KUDOS TO REP. JENKINS
Kansas Republican Congresswoman Lynn Jenkins made a mistake last week! In answering a question during a meeting with Young Republicans in Hiawatha on August 19th, she said: "Republicans are struggling right now to find the "great white hope"
OOOPS!! From a constituent's meeting in a small Kansas town to the national news media in the space of a week. Thanks to the wonder of the camera phone. You see, "The phrase "great white hope" dates to the early 1900's when white Americans were looking for a white boxer to defeat Jack Johnson, the first black heavyweight champ." Probably not the phrase you want to use when discussing how your predominantly white political party is trying to figure out how to defeat the country's first black President.
Fox4's local coverage reports:
On Friday, Jenkins claims that she didn't realize the racial significance of the phrase "great white hope," and didn't mean to offend anyone. But according to a University of Missouri, Kansas City political scientist, the phrase suggests that the GOP is looking for a white politician to defeat Barack Obama, the nation's first African-American president.
"There is a racist connotation when you say the great white hope, even if you don't mean that," said Prof. Max Skidmore of UMKC. "There is an undercurrent a habit of thought that it reflects."
Jenkins says that it was a comparison that she did not intend to make. She says that she was responding to a question from someone asking about the future of the Republican Party.
"I responded to that inquiry by saying that there were some bright lights, some hope in the Republican party for the conservatives in the crowd," said Jenkins. "Obviously I had no idea there were negative connotations associated with that phrase and apologize if someone has misinterpreted those comments."
The comment, whether it was meant to be racist or not (and I really don't think it was meant that way) was NOT a good choice of wording under any context. "The great white hope" is a phrase that I heard often growing up. (But then, I grew up in the Ozarks. I graduated from a class of over 400....with only 4 black students in the entire school. So my exposure to people who might have taken exception to the phrase was severely limited.)
So, it is very possible that she was just using a phrase that she had heard so often growing up that it's lost it's cultural context to her. There are lots of those phrases I heard daily growing up in southern Missouri that today I shudder at the thought that I or my parents used them. "N*gg&r in the woodpile", "jew" down the price, "chinese fire drill", etc. In a past world where Archie Bunker was the norm and not just a funny character on TVLand, these phrases were common. But today we are more aware that while a phrase might just be a cute saying to some, it can be an extremely hurtful comment to others.
The use of these types of phrases are not wise for anyone with aspirations of public office in this age of camera phones. But it is not the end of the world. It especially is not the end of the world when she responds quickly to the criticisms with a very simple apology!
No bitter fight to prove that she really didn't do anything wrong. No discussion of what others say that's worse than what she said. No tirade against a media that is biased against conservatives. No commentary on who she has heard say the same thing in the past.
She simply said she didn't realize the context of the saying and she was sorry for any offense it caused. She took the blame.
That's class!
Now some will say that she HAD to realize the context of her words, but absent any other slips of the tongue, that's a hard case to make. So it's time to drop the story and move on! I wouldn't vote for Congresswoman Jenkins if I lived in her district but I can at least respect her integrity!
(And of course, if she continues to make such mistakes....we hold her responsible for them!)













"Now some will say that she HAD to realize the context of her words, but absent any other slips of the tongue, that's a hard case to make."
Is it?
The boxer named "The Great White Hope" (Jess Willard) is from Congresswoman Jenkins own district... not just her own district... 30 miles from where she grew up.
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2009/8/27/773315/-UPDATE
August 27, 2009 8:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
She simply said she didn't realize the context of the saying and she was sorry for any offense it caused. She took the blame.
Ya ..??? BULL
C
August 27, 2009 9:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
I think you are letting her off pretty easy...she said she was sorry if anyone misinterpreted her comments, not that she was sorry she said it. Words have meaning...This is the non-apology apology we are getting used to.
August 27, 2009 10:21 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yeah I am kind of with Stilli on this. Rhetorically, I would use it against her.
I hear worse every day.
But she, unlike others, saw they she had been caught with her foot in her mouth and at least tried to so something about it. I am curious even though she is not in the Senate, what statements she had made about our new Supreme Court Justice.
August 28, 2009 1:03 PM | Reply | Permalink
"Obviously I had no idea there were negative connotations associated with that phrase and apologize if someone has misinterpreted those comments."
Okay, let's break it down. First word, "Obviously", in other words. Are you blind?!? Are you stupid? Obviously she had no idea there were negative connotations associated with that phrase.
Be serious, she does think we are stupid, or at least stupid enough to believe that this woman, who is a Congressional representative is stupid, and she got to Washington DC by shear happenstance also.
Then let's take it down the homestretch to "apologize if someone has misinterpreted those comments." You know, if we were stupid enough to understand the meaning of the phrase, "great white hope" as related to race. If we held some outrageous belief that white was the opposite of black? Or maybe she thought that unless the next GOP candidate was white then there was no hope. Frankly, regardless of the historical reference, great white hope is a racist expression. If you are willing to give her the benefit of the doubt, then I have no other response then to generously say, without any racial insinuations whatsoever, that doing so was mighty white of you!
August 28, 2009 2:46 AM | Reply | Permalink
GregorZap says:
"Be serious, she does think we are stupid, or at least stupid enough to believe that this woman, who is a Congressional representative is stupid, and she got to Washington DC by shear happenstance also."
All I can say is, keep in mind she's a representative from KANSAS!!! A state whose Board of Education doesn't believe in evolution! I never claimed she was smart...I've heard her speak before. She's not the brightest person on the hill.
