« Tour of TPM | FDRdog's Blog | Corporate Personhood in a Democracy »

Roots Rot


I followed a link today to the Investigative Reporters and Editors (IRE) web site. IRE is (in its own words): "...a grassroots nonprofit organization dedicated to improving the quality of investigative reporting."

 Who should be featured in an article about Accountability Reporting and Digging Deep? None other than Leonard Downie, Jr,  Executive Editor of the wapo until September 2008, and Bob Woodward. The irony hit me like a blast of hot desert air and almost took my breath away, or possibly just made me snort.  Here sat these two do-nothings on an Accountability  Reporting discussion panel while the best Accountability journalist at the wapo had just been fired.

Woodward is still riding on his Watergate laurels of course and says his "aggressiveness" failed him on the run-up to the invasion of Iraq, but neither of these men knows exactly why they didn't dig deeper.  (A little fuzzy logic and a few memos from the bushies is my guess.) 

 Woodward said, "Obviously, when you're going to war you want the evidence to be hard." Had Post reporters gotten together with Downie "to figure out what questions aren't answered," though, the editor "would have said, 'Get on that; let's mobilize.' We failed to mobilize on that."

And what did Downie have to say about it? "Downie responded by citing the complexity of the story judgments that were required to weed out all the inaccurate reports emerging in the days following the terrorist attacks."   TRANSLATION:  If we want to keep those WH memos coming, we'll  have to take the neocons' word for it.

 The Post didn't mobilized on the invasion issue, the torture issue, the warrantless spying issue, or the habeas corpus issue or...hmmm.  Anyone remember what issue they did mobilize on?  Ah, they broke the Walter Reed story, I believe.  But too many of the horrors of the last eight years were, apparently, too *complicated* for the paper to tackle. 

 Downie and Woodward and their fellow journalists are the grassroots of the MSM, they claim. The pillars of the press.  The defenders of freedom. But there seems to be trouble brewing in rootsville.  Downie says "We're not talking about the survival of newspapers; we're talking about the survival of news."   

 Downie, who appears to be a drama queen in addition to defender,  is hardly in a position to help the American press save itself since he and his former colleagues  at the wapo and elsewhere are part of the problem.  Frankly, I would call it roots rot.  They're looking everywhere in their root cellar for a cure when it can only be found by dragging their own actions out into the sunlight for some serious scrutiny.  Firing one of their critics is just digging a deeper hole for themselves, not "digging deep"  for the news.


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Yeah, I'll say! Thanks for the great post. I just spent a whole day digging up one of ten rows of blackberries because of root rot. I'm throwing them on the burn pile.

user-pic

I wish we could put in some fresh MSM plants.

user-pic

On TPM's front page, the following are featured under the heading:

TPM VOICES

Robert Reich
"What Can I Do?"
A new president can't get a thing done in Washington unless the public is actively behind him. So what can the average person do about the way things are going in Washington?


Dan Froomkin
White House Watched
In the next great crisis, the country should heed journalists who report the truth, not those who serve as stenographers to liars, Dan Froomkin argues in his final Washington Post column.


Amitai Etzioni
Reconstructing Afghanistan?
Obama's own measure of success in Afghanistan isn't how many enemies are killed, but how many Afghans are "shielded from violence." That is a very tall order.


Helena Cobban
US, Syria, Iran, Hamas
Obama's decision to return a US ambassador to Syria seems linked to the turmoil in Iran, but that's not the whole story.


Theda Skocpol
Health Care Reform: Moment Of Truth
We are at a moment of truth, a pivotal turning point -- in the form of what happens in the next days and weeks with robust, universal health reform

Can we hope that Froomkin is soon to be added to the official TPM roster?

user-pic

'Rec your comment!

user-pic

Wouldn't that be wonderful, lally? Let's hope.

user-pic

Froomkin would be a better fit for TPM than Marc Cooper was.
(Earlier, I suggested Josh revive the "Horse's Mouth" as Froomkin's home base. Don't think that including him @TPMDC would work; he should have his own section w/ permanent, featured Front Page links )

Given the uproar about Froomkin's firing, one might think his addition to TPM would elevate TPM's traffic and profile.

We of the peoples' peanut gallery can dream.....

user-pic

Woodward is a fraud

user-pic

Woodward is a fraud

user-pic

Alas, he's not so much a fraud as a sell-out. In hindsight, I think it really started when he and Woodward wrote "The Breathern," an excellent book about the behind the scenes stuff at the Supreme Court. It gave the world an unprcedented look at how the Court worked, but it was also the project when they shifted from investigative journalism to access journalism.

Leave a comment

FDRdog

user-pic

Following: 3
Followers: 20

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Nomadic
  • Party Dem
  • Politics Wouldn't be here otherwise.

Favorites

  • Favorite Books Grimm's Fairy Tales was the first favorite.
  • Favorite Quotes "It's turtles all the way down." "He did the wrong things badly." "There's more things told than are true, And more things true than are told." R. Kipling

Bio

Learned to speak Cajun before English, so my Mother says.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address