« Dept. of Enthusiasm Gaps: New Mexico Edition | Jade7243's Blog | McCain Still Not Tested During Cuban Missile Crisis »

Testing.... Testing... Testing John McCain


In his recent stump speeches, McCain makes a big deal about being "tested." In fact, McCain and company jumped all over what they (and the media lemmings) claimed was a gaffe by Joe Biden -- (paraphrasing) that early in his presidency Obama would be tested  by some agent and would be able to demonstrate his "spine of steel."

McCain played all three roles in the political version of the Nairobi Trio* -- Hear No Truth, See No Truth, Speak No Truth -- refusing to acknowledge that every president is tested by something unexpected in one way or another. (Kennedy, Cuban missile crisis; Johnson, assassination of Kennedy; Nixon, Vietnam and Soviet agression; Ford, an unexpected ascendancy to the Presidency and Watergate's aftermath; Carter, the economy; Reagan, Iranian hostage crisis; Bush I, economy; Clinton, WTC bombing, Somalia, Branch Davidians; Bush II, September 11). A President Obama will face a crumbling economy, two wars, skyrocketing debt and deficits, and a nation almost as divided as the years preceding the civil war -- thanks in part to the divisive politicking of McCain and his "Gal Friday," Sarah Palin.

But McCain sticks to his claim of having "been tested, my friends." Ri-i-i-i-i-i-i-ght. Exactly when was that, Senator?

McCain, thinking he's ready for that question offers up his version of the Cuban missile crisis: "I was in my plane on the deck of the aircraft carrier Enterprise." Okay.... but Senator, pardon us for noticing you were merely one of hundreds of thousands of men and women in uniform on full alert during that time -- like my dad. And Senator, you were not called upon for your advice or consent to do anything with regard to the Russians and missiles and Cubans and the President, were you? No. You were standing by, waiting for orders from your Commander-in-Chief, John F. Kennedy.  Sorry, but you weren't tested then.

McCain, goes on to suggest that he was "tested" by his time in a North Vietnamese prison camp. With all due respect, you were tortured, but not tested as a Commander-in-Chief. You were not the Secretary of Defense, nor the President. That was Robert McNamara and Lyndon Baines Johnson. It was the President who ordered you and hundreds of other military pilots to "bomb North Vietnam back to the stone age," as Gen. Curtis LeMay said (and years later Dick Cheney parroted with regard to Iran and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.) You again, sir -- with all due respect -- followed orders to bomb Hanoi. That was not a "test."

When you returned from Vietnam, and entered Congress and later the Senate, you were a member of a Senate committee charged with answering questions, releasing information and providing an account of the whereabout of what many believe -- with good reason -- were the hundreds of US soldiers and civilians left behind in Vietnam. Senator John Kerry, a fellow Vietnam vet, was the chairman of this committee. Once again, you failed to lead.

Respected journalist and author Sidney Schanberg ("The Killing Fields") has a blistering report in a heavily researched article at the Nation Institute about your time as a POW, your involvement in the "The McCain Bill," (a piece of legislation designed to keep classified any and all information about prisoners held in Vietnam and Laos.) It is worth the read (and Kerry gets scuffed up a little, too.)

The synopsis of the article is that the US estimates of prisoners in Vietnam and Laos were at least 1200 in Vietnam and 300 in Laos. The North Vietnamese made no real secret of their intent to withhold some of the prisoners to be used as bargaining chips for war reparations at the end of the fighting. When the prisoners were released, 591 came home from Vietnam and 10 -- yes, ten (nine military and one civilian) -- from Laos.

What  happened to the rest? Modern folklore leads you to believe "Rambo" or Chuck Norris "Left Behind" scenarios. Families of the missing and unaccounted for have reports of locator codes being used to attempt to notify the various intelligence agencies of service members needing to make their escape. Schanberg's article is detailed and worth the read for that part alone.

But it is McCain's role in shutting down all information about the missing men and any attempts to find them that is chilling. Why would a man who purports to "support the troops" and "put country first" not want to do anything to determine the whereabouts, dead or alive, of any of his fellow service members who were last seen behind enemy lines? The recent story that made a small wave on the internet about McCain shoving a woman in a wheelchair concerns these hearings.

McCain -- to the best of our knowledge -- has never been called to the Situation Room at the White House to help make any decisions with regard to any of the crises this country has faced during his time in Congress or the Senate. McCain has not served as a cabinet officer to any President since he been in Washington, D.C. 

