« Sometimes a Picture isn't Worth a Thousand Words | Ramona's Blog | Obama's "I Have a Dream" speech »

Sure Road to Success - Stick it to Labor



I can say this because I'm a liberal and a Michigander: My heart breaks for the laboring class in this country. I feel sorrow even for the workers who can't see that the unions are their only lifeline and inexplicably fight against them with a passion reserved only for one's worst enemies.

The working class, the significant majority in numbers, has somehow, ever since Ronald Reagan declared war on them, become the least of us--the minority. Privatization and outsourcing have rendered them nothing more than powerless drudges.

The working class is the laughingstock, the disposable, the darling of the politicians when they need their votes, and the most wretched of pariahs when the monied class sees their mountain top begin to erode.

The children of the working class hold no status and deserve no consideration. There are millions of people who would rather spend their money fighting against abortion laws than feed and care for poor children.
  • More than 9 million children are estimated to be served by Feeding America, over 2 million of which are ages 5 and under, representing nearly 13 percent of all children under age 18 in the United States and over 72 percent of all children in poverty.
  • According to the USDA, an estimated 12.4 million children lived in food insecure (low food security and very low food security) households in 2007.
  • 8 states plus DC have more than 20 percent of children living in food insecure households, the states of Texas (23.58%) and Mississippi (22.84%) have the highest rates of children in households without consistent access to food.
  • The top four states with the highest rate of food insecure children are Texas, Mississippi, Arizona, and New Mexico.
There is a concerted effort in this country to abolish public education, which means that the working majority would receive little or no schooling. Instead of working to fix the massive education problems that face us, there is a faction (which includes sitting politicians) that would, instead, like to see all education privatized and turned into a money-maker.

The working class is subject to scams that in any other culture would be considered criminal. PayDay loans and cash advance loans are legal in all but a few states. Credit card interest rates can run as high as 35% legally. Usury laws went by the wayside, along with even the most basic consumer protections. All that those concerned, including governmental agencies, can do now is put out bulletins warning against scammers.

The goal is the impoverishment of the working class, and I believe we're reaching that level faster than any Imperial Fat Cat could have imagined in his wildest wet dream.

What stuns me and keeps me awake at night is that there are millions of laborers here in America who see no disparity, no unfairness, no real need to change the status quo. Wages and protections go down at a dizzying pace while costs to live rise by the minute.

Robert Reich wrote in his blog today that manufacturing jobs are gone forever, so we might as well

. . .stop pining after the days when millions of Americans stood along assembly lines and continuously bolted, fit, soldered or clamped what went by. Those days are over. And stop blaming poor nations whose workers get very low wages. Of course their wages are low; these nations are poor. They can become more prosperous only by exporting to rich nations. When America blocks their exports by erecting tariffs and subsidizing our domestic industries, we prevent them from doing better. Helping poorer nations become more prosperous is not only in the interest of humanity but also wise because it lessens global instability.

Want to blame something? Blame new knowledge. Knowledge created the electronic gadgets and software that can now do almost any routine task. This goes well beyond the factory floor. America also used to have lots of elevator operators, telephone operators, bank tellers and service-station attendants. Remember? Most have been replaced by technology. Supermarket check-out clerks are being replaced by automatic scanners. The Internet has taken over the routine tasks of travel agents, real estate brokers, stock brokers and even accountants. With digitization and high-speed data networks a lot of back office work can now be done more cheaply abroad.


I don't know. Maybe that's what so depressing--that notion from even the most learned, the most logical, that we might as well just give up. Privatizing and outsourcing works. Our days of actually producing goods are over. Where it used to be patriotic to produce goods, we now find that the best way to keep our country strong is to send the workers packing.

So now what do we do? Here's Reich again:

The biggest challenge we face over the long term -- beyond the current depression -- isn't how to bring manufacturing back. It's how to improve the earnings of America's expanding army of low-wage workers who are doing personal service jobs in hotels, hospitals, big-box retail stores, restaurant chains, and all the other businesses that need bodies but not high skills.

Unbelievable. Even Reich. They got to Reich. Who's next? God??

Ramona

(Crossposted at Ramona's Voices)

33 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I couldn't agree more. We liberals are supposed to be national security wimps, but I'd like to know how you defend your national security against a big player like China if they do all the manufacturing?