I grew up in Southwest Missouri. I heard all of the expressions I mentioned (and I might add, "might white of you") on a regular basis growing up in the 70's. These were unfortunately very common expressions back then. And if you grow up hearing them constantly, they lose their impact. (Much in the same way that the term "Nigga" has lost it's negative conatations in the African-American community.)
I'm ashamed to admit that I was in college before I ever realized that you SHOULDN'T use the expression, "I jewed him down on the price". I had heard it all my life and never connected it with the Jewish religion.
Now you can write it off to me being totally stupid or you can also take into account that I was 19 years old before I ever met anyone who admitted to me that they were Jewish. Congresswoman Jenkins is from a similar part of the country. It's not right...but it's also not necessarily malicious.
I'm not saying the expression was suitable for use. I'm not saying that Rep. Jenkins deserves to be in Congress. What I am saying is that using an expression she grew up with in a small town in Kansas ONCE is not sufficient reason to crucify her for her stupidity. (Her voting record is completely sufficient to dislike her for.)
August 28, 2009 3:26 AM | Reply | Permalink
When you learned that your epxressions were rooted [no offense to the Rutabaga] in racism, did you blame the people within ear shot for misinterpreting your expression, or did you simply apologize? Did you say, "I'm not a racist and therefore I get to repeat this racist expression because I am so obviously not a racist?"
Look, it is not a career breaking moment, but it is a learning moment and, as you shared, you learned your lesson in the 70s. It seems this lady has not learned the lesson, or, given the 40 years since the civil rights movement's heyday, she has chosen not to learn the lesson. I think, based on the evidence, that is what is more likely. It's a shame to be so negative, but I think we have to face reality. My benefit of the doubt only goes so far.
BTW, I had used that expression "mighty white of you" for a few years before I realized how offensive it was. I think I had even used it with one of my black friends present. He never thought I was a racist, but he let me know it was a racist remark. That was 30 years ago.
"...the work goes on, the cause endures, the hope still lives, and the dream shall never die."
August 28, 2009 12:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
GregorZap:
I haven't heard Congresswoman Jenkins repeat the racist phrase since that time so I don't see her claiming the right to repeat racist remarks.
If she doesn't use the phrase (or similar ones) then maybe she's learned a lesson. If she does use such language again, then by all means go after her for it.
But I think this is very similar to your use of the phrase, "mighty white of you". You used a racist phrase repeatedly that you never really thought about. It just popped out! It was something you had heard all your life. That didn't make it an acceptable phrase to use. That doesn't make you a racist either. (As you pointed out, your black friend knew you weren't a racist....it was just a racist phrase.) When you realized what you were saying, you stoped using it. Give her the same chance.
And I know that this is hard to understand to anyone who lives in any kind of multi-cultural environment, but if EVERYONE around you for 50 miles is white....you just don't think about things in the same way you do if you live with a bit of variety in your life. Yes, we are 40 years after Dr. King & we've come a long way...but there's still a lot of travel time in many parts of our country.
I currently live in a predominantly black neighborhood with a Mexican wife and have two mixed race (hispanic/black) grown step-children and two grandchildren....and I live in fear everytime we visit my parents as to what unintentional toad is going to pop out of their mouths. (Remember Pres. Obama's reflection upon some of the things HIS white grandmother would say.)
The South is alive and well...for better & worse.
August 28, 2009 4:39 PM | Reply | Permalink
Rep. Jenkins spoke from ignorance. Perhaps she conflated 'great white hope' with 'knight in shining armor' and honestly did not know of the racial reference. I remember a game show once where a man said "I like to get under my wife's goat just to annoy her".
August 28, 2009 10:19 AM | Reply | Permalink
Wonder how the goat feels about it, though.
August 28, 2009 12:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
Are you mixing old sayings? Isn't it "getting her goat" or "getting under her skin" not getting "under" her goat? Just askin'.
August 28, 2009 6:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
I didn't say it Stilli, it was some guy on tv. I'm assuming he's mixed the sayings you've mentioned. The point was that people can say ridiculous things, innocently.
August 28, 2009 6:22 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for clarifying! LOL
August 28, 2009 6:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
I can only speculate whether Jenkins was aware of the racist connotations of her remark. If so, shame on her. If not, she may be like many uninformed individuals who perceive "great white hope" as similar in meaning to "white knight". The latter term probably originated in Lewis Carroll's "Through The Looking Glass" (unless he used it from some other source), and refers to a hero who comes to rescue people in distress.
Throughout history, "white" has signified purity and virtue, while "black" has represented evil or underhandedness. These distinctions have been exploited by one race of people with tannish-pink skins to belittle others with brown skins. White and black do occur in biology, but not in the human skin.
If Jenkins is innocent of intentional racism, the alternative conclusion is not much more favorable - she lives in such an insulated world of white privilege as to have no clue about the hardships and injustice in the real world, and the bigotry that has often perpetrated it. In my view, what she needs to do is less in the way of apologizing, and more in the way of learning what life is like for Americans not favored by wealth, privilege, and skin color. If she wants to be involved in law making, that would be the first baby step.
August 28, 2009 12:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
I don't know that anyone will see this this late, but seemed appropriate, showing that racism is alive and well on both sides. Unfortunate.
http://features.csmonitor.com/politics/2009/08/28/memo-about-a-black-agenda-in-mayors-race-roils-atlanta/
August 29, 2009 11:48 AM | Reply | Permalink