So the only place McCain has been tested is in his personal and very solitary dreams of glory. Like the wannabe singer who "performs" each night in front of the bathroom mirror, hairbrush microphone in hand, to throngs of adoring, albeit invisible fans, McCain's claims of "tested leadership" are simply the stuff of make believe.

This year, we simply refuse to play along.

*Those of you of a certain age, or with a penchant for classic, early television will recall the brilliant Ernie Kovacs and his zany cast of characters, including a trio of "monkey" musicians whose antics are simply priceless. Watch them here. 


12 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

So highly rec'd, it ain't funny.

I love you, Jade.

user-pic

As some Muslim commie "spread the wealth" socialist whose middle name is "Hussein" says... "I love you back!"

user-pic

I disagree! Both McCain and Obama were tested with the recent economic crisis. Obama was presidential and McCain was found wanting....

user-pic

McCain claims vast experience and having been "tested and hav(ing) the scars" (plural)...

Although the current economic crisis is a part of the all-important "steward of the economy" test, McCain and company having been jumping the shark on the foreign policy, commander-in-chief, leader of the free world" test.

He implies (infers?) that having been a POW is test enough to make him ready to be C-I-C. Except he was busy taking orders, not giving them.

user-pic

He implies it - you infer it from what he says.

Excellent run-down. A Boy Scout/Girl Scout analogy: he was always a member of the patrol, but never the patrol leader.

user-pic

I guess he's been a member of the patrol for a longer period of time than Obama has, which is apparently the only qualification for promotion in McCain's mind.

I guess he hasn't figured out that the "experience" argument isn't working. Or the "he puts his country first argument". Or the "Obama is a socialist" argument. Or the "drill baby drill" argument. Or the...oh wait, he has nothing left to run on, so he's using the same arguments over and over.

user-pic

Jade, you are a tpm treasure for sure! Great blog!!!

mcShame is all about "ME, ME, ME." That's not a leader. That's a cheerleader! When he gives speeches, it's like he's leading cheers for himself: I know this. And I know that. And on and on.

Your post is spot on!!!

user-pic

Thank you for this post! You have nailed the McCain hyperbole to the tire swing tree.

user-pic

John McCain is fond of saying he’s been tested and has the scars to prove it. All of that is true, in a sense. But, how did he do in the test is the relevant point. If I remember correctly, McCain was tested and ended up making anti-American movies for the Viet Cong. Granted we all may have done the very same thing if tortured. But, one could hardly say the fact that you did whatever was necessary to survive, is something special. Who wouldn’t?

user-pic

Some of those scars came from surgery for his melanoma. And some, it is true, from his torture. But as Schanberg points out in his piece -- let me quote him (emphasis mine):

It's not clear whether the taped confession McCain gave to his captors to avoid further torture has played a role in his post-war behavior in the Senate. That confession was played endlessly over the prison loudspeaker system at Hoa Lo —- to try to break down other prisoners -— and was broadcast over Hanoi's state radio. Reportedly, he confessed to being a war criminal who had bombed civilian targets. The Pentagon has a copy of the confession but will not release it. Also, no outsider I know of has ever seen a non-redacted copy of the debriefing of McCain when he returned from captivity, which is classified but could be made public by McCain.

All humans have breaking points. Many men undergoing torture give confessions, often telling huge lies so their fakery will be understood by their comrades and their country. Few will fault them. But it was McCain who apparently felt he had disgraced himself and his military family. His father, John S. McCain II, was a highly regarded rear admiral then serving as commander of all US forces in the Pacific. His grandfather was also a rear admiral.

In his bestselling 1999 autobiography, Faith of My Fathers, McCain says he felt bad throughout his captivity because he knew he was being treated more leniently than his fellow POWs, owing to his high-ranking father and thus his propaganda value. Other prisoners at Hoa Lo say his captors considered him a prize catch and called him the "Crown Prince," something McCain acknowledges in the book.

Also in this memoir, McCain expresses guilt at having broken under torture and given the confession. "I felt faithless and couldn't control my despair," he writes, revealing that he made two "feeble" attempts at suicide. (In later years, he said he tried to hang himself with his shirt and guards intervened.) Tellingly, he says he lived in "dread" that his father would find out about the confession. "I still wince," he writes, "when I recall wondering if my father had heard of my disgrace."

