TPM Plagiarism, Part Deux
This doesn't rank anywhere near the high-profile MoDo plagiarism recently uncovered by TPM's thejoshuablog. However, I got curious as to exactly how much stuff gets hijacked from TPM bloggers, many of whom could certainly write commercially if they wanted. (And, of course, bloggers like Deanie Mills do make a living as wordsmiths.)
To be clear, I am not one of those talents. But, I figured there was no better place to start than my own blog. So, I started using teh Google on some of my older blog titles. About five minutes later, I found a case of out-and-out, wholesale plagiarism of one of my own pieces.
I wrote the blog entry "Michele Bachmann - Unstable AND Unable" here on TPM on February 20, 2009.
A writer on Salem-News.com, Dorsett Bennett, wrote this article on February 27. To conserve space, I won't quote it here.
The first half of Bennett's article is, well, my blog. With only a few cosmetic changes, he essentially lifted my piece and made it part of his own. Of course, I am not cited anywhere in the article, nor is TPM. Clearly, Bennett's "article" violates even the most generous reading of the "fair use" exception.
I strongly advise all TPM bloggers to take some of your blog titles and run them through Google. After all, you never know what "journalists" may be sponging off your creative efforts.
















I think we do a lot of free work for a lot of hack journalists. Last Fall in the height of all of the Bill Ayers blather, I did a blog with a title something like "Obama's Political Career Began in the Living Room of a Jewish Rabbi." The next day a well-known Chicago times columnist ran an article called "Obama's Political Career Began in the Living Room of a Jewish Rabbi." So yeah, it happens.
May 18, 2009 2:21 PM | Reply | Permalink
er...just "rabbi". I remember being reprimanded about my rednundancy at the time.
May 18, 2009 3:47 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wow, that's about as shameless as I've seen. I tried to mention it in the Salem-News.com comments section, but it hasn't been "approved." Likely will never be.
May 18, 2009 2:47 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh my goddess, Boyd. You didn't say if you saw the profile on Dorsett Bennett, but here it is anyway, complete with email address.
Self-aware my doggie ass. He's a busted plagiarist. More:I don't know how you want to handle this, or if you want to handle it at all, but there is the info if you want it.
I don't know why I feel so shocked, but damn, that was word for word for word. And I'm still shocked. And, that was one of my favorite blogs, to boot.
May 18, 2009 4:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
I forgot to highlight the part where he is a Republican, no matter if he calls himself an Independent/Libertarian or not. He is a plagiarizing Republican.
May 18, 2009 4:36 PM | Reply | Permalink
Seashell, blog for chrissakes (blesses himself). I guarantee 700 comments and 200 recs. ha!!!! See I did not get this until you started describing to me 20 tabs at a time.
I told you before, but I still think you are the best researcher in our little cafe. hahahaha
May 19, 2009 1:44 AM | Reply | Permalink
Awww. Thanks, dd. That was better than getting flowers. I hereby award you a big kiss on the cheek for the day!
May 19, 2009 3:00 AM | Reply | Permalink
Excellent, puppy!
I wonder if they haz ombudsman
May 18, 2009 8:00 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks, Chickie. We will go look for budzman, also.
From comments below, it's starting to look like Bennett is one of those serial plagiarizer types.
May 18, 2009 8:35 PM | Reply | Permalink
Also, see Glenn Greenwald's column today about MoDo's plagiarism of J.M. and the "parasitic blogosphere."
May 18, 2009 4:36 PM | Reply | Permalink
Egads... well Bennett has excellent taste in choosing whom to plagiarize :) Nice detective work Boyd.
May 18, 2009 4:54 PM | Reply | Permalink
There were many times last Fall when MoDo's columns seemed to "echo" my blogs on Sarah Palin. Not whole sentences, though I never did bother to check. But themes. I saw it a lot during the campaign. I used to wait for her columns specifically to see if once again she'd use my ideas. I saw it over and over. I haven't time to go back. She may just be collecting her salary and loafing any more.
