Important negotiating documents for the successor to the Kyoto
Protocol were released by the United Nations yesterday in advance of
negotiating sessions scheduled for early June in Bonn. The documents
are compilations of suggestions by various countries seeking to shape
the international treaty expected to emerge out of the major
negotiations in Copenhagen later this year.
It is interesting to see how these documents evolve during the
months leading up to Copenhagen as they give the first concrete sense
of many countries' negotiating positions.
Two documents were released yesterday. One focuses on national commitments [.pdf] to greenhouse gas emissions reductions beginning in 2013. The second proposes systematic ways of incorporating land use into the Kyoto successor.
I haven't had a chance to read through the land use document, but
the national commitment document is quite interesting. One of the
sticking points at Kyoto was coming to an agreement as to which
countries would have to reduce their emissions and by how much. With
the Kyoto commitment period ending in 2012, this document essentially
picks up where the discussions in Kyoto left off, with an eye for
developing second commitment period targets.
There are several options being floated, with only one offering
explicit country-by-country reduction numbers for the second commitment
period. Most of the proposals simply put forward a time line for the
next commitment period and an indication of which countries should be
covered. One of the main issues that recalcitrant nations like the US
had with Kyoto was the exclusion of developing countries, like China
and India, from having binding targets. Most of the proposals keep the
distinction between the "developed" (termed "Annex I" under the Kyoto
Protocol) and "less developed" countries.
Several, however, break down that distinction, suggesting that some
countries may push for commitments from all signatories. This does not
mean that all countries will have mandatory emissions reductions as
Kyoto, for instance, set a precedence whereby some Annex I countries
had obligations that exceeded their 1990 emissions.
The document also had some negotiating points on general, global
emissions reduction targets. These included proposals to requiring
Annex I parties to reduce emissions by 40% from 1990 levels by 2018 or
45% by 2020.
Finally, there was some mention of taking into account per-capita
emissions levels. It will be interesting to see where this goes, given
that the developing world (headed by China, Brazil, India, and others)
argue that they should not be required to have any binding emissions
reductions given the fact that per capita emissions are so small. It is
the developed world that has the large per capita carbon footprint and
should, hence, be most responsible for cutting emissions.
From the standpoint of the US, it is noteworthy that Obama's target
of reducing US emissions to 1990 levels by 2020 is much weaker than
most of the proposals contained in these negotiating texts.
Reuters reports
that the UN will be releasing another negotiating document in a number
of days that looks to set forth long term (i.e. 2050) reduction
commitments.