He says that when he returned home, he told his father about the confession, but "never discussed it at length"—and the Admiral, who died in 1981, didn't indicate he had heard anything about it before. But he had. In the 1999 memoir, the senator writes: "I only recently learned that the tape...had been broadcast outside the prison and had come to the attention of my father."

But my point is with regard to being "tested" as POW (and that that makes him automatically C-I-C ready), is that McCain had an opportunity to redeem himself and rid himself of whatever demons haunted him from Vietnam if he had helped the families of other POW-MIAs determine what happened to their loved ones.

Apparently, he has decided that it is more important to preserve his own "legend" rather than seek the truth.

user-pic

John McCain has been tested on the campaign trail and what have we seen? The erratic pick of Palin, and his even more erratic behavior around the financial crisis. Contrast that with Obama in a crisis. Cool hand Luke, calm and reassuring, very Presidential. We have already seen 8 years of a President that goes by his gut, and what has the result been? John McCain can't wait to have his war, and what will happen to the economy when he goes to war on Iraq? How many will die, what about the cost to the nation, The choice is clear, more Bush style shoot from the hip irrational leadership, or rational, thoughtful leaderhip.

The choice is President who will staff his administration with lobbyists and more of Bush's Forign Poiicy team. It's time for a real change!

user-pic

George W. Bush has more executive experience than McCain and Palin combined. He's been tested, too. And his middle name isn't arabic. Anybody for four more years?
Based on these types of qualifications, Georgie should have put his dad in charge of the DEA. His CIA has sold more cocaine in this country than anybody else, so who better?
It is so refreshing to see the crap these idiots have thrown around for so many years blowing back in their faces. I was a Young Republican, Reagan sold me out (remember Iran/contra, Freeway Ricky Ross anyone?) So I went with Clinton, another sell out (more people imprisoned for "inhaling" than all other presidents in the history of the country combined). The Bush family used their control of the world this time to start opium production in Afghanistan again (remember the Taliban had wiped out the herion trade there), and Al Queda gave them the gift of an attack, so they have another excuse to strip people of their rights (not only drugs now, terrorism, too!). Will Obama be man enough to tell the American people the truth about what the US does around the world? You use your drug laws to enrich criminal enterprises, and third world countries are overwhelmed by the financial resources that these US sanctioned criminal enterprises bring to bear. As a resident of a nation severely effected by your "War on Drugs", I wonder if US citizens are aware of what people around the world think of how you operate in this field? Will Obama be more of the same, or is he in fact intelligent enough to explain to your people that Al Capone type violence ended with the end of alcohol prohibition, and the same must be done with other "drugs"? Look at the violence your are seeing on your Mexican border. The police are bought (not only the mexicans, either). That much money will buy anyone. And now smuggling routes can be exploited by terrorists to smuggle dirty bombs. Why don't you end prohibition, use the police resources that are freed up to really protect your country, and use the resulting billions in savings (not to mention potential tax revenue) to decrease your deficit thus strengthening the dollar?
Just the viewpoint of an expatriate business owner. When you need the police in the US, then you find out what they are all about. If you don't have drugs on you so that they can't seize any property, they won't help you as a victim of a crime (try to get them to show for a burglary some time). Tell them your neighbor grows pot for his own use, and you'll see a 14 man SWAT unit dispatched immediately, and a two year trial at a cost of millions, so the police can seize the house it was grown in. Your country is sick. I hope Obama is the medicine. For all our sakes. I'd like to move back to the US someday, should it ever exist again. Until then, keep up the torture, the unwarranted wire taps, suspension of habeus corpus, illegal arm sales, importation of banned substances to finance black ops., etc., and the world watches. Sadly disgusted. Best of luck to Obama. Don't let him sell you out, too.

Leave a comment

Jade7243

user-pic

Following: 0
Followers: 11

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location New Mexico.... If I squint real hard on a clear day I can see Old Mexico before my eyes tear up.
  • Party Democratic -- or "Ye Olde Par-tay Har-day" Par-tay
  • Politics Far Left of Center

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs I especially love the ones you get at Christmastime from that sausage place in the mall. I like nut logs, too.
  • Favorite Books "All of 'em. I read all of the ones that are placed in front of me. I read Starbucks cups, Dunkin' Donuts cups."
  • Favorite Quotes Man's reach should always exceed his grasp. Vote, dammit!

Bio

Take two... they're small. Mange!

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address