Plus, this isn't merely a war against the blue collar working class. Sheesh, today I was talking to a big bank and of course I get some guy in India. I mean these are the folks we are bailing out with trillions of tax dollars and they can't work fast enough to ship every white collar middle class job overseas.

What does Reich think we're all going to do? Change the sheets of rich guys like him and the Democratic members of Congres? And he's going to go to bat for another dime on the paycheck I suppose.

Like you, I do not know how long it is going to take before Americans wake up to how badly they've been screwed. It's probably too late already.

We need a real labor MOVEMENT in this this country and we need a NEW labor PARTY.

user-pic

We could have a real labor movement if the millions of working folk got together and DID something about it!

user-pic

We could take a lesson from the French. They hit the streets, hold their bosses for ransom, and the government is afraid of the people instead of the people being afraid of the government.

Just think what would happen if folks across the country followed the lead of those at the Republic Windows and Doors. Things might change quicker than we think.

user-pic

Rowan, thanks so much for that link about Republic. I remember reading a clip about it, but I never followed up. What eventually happened? I'll have to check it out.

What scares me is how ineffective the unions are these days. Without the numbers, nothing will get done. They'll always be looked at as the few radical rabble-rousers unless they're out there in such numbers they can't possibly be ignored.

Something else has to happen, too. We need to have American workers working for American companies. There needs to be some cut-off percentage point where outsourcing and off-shoring and headquartering overseas makes them no longer an American company.

If they can threaten workers with going offshore if they don't acquiesce, then the government needs to step in and threaten them with actually making them the un-Americans they seem to want to be.

user-pic

I know the difference, damn it.

You are always there saying something for the workin man and woman....

Just like Sleepin when he used to blog regularly.

We need a labor party like Bluebell says.

user-pic

I'll always be there for the labor. That's where I come from and I'm stickin' with 'em.

user-pic

Make that "I'll always be there for labor"

user-pic

Ramona, you rawk.

user-pic

Thanks, Lis. Means a lot.

user-pic

I think that someone killed Reich and put this blathering a-hole in his place. His last two entires have been the work of an elite ass kissing moron.

When oil gets a little more scarce, we'll need manufacturing all right. As for helping the poor in other countries, exploiting them for cheap goods seems to be an awful dumb way of doing it. They just work harder to sustain their poverty then they used to.

We need local economies in order to have a decent standard of living for most. Honor Labor, and for Gods sake, someone stick a pin in these rich people, they're so bloated and full of hot air it's no wonder they use their solid skulls as butt plugs.

I'll sharpen my pitchfork.

Thanks Ramona.

user-pic

Wow, Bwak, I think you may be on to something! This is not the Robert Reich I knew and loved. I may have to take him off of my bloglist.

user-pic

Thank God I don't have an MBA but whatever happened to common sense? It makes no sense whatever that you can long remain a major nation state if you don't make anything to trade or even a bow and arrow to fight. Sure we can trade in services internally but there is no service we can export that can't be performed overseas.

My own epiphany came a few years back during a period of unemployment contemplating the shipment of jobs overseas. It suddenly hit me that if they could ship one function or one department overseas, they could just as easily ship the entire office tower overseas. And while it's certainly true that we need to do a much better job of educating Americans, it's just as true that ever so many of those jobs don't need that much education. Surely, all of you have had the pleasure of talking to Harris in India and finding him every bit as robotically dumb as any call center rep anywhere in the US or anywhere. He's just cheaper. He isn't better.

Speaking of better and back to manufacturing - anyone see the article in the NYT about the miserable quality of appliances? It seems that old Maytag repairman of a couple of decades ago really did have a better product. Sure, some foreign products are better. Give me a Japanese car. But they are not all better, they're just cheaper, but designed to fail sooner so you have to buy another one. What does that do to landfills?

Maybe we need to relearn how to make high quality stuff here and train people to service it.

I mean we have a national security obsession, but who and what are we defending? Who is defending the American Dream? Who is defending the middle class? Isn't it patriotic to protect that?

user-pic

You rawk!

Don't get me started on cheap clothing. I'll take a pair of American made Levis that outlive you to these cheap chinese knockoffs any day.

=(

http://www.buyamerican.com/

user-pic

That's why I buy most of my clothes in thrift stores. Vintage, preferably, because they were made in America.

Remember "Look for the union label"?

