« Passing | Justice Putnam's Blog | The Lost War Dispatches: A Public Parody »

To Give a Little Humanity


"No civilization would ever have been possible without a framework of stability, to provide the wherein for the flux of change. Foremost among the stabilizing factors, more enduring than customs, manners and traditions, are the legal systems that regulate our life in the world and our daily affairs with each other."

-- Hannah Arendt

 

"We had orders to obey the head of state.  We weren't a band of criminals meeting in the woods in the dead of night to plan mass murders."

--Hermann Goering
"Nuremburg Transcripts 5 Jan 46"

 

"I was given this assignment which I could not refuse--and besides, I did everything possible to treat the transferee's well."

--Fritz Sauckel
"Nuremburg Transcripsts 23 Feb 46"

 

 

 

I was speculating how it was that we could do what we have done in the name of the "War on Terror." I thought of John Yoo and The Bybee Memo and how "legal justifications" were utilized to fight that "war." I then thought of the Germans of WWII. I thought how similiar the use of law was used by the Nazis to promulgate their power. 
 
What happens if we become the evil incarnate we have always said we have always fought against? What happens if, just as in Nazi Germany, that in the simple duty or the banality of just doing our jobs, we perpetuate that evil? When laws have been made and followed to incarcerate indefnitely without charge and to torture; and the philosophical morality that put substance to those laws is the lay of the land; it is then but a few short steps to when a mandate will be codified...
 
 
 

To Give a Little Humanity

by

Justice Putnam

 

Yes, yes your Honors. I remember the boy, he was the most reticent I'd seen pass through the transfer camp. Yes, yes, quite unlike all the other children. He was most difficult. You see we were mandated by the High Command to put these children at ease before they were transferred. So we used many means to elicit some kind of benign emotion. To see a young one cry or to laugh meant we were successful. It would not do for them to be transferred as mere zombies. We are not cruel nor are we uncivilized. We never tried to make those children unconscious about their lives; we wanted them to be awake and aware, as all children must be taught.

All the others had no success with him. He neither cried nor smiled; he didn't play with the other children. He was mostly by himself but always, always, awake or asleep, he kept his right fist tight and clenched.

I was called in after a few days. The next transfer scheduled was only two days after that. I offered him candies and he refused any; unlike any of the other children that have passed through the camp the last year. My! He was the talk of Camp! I asked him to relax, I said that he would be taken care of and had nothing to worry about. I assured him that he would be with his parents soon and if he could just unclench his fist, we'd shake on it.

That reticent little boy ran away! No, normally, normally that would not do. Any other child would have been punished, severely. It will not do for other children to observe such a lack of authority in those circumstances. But this boy was my project and I wanted his laughs or his cries to come without force. I am after all, as I've stated before, neither cruel nor uncivilized.

I would sit with him and show photographs of great works of Art the High Command confiscated for protection. I read passages of literary giants from the last few books not burned. Simply being there and feeding him, so to speak, with a firm but learned affection did indeed, yes indeed, calm him.

So like a frightened puppy, that reticent little boy finally began to befriend me. He finally began to speak, to only me mind you, but his little whispers gained some trust in a very short time.

And not a minute too soon. The transfer was only minutes away.

He told me how the authorities apprehended his father one morning a year before. The little one cast his eyes down to the ground as he told me his story; his right fist tight and clenched. He told me of how hungry and sick his mother was; how he would scavenge for some kind of food and bring her some little thing he found.

All the while that reticent little boy told me his story, but his fist remained tight and clenched. I could hear the fires being stoked. The drums of sarin were put in place. The children were being lined up for the transfer and I am sure the little boy had an epiphany.

Because he gazed up at me finally and held his right hand out for me to look. Some sad crumbs of an old muffin were moldy on his palm. He had been saving them for his mother, for when he would see her again. He told me she was so hungry and sick.

Then, with tears welling up in his eyes, he said he didn't think he needed those crumbs anymore. He cried as he was transferred.

You cannot know the sense of accomplishment I had! That little boy faced his transfer with the right amount of humanity mandated by the High Command.

As I've said, we are neither cruel nor uncivilized.

 

© 2006 by Justice Putnam
and Mechanisches-Strophe Verlagswesen


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

soft interrogation

Your method is so effective, Justice! Good thing you are on our side!

user-pic

I cannit allow us, as a nation, to fall into the abyss of evil without speaking up.

user-pic

We're in the same boat! I completely agree.

user-pic

Whooooo are Yoooooooo
woo woo woowoooooooo
I really wanna know

I was a teen when Hogan's Heroes was on. It was meant I think as a 'satire' on Stalag 17. I did not watch much tv in those days. I worked 30 hours/week and went to school. I remember thinking that this was a stupid show. Of course it was about POWs and not death camps.

We are having a discussion about consciousness on my blog that veered to a discussion on psychopathology. Is it about neurons or relativity?

One of the reasons Nuremberg worked was that the Germans kept such fine records. China cannot 'prove' how many died at the hands of the Japanese. There are debates over how many people including Jews, or Poles or others that died at the hands of Stalin's crew as opposed to Hitler's crew that make my gut wrench. No good records.

What about the men who put numbers on paper, doing the work they were born and bred for, documenting the deaths of so many men, women and children?

The USA never did anything this heinous in terms of numbers. But there are interesting patterns.

The people who worked 'within the system' cry out as 'whistleblowers' and they lose their jobs. I am the lowliest of the low. What do I know about POW camps or what is necessary to keep people who would blow themselves up in order to kill men, women and children to make a point?

What would I do, how would I perform as a sergeant filling out forms and recording water boarding or the piling of naked bodies on a prison floor?

I mean, I am an E-3 hoping to make E-4 so I can get a new car next year.

Have my colonel telling me what a good job I am doing. Finish up on xmas eve so I can make the party?

Your post makes one think. Thinking hurts sometimes.

user-pic

What bugged me about the "banality of evil" of nazi germany is the belief that since they wrote laws to legalize their behavior, that they were "civilized."

BushCo wrote laws and then maintained they were not criminals.

A crime is a crime is a crime, Gertrude Stein might have said.

user-pic

Laws, written and/or followed, have nothing to do with being civilized. They certainly don't exempt one from cruelty or immorality. Sometimes, words on paper are only useful as a way to deflect attention from the reality of right and wrong.

Yet, Justice, every now and then the written word is quite powerful - your post is a perfect example.

user-pic

thanks...

user-pic

I include your most chilling segment:
"Simply being there and feeding him, so to speak, with a firm but learned affection did indeed, yes indeed, calm him."

This is the mindset in most insane hierarchical circumstances. "Power over" in the service of order. It is utterly self-deluded.

Great piece, Justice.

user-pic

It never ceases to amaze me the capacity of harm we humans can inflict on each other.

Leave a comment

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address