Blaming The Church Committee Is A Misdirection
The Church Committee did not hamstring America's Intelligence Agencies. That is a myth promoted by the right-side of the political bipolarity as a method enabling them to shirk personal responsibility for the plethoric intelligence failures of contemporary conservatism. Time and time again, many of the very same governmental appointee failures from the past, have risen up like spectres from the grave to haunt the American Psyche.
This past cycle: The Tyranny of GW Bush; has traversed far beyond amusing; from my vantage point without the idiocy of the two-party system. This Administration has with willfullness, waged an immoral War Upon Iraq, the evidence notwithstanding, whilst the Nation's true enemies and perpetrators of 911 were allowed to escape at Tora Bora, when the military had them dead in their sights, and were close to taking them to ground as hunted mongrels. Al Qaida has metastasised in the Pak/Afghan Frontier, and reemerged as a threat to our tranquility. The Bush Administration has stolen Natural Liberty from its rightful possessors: ALL humans, who are endowed with this at birth, by that which they perceive to be the force of creation. They have stripped away life, liberty and property from humans who had never been convicted of any crime in a trial that afforded due process of law. They have consciously entered into a conspiracy to engage in, and committed serial acts of, human torture. The blame need be properly laid at their bloody boots, and there should be an accounting for their repeated bestial rapine of The Dreamtime America. Contemporary Conservatism is a giant slug which need be mortally wounded, then salted, to assure its manifest evil can never arise again.
When the Church Committee first supeonaed then CIA Director William Colby; Philip W. Buchen, Henry Kissinger, John Otho Marsh, Jr., and Donald Rumsfeld drafted a recommendation that Colby should not testify, and instead only "brief" the Committee.
Rumsfeld had been a Nixon director of Economic Opportunity, even though as a Congressman, he'd opposed it. He was subsequently promoted to a cabinet position by Nixon as a Counselor, and then appointed as US Ambassador to NATO. Ford made him Chief of Staff, and then Sec. of Defense. At this same time, GHW Bush was CIA head. Rumsfeld had pressed for Nixon to end the Vietnam War. Kissinger was a Nixon and Ford Sec. of State, as well as a Ford NSA. He also colluded with Nixon, and sold out S. Vietnam on his "Particularly Loquacious Day", June 20, 1972, in a secret meeting with Chou En-lai. NSC Staff member, John D. Negroponte, was a witness to that meeting.
In 1973, hawk Democratic politicians led by Senators 'Scoop' Jackson and Daniel Patrick Moynihan created the Coalition for a Democratic Majority. Elliott Abrams, Stephen Bryen, Jeane Kirkpatrick, and Norman Podhoretz were all members. Elliot Abrams, Doug Feith, Richard Perle and Paul Wolfowitz were all at various times, Sen. Jackson staff members.
Jeanne Kirkpatrick's husband, Dr. Evron M. Kirkpatrick, held many appointed spook positions in the 50's, and went on to become the Executive Director of the American Political Science Association (APSA). Some members of the APSA were a part of the academics who travelled to S. Vietnam, then published deceitful propaganda about conditions there in the 50s. Dr. Kirkpatrick was also a long-term President of the Operations and Policy Research, Inc. (OPR), a think-tank front, funded by the USIA to facilitate covert publishing of their sponsored treatises. The OCR received covert CIA cultural cold-war funding through at least two of its fronts. Irving Kristol, Bill's father, and early proponent of Neo-Conservatism, was one of "The New York Intellectuals", which also included Daniel Bell, James Burnham, and Sidney Hook. Kristol received covert CIA money through their Farfeild Foundation, which funded Enquiry and Commentary magazines, while Kristol was associated with them. Farfield Foundation paid the freight for several other unprofitable journals that were written and published by former Trotskyists. Kristol was a principle of the Congress for Cultural Freedom, whose anti-communist leftist intellectual members spied upon Americans both domestically, and abroad. Sydney Hook went on to become a founding fellow at the Hoover Institution.
Near the end of Ford's Presidency, GHW Bush set-up "Team B" at the CIA, and hand-picked the analysts who were part of it. Team B produced studies about The USSR's military capabilities which were greatly exaggerated, and ran counter to the estimates that career CIA analysts were producing. Through disingenuous dissemination of Team B's findings, using a tactic I call "The Neocon Circle-Jerk" (associated individuals, who carry multiple credentials through various think-tanks and publications, cross-referencing one another, whilst hiding their intimate connectedness, and pointing to the same underlying citation/meme over an extended period of time-thus giving power to their fabrications); the career CIA analysts were denigrated, and the exaggerated Soviet estimates ended up being the ones the public was led to believe were the true ones, at the unjustifiable expense of US Intelligence Agencies' Domestic prestige. Team B's patrons and members included, Donald Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz, Daniel O. Graham, Thomas Wolf, Seymour Weiss, Paul Nitze and Richard Pipes, father of Richard. Team B also traded information with "Scoop" Jackson's team, which at that time included Richard Perle.