May 18, 2009 6:29 PM | Reply | Permalink
Almost forty years ago I submitted an essay to the University of Minnesota newspaper. The next day it was THE editorial page with a great cartoon drawn just for me! I had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Nixon was pornographic within the Supreme Court definition of profanity.
That Sunday, the NYT publish and editorial by some famous editorialist who name escapes me now, proving that Nixon was pornographic within the definition supplied by the Supreme Court.
Yes, these pundits like Dowd have aides whose job it is to seek out and find new perspectives. It is just that Josh aint someone in his jammies. HA
Oh Good Post Boyd. Always good to read!!!
May 18, 2009 6:51 PM | Reply | Permalink
Apparently Bennett has now added in small print below the last video block a message of "special thanks" to My TPM Blog. So there you go--all fixed! Of course, the text doesn't even include "update" in it anywhere, so it appears as if it's been part of the post forever.
May 18, 2009 6:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
Good catch, Winslow!
But that is so not good enough.
There is no My TPM Blog in the first place. And if there was, a link would be good, along with the Blogger's name. And third, he didn't just use information, he copied it word for word. But this is way too little, too late.
But at least we know the comment DFH sent was seen by Bennett.
(I think I'm more outraged than Boyd.)
May 18, 2009 7:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
Even after the “corrections”, the article still has several unattributed paragraphs that are lifted verbatim (or nearly so) from Mr. Reed’s article.
And, he never credits Mr. Reed, only “TPM Cafe”.
May 19, 2009 10:37 AM | Reply | Permalink
Boyd,
This upset me enough I linked to your story in a comment under Glenn Greenwald's story on Maureen Dowd (under my alterego Liberal Artist).
Glenn thought your story worthy and relevant enough to add an update specifically about your case: (http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/2009/05/18/parasites/index.html)
Your story, like others, deserves to be told, as a warning to klepto-journos everywhere.
May 18, 2009 7:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
I was just going to announce that. So you are Liberal Artist? Good going!
Here is the update Glenn wrote:
Is HuffPo in Boyd's future next? Now Bennett is really busted.
May 18, 2009 7:38 PM | Reply | Permalink
Boyd, you are not the only victim. Bennett's article from today plagiarizes a writer from the Libertarian site LewRockwell.com. He has added an acknowledgment like on yours but I imagine he did that after the fact. The Google cache still has the original of yours without the quasi attribution here: http://74.125.45.132/search?q=cache:4ka5RPyOrUMJ:www.salem-news.com/articles/february272009/frau_bachmann_2-27-09.php+http://www.salem-news.com/articles/february272009/frau_bachmann_2-27-09.php&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-a . I also have a screen shot of it if it disappears
May 18, 2009 8:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
The front page of Salem-News now has the third part of that series with David Deming listed as the author. The end of the article says, "Also, we offer our sincere apology to writer David Deming for not correctly identifying him as the author of this story."
May 18, 2009 11:35 PM | Reply | Permalink
Also his article here: http://salem-news.com/articles/may062009/murtha_part1_db_5-6-09.php steals from this Washington post article : http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/05/04/AR2009050403743.html?wprss=rss_nation
May 18, 2009 8:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hey, we might really be able to pick-off/discredit more than a few small-town conservative newspaper folks using this method. In addition, we might be able to topple one of the BIG 3:
1. O'Lielly
2. Hannity
3. Beck
There's no way these f'ers produce all their content on their many revenue streams...
May 18, 2009 11:06 PM | Reply | Permalink
Er, actually you are too, Mr. Boyd. THAT is why you shouldn't let some grumpy troll keep you from it. We all miss you.
Just sayin'.
May 18, 2009 8:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for this. I was kinda wonderin' and all. (And you are a talent. Have you checked your blogs?)
Also.
May 18, 2009 8:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
I was waiting for you to check yours first. I hope everyone sees this. Big crowd tonight. Dickon is looking for ya.
