President-Elect Obama Needs to Reconsider
His tax cuts for the middle class or for anybody else for that matter. Now demand-siders may jump on me, but it makes no sense for the government, (which if we really squeezed out the deficit spending wouldn't be able to buy a pair of socks at the local Target), to attempt to salvage this current situation with reduced revenues. The government needs more revenue. Period. It needs it like my mower needs gas, like a butterfly needs flowers, like a fire needs wood. There is no way around this. We can not, must not, increase the deficit over the absurd, insane, reality-twisting heights it has reached under this departing administration. Do we really want our government's bonds to be downgraded to AA? Really? Well, it can happen and if it does, things will really get ugly.
http://www.reuters.com/article/Finance08/idUSTRE4AB7HT20081112
So my gentle plea to President-Elect Obama is this: Listen to your financial advisers and if any suggest increasing the deficit....show them the door!
http://www.reuters.com/article/Finance08/idUSTRE4AB7HT20081112
So my gentle plea to President-Elect Obama is this: Listen to your financial advisers and if any suggest increasing the deficit....show them the door!
Advertisement





I think there's traps no matter which way we turn, Lux. Look at the traditional read on this thing we're in. 1) Run up the deficit, and risk a downgrade, a run on the dollar, having to shove up interest rates. 2) Don't run up the deficit, and you could be staring serious deflation in the eye - probably worse.
The official dilemma right now is that even IF the financial situation is stabilized, we're ALREADY seeing the real economy fall, hard and fast - with more unemployment, tightening of belts, corporate downsizing and shuttering on its way. And once consumption stops rising (which it has), the big motor that's 60%-70% of GDP stalls, what takes up the slack? Investment is limited by all the debt out there, depressed markets, etc. Exports? They're slow to gear up, and probably not a big enough engine. So what's left? Government spending. That's gonna be the official consensus, right? Because there's no other lever to pull.
If you go that route - run BIG deficits, risk a run on the dollar - you still might be able to pull off enough international coordination to handle the downside risks. e.g. Everybody run deficits, coordinated support of exchange rates, etc. But there are a LOT of external, uncontrollable factors out there.
If I think within the box, I think there's probably room to make some budget cuts to things that cost a lot, but offer only a little domestic stimulus. I suspect there's also room to raise some revenue by going after the piles of wealth stashed away by the new hyper-rich. Pull that money out, and spend it. And US debt as a % of GDP still has some room before hitting post-war highs, maybe 2-3 years of $1 trillion deficits. So.... maybe those things could do it. I'd give it a 50/50 at best.
But I just keep asking myself, who in their right minds would buy US debt over the longer term. Sure, people have parked money in the US while the financial crisis ratchets around... but would YOU park hundreds of billions MORE - beyond existing levels - in a country in this position, once finance calms?
This is part of the reason I want to see some REALLY new voices kicking around on the economic advisory teams. Because I'm just not seeing the big established guns laying out any serious case on HOW the economy can be revived, a really bad recession avoided, the $ protected, etc. Muddling through, balancing the various traditional ways of thinking about this, just doesn't seem to me to be a recipe for very much at all.
Except lost TIME. And that's a danger in itself.
November 13, 2008 6:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
thanks Quinn. I too can't see a clear way out of this mess and I grant that Obama will probably have to run up some more debt before we are able to start paying it down and I also grant that though our treasuries getting downgraded by Moody's is a possibility its a long-shot so I am not ready to climb out on the ledge and do a cliff dive yet like John seems gearing up for. But....
Now things are changing. We are downplaying the G20 summit, but I don't think China and Russia feel so carefree about it.
November 13, 2008 7:19 PM | Reply | Permalink
Krugman. Tough.
November 14, 2008 1:35 AM | Reply | Permalink