« Appellate judging | barth's Blog | D-Day 2009 »

The Speech


There is much more to say about this important moment and, when I have a few minutes this weekend I will try to present a few here to see what others think, but I did have time to throw this out:


It was, of course, a masterful speech and yet another reason to suspect we may have greatness among us.  He said what we all want to say, and told Egyptians truths about who we are and what we are willing to do, consistent, I think, with the views of most Americans.  I was so proud of him and my country.

I cannot say the same for his audience, willing to applaud for his call to the end of Israeli settlements, but not for the end of Hamas support for violence or to recognize the right of the State of Israel even to exist.

It is a first step, though and a step in keeping with who we are as a nation.  We left that path somewhere during middle part of the Vietnam War and it has taken us about forty years to get back on it, but we are.  

There are always questions to be asked about the claim of American exceptionalism, but when we send a person of this quality to say these kind of things to a foreign audience, there is much to be said in support of the claim that we are the last best hope and a beacon for a world in conflict.

As with all great speeches, its words keep rebounding in my head.  I am looking forward to hearing it again.

Throughout the last portion a prayer from many Saturdays of my youth kept playing itself in my head.  I have looked up the exact English text and in quoting it, I submit that "Israel" in this context means the Jewish people" not the State of Israel, which did not exist when the prayer was written:

Grant us peace, Thy most precious gift, O Thou Eternal Source of Peace, and enable Israel to be its messenger unto all peoples of the earth.

Bless our country, that it may ever be a stronghold of peace and its advocate in the council of nations.May contentment reign within its borders, health and happiness within its homes

Strengthen the bonds of friendship and fellowship among all the inhabitants of all lands.

Plant virtue in every soul and may the love of Thy name hallow every home and every heart.  Praised by Thou, O God, lover of peace.

You may call those wishes naive, as some have already, but (with the exception of the call to honor God) it is a message of hope and as expressed by the President of the United States to students in a Muslim nation, one well worth conveying.

Still, that it is politically incorrect to applaud for the end of violence is off putting to this American.

I really see this speech as a challenge to the Muslim world, one which the prior President tried to convey but could not, particularly given his childish views about evildoers.  This President has thrown the political equivalent of a hard fastball down the middle and challenged the Muslim world to try to hit it, but at least swing for it, hoping that they can.

My pride in our president really is beyond description.




6 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I have the same pride in my President Barth. No kidding. I still like to relate that even at this late date it draws a tear to my eye once in awhile when I see him introduced as such. Sometimes I think I will awaken to a a reality much different than this.

Jack Cafferty on CNN, another worn out old man, cannot help himself. He really LOVES this president. Sometimes he just says it straight out. Today he made clear his belief that this speech in Egypt will be read and analyzed decades from now.

THIS WAS A REAL HISTORICAL EVENT. OF the first magnitude. Ramona and others have expressed that sentiment.

Thank you for your take on it and I do look forward to anything else you might put together on this over the week end.

user-pic

Oh Barth, there ya go again...

Posting another good blog!

It is (to quote you) a message of hope and yet too many want to only concentrate on percieved negatives and what he should of said or didn't say.

It's a start and a damn fine one. 'nuff said.

Thanks for this. Rec'd.

user-pic

Maybe the speech was like this
"It is a cultural war. This is the culture we are fighting for. Any questions?"

user-pic

great post barth. Inspired me to listen to the speech again. Thanks

user-pic

I watched it live and was transfixed. Where have we been these last 8 years?

user-pic

Nice post. Me too.

Leave a comment

barth

user-pic

Following: 8
Followers: 29

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs Firedoglake HuffingtonPost.com Talking Points Memo FiveThirtyEight.com Daily Kos Media Matters for America Electoral-vote.com SCOTUSblog Borrowed Suits Robert Reich's Blog Eschaton The Public Servant White House Watch/Dan Froomkin Salon Extra Bases - Red Sox blog The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
  • Favorite Books currently reading the autobiography of one of the greatest public figures of our time: Senator Edward Moore Kennedy
  • Favorite Quotes "We will not be driven by fear into an age of unreason, if we dig deep in our history and our doctrine..." (Edward R. Murrow) "Ask not what your country can do for you; ask what you can do for your country" (President Kennedy)"The test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; it is whether we provide enough for those who have too little." (Pres. F. D. Roosevelt)"So let us summon a new spirit of patriotism; of service and responsibility where each of us resolves to pitch in and work harder and look after not only ourselves, but each other." (President-elect Obama)

Bio

A dedicated public servant, as discussed at some length at http://edsbarth.blogspot.com/

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address