« McCain: Catholic. Protestant. What's the Difference? (For Real!) | GFunk's Blog

Let's Game the Scenario: Russia, Ukraine, October Surprise?


I was an enthusiastic Cafe denizen a few years ago and, encouraged by the new tools, am inching back into the fold.  I hope to use this post for something I found the Cafe to be especially good for back in the day - gaming a future scenario - with the goal of keeping Dems prepared for whatever Republicans might throw at us. 

The scenario, as the title suggests, is Russia invading Ukraine sometime in the next few weeks.  What would it mean for the election?  How could Obama turn it to his advantage?


Why is it important to think this through?  Some background.  Over at Politico yesterday, they asked a number of politicos to "sketch out a scenario--plausible or not--in which McCain turns this around and is the next president." The answer provided by the republican lobbyist Tom Korologos is that "Russia invades Ukraine." 

Now, Korologos is deeply connected in Republican circles, and this is a strikingly specific scenario.  Korologos, oddly, doesn't elaborate, but that's because he knows that McCain has hitched his star to a hawkish anti-Russia policy, one that's seemed somewhat discordant at various times in this campaign. 

McCain's clearly been gunning for the title of prophet on Ukraine, sometimes at the cost of looking Ahab-like on the topic.  In the first debate, McCain said

And watch Ukraine. This whole thing has got a lot to do with Ukraine, Crimea, the base of the Russian fleet in Sevastopol. And the breakdown of the political process in Ukraine between Tymoshenko and Yushchenko is a very serious problem. So watch Ukraine, and let's make sure that we -- that the Ukrainians understand that we are their friend and ally.

In the second, he repeated this

I said before, watch Ukraine. Ukraine, right now, is in the sights of Vladimir Putin, those that want to reassemble the old Soviet Union.

The right-wing press has similarly advanced this notion, as in Jefferey Kuhner Washington Times column this week, "Will Russia-Ukraine be Europe's next war?", where he wrote

Russia has been distributing thousands of Russian passports to supporters in the Crimea. The plan is to replicate what was done in South Ossetia and Abkhazia: Create a pretext to send in Russian "peacekeepers" to protect supposedly endangered Russian "citizens."
Palin's Putin-rearing-his-head could take on a very different cast very quickly, and McCain, as we all know, has lots of back channel Davis-Manafort links to the region. 

So, thoughts? How does Obama own this scenario if it comes to pass, rather than cede it to McCain? 

3 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

GFunk, I keep trying to imagine this scenario, but it fails my reality checks. I need help getting over these stumbling blocks:

  • Most Russians prefer Obama over McCain. Putin knows that looking sideways at Ukraine will help McCain because...
  • Putin accused Bush of having a hand in the row over Georgia in order to help McCain. The LA Times ran a poll asking how many thought Putin might be right and out of 470 votes, 55% thought so. (Admittedly, not scientific.)
  • Unlike like the war crazies in the Republican Party, the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace's expert, Dmitri Trenin, believes it may be Yushchenko that starts something.
  • I suppose McCain would spin it into Russia's fault anyway, but I don't see that scenario winning big time over the current economic crisis and pushing McCain ahead in the polls. What, we're all poor Ukranians now?


What am I missing here?
user-pic

Seashell--Thanks for the LAT poll--very interesting and suggests, as you note, that Americans might reasonably resist the "We're all Ukranians now" line. As for Yushchenko agitating, that's worrisome enough, isn't it? McCain and the right have primed Americans to see Ukraine as faultless victims and lovers of democracy, whatever the precise causus belli. Would Obama then defend Russia? Uncomfortable, no?

Needless to say, the Powell endorsement from this morning, wonderfully, would give Obama more room to maneuver.

user-pic

Gfunk, I really enjoyed the exercise. Do you have any more thought out yet?

Leave a comment

GFunk

user-pic

Following: 7
Followers: 3

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address