« Persecution Politics: Illegals to Steal Grandma's Heath Care | ☠enghis's Blog | Persecution Politics: Beating on White Kids »

Glenn Beck, the Man With the Crazy Plan


You may have heard about Glenn Beck's recent paranoid accusations, but if you are a drive-by voyeur of right-wing hysterics, you might not appreciate the method behind the madness. Relying on out-of-context quotes, tenuous associations, and giant leaps of speculation, Beck has meticulously pieced together the most elaborate, nefarious government conspiracy in the history of cable news. His argument consists of four primary elements:

Part 1: The Czars

"Czar" is not an official title in the Federal government, and it is not printed on anyone's business card. It is a label that journalists and politicians assign to appointed officials in the executive branch, a common practice of Democratic and Republican presidents since F.D.R. Last February, Democratic Senator Robert Byrd criticized President Obama for appointing too many "czars," whom he believed were not sufficiently accountable to Congress. Glenn Beck took up the issue in early June and added his own sinister spin, stating, "A shadow government is giving the Obama administration unprecedented power with virtually no oversight."

More recently, Beck began airing regular segments called "Know Your Czar" in which he digs up the most outrageous biographical details he can find about bureaucrats and advisors in the Obama administration. His favorite bête noir within the Administration has been a man named Van Jones, the Special Advisor for Green Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation at the White House Council on Environmental Quality. (If the length of the title were related to political power, Jones would indeed be a powerful czar.) In his youth, Jones had been a Marxist sympathizer and black activist, but he embraced eco-capitalism in 1990's. Beck, of course, focuses on Jones' Marxist roots, which he has mentioned in almost every broadcast lately. Presenting Jones along with a few more appointees with tenuous connections to socialism and right-to-die movements, Beck argues that the Obama administration is an angry hive of "anti-Capitalist nutjobs" with unchecked political power and radical plans, saying, "There is a revolution, and they think they can get away with it quietly."

In response to controversy over Jones' past statements, he has just resigned. So much for the revolution.

Part 2: The Secret Army

Malevolent Marxist bureaucrats are disturbing, but they're not quite scary enough for a potent conspiracy theory. The evil czars need some muscle to carry out their sinister plans. That muscle takes the form of the fearsome AmeriCorps. Yes, according to Beck's theory, an army of teachers and community activists will establish martial law and suppress dissent. Beck's ammunition comes from a July 2008 campaign speech in which Obama explained his plans to expand AmeriCorps and the Peace Corps, saying, "We cannot continue to rely only on our military in order to achieve the national security objectives that we've set. We've got to have a civilian national security force that's just as powerful, just as strong, just as well-funded." This statement is all the evidence that Beck requires to allege that Obama and his Marxist cohorts intend to use this new "security force" to suppress people like...well...Glenn Beck.

Mr. President, is your civilian national security force to protect us from things the Missouri State Police, your own Homeland Security and the liberal Southern Law Poverty Center have come out and said were a threat: militia groups; tea party goers; folks with "Don't Tread on Me" flags; me; Sarah Palin? Think about this: Is it unreasonable to think this government would ask you to spy on your neighbors, in light of these recent stories?

Beck doesn't offer any context to the quote. Here's Obama's next sentence:

We need to use technology to connect people to service. We'll expand USA Freedom Corps to create online networks where Americans can browse opportunities to volunteer. You'll be able to search by category, time commitment and skill sets. You'll be able to rate service opportunities, build service networks, and create your own service pages to track your hours and activities.

We can see why Beck left out the context; a browsable database of volunteer opportunities just isn't that scary.

Part 3: The Gag

To execute their plan quietly and efficiently, the conspirators need to silence those strident voices of dissent. Their mechanism, Beck charges, is a proposal by Mark Lloyd, chief diversity officer of the FCC, to promote local, minority, and public broadcasters by tightening FCC regulations and taxing media conglomerates:

Our diversity 'czar' has just proposed that radio companies pay 100 percent of their operating budget, yearly. A 100 percent tax which would then be transferred to the state-run radio of NPR. If you can't pay that, you'd lose your license and it would be sold to minority group.

This "proposal" was taken from Lloyd's 2006 book critiquing corporate control of the media. The "100 percent of their operating budget" canard was invented by Matt Cover of CNSNews.com ("The Right News. Right Now."), and it quickly circulated around the conservative end of the blogosphere before Beck added it to his arsenal. Beck fears that Lloyd will use his awesome powers as FCC "diversity officer" to enact legislation that would shut down FOX News and other conservative media outlets:

Speak without fear or more "harmless legislation" will be passed and you will not be able to speak and you will experience the kind of fear that no one in this country has experienced before. All it will take is an "emergency." God help us all.

Which brings us to part 4.

