« Four daughters, Two Very Different Examples: George W. Bush vs. Barack Obama | Orlando's Blog | Has Anyone Told the House Republican Whips That They Lost? »

Modern Day Witch Hunting in Papua New Guinea: The Dark Side of Human Nature


Before last week, all I knew about Papua New Guinea was that its capital was Port Moresby and that it was that island on top of Australia. But I've been writing a music series over at Dagblog and while I was searching the internet for examples of the country's musical offerings, I was fascinated to learn that over 700 languages are spoken there, that most of the island doesn't have access to television and can only be reached by airplanes, and that there is an incredible diversity of flora and fauna in the mountains and rainforests.

I watched one particularly interesting video about a still-existing tribe of cannibals. In the video diary, a group travels to the far interior of West Papua, which shares the island of New Guinea with PNG, but is under Indonesian control. There, they encounter a tribe that has never before laid eyes on any Caucasians. The video is about sixteen minutes long, and, at the end provides some insight into why there are reports this week about an increase in witch hunting in PNG.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTRvcROcWHg


Amnesty International reports:

Authorities in Papua New Guinea are being urged to take greater action to prevent further killings related to allegations of sorcery.

A father and son became the latest victims on Sunday. Local men in Ban village shot dead 60-year-old Plak Mel Doa and threw his body into a fire. His son, Anis Dua, was dragged from his home and burnt alive. Local people had accused them both of causing the death of a prominent member of the community by sorcery.

There has been an increase in reports of sorcery-related killings over the last year. According to the media there were over 50 such deaths in 2008.This is either because of an actual increase in such incidents or that more incidents are now being reported.

 

According to another report, this happened close to the city of Mount Hagan, which is the capital of the Western Highlands province and also where the Papua Tribe Festival featured in my PNG music blog takes place each year.

If watched the entire video, you learned that when there is an unexpected death, the Korowai tribe, ignorant of modern science and medicine, attributes the death to black magic, or khakhua. Relatives of the deceased exact revenge for the death by killing and eating the witch deemed responsible. How they determine the identity of the witch seems a little bit arbitrary.

On the east end of the island, in PNG, the witch hunting continues, without the cannibalistic aspect but by the same rationale. People place the blame for untimely death onto black magic, declare a witch, and then brutally murder her or him.

Crazy, right?

Maybe not. All of us look for something or someone to blame when things go amiss. At the moment, I'm fairly certain that, if someone wanted to burn one or two of those Wall Street bankers at the stake, I'd have to take a long, deep breath before suggesting that maybe it's not such a great idea.

When cause and effect is too complicated to be easily understood, we all want a scapegoat toward whom we can direct our anger and pain. Please don't get the idea that I think witch hunting in PNG should be allowed to continue because the grieving need to feel better. I'm with AI on this one, and maybe we could get the PNG Highlands some science textbooks while we're at it.

But why is it such a strong human desire to attribute blame and exact revenge? It's food for thought, hopefully only metaphorically speaking. 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Cross posted at Dagblog.com, where we promise not to hunt you down and cook your brains if you piss us off.


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Maybe not. All of us look for something or someone to blame when things go amiss. At the moment, I'm fairly certain that, if someone wanted to burn one or two of those Wall Street bankers at the stake, I'd have to take a long, deep breath before suggesting that maybe it's not such a great idea.

That is what I was thinking as I read your essay. Do not get me wrong, but 90% of the time when I hear a repub on CSPAN discuss an issue I know he or she is wrong and I know the opposite when a Dem is discussing an issue.

But I really do not KNOW what they have been doing at the SEC. And yet I KNOW that there are employees over the last 8 years that should be imprisoned.

As a child I knew there were angels at the local Basilica and communists at the Farmers & Mechanics State Bank.

I still love Gramma Pelosi and I still despise Boehner. And I hope that conclusions I reach are based more upon 'fact' than when I was a child.

But am I absolutely SURE about that?

user-pic

I don't have the answer. But it's a really, really good question.

But why is it such a strong human desire to attribute blame and exact revenge?

It seems to me your question pertains to so many conflicts right now. Palestine/Israel. Torture. Jailing illegal aliens. Sarah Palin.

Please chime in with more please. I'm leaving before the cannibals arrive...

user-pic

In the case of the PNG witch hunts, armed with scientific evidence about disease and modern point of view about accidental death, I think most of us would agree that seeking to scapegoat a person as responsible for random death is extreme.

The complicated part comes in when there is at least some valid argument for cause and effect. What caused the current economic crisis? Wall Street? Freddie Mac? George Bush? None of the above, all of the above, some combination of these people and other factors, some random, some not?

It's way easier to just give us a target than to try to understand, especially when we WANT to be pissed off. Delving into a matter tends to decrease the amount of vitriol surrounding it.

user-pic

A different lesson we can draw is how rare this is in industrial civilization. Like the San in South Africa, Papa New Guineans are taken to represent some older ways of life. I've heard there are 6,000 languages on the planet, 4,000 of them on New Guinea. 700 probably is a conservative version of that.

The setting is those difficult-to-travel steep hills and dense jungle valleys, which reduce interaction. The lack of outside contact, like with some Amazonian groups, makes it reasonable to assume unchanged, or only slightly changed, routines for thousands of years.

If the hunter-gatherers of Africa are at all representative of earlier lifestyles, things are much better now, if you are a male and wish to die in your bed. They have about a 30% chance of dying violently, in revenge attacks, or witchcraft defense. This also happens in Amazon tribes.

But the study of these old traditions does inform us about characteristic still present in us, from the likely largest size of functional group, around a hundred, to the reasons for war---women, according to Yanomamo.

user-pic

Hell,

You don't have to spend that much money on airfare to witness baseline human savagery.

Next time you take a couple of weeks vacation, just hop on a jet for a fourteen hour ride to Warri Nigeria.

You ain't seen nothin yet!!!! First few hours you'll think you're in a hood. Naw!!!! Don't get anything stuck in your teeth you don't want to take home with you!!!!

user-pic
But why is it such a strong human desire to attribute blame and exact revenge? It's food for thought, hopefully only metaphorically speaking.

Ever watched the documentary of the Chernobyl disaster? When I was watching the Ukranians (I think it was in the Ukraine) rushing in to bury the meltdown so as to save their fellow countrypersons, knowing they would die for their efforts, I thought if such were to occur in the USA most folks' initial response would be to look for whom to blame.

Likewise, the folks of Stalingrad endured three years of privation to save their city from the invaders; and I have often wondered if the folks in NYC, D.C., or any other USA city would do such. I think, probably not.

By the way, if you're interested in Papua New Guinea, I recommend Jared Diamond's excellent book Guns, Germs, and Steel. Though the book addresses the question as to why it was that Eurasian folks came to dominate the planet, the book was spawned and germinated during Diamond's time in PNG.

user-pic

Second the book rec.

user-pic

Codegen86 wrote a well-received review of Guns, Germs, and Steel last summer:

http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/07/guns-germs-and-steel.php


user-pic

I say we burn all the fundamentalist Christians, they seem to be the worse of the worst. Close behing are the Muslim fundamentalists and then every other religion follows.

When human beings realize that there is no "god", this will give them a couple of decades of peace, until then find another way to self-destruct and kill each other off.

Unless of course if we are nuked before that time.

One can only hope!

Corey Mondello
Boston, Massachusetts
CoreyMondello.com

Leave a comment

Orlando

user-pic

Following: 85
Followers: 67

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Midwest
  • Politics Progressive

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs Dagblog.com TPM washingtonmonthly.com americablog.com
  • Favorite Books The Mists of Avalon; The Poisonwood Bible

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address