« In Iraq, Sometimes Luck Is All You Have | Morgan Pardee's Blog

Bringing Home Our Troops Isn't Stupid


On the anniversary of 9/11, as I stepped off the bus from work, I approached a group of sign-wavers demonstrating in front of the local library. I had just moved to the community and didn’t realize this was a weekly event until I stopped to chat with a few of them. And like last week, the “Bring Home the Troops’ and “End the War” sign-wavers were quietly chatting amongst themselves or standing in silent vigil.

But tonight there was another group holding signs gathered on one street corner. Their signs read, “Support the Troops, Support the Mission.” At first, I thought they were part of the group I’d seen last week, but their behavior told me otherwise.

These demonstrators brandished American flags in front of passing cars, volleyed pro-war slogans across the intersection. It appeared they were trying to instigate a face-off with the “anti-war” movement.

I stopped and watched for a few minutes and then went over and picked up a sign from a pile stacked against the library and stepped up to the street corner.

My son will be home in a few days after serving 15 months in Iraq, mostly in the troubled Diyala Province near the Iran border. May was a bad month for his company, the 5-20 Stryker Brigade. His stryker was blown up, two of his best friends died, and he saw six others blown to bits in another explosion. And I'm sure he's seen things he'll never be able to talk about.

Yesterday I read his brigade lost 47 during this deployment. Tragically, another from his company died today from injuries sustained that week in May. My heart ached for his family back in my home state of Oregon.

And two young women I spent some time with this last year are coming to grips with the grim reality that they will not be part of the joyous homecoming celebrations that will be held at Fort Lewis next week, because their loved ones were lost that bloody week in May.

“Support the troops, support the mission,” the man standing next to me shouted over the top of my head.

I turned and asked: “Sir, do you have any family members serving in Iraq?”

He shot me a look and said, “Well, not in Iraq – but we all serve!” he quickly added. “We have to win! Otherwise, my grandchildren will be fighting to keep us free. Our troops are doing this for them. It’s people like you that are keeping us from winning this war.”

I guess he thought I was a member of the anti-war movement he and his group were trying to challenge.

“Sir, my son has served two deployments in Iraq. And it’s because of people like YOU that he keeps having to go back there again and again.”

I thought he was going to hit me with his huge sign. But, instead, he walked away and stood near another man who was carrying a sign that read, “Impeach.”

He soon came back.

“Everyone has the freedom to their own opinion,” he said, “but I don’t think your son would appreciate you holding that sign.”

“Sir, my son knows exactly how I feel. He has told me preserving my freedom to speak my mind IS worth fighting for, but I don’t believe he has to go to Iraq to do that.”

“Then you don’t know what this war is about,” he shot back.

“However,” I said, “I see that it’s OK with you that MY son sacrifice his life for YOUR beliefs, but it’s not OK for YOUR grandchildren to die for the same cause.”

“You’re a stupid, stupid woman.” He turned and walked away.

Perhaps I am stupid. But if I am, it’s because I’m senselessly in love with my son, dulled witless with worry over his safe return and stupefied at how ignorant and insensitive and self-absorbed people can be when it’s not their child – or grandchild – in harm's way.

That man and many like him aren't "supporting the troops," they're supporting their egos, too insecure to admit they trusted an administration that lied, blindly supported a political party that cooperated in reducing our freedoms and were too lazy to step outside their self-rightous comfort zone to check the temperature of the cold, hard truth -- they made a mistake.

My son will be home in a few days; and I could have just passed on by with very little effort. But who will stand up for all the others who are still in Iraq, still in harms way, still dying for this administration's lies?

And who will stand up for those preparing to return to Iraq for their third and fourth deployments so that Mr. Flag Waver's family doesn't have to?

I looked up at the sign I was holding: “Bring the Troops Home,” and wondered: Would that man still call me stupid if I were standing on a street corner holding it up for a total stranger, perhaps, HIS grandson?

Or would HE be the one holding that sign?

