastards as much as we need the companies that see us as one big community.
November 13, 2009 11:16 AM | Reply | Permalink
A quick note on health care reform: that was supposed to help small businesses by reducing their insurance costs. We'll see.
As for the bulk of your post, one thing that strikes me is that there is no national loyalty in Corporate Land. Among the multi-nationals we are basically just another set of assorted demographics. I tend to believe that the slow, painful death of the middle class is actually a goal. Outsourcing, union busting, too big to fail, NAFTA, GATT, foreclosures, health care bankruptcies, educational declines, never ending wars - not exactly a friendly environment for the health of the middle class. And I think that's the way "they" want it.
Back in the day when things were better we had tariffs, unions, very progressive taxes and a much tighter regulatory environment. And one-worker families. And better schools. And we were a creditor nation, not the world's largest debtor.
Re-creating these conditions will be difficult. One thing I believe is a must do: ban all corporate money from elections and lobbying. Re-instate tariffs. We have to protect our workers. If that reduces imports, well, good. Re-regulate: banks, insurance companies, pharma, oil companies, coal mining, agribusiness, chemicals, etc, etc. And as Miguelito suggests, stimulate those small, home grown industries that benefit us as consumers and as a nation. And fix the tax laws. Thiry years on and I'm still waiting for the trickle down.
p.s. About that 10.2% unemployment rate. It's the highest since 1983. In 1983 St. Ronnie had been in office for two years. Just some perspective.
November 12, 2009 8:10 PM | Reply | Permalink
TJ, there is that nagging thought. . .that the destruction of the middle class was planned, executed and accomplished. But if it's true, how short-sighted is that? What happens now? We have millions and millions of healthy workers out of jobs, which means no money, no health care, no reasonable ability to keep the economy going. In fact, those out-of-work, otherwise strong, healthy workers are now a drain on our system.
So what exactly was the plan? Didn't anybody think it through enough to play devils advocate and maybe come up with a doomsday scenario that pretty much shadows what we have today?
It's pretty evident that the "plan", if there was one, was a miserable failure, yet the Fat Cats are out there still lobbying for deregulation, for the status quo, for their very Country Clubbin' lives--when a jail cell, or at the very least, a turn taking orders at a Burger King window, would suit them better.
November 12, 2009 8:35 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ramona, I don't think there was a "plan" per se, in the sense of people sitting around a table "strategerizing". I do believe that Reagan & Co. intentionally worked on breaking up unions. I believe the Repugs intentionally try to shrink government, i.e. social services. I do believe the minimum wage was stagnant for so long because of conservatives. In other words, the things I mentioned were done intentionally, if not as part of a "master plan".
I think the Masters of the Universe, and the Creationists among them, take a very Darwinian approach to the economy. If you can figure out a way to make it big, you'll be welcome to the club. Otherwise, you're just part of the labor force, a cost of operating a business.
Again, patriotism is not a motivating force for these elite. They operate globally. They will exploit resources where they are cheapest and they will sell into the best markets, wherever they may be. There is an economic ebb and flow and their interest is in exploiting that to the nth degree. As TPC points out below, the focus now is on China and perhaps India.
I just don't think they give a rat's ass what happens here as long as it doesn't interfere with their wealth accumulation. And the politicians are just playing their role and being compensated accordingly.
November 13, 2009 8:11 AM | Reply | Permalink
TJ, I don't think "they" are all the same or have the same mindset. But it's just part of the structure of a competitive economy that the folks calling the shots are bound to treat compensation as a "cost"--a big one, usually, and one they feel more able to do something about than some other costs.
Many companies are facing competition from abroad, where labor costs are far lower.
Businesses are basically designed to be sociopathic, to operate without a "conscience". They are profit-making entities, deliberately intended to be so.
The question is, as has been suggested, how can a society act, through its government as well as otherwise, so as to ameliorate the worst consequences of that?
Notwithstanding Margaret Thatcher's too-revealing comment awhile back that "there is no such as society, just individuals", there actually is such a thing as society. A society is not an economy. Unfortunately, where we seem to be in this country is that government has largely abdicated its responsibility to serve as a counterweight and to act for the good of the entire society.
