Why 'grandma' doesn't die...
There are many ways to talk about the "unnecessary death rate" of a developed country. I linked to one article defining it in my previous blog post. One of the simplest ways to define it is to say it is the number of deaths that occurs due to lack of access to proper medical care.
For the first time in the US, it is not simply the unemployed or financially precarious who lack access to medical care: it also depends upon the fine print in your insurance policy. I believe this is why there are an alarming number of older people holding these pathetic signs about "grandma" dying because Obama's lying and the like. They utterly fail to see what is happening to younger generations in the US. Their plans were put into place in a period of relative prosperity when health insurance companies actually paid for healthcare with no lifetime limits and no strings attached.
This article, about a courageous doctor who has set up a chemotherapy unit in an abandoned warehouse facility in Nevada (for patients whose insurance fails to cover these costs) is a dramatic illustration of the phenomenon.
I know we are sick of hearing about death panels, but perhaps we should simply consider this term with a new target group in mind. It is not end of life decisions that are the crucial issue. People over sixty generally (though not all) have excellent healthcare plans. It is young to middle aged working adults who are now dying because they cannot get the medical care they need.
For the first time in the US, it is not simply the unemployed or financially precarious who lack access to medical care: it also depends upon the fine print in your insurance policy. I believe this is why there are an alarming number of older people holding these pathetic signs about "grandma" dying because Obama's lying and the like. They utterly fail to see what is happening to younger generations in the US. Their plans were put into place in a period of relative prosperity when health insurance companies actually paid for healthcare with no lifetime limits and no strings attached.
This article, about a courageous doctor who has set up a chemotherapy unit in an abandoned warehouse facility in Nevada (for patients whose insurance fails to cover these costs) is a dramatic illustration of the phenomenon.
I know we are sick of hearing about death panels, but perhaps we should simply consider this term with a new target group in mind. It is not end of life decisions that are the crucial issue. People over sixty generally (though not all) have excellent healthcare plans. It is young to middle aged working adults who are now dying because they cannot get the medical care they need.
Advertisement
















"People over sixty generally (though not all) have excellent healthcare plans. It is young to middle aged working adults who are now dying because they cannot get the medical care they need."
Well said Jane B.
This is why single-payer (Medicare for All) would have been the best approach to take in health care reform. And then the Dems take it off the table from the start. So then we go to the next best thing, the public option, and Obama calls that a "sliver". Go figure.
August 22, 2009 8:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
I agree. Don't pit us against grandma. I spend a lot of time with my 88 year old mother and her friends and they have plenty to teach, that's for sure.
Let us be a country that takes care of ALL of its people.
But to show you how rotten to the core the current situation is, I heard Willie Brown on Hardball seriously suggesting that the answer to the Democrats' problem is to simply cut loose the 50 million uninsured and just tweak preexisting conditions a wee bit.
Don't blame grandma at the rally. Blame the establishment in power. They are both using grandma and selling us out.
August 22, 2009 10:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
You are absolutely right Tiess2: the Democrats' and Obama's approach seems to be an odd way of going about health reform since the root of the problem in the US is the 29-56 age range whether they be blue or white collar workers.
We all want retirees cared for but any nation that ignores the wage earners themselves will pay dearly.
August 22, 2009 12:05 PM | Reply | Permalink
Tell me about it, Jane. (Wracking, painful, cough)
I finally bit the bullet and went on my companies insurance. (Doesn't help me now, but...) I remember fondly the days when healthcare wasn't even an issue, or expense. You got sick, you went to the doctor, and that was it. It wasn't all that long ago, either, maybe 15 years ago? I remember calling Kaiser when I was 29 and pregnant and asked them if pregnancy was a pre-existing condition", and they laughed as if the idea was absurd. Now pregnancy is excluded from most private plans unless you have $$$$. It went south, so quickly.
The stress of this is going to kill a lot of us 40-somethings. I think, it's killing me.
August 22, 2009 12:38 PM | Reply | Permalink
Its times like this that I am sure there is no god.
Lies just keep being perpetrated, and there is no lightning
August 22, 2009 3:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
I can not agree more. My parents are retired and unfortunately drink the kool aid in BIG glasses. They have always had health insurance for their family and can't imagine what it is like to be concerned about coverage.
August 24, 2009 4:37 PM | Reply | Permalink