« New YouTube Healthcare Reform Video | Fred Moolten's Blog | Is The Public Option Important? »

What Will President Obama's Wednesday Speech Be Like?


I don't mean what will he say - there's already enough speculation on that.  Rather, what will the speech look like?

"Look", not "sound"?

His own skills and the suggestions from his advisors will undoubtedly permit him to deliver a speech in an effective manner.  What I'm wondering is whether this occasion might not also be an appropriate opportunity to emphasize  visual rather than exclusively auditory means of communicating content.

As I understand it, Obama will tell the country that healthcare reform entails a set of essential changes.  It seems to me this type of listing lends itself to visuals - in big, bold print, and kept in view for at least a minute each to ensure their retention in the memory of the national audience.

Just some examples.  "AMERICA MUST KEEP WHAT IS GOOD ABOUT OUR HEALTHCARE AND CHANGE WHAT NEEDS TO BE FIXED.  HERE ARE THE CHANGES THAT CONGRESS MUST MAKE TO GUARANTEE HIGH QUALITY, EFFECTIVE HEALTHCARE FOR ALL OUR CITIZENS:"

slide 1: NO AMERICAN WILL BE DENIED HEALTH INSURANCE

(while the slide is up, the President discusses "cherry picking" and "pre-existing conditions, and the following slides will also be accompanied by relevant talking points)

 

slide 2: NO AMERICAN WILL BE CHARGED UNAFFORDABLE RATES FOR BEING SICK

 

slide 3: EVERY AMERICAN INSURANCE PLAN WILL COVER BASIC MEDICAL NEEDS

 

slide 4: NO INSURANCE COVERAGE WILL EVER RUN OUT OR BE TAKEN AWAY TO SAVE THE INSURER MONEY

 

slide 5: AMERICANS MUST BE GUARANTEED AFFORDABLE COVERAGE BY REQUIRING COMPETITION

(Here, of course, is where the public option will be discussed.  From media reporting, I judge it unlikely that Obama will threaten to veto a reform package without a public option, but he can make the point that a public option is the only sure means of guaranteeing effective competition in areas where insurer monopolies and weak bargaining leverage for subscribers render coverage unaffordable - mainly, those who must purchase individual coverage, or small businesses with meager bargaining power.  He can point out that large employers can already negotiate favorable rates, and that no proposal in Congress would add a public option to the mix for those employers, or attempt to eliminate insurers for those employers.

 

slide 6: HOSPITALS AND DOCTORS MUST BE REWARDED FOR PROVIDING BETTER HEALTH

(this is the place to discuss changes that reward providers for outcome rather than unnecessary tests and procedures that raise costs but don' t help patients, or may even harm them (e.g., unnecessary radiation exposure from routine CT scans when they don't confer any benefit)

 

Finally, at some point, these might be reiterated in a summary slide:

 

NO AMERICAN WILL BE DENIED HEALTH INSURANCE

 

NO AMERICAN WILL BE CHARGED UNAFFORDABLE RATES FOR BEING SICK:

 

EVERY AMERICAN INSURANCE PLAN WILL COVER BASIC MEDICAL NEEDS

 

NO INSURANCE COVERAGE WILL EVER RUN OUT OR BE TAKEN AWAY TO SAVE THE INSURER MONEY

 

AMERICANS MUST BE GUARANTEED AFFORDABLE COVERAGE BY REQUIRING COMPETITION

 

HOSPITALS AND DOCTORS MUST BE REWARDED FOR PROVIDING BETTER HEALTH

 

Ross Perot once did something like this, and it went over well.  Maybe if done on a grander scale, in front of Congress, the effect could be even more compelling.  It would also lend itself to recapitulation in the print media, YouTube, and the Evening News on TV,

Just a thought.

 

 

 


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I think you have components of a project plan there but what's been missing from the get go is a strong simple mission statement. The reason Democrats have been lost in the woods is that they can't even find their forest on the map. He needed the Norman Rockwell slide. He needed an FDR moment listing the 5th freedom. FDR didn't achieve freedom from want or freedom from fear with one speech but you could draw a picture of it and you can name the value and state the goal.

Democrats are still telling us its about cutting costs. That is not the goal. FDR didn't tell us he was going to cut the cost of living. He stated the value: freedom from want.

user-pic

While what it looks like is important, I hope it also sounds like your last video. I sent it to him. I hope he'll crib something from it.

I'd still like to see you post the script.

user-pic

Thanks again, amike. My video was unscripted, but if you think it would make an important difference, I can replay it, with pauses, and copy down the remarks to create a transcript. Let me know.

user-pic

One of the persons who bravo'd it gave a partial transcript. There are people I'd like to send it to, but maybe it would be just as well to have them watch it as read it. I have the link from youtube and I've already passed it around.

Happy Labor Day from Southern New England. :-)

user-pic

Thanks again, amike. Here's an opportunity to give the link to the video again, for those who haven't seen it. It's at

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1ZFNOAL-Tg

I hope reposting the link doesn't come across as self-serving. I'm not trying to gain fame and fortune via YouTube, but only to help a good cause. Although the video is not important enough to do more than help at the margins in reinforcing the healthcare reform message, we can probably use all the help we can get.

user-pic

I hope reposting the link doesn't come across as self-serving.

No Fred. It is a service you are providing no need to qualify it. Really you do great things. Please keep it up!

user-pic

Amen and Amen. Post it until this thing is settled, and we'll do what we can to get it going viral.

user-pic

Thanks for re-posting the video .. I hadn't seen it before. Excellent. ---- Re: how the speech/campaign "look" Maybe they should get Al Gore and whoever worked with him on "An Inconvenient Truth" to put it together. That's teh part that people remember -- the visuals, even the graphs.

user-pic

I heard back from Peter Lesser about the video, who says:

This is good stuff. While I do not have the ear of the President (I wish I did), I will share it with people in our organization. Thanks for passing it along.

--Peter

Who else close to the WH should see it to reinforce the good work amike has done? Whom does anyone know who has the ear of the President?

I happen to think the Dr. Fred video is exactly what's needed. But then I happen to think the President is exactly whom we have needed for a long time.

Leave a comment

Fred Moolten

user-pic

Following: 0
Followers: 27

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

Bio

Current interests include climate change, folk music, and politics.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address