At the beginning of the Carter Presidency, many of the aforementioned individuals formed a new incestuous alliance: The Committee for the Present Danger, which played a significant role in Ronald Reagan's 1980 election win. During the Reagan Administration, many of them were rewarded with glossied-over shiny new revisionary conservative labels, and powerful positions within his administration. These included : Jeane Kirkpatrick, Richard Perle, Stephen Bryen, Ken Adelman and Elliott Abrams. Bryen at one time, aided and abetted by Richard Perle, attempted to circumvent military export restrictions on new radar technology, and hand it over to Israel. When Richard Armitage discovered the scheme, he put an end to it. Michael Ledeen earned his weasel-walking papers in the Iran/Contra affair, and still to this day defends Manucher Ghorbanifar, claiming that he isn't the habitual liar that the CIA has shown Ghotbanifar to be. The Reagan Administration, educated Arab Afghan-Freedom fighters in the dark arts of insurgency, put stingers at their shoulders, built cement bunkers for their operational centres at Tora Bora, and then pushed them down through the Khyber Pass, cheering mightily. This did nothing to hurry along the End of the Soviet, which was in reality, a collapsing bear made of substandard cardboard manufactured in state-run factories, unable to sustain its own weight. The Soviet/Afghan War instead lengthened the iron-fisted control of the Kremlin over the USSR. After the Soviet's fall, during the GHW Bush Presidency (much to the startled surprise of that administration's intelligence failures); America just packed up and walked away from Afghanistan, leaving it to descend into a stone-aged barbarity. A short time later, The Administration of Papa Bush again proved its absence of intelligence gathering capabilities, when they got blind-sided by a 2nd World tin-horn dictator, Saddam, who perceived the Administration's message to him, which was transmitted through State Department official, April Glaspie, as a sign of hesitancy, and an opportunity to wage offensive war. Glaspie took the hit, and the guilty policy wonks walked away unscathed.
The Church Committee did not tie the hands of America's Intelligence Agencies. They have instead for over 30 years now, been made the patsies who end up taking the fall for contemporary conservatives' preponderant incompetence, hiding their own culpability in the fog of their wafting mendacity. The New-Right and former Trotskyists have since the Nixon presidency worked tirelessly to pollute American Conservatism, and navigated it over the event horizon into the dark fetid well of moral relativism, where it still spins in a decaying orbit. In the past 30 odd years, it is difficult to perceive more than a scant handful of valid insights, promulgated by Contemporary Conservatives. They have offered an abundance of anecdotal evidence, that The Peter Principle is naught but a myth, perpetrated by the liberal media. Self-evidently, they have proven time and time again with personal examples, that people can and do get promoted past their level of incompetence. They also brought into the American consciousness a new oxymoron on September 11, 2001: National Security.
The Rumsfield-Cheney axis has self-destructed right in front of our eyes, along with the once-proud Perle-Wolfowitz bund that is turning to wax. They somehow managed to blow it all, like a gang of kids on a looting spree, between January and July, or even less. It is genuinely incredible. The U.S. Treasury is empty, we are losing that stupid, fraudulent chickencrap War in Iraq, and every country in the world except a handful of Corrupt Brits despises us. We are losers, and that is the one unforgiveable sin in America.
Beyond that, we have lost the respect of the world and lost two disastrous wars in three years. Afghanistan is lost, Iraq is a permanent war Zone, our national Economy is crashing all around us, the Pentagon's "war strategy" has failed miserably, nobody has any money to spend, and our once-mighty U.S. America is paralyzed by Mutinies in Iraq and even Fort Bragg.
The American nation is in the worst condition I can remember in my lifetime, and our prospects for the immediate future are even worse. I am surprised and embarrassed to be a part of the first American generation to leave the country in far worse shape than it was when we first came into it. Our highway system is crumbling, our police are dishonest, our children are poor, our vaunted Social Security, once the envy of the world, has been looted and neglected and destroyed by the same gang of ignorant greed-crazed bastards who brought us Vietnam, Afghanistan, the disastrous Gaza Strip and ignominious defeat all over the world.
The Stock Market will never come back, our Armies will never again be No. 1, and our children will drink filthy water for the rest of our lives.
The Bush family must be very proud of themselves today, but I am not. Big Darkness, soon come. Take my word for it.
Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, "Welcome to the Big Darkness", ESPN Page 2 -July .22, 2003.












It galls me no end to see the work of the Church Committee disparaged by people who are A) Fascists or B) Clueless.
November 27, 2008 8:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for the roundup.
