« Blagojevich Complaint: Individual C - Is It Dennis Hastert? | PseudoCyAnts's Blog | Rick Warren's Maculate Misconceptions »

UnCheney America's Heart


Dick Cheney in a December 15, 2008, telephone interview with Rush Limbaugh (White House dot gov source):

I think Guantanamo has been very well run. I think if you look at it from the perspective of the requirements we had, once you go out and capture a bunch of terrorists, as we did in Afghanistan and elsewhere, then you've got to have some place to put them. If you bring them here to the U.S. and put them in our local court system, then they are entitled to all kinds of rights that we extend only to American citizens.

Remember, these are unlawful combatants. These are people who don't belong to any recognized military force. They don't obey the rules of warfare. They're unlawful combatants. And you can't -- if you're not going to have a place to locate them like Guantanamo, then you either have to bring them here to the continental United States -- and I don't know any member of Congress who's volunteering to have al Qaeda terrorists deposited in his district -- or you've got to turn them over to some foreign government. And we found lots of times when you do that that a number of them have gone back into the -- on to the battlefield and tried to kill Americans again.

So Guantanamo has been very, very valuable. And I think they'll discover that trying to close it is a very hard proposition.

Cheney's claim that these are "unlawful combatants" is itself an admission that he advocates an unlawful abrogation of the Geneva Conventions. The Geneva Convention relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War; Part I - General Provisions; Article 5, paragraph 2; states:

Should any doubt arise as to whether persons, having committed a belligerent act and having fallen into the hands of the enemy, belong to any of the categories enumerated in Article 4 (persons defined as POWs), such persons shall enjoy the protection of the present Convention until such time as their status has been determined by a competent tribunal.
A president, by his determination alone, is not a "competent tribunal". Additionally, the very instant that humans are being held as an "unlawful combatant", the government is detaining them as criminal actors, not as POWs. The Constitution's due process of law dictates control.

In another interview given December 15, 2008, this one with ABC News, Cheney admits that he was fully briefed on the interrogation techniques used against the detainees:

I was aware of the program certainly, and involved in helping get the process cleared, as the agency, in effect, came in and wanted to know what they could and couldn't do.  And they talked to me, as well as others, to explain what they wanted to do, and I supported it.
He also claimed that these interrogation methods were not torture:

On the question of so-called "torture," we don't do torture, we never have.  It's not something that this administration subscribes to.  Again, we proceeded very cautiously; we checked, we had the Justice Department issue the requisite opinions in order to know where the bright lines were that you could not cross.  The professionals involved in that program were very, very cautious, very careful, wouldn't do anything without making certain it was authorized and that it was legal.  And any suggestion to the contrary is just wrong.
Cheney subsequently admitted that all detainees were not in fact terrorists, implying that there were some detained without cause:

It's very hard to do.  Guantanamo has been the repository, if you will, of hundreds of terrorists, or suspected terrorists, that we've captured since 9/11.  They -- many of them, hundreds, have been released back to their home countries.  What we have left is the hardcore.  Their cases are reviewed on an annual basis to see whether or not they're still a threat, whether or not they're still intelligence value in terms of continuing to hold them.
There has never been any hard count of detainees held by the government provided to the people, but given the estimates which have been provided in the past, the number is over 700 held at Guantanamo alone. Of those, how many have been charged as "unlawful combatants"? How many of those charged have been convicted?

This has nothing to do with coddling terrorists. It is instead a defense of liberty. The government is not the source of human rights. These rights are secure in their possession by all of humanity. If they are unassailable rights, then they must also be universal rights. Take these detainees into an open court, and secure righteous convictions against them in a trial that afforded due process of law. Then, let the guilty hang. Anything less defames America's very soul.

A people who believe their rights are derived as a generous gift from a magnanimous state can never be free.

A legal system that posits differing standards of applicability, based solely upon nationality can never be just.

An American future in which we the people did not once again chain and muzzle our leviathan, which in the understandable thirst for vengeance because of September 11, 2001, we set loose upon this world as rabid wolf amongst the sheep, will never again experience peace.

13 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

"The government is not the source of human rights. These rights are secure in their possession by all of humanity. It they are unassailable rights, then they must also be universal rights."

"A people who believe their rights are derived as a generous gift from a magnanimous state can never be free."

YES, YES, YES, YES, YES, YES, YES!!!!!!!

THANK YOU!!!

user-pic

THANK GOD WE ARE LAWFUL COMBATANTS. SORT OF.

That son of a bitch said that everybody should stay at GtMo UNTIL THE WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

Jesus Christ will be here for the second coming a thousand years from now and the war on terror will not quite be over.

We will give you your constitutional rights back as soon as the WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

We will stop 'enhanced interrogation techniques' as soon as the WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

We will end the de facto dictatorship AS SOON AS THE WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

We will disclose all the secrets we have been keeping from the American People AS SOON AS THE WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

We will pull our troops out of the Middle East AS SOON AS THE WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

We will inform America as to where one half the defense budget went AS SOON AS THE WAR ON TERROR IS OVER.

user-pic

The war is over January 20th.

user-pic

Imitation being the sincerest form of flattery, I have written a post which takes off from your title. I hope you will not mind....

user-pic

no, i certainly do not mind.

user-pic

Cheney is a sociopath.


user-pic

Socio or psycho?

user-pic

=D

Highly amusing. Rec'd.

user-pic

It went bump in the night: Cheylin or Paliney, whuichever you prefer. Not my best chop, and never completed, but it should be good enough for now.

user-pic

Great! Now I'm gonna have nightmares...

user-pic

I love the way you parse unlawful combatants as meaning "not lawfully defined." (or that's how I took it) And I so agree.

His argument turns on a tautology. We have defined them as "unlawful." And therefore these folks don't deserve to be treated lawfully. Grrrr...

They "committed a belligerent act" um.... by whose definition? What about your act, cheney, of shooting someone in the face?

They "fell into the hands of the enemy" - well, cheney, suppose you "fell" into the hands of the enemy - like some of these poor folks, because you got "sold" into the hands of the likes of you!

And then suppose, cheny, that you were treated as these poor folks were treated? And the enemy insisted it was not torture... even though you had been reduced to a state of catatonia, cowering in the corner, in your own feces and urine.... but, no, I guess you just would have "chosen" that, right?

Habeas corpus is the very bedrock of our legal system. You, cheney, have undermined the very bedrock! And in so doing, you have placed yourself outside the community of humans - as if you were above us. And that is a not a free society!

Thank you PCA!!!!

You are a true patriot!

user-pic

no, not intended, but i'll take it; and may be able to work with the idea later, thanks.

user-pic

Righting these wrongs is going to be so incredibly difficult. With all the practical problems facing us, it will be so easy to forget the larger ideas and causes that make us who we are, the things that have been destroyed these past 8 years. All I can say is thank Goodness we have such a gifted leader about to take office.

Expectations are high, yes, but so are the spirits of millions of Americans ready to do what is necessary to turn things around. We await our marching orders, Mr. President-Elect, and at this crucial moment in history, we know you will do more than suggest we go out shopping.

Leave a comment

PseudoCyAnts

user-pic

Following: 109
Followers: 52

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Party Boston Tea
  • Politics Jeffersonian

Favorites

  • Favorite Quotes "An avidity to punish is always dangerous to liberty. It leads men to stretch, to misinterpret, and to misapply even the best of laws. He that would make his own liberty secure must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself." Thomas Paine, "Dissertations on First Principles of Government", 1795

Bio

Walkabout in the Dreamtime America

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address