I believe we, and only, we the people have the tools we need to take our country back. But I am becoming radicalized; I am coming to the conclusion, one I do not welcome, that this will probably require mobilization of people into a movement that will confront the government, peacefully, to demand change.
I have come to despair that electoral and legislative politics can, right now, respond to the moment at hand without such an organized movement presence to pressure and eventually force it to do so.
We know there are times in American history where that has been the case, and not so long ago--to win civil rights, notably. We appear to be at another such juncture today as I see it.
November 13, 2009 10:27 AM | Reply | Permalink
Yes, we need to mobilize. The gov't needs to understand that there are millions and millions of us who are fighting against what the system has become. The Tea Partiers fall into lockstep with the Status Quo, as if they are somehow going to benefit from an ongoing unfettered feast of greed by the upper class.
I see a huge internet movement going in our direction, and I wonder if that needs a harder push? We need to get to the media. They're our only hope, and though I see more and more attention to blogs and websites as they plan their programs around issues, we still don't get the respect that our numbers would ordinarily demand. I supposed it's the old "anyone can do it" assessment. But the most important thing we bloggers do is to link to other opinions that reinforce our own. We're spreading the word in a way that is unprecedented and we need to make the most of it.
November 13, 2009 11:24 AM | Reply | Permalink
AD,your observations are valid and your interpretation much kinder than I would render. Yes, compensation is a cost. But the effort to drive that cost below a living wage is, or should be, unacceptable to society as a whole. Even Henry Ford believed his workers should be paid well enough that they could afford one of the cars they manufactured.
I am unsympathetic with the "low cost imports" arguement. Especially since Wal-Mart supposedly owns over 700 factories in China. We used to have tariffs to protect domestic production.
As far as our government helping "to ameliorate the worst consequences" of the global economic environment - well, God bless you for your optimism. Until we figure out a way to ban corporate money from the electoral and legislative processes, we're just screwed. "They" own the means of production, they control the access to capital, and with the exception of a dwindling number of politicians with integrity, they own the government. At the risk of being facetious, I'm just waiting for Wal-Mart to form its own political party.
November 13, 2009 3:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
TJ, we don't talk enough about the lowering of wages, and thus the standard of living, for most people these days. We talk about unemployment ad infinitum, as we should, but the fact is, for most of us who come from blue collar backgrounds, our children are not nearly as well off as we were when we were young.
A single wage-earner could support a family, own a home, be guaranteed job security, have the promise of a good retirement, and still be able to sock away a little nest egg--all on factory wages.
Sadly, we'll probably never see those days again.
November 14, 2009 2:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
Sadly...true.
I know I tend to get a little dark and dismal about these topics, but your comment is exactly what I'm talking about.
November 14, 2009 3:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
I like to see a couple million community organizers with as many lawn mowers and garbage hampers and hedge clippers as they have pens and notebooks.
Send troops of these fine people to urban areas just to help work with the locals to clean up their yards and their homes. Help them feel proud again about who they are and what they can contribute.
Paint cans and scrapers, brushes and roof tiles...
Hell, redo our American cities. Why not?
And when the rich bitch about deficits, raise their damn taxes.
THE END
November 12, 2009 8:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hey DD, I'm not rich (at all.) but I'm bitching about deficits. But, heh, I've no qualms about raising their taxes.
November 12, 2009 8:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
But DD, don't you remember Sarah Palin making fun of Community Activists? They don't DO anything, according to her.
November 13, 2009 11:17 AM | Reply | Permalink
Using the WPA and CCC as a model, we can put some people back to work on basic things. Not like some of what's falling apart around here couldn't use a few nails and a coat or two of paint.
That aside, I do think things are about to uptick. Here's why: A couple weeks ago, I had lunch with a friend/sometime client. (We've worked together off and on, for and which each other, for the last ten years or so.) He's in B-2-B sales right now. He tells me that last year around this time, things were flat. Contracts and projects being yanked all over the place. This year, he and the rest of the team are sending out bids and quotes left and right for all sorts of activity.
