Is it really all that big a surprise that its own greed got the best of the insurance industry causing them to agressively criticize the Baucus Caucus Insurance Subsidy bill? Despite being handed tens of millions of new customers and the billions in profits that means to them, the insurance companies seem to be having cold feet when it comes to health insurance reform. Remember, we gave up health "care" reform a long time ago.
I've heard several "experts" speculate already that this signals that the insurance industry as a whole has gotten cold feet and they will try to kill the reform effort altogether. Of course the first reaction of any progressive is naturally to start thinking about how to stop them from scuttling the efforts of Congress when we are this close to the end of the process. But ya know what? I'm not sure that scuttling the tortured morass of industry protections, subsidies and other favors that we are being asked to swallow is all that bad and I'll tell ya why.
We all agree, even the President agrees, that we ought to have a single payer health care system in the United States. It is only because of the President's unwise decision to take the best option off the table that it hasn't been seriously discussed this year. Instead, we have had to swallow mouthful after mouthful of rotten half measures that will neither cover the entire population nor do a great deal to reduce healthcare costs in the long run. All this was done to placate and buy the support of the insurance industry and their fellow travelers in obscene profit at the expense of the sick. The insurance industry has been kept in line up until today with the prospect of all those millions of new customers and profits subsidized by taxpayers. But their greed just won't let them stay in line. And good for them! I think it's important that they show their true colors to the American people. They are about profit for themselves and nothing else and the people need to be fully aware of that.
If the insurance industry turns the screws here in the coming weeks they will likely be able to kill the entire effort of the many committees of Congress and the White House and the various interest groups that have been lobbying their little $400/hour hearts out all year long to come up with a dog of a bill featuring the onerous mandated insurance subsidy scheme. And when they kill reform what should the response be from the President and the progressives in Congress be?
My suggestion is that they should respond to this as a call to arms. They should respond to the perfidy of the insurance industry as a declaration of war that must be answered. My suggestion is that the response be a full court press for Medicare for All!
All year long, despite refusing to even discuss single payer, the President and the Democrats have been accused of favoring a single payer system. They have weathered the storm of criticism. They have managed to counter all the claims of the Republicans and their allies in the insurance and related industries that are sucking the life out of our economy for their own profit.
So since Democrats are being accused of wanting Medicare for All I say the President and the progressives in Congress go balls to the wall for just that come January. The timorous corporate Democrats cowering at their wine and cheese parties and at their elegant dinners in Georgetown would shriek in terror at the very thought. The oh so wise and serious mavens of our insular and out of touch Capitol City would declare the Democrats crazy and perhaps even suicidal. And perhaps they would be. But I think not.
We would, however, for the first time have a proposal we could all get behind that is everything the malodorous beast moving through Congress right now is not. Medicare for All is simple. It is easy to explain and to understand. It is the best plan for our nation and achieves the greatest savings possible while covering everyone. And on top of it all it can be relatively quickly and easily implemented because the system is already working efficiently and equitably for millions of our seniors. The Medicare for All legislation could take effect (even if passed in 2010) long before the garbage they are now debating would ever begin to take effect!
By championing Medicare for All, our candidates would have an energized population behind them. Remember, a majority of Americans support a single payer system already even though most of our leaders have been too timid and cowardly to fight openly for it with the exception of a few brave souls like the late, great Teddy Kennedy and a handful of others in Congress. What the Democrats would also have, for the first time, would be the strategic advantage politically. They could go on the offensive and stay on the offensive making the issue of Medicare for All the line in the sand that would define American politics favorably for Democrats for the next 50 years just as Social Security has done for the last 70 years. And when they do this, the President should push for quick action on Medicare for All so that two things could happen. First, citizens across the land would find out where their members of Congress stand on the issue of Medicare for All and if they don't support it, primary opponents who favor it could be found. And second, for the Republicans, their Democratic challengers could bludgeon them day and night through Election Day in November and possibly even defy the odds by knocking off some Republican incumbents and actually increasing the majority Democrats have in both houses in an off year election despite it being midway through the term of a President of their own party.
If, just for once, the Democrats in Washington DC would have the courage of their convictions, if they would just stand up and really fight for what is right, the American public would back them up. But that is clearly the toughest part of the task... getting the pathetically cowardly DC Democrats to stand up and fight for anything let alone the most important thing they could possibly fight for: the health of their constituents and the simultaneous rescue of millions of small businesses while making American corporations competitive once again with foreign companies who already have government run, single payer systems.
The wimpy Democrats of DC would, of course, need to learn how to actually stand for something but they could take lessons in having balls and backbone from a few of the more courageous members of Congress like House members Grayson, Weiner, Kaptur, Kucinich and Conyers. They might even get a few tips on standing up for what you believe in from Senator Brown of Ohio.
So, despite the huge obstacle of Democratic spinelessness in Washington that has plagued us now for a generation that remains my suggestion: come back in January and make Medicare for All the singular priority of the Congress.
Be relentless in demanding Medicare for All. Let the President forcefully denounce (if he can bring himself to do it) the insurance industry and the other parasites that killed the bill in 2009. Let him actually lead us in an effort for demonstrably real change of the kind we elected him to pursue! Let our progressive Democrats lead a vigorous populist assault against the corporate greed of big pharma and big insurance, et al. Make Medicare for All the litmus test for everyone running for Congress in 2010.
If we lose, we are better off, in my opinion, and certainly no worse off than we would be if we get saddled with the rotten bills going through Congress this year. But, if we lose we will have at least defined the debate on our terms now and forever and we know it is only a matter of time before we do pass Medicare for All because it is a necessity for our people and our economy. And even if we don't get it passed in 2010 the people will finally be able to have some respect for the Democratic Party once again as a party that fights for what it believes in and that also fights for the interests of the common man and woman in America: even when it is hard.
So for now I say to the insurance industry go for it! Do your thing! Kill that rotten insurance subsidy scheme and show the people how truly ugly and worthless you really are so they'll never forget it. Set the stage for progress by showing your true character, you reprehensible parasites, so we can finally do what should have been done 60 years ago.
Bring it on baby!