Part 4: The Emergency

Even with the czars and the civilian brownshirts, the Obama administration would need some kind of justification to execute its tyrannical agenda. Beck alleges that the conspirators are planning to manufacture some kind of emergency to provide the catalyst. For instance, discussing Sarah Palin's "death panels," Beck played the history scholar and theorized that economic crisis caused Nazi Germany to institute a eugenics program that murdered tens of thousands. (This theory is known as the Gross Oversimplication Hypothesis.) At the end of the program, Beck darkly mused:

"What are [Obama's health advisors] saying to the president behind closed doors when we aren't there to watch it? I guess we won't know, because we'll all be too focused on the emergency that starts the rationing and the czars don't have to answer to anyone."

In another program, Beck reconceived Joe Biden's infamous gaff: "It will not be six months before the world tests Barack Obama like they did John Kennedy." Beck wondered, "Is this civilian national security force just preparing for what Joe Biden predicted?"

Finally, Beck claims that the liberal media will be the mouthpiece through which Obama's czars manufacture the crisis.

"If you watch what could only be called the organizations -- or the administration's organ -- anything involved with GE or NBC; you've got now Jeffrey Immelt on the board of the Federal Reserve, you have in the Oval Office consulting not only on health care but the financial situation, and they are an organ. If you watch MSNBC, I contend that you will see the future, because they are laying the ground for a horrible event that will be... What they're laying the ground for, anything from the right some awful event -- and I fear this government, this administration, has so much framework already prepared that they will seize power overnight before anybody even gives it a second thought."

And there you have it, an easy-bake Fascho-Communist revolution in four simple steps: hire powerful Marxist czars, silence the dissenting voices, manufacture a crisis with the help of the liberal media, and deploy the civilian security force to round up Americans of conscious.

Beck's ratings are up, of course. There's nothing like a juicy end-of-times conspiracy for that exhilarating jitter in the gut and the lump-ditty-lump of pulsing indignation. Taking note of Beck's success, right wing commentators and politicians are jumping on the conspiracy bandwagon. Clear Channel's Jim Quinn praised Beck and decried the "Marxist takeover of the United States." Rush Limbaugh went on Beck's show and warned, "This is statism, totalitarianism versus freedom. And if these people are allowed to go where they want to go unchecked, then some people, a lot of people...will wake up one day and find, "My God, what the hell happened?" Putting her facebook page to good use, Sarah Palin wrote, "Glenn Beck is doing an extraordinary job this week walking America behind the scenes of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue and outlining who is actually running the White House."

In the conservative echo chamber, paranoid voices have produced a feedback loop where each apocalyptic alarm bell facilitates another shriller peal of artificial terror. We can look forward to even more elaborate manifestations of the paranoid style from Beck and those he inspires in the days to come.

Update: Articleman offers a counterpoint to media obsession over Beck.

Genghis will speak live about Beck's paranoid theories on Tuesday 9/8 at noon EST / 9am PST with on KRXA 540 AM. [Cross-posted at dagblog.com]


18 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

We tend to dismiss this stuff as unlikely to move anyone, because it's nonsense. Apparently we're wrong. It seems to me, inciting a riot used to be against the law. Where are the government officials to actively refute this nonsense?

I think, pretending it is beneath their notice won't work. They need to get out there and actively refute Beck, demand that he back up these assertions, and censor the network that is allowing these hate-mongers to speak without taking any responsibility for the damage they are doing.

user-pic

It's a difficult problem to address. Unless Beck directly incites violence, which he has not, his speech is protected, and he cannot be censored. Private individuals and companies can of course boycott him, but we've seen how well that works. Beck's ratings are up, and FOX claims not to have lost any money from the current boycott. Such measures also feed Beck's persecution complex.

As for refutation, I think that it's useless to debate paranoics. Worse, the media would likely attempt to present the debate evenhandedly, which would legitimize Beck's nonsense.

But a little satire is always helpful when dealing with crazies.

user-pic

Well, there are none better at that, then you.

I'll try and take a page from your notebook.

user-pic

Why are these nut-cases not laughed out of town? The birthers; the deathers; the tea-baggers; the "how dare our duly elected President speak to my witless schoolchilders -- but someone questions legitimate holes in what we know about the 911 tragedy, and they lose their job?

Good job, Ghengis, of putting this all together. BTW I miss the ever-changing collar, but prefer this one to the headless play-ground pic.

user-pic

Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert are leading the laugh track, but Beck's audience isn't tuning in.

The sad fact is that these conspiracy theories have been simmering for years on for years on the right back-burner. Beck just turned up the heat a bit. Now it's starting to bubble over a make a mess.

user-pic

In Europe, resentment for the Jews had been on a slow boils for many, many years. Hitler and the Nazi's occurred at just the right time, when the kettle was beginning to boil over because of a whole different issue and the public needed a scapegoat to vent their frustrations on. History has a nasty habit of repeating itself when people don't consider actions from the past. Obama must be just the stimulus they're looking for. The problem is...what is the motive.

user-pic

I think you are writing of an 'Insane man' with a crazy plan which is far more dangerous.

When I look at these people Beck, Palin, Bachman, O'Reilly, Limbaugh... the thing that they seem to have in common besides claiming to be republicans is that they all seem to be 'actually' mentally ill.

