Being Gay is a Gift: change is in the air
One of the biggest challenges to GLBT rights is organized religion. Prop8 in California, denying marriage rights to a minority, was passed in large part by the unholy alliance of conservative Catholics and Mormons (especially Mormon money). Many gay people see their lives in opposition to religion, thanks to the ascendance of fundigelical Christianism under successive Republican administrations. There has been a defacto establishment of conservative evangelicalism as a state religion. And yet, along with other changes, perhaps that is changing too.
Progressive Christians are finding their voice on a national stage and offering a radical welcome to all. Will their voices finally be heard in Washington and in the wider culture?
Item 1 :Just this week, Rev. Ed Bacon, rector of All Saints' Episcopal Church in Pasadena, CA, went on Oprah Winfrey's show and announced "being gay is a gift from God".
As documented by his colleague Rev Susan Russell, Rev Bacon then on successive occasions defended and extended his comment, explaining that "I meant exactly what I said". He went on to say that his mail was running 30:1 in favor of his inclusiveness and affirmation. "Ironically," he lamented, "some of the most meanspirited email I received was from Christians".
Item 2: Apparently in response to the outrage over Rick Warren giving the invocation at the Inauguration, the Obama transition team invited Episcopal Bishop Gene Robinson of New Hampshire to give an invocation for another inaugural event. Robinson is an out gay man who recently celebrated a civil union with his partner. On an interview on Rachel Maddow's show , Bishop Robinson reminded the audience that "Jesus had the biggest tent of all," scolding those who choose to exclude.
Item 3: In a series of screenings around the country, the award-winning film For the Bible Tells me so challenges the Christian Right's attack on homosexuality by showing the lives of faithful GLBT people and their families.
Item 4: The California Council of Churches filed an amicus curiae brief against Prop 8. This group represents over 4000 congregations of different mainstream traditions as well as ecumenical allies from other faiths.
Item 5: Finally, today, the estimable Mary Frances Berry of the Commission on Civil Rights takes on the subject:
To help resolve the issue of gay rights, President-elect Obama should abolish the now moribund Commission on Civil Rights and replace it with a new commission that would address the rights of many groups, including gays.....
There is no need to analogize the battle for the rights of gay and lesbian people to the struggle of African Americans to overcome slavery, Jim Crow and continued discrimination. But as Coretta Scott King said to me as she tried to imagine what position the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. would take on "don't ask, don't tell": "What's the yardstick by which we should decide that gay rights are less important than other human rights we care about?"
We know that the anti-gay rights people are on the losing side of demographics. They are fighting savagely as a result. But perhaps with other changes, they are losing the battle to define Christianity by their exclusionary rules. And perhaps with the progressive Christians increasingly and vocally on our side, we can win this battle and offer the positive side of change, with peace.
Obligatory disclaimer: I am an atheist lesbian, married (at least for now) in California. But I live my life among people of faith, people whom I respect, and I am intrigued with how progressive straight Christians are now picking up the rainbow flag to march with us.
Cross posted at StreetProphets. DailyKos and Friends of Jake





I march with you, IT. It is possible to be a believer, but to follow a God who, yes, has blessed you in who you are. Just a few days ago, I read something by an old friend, a devout Jewish philosopher/teacher of religion, describing how "God is with the suffering." Not that you should have to suffer for that to happen, but that in your suffering (and you have my great compassion) you are in the hands of Holy Mystery - though you may not even be aware of it. But your beloved BP is proof of that, I might add.
For anyone who might be interested, IT has a lovely description of how she and her wife were treated when they went to the Episcopal Cathedral's gathering for newcomers in San Diego. And the beautiful words of the Dean, welcoming them, whether for a time or for longer. Just follow her link to Friends of Jake. I promise you, it's a treat.
Good to see you here, IT.
January 16, 2009 6:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Peace be with you!
January 17, 2009 3:17 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks so much for your post, IT! As a long-term leader of the LGBT community, it is difficult for many to understand that the enemy is not governmental officials of an opposing party, but the religious institutions that foster the crutches on which the politicians the populace base their animosity.
To thrust out from under them that crutch would be a miracle of human advancement. To paraphrase what St. Anselm said himself, the God who made me, made me gay.
January 17, 2009 9:28 AM | Reply | Permalink
According to the Obama team, the other pastor was not invited to make up for Rick Warren. They say that he was invited long before. And anything Obama does for gay rights going forward will not be to make up for Rick Warren (I'm sure many people will think that). It will be because he believed it was the right thing to do.
January 17, 2009 10:35 AM | Reply | Permalink
Amen.
January 17, 2009 1:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
I attended Southern Baptist three times a week my entire upbringing. Thus, I have listened to thousands of hours of preaching, praying, and Sunday school teaching. I am yet to hear even the most oblique reference to gays, lesbians, or homosexuality in any way. The foe GBLT is facing is not protestantism, but nausea.
Heterosexuals, to a degree proportional to their heterosexuality, are simply hard wired to view the actual physical things homosexuals do with revulsion. It's not learned prejudice. It is innate in the same way homosexual urges are innate. In order to ever advance their causes, homosexuals will have to focus on this nausea.
January 17, 2009 2:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
Please don't reproduce.
Thank you.
January 17, 2009 3:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
homeaux
January 17, 2009 9:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ignore the troll, IT. Apparently "irritable bowel syndrom" has taken over - and nothing but waste matter spills out.
January 17, 2009 3:25 PM | Reply | Permalink
I see no call for you posting things trying to hurt my feelings.
January 18, 2009 3:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ah... but this was not addressed to you. This was addressed to IT in view of "her" feelings - due to your comments above. Apologize to IT before you seek to make yourself into a victim.
January 18, 2009 3:51 PM | Reply | Permalink