« What's with the "Live" color change for Keith's show on MSNBC? | jdkrheum's Blog

9/11Truthers Are Not Liberals


Over the hot August recess, while organizations, corporations, and partisans on the Right unleashed their fact-challenged rage at Democratic town hall meetings, the conventional wisdom coalesced: The Left can be as extreme as the Right. The evidence? The existence of the 9/11 Truth movement, falsely fused with general progressive suspicion of the George W. Bush Administration.

For instance, on July 31, MSNBC

aired a segment
exploring the "birther" phenomenon, moderated by anchors Tamaron Hall and Donny Deutsch. David Freddoso
, formerly of the National Review Online, and now at The Washington Examiner, quickly made the comparison between a recent poll showing a shocking percentage of Republicans believing the birther conspiracy, and a 2007 poll showing that a majority of Democrats believed that George W. Bush had "advance warning" of 9/11.

As Media Matters

reported, Chris Matthews followed up the hype, by characterizing the polling question as accusing Bush of having "deliberately sat back" and allowing 9/11 to happen. Only the poll didn't ask what Matthews claimed it asked. As Media Matters pointed out, the Democratic respondents were likely thinking of the August 6, 2001 Presidential Daily Briefing, which did warn that bin Laden was determined to strike within the U.S.

Even before the volatile town hall meetings, conservatives seized on the Holocaust Museum shooter as an example of left-wing extremism, due to his criticism of "neo-cons" and belief in 9/11 truth conspiracy theories. This claim was thoroughly and effectively

debunked by Keith Olbermann, along with his guests Mark Potok and Eugene Robinson, on June 11.

But the misreading of poll questions aside, the equating of right wing conspiracy theories with 9/11 truthers, clearly has an agenda: to suggest that the left of center is as extreme as the right of center. This rests on the assumption that - since they were critical of the Bush Administration - the 9/11 Truth movement is left of center. However, that assumption misses the fact that the movement has more in common with right wing anti-government militia movements that took aim at the Clinton Administration, than with liberals or leftists.

Any perusal of the movement's beliefs - which tend to veer far from the topic of 9/11 - will reveal a familiar list of right wing anti-government positions. A prime example of this comes from the guru of many 9/11 Truthers, radio talk show host Alex Jones. In addition to pushing the idea that 911 was a Bush Administration conspiracy, Jones' websites and radio show tout an amalgam of anti-government positions, from gun rights advocacy to fear of mandatory vaccinations. In fact, his infowars.com website features an article that repeats the very accusation that birthers, deathers, and tea-partiers are so fond of:

that the Obama health care plan is a eugenics program. Media Matters for America has chronicled Jones' recent history, including touting himself as a founding father of the 911 Truth movement. They also document his promulgation of the Obama-as-secret-Muslim lie, saying on the air that Obama should not be allowed to be President, as that would lead to "infiltration."

I became aware of the conservative nature of so many of the beliefs of 9/11 Truthers, when a relative of mine became an ardent 9/11 Truther and Alex Jones follower. I've been watching a life-long liberal slowly turn into a right-winger, ever since. Suddenly, being a conspiracy theorist was less and less about 9/11, and more about age-old conservative canards. The real turning point was when my relative explained to me that "man-made" global warming didn't exist, and was merely a ruse by the federal government to bring about a carbon tax. My relative hardly makes enough money to worry about taxes. Alex Jones'

website similarly claims that global warming is an excuse to raise taxes and bring about "one world government."

When conservatives try to use these conspiracy communities to excuse the extremists in their midst, it's dishonest. When liberals, such as my relative, are manipulated into metamorphosing into right-wingers, it's sad.

 


4 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

But once again, questioning the official story of 9/11 is being bundled in with everything from Illuminati theorists to Hollow-Earthers... which makes the simple act of doubting the status quo tantamount to insanity.

So yes, the Alex Jones-Zeitgeist-Loose Change wing of the truth movement is reactionary. But lefties like me? Normal.

user-pic

Not only climate change does not exist, even Australia doesn't exist.

Yes. That is the horrible truth. Australia doesn't really exist. I know you are skeptical. I was also skeptical at first. But just ask yourself. How do you know Australia exist? Have you been there? OK so you met people claiming to be from Australia. Fine! How do you know they really ARE from Australia? Did you see their birth certificate? And if you did, are you sure they were not fake? Do you know how easy it is to fake a birth certificate?

Here's the SHOCKING TRUTH. Australia is a decoy, a false flag operation, artificially created by a vast conspiracy headed by none other than the government of Australia itself for their pitiful self-serving reasons, reasons like falsely gaining a seat at the United Nations, or encouraging tourism to Australia, or enriching themselves by printing fake Australian dollars.

Australia is nothing but a racket!

user-pic

I agree with your title that 9/11 Truthers are not liberals. I also don't think that crazy people like Timothy McVeigh is a "right-winger". Nor do I think Bill Ayers is a left-winger.

If I could generalize, I think that most of these people are just nutty loons that hate government and unfortunately take pleasure in hurting innocent people. They don't really care who's in office or what color the President's skin is.

user-pic

Left. Left. Left.
On and on it goes.
There is no 'Left.'
How many Anarchist candidates run ? Communists ? Socialists ? Marxists ?
It's all 'Branding' under its various names and guises.
Autocracy vs. Anarchy.
Freedom for People vs. Freedom for Governments/Corporations/(name your poison)
The 'confusion' is systemic and relentless. It cannot be ignored nor defused.
It is still bafflegab and bullshit : propaganda.
http://opitslinkfest.blogspot.com/2009/07/perception-alteration.html
Articles on 'Moving the Goalposts.'

Leave a comment

jdkrheum

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 2

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address