I could cry. . .

user-pic

Wow. High quality, American made. What a concept! Even the high end stuff isn't made here anymore.

user-pic

Ramona, when I read Dr. Reich earlier today I didn't know where to begin. First off, I got a little hot under the collar. But, I didn't know how to respond without resorting to swear words. So, I let it go.

Boy, am I glad you posted.

Okay. Above is how I started off my comment to your blog, but then I went off on a rant, so I decided rather than clog up your thread with it, I'd just post it on my own blog.

GOOD POST, YOOPER!

user-pic

Flowerchild, I just went over and read your blog. Stupendous! We need to keep this thing ALIVE!

Thanks, Michigander. Great job.

user-pic

Ramona, the liberal "intellectuals" are so lost these days it's almost not worth trying to save them.

1. They're all for international trade & international knowledge & the international movement of "capital" - but labour doesn't move internationally very well. That's for starters. And their theory has NEVER coped well with it.

2. There is NOTHING in world economic history to compare with a situation where a large, reasonably well-paid working class is suddenly subjected to competition from (literally) hundreds of millions of brand-new workers, many of them educated, able to speak English, and with wages not 10% of ours. Ask Reich to please provide ONE real-world historic example of where this has happened, on this scale, and been successfully managed before. Nice to be the guinea pig, Reich.

3. Yes, they're happy to see capital become more international, and take advantage of all those fabulous opportunities to make a profit, and they have a million arguments to defend it. Why, it'll help make your pensions larger. It'll help us sell the associated services - jobs for us. And it'll help the workers in other countries. Except... there are NO guarantee that we can ensure the profits come home, and then be taxed, or in any other way ensure revenue streams for the working classes being asked to make the hardest transition.

4. Oh yeah, and the working class is supposed to make this transition from a situation where they have NO savings, ALL family members working, and with almost NONE of the core services required being offered by the state - health? education? ha!

5. And then he says the core challenge is to raise the earnings of America's expanding army of low-wage workers who are doing personal service jobs in hotels, hospitals, big-box retail stores, restaurant chains, and all the other businesses that need bodies but not high skills." WOW. Just what we need in life. Better pay for the servants. Where have I heard that before? I'm so glad Reich sees our future as having an EXPANDING ARMY of clerks and chambermaids and bartenders and waitresses and greeters and scanners and busboys.Great.

How about instead we send the well-off and the financial traders and intellectuals to war, and PROMISE them that they'll be supported by the key equipment, vehicles, armaments, intelligence and supply lines... and then maybe NOT do it. Let's see you fight now, Reich.

For a more intellectual example, let's insist that Reich compete IN MANDARIN. And if he can't, hello rice fields.

Or best yet (and to be more apropos the real circumstances facing a 50 year old unemployed auto-worker) let's ask Reich to go compete in the NBA. Tell me we'll offer him a retraining allowance. And heels.

user-pic

Yeah. How did that argument for pensions work out?

Hell sometimes half, HALF of what would be profits go to management....

ah f...it

user-pic

Priceless! Thanks. . .and thanks for speaking out for workers. But again my question: What's going to happen now, when even RR thinks we should play nice with the poor workers in OTHER countries?

I remember now why I'm depressed.

user-pic

Yes, play nice with workers in other countries. Stop dropping bombs on them. Stop supporting governments that send troops against labor organizers. Stop letting "US" corporations pay them dirt wages while wrecking their and our environments. By all means we need to play nice after over a century of being the ugly americans who send our youth and dollars to support yanky robber barrons.

user-pic

I'm happy to "play nice" as long as American jobs aren't being lost in the process.

user-pic

Agreed 100% about the importance of unions for the vast numbers of Americans. And therein lies the answer to how we rectify the problem. Only through organizing themselves will workers ever be able to defend their own interests. That is why EFCA is so critically important. It is the only realistic hope for the common people of the United States. Demand your members of Congress support EFCA.

user-pic

Thanks for the great post Ramona!

user-pic

Thanks, Rowan. And thanks so much for commenting.

user-pic

Brilliant blog. Sad, but brilliant.

user-pic

Rec'd. It's overstated somewhat in that it's too broad brush a class indictment. There are folks near the top who strongly oppose this agenda but they are seriously outnumbered. This is partly because they can't or don't understand that, if they are sincere and at serious, the only chance they have is to build back up the popularly-based institutions, especially the unions as you point out, and join forces with them to combat the corporate agenda.