I know one thing: I sure wouldn't call him stupid.


6 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Right!  And do see one of Morgan's fabulous contributions to our Redress Day here.

Best Constitutional wishes,

Tish

No nation is conquered until the hearts of its women are on the ground. 

user-pic

Wow! I had a similar discussion with a biker years ago over a flag burning amendment. People like him and your adversary in this discussion love their right to free speech but can’t stand the other side having the same right.

The biker threatened to beat the young man who was protesting the war by burning a flag. He said the guys in Vietnam were fighting for that flag. He went on and on about all that flag meant. I told him I’d just returned from Vietnam. I asked if he’d been. He didn’t answer. He just scowled at me. I told him the guys there were fighting for the other guy’s right to free speech as much as they were for that piece of cloth.

I remember when I went through my survival training (SERE – Survival,Evasion,Resistance,Escape) before deploying to Vietnam. There was a 3 day phase we spent in a “prison camp” environment. I won’t go into detail here but it was VERY real. The last morning as the sun began to light the horizon, the North Vietnamese flag was lowered and Old Glory was raised. I’ve never been more moved by a flag raising and I’m always touched by them. The flag means a lot to me. Civil liberties mean a lot to me. Without freedom of speech, we are not America. Why don’t the right wing pundits and your adversary in this blog understand that

user-pic

Because they're scared they may be wrong in their convictions, and they don't like hearing people who disagree with them because it might make that mustard seed of doubt lodged in the base of their brain grow into something they can't keep under control. So they keep themselves blinded and deaf.

The sad thing is that these people couldn't see the dimple truth even if it was stending right in front of them, because they don't WANT to.

Morgan

With reasonable men I will reason; with humane men I will plea; but to tyrants I will give no quarter, nor waste arguments where they will certainly be lost.

-- William Lloyd Garrison (1805 - 1879)

user-pic

I'm told that in Texas when someone agrees with everything you've said they do so with just one word and that word serves me well, at this moment.

I will therefore use it..."MYSELF"

-A Korean War Vet

user-pic

Hello, my stupid friend.

I was so impressed by this that I copied it over into an e-mail, link provided, and sent it to everybody on my e-mail list, especially the 3/5 moms whose kids just got sent back for a FOURTH deployment.

I think you hit right-smack at the crux of the issue, and that is that if you want to stand on street corners or sit in the halls of Congress and support Bush's war, then by God you should send your own damn kids to fight it.

America is not at war. The US military is at war, and they are exhausted and burnt out. Right now, the entire Joint Chiefs, Lute himself, and Gates as well, are trying desperately behind the scenes to protect the military from being completely broken by the stresses and strains of these multiple deployments, extended deployments, stop-loss, reserve activation, and so on that have provided a back-door draft to those who already served with honor.

The long-term consequences of this stress is unknown at this point, but it will be grave, and they are figuring that out.

Of course, it's easy to stand on a street corner and wave a plaque.

Try hugging your child good-bye and wondering if you will ever look on their face again.

I have come to loathe these people.

How dare he call a military mom stupid.

user-pic

I edited the exchange for brevity. But just before he called me stupid, he tried to discredit me by calling me a liar. It didn't matter to him that I'm wearing my son's dog tags next to a locket with his picture in it. He said, "I don't know what that is and how do I know it's even real."

The guy has been floating down the river of "denial" for so long he has forgotten how to use his eyes and ears -- he hears and sees only what he wants to hear. His brain's been on a steady diet of "conservatism" ... and now his brain has become the "gatekeeper," ensuring that he only hears and sees what Bush and Company want him to know.

Isn't that what happened in Germany when Hitler and his Brown Shirts were in control?

Morgan

With reasonable men I will reason; with humane men I will plea; but to tyrants I will give no quarter, nor waste arguments where they will certainly be lost.

-- William Lloyd Garrison (1805 - 1879)

Leave a comment

Morgan Pardee

user-pic

Following:
Followers:

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address