=D
Just sayin'.
May 18, 2009 8:36 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ack! Seashell, too!!! Look!!
I guess this blogger at least put up the word TPM, with no link or mention or seashell.
It sucks, though. Even if it isn't a Newspaper, newspaper. Wot a world!
May 18, 2009 9:00 PM | Reply | Permalink
The blogger that took seashell's work usually puts in a link where it says "TPM" so it may have been an innocent error. Perhaps if contacted they would insert the link where needed.
May 19, 2009 7:23 AM | Reply | Permalink
Here's another 4-part "article" from Bennett that is a hodge podge of stolen paragraphs from two or three sources including Wikipedia:
http://salem-news.com/articles/january232009/illegal_drugs-sb_1-22-09.php
Has anyone sent this man an email to introduce him to quotation marks?
May 18, 2009 9:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
Jeez, it's not like professional punditating is hard work or anything. Newspapers let you just make up shit. But people aren't even making the effort to make up their own shit.
May 18, 2009 9:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
I would like to remind everyone that the plagiarist is supposedly a lawyer.
May 18, 2009 9:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
You know, I forgot about that!
May 18, 2009 10:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wow! Just wow!
May 18, 2009 9:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
Are there any plagiarism identification programs out there that can protet the random (talented) blogger?
May 18, 2009 10:03 PM | Reply | Permalink
I'm not sure that anything will happen to Dorsett Bennet since it appears that everything on the Salem-news.com website is plagiarized.....even the article not written by Bennett. Google the first sentence of any "article" they print and you will find it printed somewhere else first.
May 18, 2009 9:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks to everyone who has posted on this. Special thanks to RobertoW for flagging this for Glenn Greenwald.
It appears that much of Salem-News.com is plagiarized. However, I've done my part by sending a letter to their corporate counsel (h/t seashell for the suggestion).
I also e-mailed the executive editor and publisher of Salem-News.com. I think *something* needs to happen, as this site obviously generates money from advertising.
May 18, 2009 10:03 PM | Reply | Permalink
Good for you, Boyd. The strange thing is I took your suggestion and Googled one of mine, as Bwak noted. The first (and only) one I tried was on another blog, word for word and the only attribution was "TPM", and it wasn't even a link. Makes it sound like Josh wrote it.
Didn't have the heart to go any further.
May 18, 2009 10:10 PM | Reply | Permalink
I don't know when was the last time you checked, but as of like 3 minutes ago, they did put up an addendum crediting TPM(though not you specifically). I bet that was done by corporate counsel/webmaster).
May 19, 2009 12:34 AM | Reply | Permalink
SLATE: "Dude, You Stole My Article: How I investigated a suspicious alt weekly."
By Jody Rosen
Posted Wednesday, Aug. 6, 2008, at 4:00 PM ET
The saga began in the classical manner: with an e-mail about Jimmy Buffett. Several weeks ago, I received a note from a Slate reader drawing my attention to an article published in March 2008 in the Bulletin, a free alternative weekly in Montgomery County, Texas, north of Houston. "I believe your … profile of musician Jimmy Buffett was reproduced wholesale without attribution," the reader wrote. "I thought you should know." I followed a link to . . . . . .
http://www.slate.com/id/2196810/pagenum/all/
May 18, 2009 11:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
As Atrios always says:
I think its time for another blogger ethics panel!
Journalists and their editors are quite often very pitiful at their jobs, criminally so it seems now. This must be tip of the iceberg, I bet there are thousands of cases like this (maybe not quite this egregious)
The top of their profession consists of such luminaries as the canadian MTV video Jockey on CNN John King, David Gregory (Karl Rove's backup dancer), Chris Mathews (Mr. codpiece), Maureen Dowd (nuff said), and Doris Kearns Goodwin who was caught plagiarizing (by my ~uncle Philip). Failing up is the name of the game here.