It's not going to be a fast start, it's not going to be a vertical takeoff. It is going to happen. And not that far off.
And that said, you're right. We need to have a high-value-additive jobs based economy again. Pushing paper isn't going to do it this time. (His company pushes multiple things, but not paper.)
November 12, 2009 8:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
Well, I glad to see some new work activity somewhere. I hope it spreads. But what is B-2-B?
I just don't see how we're going to create new or better jobs without a whole lot of rebuilding, and that's going to take a while. Unemployment is going to run out for a lot of people in the middle of winter. I truly fear for them.
November 12, 2009 10:13 PM | Reply | Permalink
Business to business. They, and I, do not really do what could be described as "retail" in any way.
November 13, 2009 12:48 AM | Reply | Permalink
I'm not holding my breath waiting for this to change. The global migration of manufacturing to China is fueled by cheap labor and cheap energy. The labor piece speaks for itself. The energy side of this equation is fueled by China heavily subsidizing energy costs. Things like the Three Gorges dam and an agressive nationl policy to developing green energy technologies is driving this. It won't be long before China holds the global lead in the installed base of wind and solar energy production.
There are zero economic units that can compete with what China is doing. Economically, politically and labor force wise it isn't possible. We could even this up within reason but the possibility of that occurring with what it implies just ain't happening. For a whole host of reasons that kind of change will never occur in the U.S. A democratic republic with an economy based on capitalism can't operate that way.
November 13, 2009 5:58 AM | Reply | Permalink
TPC, I don't pretend to know the ins and outs of global economy. My point is that in order to get us back to any kind of stability we have to engage in all-out war, and if that means war against our own people, so be it. We just can't go on allowing a small minority of all-powerful Poobahs to destroy a society that we and our ancestors worked so hard to build. It really doesn't matter what their motives are. We built this country and they're tearing it down. We have an obligation to those who are no longer here to stop them in their tracks and begin to turn this thing around.
No, I won't hold my breath either, because I see it taking years and years of dedicated hard work. The first thing we have to do is change minds. The rich who take advantage of any segment of our society don't deserve to get richer. We need to stop glorifying the super-wealthy. And we need to go back to encouraging unionism.
There's more, but I have a doctor's appt. I'll be back.
November 13, 2009 9:36 AM | Reply | Permalink
We are talking about two distinct things here Ramona.
One is our domestic policies have gone to hell in a hand basket and made a mess internally.
The other is a dramatically altered global economic picture.
The two are not mutually exclusive. But only one of them is under our control. The other almost not at all.
November 13, 2009 10:21 AM | Reply | Permalink
I agree with your suggestion that President Obama and Congress propose a WPA-type program to put millions of Americans to work.
There's plenty to be done to strengthen our country, just not stuff that our economic structure values. That's one major reason we have representative government--to address important human and societal issues our economic system doesn't address. I hope we can call on our collective historical memory to help us remember how to use the power we still have in our republic.
Dare the Republicans to filibuster it. It would make my freakin' day. Let's just put it right out there on the table.
November 13, 2009 10:00 AM | Reply | Permalink
I don't understand why a Federal works program is not a priority. I don't see any other way out of this. And especially now that we've reached the 10 percent and above unemployment number. What better time to get busy and work out an emergency plan to put people back to work? The Privates aren't going to do it. They don't have to. They have all the cheap labor they can use. So let's leave them out of it, and head toward a crash plan. We're in a crisis and the people in high places are still pretending it's going to be all right.
It's time for all of them to recognize their own culpability and do something about it. They ought to be horsewhipped.
November 13, 2009 11:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
Well, we're off to the big city for some meds. Nothing serious, but it's two hours each way so I probably won't be back before this has ended. I hope it continues, because this conversation needs to happen I'll be writing about it again. I hope others do to.
But carry on, guys, please. What you all have to say is so important, and you all say it so well.
November 13, 2009 11:37 AM | Reply | Permalink