Like, Bwak, I am wondering where the checks are on this kind of sick inciting of violence and distribution of psychotic insanity. I really think there should be some sort of deprogramming protocol for Limbaugh and Fox listeners. Are scientists working on this?

Fox is afraid of their listeners getting any real or direct information lest they start thinking for themselves. They are 'afraid' to show the President's address to congress.

user-pic

In 1964, the historian Richard Hofstadter described "the paranoid style in American politics" as follows:

I call it the paranoid style simply because no other word adequately evokes the sense of heated exaggeration, suspiciousness, and conspiratorial fantasy that I have in mind. In using the expression “paranoid style” I am not speaking in a clinical sense, but borrowing a clinical term for other purposes. I have neither the competence nor the desire to classify any figures of the past or present as certifiable lunatics., In fact, the idea of the paranoid style as a force in politics would have little contemporary relevance or historical value if it were applied only to men with profoundly disturbed minds. It is the use of paranoid modes of expression by more or less normal people that makes the phenomenon significant.

Beck and co. are also "more or less normal." That's what makes their crazy talk so disturbing.

user-pic
user-pic

Interesting article.

I would agree that this applies to some but surely not all. In fact Beck is one that I suspect 'is' mentally ill.

I could find a better source but I know that a big percentage of the American population is considered mentally ill. This information suggests that total is over 26%, a large portion of which may be Fox viewers and Limbaugh listeners so while I think Hannity, O'Reilly(not as sure about Bill) and Gingrich could qualify as 'fairly normal', I would still question whether Palin, Limbaugh, Beck, and Bachman may be actually suffer from mental illness.

statistics on mental illness in US population... http://www.answerbag.com/a_view/4148997

user-pic

I'm not a shrink, and I'm not even sure if Beck believes his own rhetoric. Regardless, a lot of people are buying into the paranoia, and that's a problem regardless of their the technical diagnosis.

user-pic

Most excellent link !!!

I wasn't aware the paranoid conservatives had such a historical nature. And that was back in the mid 60's! WOW !!! To think they're fighting to win their country back, but they don't realize just how far back they're talking about - that America doesn't exist anymore.

user-pic

If Hitler were alive and living in the US today, he would be allowed to carry on with his rants and raves. In Germany, it wasn't so much his rants and raves that got him into power, it was the people who supported him and his ideology. That's the danger zone - not the person but the people who believe the person.

user-pic

I think that today's paranoia is much closer to the Red Scare than Naziism, but all political paranoia has a common thread.

user-pic

Paranoia is truly a problem. Why do I get the impression it's like catching a cold or flu, but you never get well? There's always a lingering germ that can manifest the full blown cold or flu again out of the slightest of incidents that have little or no bearing to the original malaise? After reading the article, I can't help but wonder how can a reasonably sane person fall under a paranoid's influence?

user-pic
And there you have it, an easy-bake Fascho-Communist revolution in four simple steps: hire powerful Marxist czars, silence the dissenting voices, manufacture a crisis with the help of the liberal media, and deploy the civilian security force to round up Americans of conscious.

This is interesting because it is exactly what George W. Bush did (only changing a few adjectives) to steal the White House for 8 years.

1) Hire loyal lackeys (and family members) to enable the theft of the 2004 election;
2) Silence dissenting voices with the Supreme Court;
3) Manufacture absolute chaos with multiple invasions of other countries, using the New York Times for cover (liberals will never suspect!);
4) Deploy constant scare tactics to keep the public off-balance and convince corporations (like the telecoms) to break the law at our bidding.

Either Karl Rove is back at work or someone is copying his model.

user-pic

Genghis on beck, hahahaha. I laugh at this because I saw that dumb fuck on Cnn or HNN or whatever years ago. There had been a rise in approval ratings for w, like from 29% to 31% hahahaah.

Then, of course, it got worse and worse because his ratings began going up and up and so he began to be quoted by Mediamatters and then KeithO got in on it.

I did my own little post finally and discovered he had a high school diploma and one semester at Yale given to him by some right wing Christian nuts. His mom and brother offed themselves. Another brother died from cancer or some such.

He went into the bottle and prescription drugs and arose 'reborn' but still uneducated, unread.

So he spews out his venom, promises to pay for the bullet that kills Moore.....

This Quayle mistake with oligarchy was a joke since he has no idea what the word means, no sense of etiology..

Some right wingers here say I am just beck dressed up in radical left clothing which really is a slam when you think about it.

I mean when they compare KeithO to rush or beck, it just enrages me.

But a right wing fascist demagogue only needs the ears of the .01 percent of the nut jobs who would shoot Moore or Obama without hesitation. And rush garners a full 1% who need to have their racist and fascist views aired.

But when MSM begins reairing the demagogues, the messages must be confronted.

So thank you for the post.

user-pic

Um...you're welcome

Leave a comment

☠enghis

user-pic

Following: 58
Followers: 82

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Website: dagblog.com
  • Location New York
  • Party Yes
  • Politics No

Favorites

  • Favorite Quotes "I have a vast variety of sources where we get our news." S.P.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address