November 28, 2008 8:59 AM | Reply | Permalink
If anything the Church Committee and its aftermath didn't go far enough. We needed to have ripped it all down. It's the apparatus of the national security state that has been slowly choking the American Republic to death since the start of the cold war. All of it: the coups, assassinations, boundless payments to Thugs & Kleptocrats the world over, endless justification for more war spending, and spying on Americans who dare question any of it.
It's been going on far longer than George W Bush!!
He just jammed his foot on the gas pedal of national self-destruction, with Cheney riding alongside cheering, like some Thelma & Louise of the National Security State headed straight over the cliff.
November 28, 2008 12:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
When quickly perusing some of the Church Committee's published reports the other day, I was struck by The Additonal Views of Senator Barry Goldwter to The Interim Report: Alleged Assassination Plots Involving Foreign Leaders. In some ways,Goldwater got closer to the crux of the problem than the Committee did itself.
He was right about Bobby Kennedy's and The CIA's possible plotting of Castro's assassination, given the circumstances which had recently occurred at that time. Castro had allowed Russian Nuclear missiles to be placed upon Cuban soil. This was tantamount to an act of war against the Nation at that time. Plotting to kill the state leader that a nation is at war with possesses no greater immorality than the act war itself and if effectuated properly, could instead turn out to be a cause of much less human suffering due to the war, if it shortens its duration. Castro had a right to be concerned about America's desire to overthrow the Cuban government, but allowing The Soviet to make Cuba a nuclear launch facility was counterproductive to a defense against this, and only further enraged our government.
Goldwater's assessment of the Allende assassination was well off of the mark, yet much evidence of this is contained within documents that were completely classified from even his eyes at that time.
Where Goldwater almost hit the target without actually spitting it out, was his underlying assertion that America's assassination plans had almost always been promulgated top down from within the White House, and the intelligence communities were not across the board blameworthy, because the vast majority of career intelligence employees were not even aware it was going on. It was the appointed head of the CIA, and a few "team players", believed to be tight-lipped loyalists, who cared little about the lawfulness of their covert acts. There were many in Congress at that time, who went after the CIA with a battle-ax, instead of attempting to surgically excise the melanoma with a scalpel.
I have ambivalent feelings about the Cultural Cold War. Covertly patronising American arts and funding artists' tours through Europe as a foil against Soviet expansion was a stroke of pure evil genius. I can only imagine what the Kremlin and the KGB were making out of Improvisational Jazz musicians, and exhibits of post WWII American modern art. We buried them. They had nothing that could come close to countering its affect upon both West and East Europe. It was pure culture war, using our own native born talent. It's comically amusing comparing what Soviet leaders and America's far right were saying about the destructive and corruptible influences this had upon their own respective countries. The comments can almost be interchanged without really changing the other's message. The CIA's covert funding of domestic publications with the intent to serve disinformation up to the American people, and secretly recruiting respected individuals to spy upon the acts of American citizens, even if there was justifiable cause to do so, was far beyond the CIA's legitimate charter, and was an act of Unconstitutional overreach.
November 28, 2008 2:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
p.s. You left out the last "e" in Committee, in the title.
November 28, 2008 12:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
fixed, than-you
November 28, 2008 2:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
In the past 30 odd years, it is difficult to perceive more than a scant handful of valid insights, promulgated by Contemporary Conservatives.
I'd be interested in hearing just one valid insight. :-)
Contemporary Conservatism is a giant slug which need be mortally wounded, then salted, to assure its manifest evil can never arise again.
Is this possible in terms of military use? Historical similarities can be traced back to Cato the Elder, who didn't let a day or a speech go by without urging the destruction of Carthage so that Roman power would never again be challenged.
November 28, 2008 2:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
Just wanted to add that I totally agree about the Church committee.
November 28, 2008 3:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
"Contemporary Conservatism is a giant slug which need be mortally wounded, then salted, to assure its manifest evil can never arise again."
Maybe the beer traps are doing it, Bush et al having given conservatives everything they thought they wanted.
November 28, 2008 6:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
Your post prompted me to reread the Covert Action in Chile 1963-1973. by the Church Committee. A couple of things in the report jumped out at me regarding the debate about whether the Agency was crippled by the imposition of Oversight:
The message about it not being okay to fight secret illegal wars is combined with the observation that the money for the war was embezzled instead of procured. The Iran-Contra scheme was a work around to get back to the way things were.
The importance of following the money is given a broader meaning at the conclusion of the report:
When the costs of "blowback", which has proven to be such a hearty expenditure multiplier is added to the balance sheet, why would anyone think that it would be in the nation's interest to just hand over money to these fellows and trust they are smart and honest enough to the right thing with it?
The neo-cons have had multiple opportunities to prove that they are geniuses and time has run out. The thing about unsustainable conditions is they eventually come to an end.
November 28, 2008 7:14 PM | Reply | Permalink