« Eggles Millenium Version | GC Observer's Blog | Family Legacies »

What Admiral Adama Would Do


While I suspect that the only folks willing to read this post are under 30 and occasionally exhibit -- if honest with themselves - what Jon Stewart might label "douchebag-type" behavior, I wanted to memorialize my 12-hour BSG catch-up session before the advent of the final episodes commencing January 16.  I got a lot more out of this series than the West Wing.  Or most anything on pay cable, excepting, perhaps, Showtime's The Brotherhood.

BSG explores a lot of difficult moral questions.  One of the writers' favorite themes is to challenge us to answer questions like:

"how many lives would you risk to save a friend?"
"how many lives would you end to preserve a foreign relations strategy?"
"how bad does your opponent have to be before you steal an election?"
"would you sacrifice yourself to save someone who could help your country more?"

Or how about this one:

"would you play golf and side step issues to preserve an optimal foreign relations/public relations strategy even if it meant 100s would die?"

Maybe it's worth it.  I don't have the big picture.

Ron D Moore, I shall miss you when you're gone.



8 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Is it Battlestar Galactica?

user-pic

So Obama is directly responsible for Israel's actions? That's pretty interesting.

I don't think BSG's arguments are so flimsy though...

user-pic

Also, weren't you the one chastising Obama supporters a while back for allegedly believing that he had superpowers?

Now you expect a man who currently has no official position to end a centuries-old conflict with a press conference and the snap of the finger?

The expectations change to suit our need to gripe, eh? I just wish you guys would try to be a little more consistent...

user-pic

The funny thing about discussion is that it's not the same as argument. If anyone has all the answers, please point the way!

user-pic

All voices are welcome here, young and old. Some think they know everything, most are here to learn as much as to teach. We have learned much from some of the brilliant 20 somethings who have written on this forum.

I continue to be surprised by the level of cynicism you exhibit. I hope that someday you'll share your story so that we might understand how someone so young can have so little "idealism."

user-pic

Apologies to all; should have been a little more clear. I'm basically begging for the big picture. Tell me why he's not saying anything -- at least, a justification other than "I'm not president yet." Or at least flush it out a little more for me :o)

user-pic

We are not clairvoyant... Those of us who trust him, think he probably has reasons for not speaking out that he is unable to convey at this time. Those who don't think there is something funny going on.

We are missing a few key puzzle pieces at the moment, so an accurate big picture can't be seen.
But that's what we do here, we guess...

user-pic

That's the funny thing about trust. You have to be like Mike and just do it.

Leave a comment

GC Observer

user-pic

Following: 6
Followers: 6

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Philly
  • Party Dem
  • Politics Finding a way to compassionate globalization

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs paul krugman; delawarelitigaton.com; TPM (of course), Politico; Opioniojuris.org; http://drezner.foreignpolicy.com/; International Law and Economic Policy Blog (http://worldtradelaw.typepad.com/ielpblog/); http://www.eschatonblog.com/

Bio

Overpacked with overcompensations

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address