Corporate Journos' role models are the dregs of the cesspools of intellect
May 19, 2009 1:54 AM | Reply | Permalink
Boyd, this is a great post, thank you. And all that added comments and research - I applaud you. The MoDo bit really opened my eyes and I am so glad to see this follow up.
In the middle of the presidential campaigns I was contacted by a reporter from USA today that wanted to quote a comment I made here. She was very professional about the whole thing and really nice. All it took was a few emails back and forth. By the way, TPM made the original contact - they did not give the reporter my info. Just wanted you all to know that some papers appear to have some professionalism.
May 19, 2009 3:18 AM | Reply | Permalink
There are now "TPM Cafe said/wrote/reported" additions all over the "Bennett" article and a a 'special thanks' link to your original post at TPM Cafe. No indication though that the original version has been amended. But the cached version of the unattributed original Salem-News article (link posted above by tempsan at 8:07) is still working for all to see.
May 19, 2009 8:44 AM | Reply | Permalink
Who is TPM cafe - to speak? This guy needs to be bombarded with the fact that his plagiarism comes from people! Not from a website.
May 19, 2009 10:07 AM | Reply | Permalink
I've certainly no issue with that true point! 'Boyd Reed at TPM Cafe' is clearly what was needed. I was just noting the increasing number of attributions. And at least they did, after being caught red-handed, finally manage a link to Reed's original post revealing the (youthful) face behind impersonal reference.
May 19, 2009 7:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
Mine was not a complaint against your comment. Just adding to it. :)
May 19, 2009 8:10 PM | Reply | Permalink
Another person noted that Dowd lifted another identical phrase from Masrhall in the same story:
"old fashioned P.O. W". Sounds to me as if Dowd actually read Marshall's column herself and lifted it from him. I don't frankly believe a "friend" gave it to her.
http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/kenneth_thomas/2009/05/more-to-the-maureen-dowd-plagi.php?ref=reccafe
May 19, 2009 8:56 AM | Reply | Permalink
Wow, what an eye-opener. And scary, too. I use a lot of sources in my blogs and I'm a stickler for attributions. I don't have to tell any of you that if you use someone else's words, you KNOW it! There is no "inadvertent" involved.
If you're online and you're cutting and pasting, it's a simple matter to give credit to the original author.
But I have to admit to a little jealousy here. As far as I know, nobody has lifted my words. So what's wrong with ME??
May 19, 2009 10:37 AM | Reply | Permalink
OMG! I just googled my blog title, "Sometimes a Picture isn't Worth a Thousand Words" and. . .guess what? It ain't nothin' new! It's been used at least three times before--maybe even hundreds, as far as I know. (And I thought it was so darned clever.)
Now, I know headlines and titles aren't copyrightable, so it isn't technically plagiarism, but I can stop feeling so smug now!
May 19, 2009 10:52 AM | Reply | Permalink
Hey Boyd - this blog is about to disappear which is too bad. Bennett's remedies to my mind just aren't good enough. Basic journalistic practice. Just sloppy and unethical that his piece hasn't been retracted/redone with proper permission and attribution. Pathetic. Something to keep a look out for. If there are any further developments republish with updates please!
And most importantly: YOU SHOULD BE BLOGGING MORE. We all miss your stuff!!
May 19, 2009 11:07 AM | Reply | Permalink
And they tease us for blogging in our pajamas in the basement of our parents ... then they steal our stuff.
My favorite was when I wrote that Rush was the Leader of the GOP. Everyone called me daft until Rahm Emanuel brough it to Meet the Press. I figured if there was no one with the cajones to object to Rush making that assertion, then he was. It's true to this day except when Michael Steele is in the Heezie[sp]*.
*Heezie is attributed to Micheal Steele, and lifted from Barack Obama's speech at the Press Dinner.
May 19, 2009 11:36 AM | Reply | Permalink
Good catch Boyd. There is no excuse for plagiarism. On the bright side our written words here obviously have an impact that goes well beyond the regular commenters here at TPM. Well done
May 19, 2009 11:45 AM | Reply | Permalink