Large swaths of the educated upper middle class, which have financial resources as well as what the social scientists call both human and capital they could contribute, aren't invested in growing the labor movement, whether through unions or some successor institution serving similar purposes. For the most part they either don't believe or have been slow to realize that they're next on the chopping block.

As a description of the dominant dynamics, though, I think your post is largely accurate and well put.

Also, the goal isn't to destroy the working class (I would say it's beyond the "working class" and includes working people, broadly defined as people for whom their wages or salary are their dominant source of income) per se--it is to utterly and completely and permanently disempower it so that the lords and chieftains will be able to do what they see as necessary to survive and compete under the current economic rules, unencumbered by organized groups with power to push back or enough politicians that might consider changing the economic rules, at their (perceived) expense.

If you're some fatcat who just can't live with the prospect of going to your grave never having gotten higher than, say, number 57 on the Forbes list of wealthiest Americans, you also realize--even if you're not crazy about going this route--that the way to move up that list is, as Willie Sutton might have said, to go where the money is. Which is the compensation of the people who do the work for your company. Because, you know, it must kind of embarrassing to have to sometimes be in the company of people higher up on that list, or have it known publicly that they have accumulated more toys than you have.

If we're talking about other super-wealthy people like star athletes and entertainers, they just go for the money because they can. They don't need to union-bust or keep politicians from meddling. In these cases unions are generally their allies, not impediments to what they want.

Robert Reich is a very sharp guy. I've never been able to figure out why or how he could place as much faith in job retraining programs as he historically has, though.

The importance of a larger, effective union movement isn't just to do whatever is possible to save jobs and protect compensation packages. In many cases, there is little they can do in this regard.

Their greater importance is in becoming enough of a political force, an essential counterweight, that can participate constructively in, and move, policy changes in the economic rules as they apply in our country and globally.

What we see now should not be terribly shocking, given that corporate managers have a fiduciary duty recognized in the law to try to maximize shareholder returns. If we think that is a problem then we need to make some adjustment to those rules, and given what appears to be the prevailing view that government regulatory action is only a hindrance to them and is not seen as, potentially, a help. Any adjustments that are made to the US domestic rules won't necessarily have their intended effects absent adjustments in the economic rules that govern the international economy.

The rules regarding the international mobility of capital, for example, play a key role in accelerating the pace of economic change, with all of the good and bad consequences that flow from that. It's hardly an off-the-wall comment to wonder out loud whether the current rules can or need to be adjusted to strike better balances between shareholders, workers, communities, the environment, and quality of life more generally for the human beings who, after all, are supposed in any worthy view supposed to be the beneficiaries if not the masters of the rules and the system, not their servants.

Long one, I know; in my defense I've not been using a lot of band width here over the past few months.

user-pic
U.S. Study Says Job Retraining Is Not Effective

By PETER T. KILBORN, Published: Friday, October 15, 1993

An internal Labor Department report says the Government job training program for workers hurt by foreign trade is largely ineffective and used primarily as an income crutch for the unemployed.

...

In a thorny aspect of the debate, Labor Secretary Robert B. Reich frequently says that with training, workers will again find good jobs, but critics say the only jobs the economy is generating in any volume are relatively low-wage service jobs that require little training.


At least he's consistent.
user-pic

Good find!

user-pic

Well put--and not at all too long.

Yes, maybe "destroy" is too harsh. How about "enslave"?

Here you say:

The importance of a larger, effective union movement isn't just to do whatever is possible to save jobs and protect compensation packages. In many cases, there is little they can do in this regard.

Their greater importance is in becoming enough of a political force, an essential counterweight, that can participate constructively in, and move, policy changes in the economic rules as they apply in our country and globally.

Again, you're absolutely right. The power of the unions was in numbers. If we could build a labor coalition ready and able to do battle against inequity and unfairness, wages and benefits might just fall in line.

I don't know. All I know is when I think about half a million jobs lost a MONTH, I'm petrified. When I think of all jobs being converted to service jobs I have to wonder--WHO are we servicing?

user-pic

Enslave? Hmmmm. How about neuter? Emasculate? Or...how about...is there a word that means to turn someone into a serf? Is "serfify" a word?

user-pic

We've hit bottom. Forget all those old,shopworn expectations. This is a brave new world we live in.
Abandon the system; it will not bail us out. Renew the bonds of love you have with family,friends,and those you hold dear. Do whatever is necessary to prosper yourself and your community.

This is how our shipwrecked economy will be rescued. It will not be rescued by the US Treasury or the Fed. It's up to us...

