What a joke! The clique controls the blog here at TPM? Josh controls the blog, no one else. The clique censors those who disagree? Look if you posted the comment and your post is still standing, you've had your fifteen minutes. You're making as much sense as those astroturfers bringing their guns to the townhalls. How can you argue with a gun on your hip that people are taking away your guns? We see it right there on your hip! Is it raining or are you relieving yourself on my back?!? There's too much encouragement here? Not any more!!! I think the recent "rain" has pretty well balanced the love fest we were having.
The clique! Who is in and who is out, is what I want to know. I went thru the DanK post, only 86 recommends into it, and found a couple newbies and all the rest were familiar and I wondered, are they the clique? Or maybe some of them are in, and some of them are out. I just could not tell! Am I in?!?!
As I usually do, I will take the proposition, seemingly absurd, and accept it to see where it takes me. There is a clique at TPMCafe. Okay, let's remove the clique, because it is a poison. Who leaves? Would it be all the familiar faces that should go? Maybe just me, a clique of one? Would it be the huggers? Oh GAWD! These people are making contact with each other, someone pass me a barf bag!!! Quick!!! Don't touch me!!! On the face of that I have to get back to that raining thing. Referring anything here as a hug is ridiculous. I was hugged once, and it wasn't anything like this cyber-world in which we are all playing. It was AWESOME too!!!
Now let's take another tack. Let's accept it is a clique and that it dominates this site. Oh, and it's so wrong, too. Did I mention it was disagreeable? Well, I believe it is not so tight. It's no conspiracy. The clique just shares certain values and beliefs. Not to get too religious, but we, and I will assume I am part of the "clique" and can speak for its "members", have a penchant for progressive/liberal ideas and prefer common decency. Therefore, when something comes up less then liberal, we speak out against it, we defend our position, and if something is offensive and rude, we tend to answer back, and some of us, and I KNOW I am in this group, are willing to meet the poster/commenter in whatever gutter they choose to originate the post/comment. It's kind of antithetical to the preference of common decency, but it speaks loudly to the penchant for progressive/liberal ideals.
TPMCafe is the clique. We are unique and I find that the level of discourse, even in the gutter, is more creative and insightful then most other places. We have little tolerance for, or patience with, those who cannot support their arguments. We abhor dishonesty, such that anyone can perceive the truth, but that is also one of our strengths being from the Left. We are willing to question whether we have found a truth. But we have also gotten to a point where the Right has managed to dispense absolutely ridiculous ideas with success and that destruction of reality is a threat to the nation we love. So we get loud when it comes to this blog.
The bottomline is this. The clique rulez! It is the influence of the clique in their posts and comments that makes the Cafe what it is. If TPMCafe was a landing place for random posts with no continuity, people would not be returning to the site again and again. People come to read the clique. They also come to read the objections to the clique, but may the clique always be there, because, as was recently remarked in another post on this topic, other sites began with one perspective and devolved into a cacophony of emotionalism and unsubstantiated screeds that should be rejected out of hand for their lack of grounding in any reality.
The clique is what keeps things grounded, IMHO, and although some would object to this, I think people even appreciate those self-appointed defenders of the GOP or the Right, if for nothing less then the foils on which we display our positions. Although I find that they really are much more then that. I believe they are, in fact, part of the clique and accepted, even though they hold different views. Very few have asked them to leave, though when it does occur, I am sure those events strike deep, cyberically speaking. {Hey! I just made up a word! Kewl!} I believe we are aware that if we are not challenged, we just might lose our grounding in reality. We might become like those "other" sites. I am hoping we do not and that people take this picture of the clique with a grain of salt because this clique is eager to wlecome new members and has done so on many occassions, even very recently.
It does not seem "clique" is the best characterization of who we are, and what TPMCafe is, but I can see how some might come here and, when their beliefs and values are met with objections, color the TPMCafe in that way. Be civil, prove us wrong. Just be sure you can back it up because we do enjoy a challenge and don't think if you go into the gutter to throw stones at us, we will ignore you. We are eager to meet you too!