Medicare for All: Senator Kennedy's Bill as the "Public Option"
Senator Kennedy had previously introduced a bill to open Medicare coverage to all persons. The beauty of this form of "public option" is its simplicity and its progressive potential. Previous public options would create a new insurance plan with costs somewhere between Medicare and private insurance. This approach would be more progressive and would reduce administrative and bureaucratic costs.
To further simplify the process, I would suggest having Congress pass a resolution which spells out broad principles of health care reform rapidly. Then follow up with the 1,000 page bill markup at their leisure. Haste in cementing points of agreement is critical. That is precisely why opponents of any reform see delay as their best tactic.
Here is a modest proposal of points on principle on which Congressional Democrats may be able to get agreement quickly enough to pass a resolution:
I propose a short bill of no more than 2 pages with simple declarative sentences, such as:
1) No health insurance plan may decide to drop coverage on a person because the value of their life is not deemed worth coverage.
2) When a person leaves one insurance plan, their previous insurer must maintain coverage for six months or until they get their new coverage in place.
3) No health
insurance plan may kick people out for failure to disclose a condition.
4) Health insurers can no longer deny coverage on basis of pre-existing conditions.
5) All citizens will be required to have some form of health insurance coverage.
6) No person will be forced by the government or their employer to drop their existing health insurance plan.
7) All citizens whose employers do not provide health insurance must purchase their own health insurance.
8) The Federal Government will allow citizens who are currently ineligible for Medicare benefits, the option of enrolling in Medicaire by paying premiums. This optional Medicare coverage will help bring down the cost of health insurance for the uninsured who work.
9) The optional Medicare coverage will work just as Medicare does: reimbursing private doctors for covered services.
10) The optional Medicare coverage must be self-sustaining financially, not draining any benefits away from enrolled Medicare recipients.
11) Those citizens who cannot afford private health insurance or optional Medicare coverage will get a tax credit to cover the extra cost of the optional Medicare premiums.
12) The tax credits will
be paid for by the extra revenue generated by the cap on health insurance tax exemptions
for those making more than $250,000 per year.
No one making less than $250,000 per year will have their exemption for
employer paid health insurance capped.
Those making $250,000 per year or more will have their health insurance
tax exemption capped and their tax deduction for health care costs capped. If this cap is insufficient to create revenues to offset coverage, adjustment of the marginal tax rate for those earning more than $250,000 per year may be made yearly.
















If someone's policy is rescinded because of a preexisting condition, does the pseudo-insurer return all the premiums they received due to their error? I mean, if they were not going to cover the person when it was needed, why should we believe that person was ever covered at all? Because they paid premiums? I think the insurance company is emphatically in disagreement that premiums equate to actual coverage or they would not rescind the policy.
August 28, 2009 3:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
[Kennedy's Medicare for All bill] is an idea whose time has come, and there ought to be robust public discussion about it. TPM Reader BR
Too bad Kennedy's not here to lead the discussion.
Oh, that's right; himself had already abandoned the idea. Instead, he shepherded the Affordable Choices Act through his HELP Committee which leaves 34 million uninsured.
August 28, 2009 3:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
GregorZap has a great point about coverage. They are taking the premiums and then arguing that the insured misled them about their health. Of course, anyone who has endured a sales pitch from an insurance salesperson knows that coverage is a selling point. It is just another example of bait and switch.
It is sad that Senator Kennedy is gone on, but I think the policy he promoted is a simple and elegant solution to the problematic "public option." It may in the end help keep Medicare costs down while increasing its solvency. Great idea. My hats off to Teddy!
August 31, 2009 8:35 AM | Reply | Permalink