« The GOP's triple false axioms | Matthew Stavros's Blog | Secret Legal Memos and the Meaning of "War" »

The Military in the GOP "Gotcha" Game


Huffpost is reporting that:
Vowing to fight Barack Obama's budget in Congress, Republicans have resorted to a three-pronged attack: accusing the president of proposing unprecedented spending, irresponsible taxation, and using dishonest projections about how to pay for it all.
The GOP apparently got some help from Admiral Mullen, the head of US forces, with a suggestion on Fox New Sunday that he did not know where the Obama administration was getting its long-term projections for the money it will save by drawing down the war in Iraq.

Gotcha!!

Not really. Budget projections don't (and shouldn't) go in that directions. Top brass can make suggestions about what equipment to buy and how to move people around but the bottom line on spending comes from a civilian government. The government sets policy and the military follows orders. This separation of powers and duties is one of the hallmarks of a successful progressive democracy.

Going further, am I the only one who feels it inappropriate for military leaders to appear on TV commenting on the budget or policy in general? Is it their place? 

For more on Mullen and this topic see my earlier blog post.     


... 

2 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I saw that headline at HuffPo, but without reading the article I said, "why would he know?" It isn't his place to speak on that at all. That's not his responsibility.

user-pic

Going to fox noise to degrade your commander and chiefs credibility. Yeah i dont think thats what commanders should be doing.

Leave a comment

Matthew Stavros

user-pic

Following: 3
Followers: 11

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

Bio

Professor of Japanese History. American resident of Australia and Japan.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address