We, the people...(this means you)

Keep your eyes open for the opportunities that surface as the old order plummets into the depths. Old resources will become available in new ways. Old ways of doing things, and old ways of thinking about who is or is not responsible for this mess--these will fall away.

Take control of your destiny.Act thoughfully, lovingly, to reconstruct the life of your community. Shake off discouragement and defeat. Don't believe anyone who says we are powerless. Work diligently on behalf of yourself and those around you. Working together we will get through these perilous times.

This is what those folks(the 10% ones) in the developing countries are doing. Their communities have not yet been decimated by the artificial constraints of automotive dependence and keeping-up-with-the-joneses superfluousness. We need to learn from their example. Love and community trumps affluence and obliterates dependence on the corrupt system that is collapsing as we speak.

It's too late too save American opulence; but it's not too late to save ourselves. Look around you; find out what needs to be done in your neighborhood or city and do it.

Carey Rowland, author of Glass half-Full

user-pic
Abandon the system; it will not bail us out. Renew the bonds of love you have with family,friends,and those you hold dear. Do whatever is necessary to prosper yourself and your community.

This is how our shipwrecked economy will be rescued. It will not be rescued by the US Treasury or the Fed. It's up to us...

It's too late for that, I'm afraid. It's going to take more than a village. We're in the midst of a disaster of horrific proportions. It doesn't matter how it happened or who is at fault. Millions of Americans who want to work are losing their jobs. Millions of homes are being foreclosed upon. Millions of men, women and children are going without food, shelter and health care.

Platitudes aside, we're in the midst of a crisis so extreme it requires vast amounts of money and know-how to fix. ONLY the government has the resources to even begin to put us back on track.

As much as we would wish it, we simply cannot do it by ourselves.

Leave a comment

Ramona

user-pic

Following: 94
Followers: 49

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs TPM, Robert Reich, Margaret and Helen, Preserve Protect and Defend,
  • Favorite Books Molly Ivins, Studs Terkel, John Steinbeck, Eudora Welty, Annie Dillard, Barbara Kingsolver, J.K. Rowling, Michael Chabon, Carol Shields,Wallace Stegner, Larry McMurtry, John Irving, Elmore Leonard, John McPhee, Rachel Carson, Shelby Foote, Kaye Gibbons, Marilynne Robinson, Anita Shreve (more to come)
  • Favorite Quotes

    "Liberals got women the right to vote. Liberals got African-Americans the right to vote. Liberals created Social Security and lifted millions of elderly people out of poverty. Liberals ended segregation. Liberals passed the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act. Liberals created Medicare. Liberals passed the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act. What did Conservatives do? They opposed them on every one of those things...every one! So when you try to hurl that label at my feet, 'Liberal,' as if it were something to be ashamed of, something dirty, something to run away from, it won't work, Senator, because I will pick up that label and I will wear it as a badge of honor." -- Matt Santos, The West Wing


    Every time someone down the line is irreverent about authority, I'll have my monument. Every time some kid who was born a nigger, a kike, a wop, a Polack, a gook, a gimp, a fag, or just a plain maverick lifts up her head and dares anyone to stop her, I'll have my monument. Every time they peaceably assemble to petition their government for redress of a grievance, I'll be there. Whenever they worship as they please (or not at all), I'll be there. Whenever they speak up and speak out and raise hell, I'll be there. And every time some blue-bellied, full-blooded nincompoop who holds elected office is called to the floor for deciding to keep us safe by rewriting the Constitution, or by suspending due process and holding a citizen indefinitely without legal representation, I'll be there. Now that is immortality. I don't have any children, so I've decided to claim all the future freedom-fighters and hell-raisers as my kin. I figure freedom and justice beat having my name in marble any day. Besides, if there is another life after this one, think how much we'll get to laugh watching it all -- Molly Ivins

    The great enemy of clear language is insincerity. When there is a gap between one's real and one's declared aims, one turns as it were instinctively to long words and exhausted idioms, like a cuttlefish spurting out ink. - George Orwell

    You can't wait for inspiration. You have to go after it with a club. - Jack London

Bio

I am a lifelong Liberal and a long-time writer who has found my voice again with the dawning of the Obama age. I lived underground during the Bush Regime, spouting off under a variety of assumed names, but now I'm who I am--just as I am. Email: ramonasvoices@gmail.com

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address