« Flash: Obamacare Passed in Secret Session - Death Panel Selects Glenn Beck to Go First | Gregory North's Blog
What we are up against: CBS edits out Obama supporters in NH
Yesterday the President held a a town hall in Portsmouth, NH in which 1,800 people respectfully listened to his remarks on the success of the Stimulus plan and the current debate underway on health care reform. They applauded when he called for a more civil debate of the issues. Outside the hall were many demonstrators - over 1,500. Some were there to protest against Obama, carrying signs like "Obamacare Makes Me Sick." Others were there to support the President, carrying signs reading "Reform Now - Insure People, Not Profits." I was not there but I did watch the raw footage of the demonstrators shot by CBS and posted on their website. And you can watch it too - here. But if you happened to tune in to the CBS Evening News with Katie Couric last night what you saw instead was this.
When I watched them back to back I was stunned. In the first Obama supporters offer sane comments about why they support health care reform now, balancing out the Anti-Obama demonstrators who seem cranky and crazy in comparison. In the second link - the one watched by many more Americans who tuned in to the Evening News mind you - you will find only Obama inside and anti-Obama protesters outside railing against his socialist policies. The pro-Obama forces present are nowhere to be seen - erased. Why? Because they don't fit the narrative the so-called liberal mainstream media is pushing - an embattled President struggling to get his message across - under fire from an angry mob. Putting their slant right up front, the CBS segment was entitled "Anger Management."
CBS missed a chance to inform the American people on a critical debate raging around a complex issue - letting the sounds and sights of the protest line in Portsmouth speak for themselves. On one side a woman interviewed spoke about why the Public Option makes sense to her as a way to keep the insurance companies in check. On the other a man relayed how he pays for his own insurance and he is not about to pay for someone who has none. On one side a drumming group sits in front of a sign reading Health Services for Women. On the other a cute little girl holds a sign reading "Obama lies, Grandma dies." Powerful stuff.
Remember wen the Evening News covered the Civil Rights struggles or the Vietnam protests? Imagine if the Portsmouth story was reported like that. Americans could have watched what happened in Portsmouth and drawn their own conclusions. But that was CBS then. This is CBS now.
The CBS News team's failure to report the facts of what happened in Portsmouth would be a journalistic disgrace if what they were practicing was truly journalism. But that word seems old, something best used in the context of Morrow and Cronkite - back when reporters fought to get the story right and called it like they saw it.
So what to do we need to do? Show up with 10 times as many protesters as the other side? 100 times? March on Washington? How can we hope to get our story across when CBS outdoes Fox in the real-time revision of history department. It is easy to fall into despair.
But hope trumps fear, remember? We learned that in the campaign. So let's hope the MSM can get the story straight if we begin holding them accountable for doing their job.
Let's start today by writing to CBS today demanding that they run a story on the Evening News on the rising chorus of voices in support of the President's Health Care Reform initiative.
Here is the email address for The CBS Evening News:
evening@cbsnews.com
And a sample comment you can send to the Editors there:
Last night you aired a segment called "Anger Management" which covered the President's town hall in Portsmouth, NH. Your images and narration highlighted those protesting the President's policies but, unlike the raw footage of the event posted on your website, completely eliminated any reference to the many supporters who were also present. Please correct this factual error in tonight's CBS Evening News in a story on the increasing numbers of people coming out in support of Health Care Reform along the lines Obama has recommended.
When I watched them back to back I was stunned. In the first Obama supporters offer sane comments about why they support health care reform now, balancing out the Anti-Obama demonstrators who seem cranky and crazy in comparison. In the second link - the one watched by many more Americans who tuned in to the Evening News mind you - you will find only Obama inside and anti-Obama protesters outside railing against his socialist policies. The pro-Obama forces present are nowhere to be seen - erased. Why? Because they don't fit the narrative the so-called liberal mainstream media is pushing - an embattled President struggling to get his message across - under fire from an angry mob. Putting their slant right up front, the CBS segment was entitled "Anger Management."
CBS missed a chance to inform the American people on a critical debate raging around a complex issue - letting the sounds and sights of the protest line in Portsmouth speak for themselves. On one side a woman interviewed spoke about why the Public Option makes sense to her as a way to keep the insurance companies in check. On the other a man relayed how he pays for his own insurance and he is not about to pay for someone who has none. On one side a drumming group sits in front of a sign reading Health Services for Women. On the other a cute little girl holds a sign reading "Obama lies, Grandma dies." Powerful stuff.
Remember wen the Evening News covered the Civil Rights struggles or the Vietnam protests? Imagine if the Portsmouth story was reported like that. Americans could have watched what happened in Portsmouth and drawn their own conclusions. But that was CBS then. This is CBS now.
The CBS News team's failure to report the facts of what happened in Portsmouth would be a journalistic disgrace if what they were practicing was truly journalism. But that word seems old, something best used in the context of Morrow and Cronkite - back when reporters fought to get the story right and called it like they saw it.
So what to do we need to do? Show up with 10 times as many protesters as the other side? 100 times? March on Washington? How can we hope to get our story across when CBS outdoes Fox in the real-time revision of history department. It is easy to fall into despair.
But hope trumps fear, remember? We learned that in the campaign. So let's hope the MSM can get the story straight if we begin holding them accountable for doing their job.
Let's start today by writing to CBS today demanding that they run a story on the Evening News on the rising chorus of voices in support of the President's Health Care Reform initiative.
