PA-Sen: Early prognosis
Hi, everyone. First, a personal note. I've been hip-deep in MBA classes and work over the past year, and I take the LSAT in two weeks as well. So I've been mostly lurking.
I wanted to take a minute, though, and post my thoughts about the November general election for the US Senate seat out of Pennsylvania.
Congratulations to Joe Sestak on a solid win in the primary. I was exposed to his media ramp-up for the last couple of months, and his campaign did an excellent job, especially with their TV ads. Those helped his poll numbers climb steadily, and those rising poll numbers kept Obama and Biden away from the state in the closing push, when they might have helped increase what was pretty crappy turnout.
Obviously, I'll be working for Sestak's campaign when I can. I've already asked about phonebanking. And it's a rather obvious choice for me in the general, as I don't want Pat Toomey anywhere near a lever of power.
Having said all that, I do believe that Ed Rendell has reason to worry about the general election. Here's why - and here's what we need to do in the Keystone State to ensure that a nutburger like Toomey doesn't get in under the wire.
First, one of Specter's biggest general-election strengths was his ability to attract crossover votes. He was never seriously challenged in his November re-election battles, in large part because he could always count on pulling 20-30 percent of the Democratic vote. I don't think there's much Sestak can do in that regard; he's just not going to pull very many Republican votes.
Second, Specter would have been very difficult for Toomey to run against, because Toomey would have to run way to the right to establish any significant difference between him and Specter. This shift would help Specter rack up moderate votes, which would probably lead him to win a lot of the "T" in Pennsylvania against Toomey. (For those who don't know, the "T" is the state of Pennsylvania, minus the greater Pittsburgh and greater Philadelphia areas.)
Toomey, knowing this, has already tried to moderate himself on a number of issues, and has stayed far, far away from the bombast he employed when he was president of the Club for Growth. However, with Sestak in the race, Toomey will have greater room to tack to the center and get more of the moderates.
Can Sestak win in November? Obviously. Rendell, despite his probable gloom over Specter losing, has already endorsed Sestak, who will also enjoy support from the White House as well as Bob Casey, who will become our senior Senator. However, the two factors above are significant. So, what to do?
Well, first, Toomey's past positions and pronouncements must become a major factor in the November race. Elections are often won by the candidate who defines the other first. Sestak has to get out in front and make sure that everyone - especially the state's registered Democrats - knows that Toomey is a few Sandinistas short of a coup. The contrast between the two candidates should stand out in bold relief before the end of the summer. Yes, I know most voters aren't paying attention until fall rolls around. But it can't hurt to stake out your ground now.
I'm not suggesting that Sestak go totally negative. But this general election will not feature much crossover voting. So Sestak has to get the state's Democrats excited. Judging from the primary turnout, now would be a great time to start on that.
Sestak has the added disadvantage of being just about as anonymous to the average voter as Toomey (with the exception of PA-7). That relative anonymity, however, is also an opportunity for great advantage...if Sestak can fill those voids the way he wants.
Second, Sestak really needs to go wide (national) with his personal story. It's the one thing that really made me think he could win, if he could get past the state machine (which I did not think would happen) and let voters know what he's all about. Nationally, he could definitely draw contributions based on personal appeal. And the higher the profile for this election, the better it is for getting PA voters excited in general, which benefits the candidate whose party has a voter-registration edge.
Third, Sestak needs to run even harder in the general than he did in the primary. No pulling a Martha Coakley here. Voters in this state won't take kindly to it. All those personal appearances will be exhausting - but they will result in votes, especially in this state.
Hope everyone's doing well. Looks like last night went better for the good guys than I thought. I just hope it translates into one big moose-pie sundae for the GOP in November.











