jah627's Blog

The Real Healthcare in America


I am sitting outside the Emergency Room at a major hospital in the Bronx, smoking a cigarette, taking a breather. Yes, that's right, taking a breather. Inside is a scene that would make a sadist proud. The lights are harsh and bright. The thin curtains that give the illusion of "rooms" are spaced three and a half feet apart, barely wide enough to fit a thin hospital bed. Most are stuffed with two.  To get to them, you need to wade through floating pallets of other beds, stacked three deep in front of the "rooms" and filled with mostly silent, mostly elderly patients.  
When I first walked in, I strolled right past the reception area. There is a large sign, but with the beds stacked everywhere, milling doctors; nurses; and family members, and monitors beeping like an old-style department store on steroids, I missed it and walked right past the desk while looking intently for it.  
A small family is clustered around an elderly man a few beds away. The man is bleeding profusely, and his wife and daughters are clearly worried. They try to find a nurse, a doctor: anyone really, but there is no one available or approachable. Finally a nurse comes over.  She notes that the man is scheduled for an MRI., assures his wife and daughters that everything is fine, and convinces the daughters that they can go home. Their mother refuses to leave her husband's side.  
Fifteen minutes later, on the way to be tested, the man is dead and his wife's screams of misery cut through the beeping drone. 
Health Care for the poor: It is one thirty in the morning, and right now I'm finding it hard to be proud to be an American. This is not compassionite conservatism, this is a tragedy, and a travesty. 
There are thousands of Emergency Rooms in America, and they are assuredly not all like this one. I remember, years ago, showing up at an Emergency Room in wealthy Westchester County, in the middle of the night. There was a small sign on an otherwise empty reception desk. It said, "Ring Bell for Service". 
But for the poor, and especially the elderly poor, this hospital scene in the Bronx is more the rule than the exception. The rest of the hospital is state-of-the-art, fueled by insurance dollars and grant money, but the Emergency Room is a packed, nightmarish place. Triage rooms and cots give the impression of battlefield medicine, but there are no war heroes here, not of this war anyway: only the unglamerous urban poor.

7 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Rec'd. A powerful first-hand account of how our system is failing us. I am addened by your experience and that of the poor woman whose husband died in a hospital waiting for medical attention. Well written and deeply affecting.

user-pic

*saddened* not addended

user-pic

If it's all that saddening to you, why don't you put that cigarette down? Perhaps, just perhaps it will save our failing medical system from having to spend its precious, limited recourses on a stupid, young lung-cancer patient who refused to stop smoking, and "reallocate" those resources to the geriatric ward.

ex animo
davidfarrar

user-pic

Actually, smoking dramatically reduces the cost of healthcare, because smokers die before they acquire the expensive chronic illnesses of old age. If everyone smoked, we could forget the healthcare debate, and everyone could go home.

user-pic

This standout post deserves more recs than it can possibly get at this site. It's the best post about "health care" I've read: It's not academic, it's not Washington- or TV-focused, it's not contrived, it's not all about you. Thanks for the effort, even if the attention at TPM stands at an unbelievably stingy 5 comments and 8 recommends.

user-pic

Thanks -- and BTW, its all true. Sorry 'bout the unPC cigarette. I guess everyone reacts differently. For me, I needed a smoke.

user-pic

The opposite is also true. When I went in for an emergency appendectomy, the hospital I was referred to is in a fairly up scale area. Even though it is where the EMT's take you if you are east of the area, it was fairly quiet. I processed in almost immediately. There were only about a dozen people waiting and the ER itself had only two other people in it besides me.

The only reason I had to wait to get into the OR was because they wanted 8 hours since I last ate before the would operate.

I was the only one in the short term OR and after the surgery was over, I was sent to a room for over night recovery. I had the room (meant for two people) to myself.

Most of the rooms there had only one patient. Most of the other patients were elderly.

The whole hospital itself was very quite with few people.

A large par of the problem is the availability of medical services are totally out of whack.

This hospital is one of 8 in this immediate area (Central Florida). More than Cleveland Ohio. As many as Phillie.

We have more specialists here than you can shake a stick at. And yet the cost is out of this world.

Now tell me how the "free market" and "competition" is helping ?

C

Leave a comment

jah627

user-pic

Following: 0
Followers: 0

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address