Here is the email address for The CBS Evening News:
evening@cbsnews.com
And a sample comment you can send to the Editors there:
Last night you aired a segment called "Anger Management" which covered the President's town hall in Portsmouth, NH. Your images and narration highlighted those protesting the President's policies but, unlike the raw footage of the event posted on your website, completely eliminated any reference to the many supporters who were also present. Please correct this factual error in tonight's CBS Evening News in a story on the increasing numbers of people coming out in support of Health Care Reform along the lines Obama has recommended.
Advertisement
















What? Are you suggesting that the MSM would actually distort their news coverage to fit their own template?
Well, I never...
ex animo
davidfarrar
August 12, 2009 9:38 AM | Reply | Permalink
I know David, it's not exactly a surprise. But if enough of us stop buying their non-news product then perhaps they will get the message. It's all business.
August 12, 2009 10:39 AM | Reply | Permalink
The media has sponsors to coddle, sponsors for drugs and healthcare and insurance. You can bet many of their managers called CBS to get the story altered. The only way to really get our voices on the TV will be for a massive rally, or hundreds of rallies in many places all at once. It's more difficult to alter the size of a massive crowd. Although, now that I think about it, the crowds at the GOP Convention in NYC were pretty underreported. So I guess what really matters is what they tell their Congress Critters.
August 12, 2009 12:30 PM | Reply | Permalink
Zap, could not agree more. I recalled this morning the way Reagan ignored the entire No Nukes movement that included some very large rallies in the US and in Europe. Key is pressure applied directly on Congress. OFA recommends visiting their local offices.
Gregory
August 12, 2009 2:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
After her town hall on healthcare yesterday, Senator MacCaskill stated that all the media would report is on the small disturbance where two were escorted out by police.
'By and large we had a very good meeting,' she said in closing to the group. She was applauded!
However, her prophecy about the media was exactly right! CNN and yes, here on TPM the headlines were only about negative. And even that didn't advise the whole story, that the confrontation wasn't about MacCaskill and what she was addressing but about another taking away the other's sign.
There is no doubt that corporate ad revenue sources do, indeed, 'create' the 'news'.
Yes, we do need to communicate with the media and advertisers who do are not related to healthcare industry.
However, full disclosure for me - I believe that President Obama and his administration did not and continue not to put forward a cohesive, specific and needed proposal. We can only effectively cure what ails us in healthcare reform if he and his supply the right medicine.
Appreciate your posts greatly. Rec'd.
August 12, 2009 2:41 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's difficult to evaluate your post Gregory, as the two links to the CBS footage in your blog appear to be to the same clip. Whether that is a mistake on your part, or whether CBS has removed the 'before' clip I cannot hazard to guess.
August 12, 2009 3:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for the heads up on the broken link. It has been repaired. Refresh your web page to get the update.
Gregory
August 12, 2009 5:22 PM | Reply | Permalink
The Today Show was also suggesting that the NH town hall was less boisterous because of Secret Service presence. In other words the President's men intimidated participants.
They also went to day-two of the Hilary 'I'm the Sec.State' outburst. To NBC the loss of prestige is now palpable.
August 12, 2009 9:50 PM | Reply | Permalink
The MSM is about making money. If that happens to get in the way of giving viewers an accurate portrayal of the news, too bad.
This is exactly the same as everything else in this country. The product being delivered comes second to profits.
August 12, 2009 11:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks Greg, it's in the mail.
August 12, 2009 11:30 PM | Reply | Permalink
What is baffling, is that the news is about catering to the sponsors and not viewers, although more viewers is supposed to enable networks to charge more from their sponsors. Sponsors want their ad dollars going where they will be seen the most. So, if 70% of people want healthcare reform, and no one else is really covering it, why would there not be any networks out there uncovering the stories about people whose insurance companies have failed them, who are suffering because of lost insurance with their job, or who are currently engaged in an insurance battle. They would not have to go very far, or dig very deep. We ALL have examples of these tragedies. Theoretically, it could bring 70% of the viewers to their network. Now THAT would attract some sponsorship dollars, and maybe even new sponsors other then heatlhcare, pharma or insurers.
August 13, 2009 3:31 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for posting this, Gregory.
I recently put up a post covering the Brighton, CO town hall (which was a spectacular success BTW). I noted, however, that the only coverage of the event focused on the ONE MAN who made a spectacle of himself. His mug is platered all over the internet and has been featured on television news programs. There has been no mention of the fact that the meeting was otherwise peaceful and there was no indication whatsoever that pro-reformers outnumbered teabaggers at least 3 to 1 (no footage of the crowd at all).
Meanwhile, my post went up in smoke for some reason though I don't understand how. It didn't make its way out of the rec. reader queue in the usual way (one minute it was there with 12 recs and then poof, while the posts prior to mine and after mine remained).
Truly wierd. Anyway, my hasband had this to say about the town hall in an email to me from D.C.:
"I did see "Bob's" face on the TV this morning on the Early Show. The only soundbite they came up with from the Brighton town hall was him yelling. Not that the crowd was peaceful or anything like that, just him yelling. Then they showed a quick clip of Perlmutter talking to folks and then the old guy trying to talk to Bob."
FAIR, a media watchdog group, has been campaigning for fair coverage of the health care reform debate. Just FYI.
FAIR: http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=100
August 13, 2009 4:14 AM | Reply | Permalink
P.S. Just sent an email to the email address you provided for CBS... added my example to yours ss stated above. Pls. excuse the typos in my previous comment and thanks again.
August 13, 2009 6:10 AM | Reply | Permalink