Most of you have already read about
the big Digg manipulation scandal, whereby a relatively small but determined group of about 100 conservative operatives have worked in concert to game the open system of Digg's approval function, to generate both positive results for the far right and negative results for the middle and the left.
After watching and STUDYING a similar manipulation conspiracy take down any usefulness of the Democratic Party Builder site back in 2008, I posted here and at KOS and elsewhere my concerns that the open source nature of these blogs IS being gamed with very little effort by determined deceivers who take advantage of the freedoms that are extended by the blogs.
If you haven't read much about it yet, here's the original Alternet blog that opened up this bloggers Pandora's Box of Worms.What I would like everyone here to note is the particular paragraph that mentions the fact that, along with the actual conspirators who have promulgated this offensive tactic, many of the regular, non-conspirators who contribute to these blogs have enabled those cheaters in the name of fair play, by refusing to acknowledge or even recognize the patterns of abuse that are so evident.
Here's that excerpt:
"Although this is a fringe group of Teabagging wingnuts, many well established figures in the Digg community are also present, such as BalancingAct, EMFK, Janinco, mikeinto, and spindig. 10 members have been part of Digg since 2005-2006, with 43 having their current account there for over 2 years."People with moderating authority need to watch this very carefully, on any progressive site, because the blogs themselves may the only source to "police" these miscreants. This includes moderators and blog hosts who consistently allow posers and sockpuppets to proliferate despite rules to the contrary.
I have seen it here at TPM, on a much more intimate scale, especially on the far left where some constant complainers whose motives I have always suspected re consistently rec'd by others who just don't realize they are being gamed, and always in the name of "fair play", even as they are decieved so unfairly.
My point is, this Digg fiasco is pretty good proof that there's a fairly sophisticated right wing conspiracy to dis-empower the best progressive blogs and the rating systems they have contrived, And these conspirators treat the blogs with the same contempt they hold for democracy itself. And as long as the far-left is willing to include these cheaters in their delusion of "equal time" and "fair play", we can hardly trust them any more with the keys to the car, they are enabling their own adversaries to make tools of them.
As for the most-guilty parties, you know who you are, and if this blog offends you, then you are probably either one of the fakes or one of the enablers unwilling to admit your "inclusive nature" is nothing more than naive submission to your own adversaries' deceptions.
I've seen it so often, the smooth-talkers come into a conversation praising the poster and kissing personal ass, then they twist the conversation immediately to a trashfest of Obama or the Left or anything to the right of Newt. And unfortunately, the naive among us fall for the personal part, to the point they seem almost to defend the cheaters' very premise, because they were "so polite" and know just who to kiss up to, to gain access to this naive consensus.
I'm just sayin'... don't be naive, there is a very pernicious effort on the part of the right to deny the reality-based blogs their rightful place in the political debate, and they are no more reticent about gaming the blog society than they are about gaming society as a whole. They are so determined to win, they will trash the very concept of free speech even if it destroys the very society they deign to manage. Expecting them to play by any set of rules ignores the fact that they break their own rules with sheer, unmitigated hypocrisy whenever it serves their immediate needs.
They have proven conclusively, especially under the Bush legacy (BOTH Bushes) they aren't even capable of managing their own corporations safely, let alone the politics of our country.
Stop enabling them. Open your eyes, people and recognize that you are being fooled, and that every time you gleefully jump on one of their dogpiles you are giving them the power to deceive others, and credibility they have never earned.
Like I said, you know who you are.
One last note of reference, I've had some people here passively accuse me of being obsessive when I look back at the archives to see what some of our questinable members have posted in the past, to get an idea of how their participation has evolved.
II you take the time to read that Alternet article, you will see, it took some very determined research to ferret out the very obvious proof that there was a virtual conspiracy underway, and now that it is :out there" there is no way they can continue to deny it, or continue to get their naive enablers to back them up.
That sort of diligent research and investigation into the archives of any blog should not be discouraged or seen as extreme, it is the essence of gaining a whole understanding about this veritable babe of a media, and unless we are vigilant and observant, they will continue to take advantage of the freedoms we all enjoy, to diminish those very freedoms.
I don't have the time or the expertise to sift through the TPM archives with the exhaustive energy the Alternet investigators did with Digg, but I am quite certain, anyone with a healthy skeptical eye, armed with the proven certainty that this manipulation is real, can perceive the truth of what I say.
It is all there in black and white, and unless "they" can get in and destroy those archives, those records will always be available to any determined investigator willing to do the work it takes to make that discovery.